Defensive inking in Aplysia spp: multiple episodes of ink secretion and the adaptive use of a limited chemical resource.

The seahare Aplysia spp. extracts many of its defensive chemicals from its red seaweed diet, including its purple ink, which is an effective deterrent against predators such as anemones and crabs. It is believed that the inking behavior is a high-threshold, all-or-none fixed act that nearly completely depletes the seahare of its ink supply. If a seahare depletes its gland of ink, it must seek out a source of red seaweed and then feed for at least 2 days to replenish its ink supply. This suggests that the animal would not be able to deploy ink more than once in rapid succession in response to successive attacks from one or more predators. However, we found that Aplysia spp. can secrete ink in response to three or more successive stimulations with (i) anemone tentacles, (ii) a mechanical stimulus, consisting of grabbing and lifting the animal from the substratum, or (iii) a noxious electric shock. A spectro-photometric measure of ink secretion showed that only approximately 48 % of the gland's releasable ink reserves are deployed initially. Thus, deployment of this defensive chemical is not strictly all-or-nothing, although the trigger mechanism is. Moreover, the animal tends to secrete a relatively fixed proportion (30--50 %) of its available ink reserves even after its gland has been depleted to approximately half its initial content. Since an animal need only use a proportion of its ink reserves to deter an attacker effectively, the inking behavior is adaptive in its economical use of a limited resource.

Why do cubomedusae have only four swim pacemakers?

The classic view of swimming control in scyphozoan and cubozoan jellyfish involves a diffuse motor nerve net activated by multiple pacemaker sites that interact in a simple resetting hierarchy. Earlier modeling studies of jellyfish swimming, utilizing resetting linkages of multiple pacemakers, indicated that increases in pacemaker number were correlated with increases in the rate and regularity of network activity. We conducted a similar study using the cubozoan jellyfish Carybdea marsupialis, concentrating not only on the adaptive features of multiple pacemaker networks but also on the mechanism of pacemaker interaction. The best fit for our experimental data is a model in which pacemakers express a degree of independence. Thus, our results challenge the idea that pacemaker interactions in scyphozoan and cubozoan medusae are based on a strict resetting hierarchy. Furthermore, our data suggest that the combination of semi-independent linkage of pacemakers with the small pacemaker number characteristic of cubomedusae is important in (i) maintaining a biphasic modulatory capability in the swimming system, and (ii) allowing behaviorally appropriate directional responses to asymmetrical sensory inputs in the radially arranged jellyfish nervous system.

Defensive ink pigment processing and secretion in Aplysia californica: concentration and storage of phycoerythrobilin in the ink gland.

The marine snail Aplysia californica obtains its defensive ink exclusively from a diet of red seaweed. It stores the pigment (phycoerythrobilin, the red algal photosynthetic pigment, r-phycoerythrin, minus its protein) in muscular ink-release vesicles within the ink gland. Snails fed a diet of green seaweed or romaine lettuce do not secrete ink and their ink-release vesicles are largely devoid of ink. Successive activation of individual ink-release vesicles by ink motor neurons causes them to secrete approximately 55 % of their remaining ink (similar to the percentage of ink reserves released from the intact gland). The peripheral activation of vesicles appears to be cholinergic: 70 % of isolated vesicles were induced to squeeze ink from their valved end by solutions of acetylcholine at concentrations of 0.5 mmol l-1 or below. Ultrastructural analysis commonly found three cell types in the ink gland. The RER cells, the most numerous, were characterized by an extensive rough endoplasmic reticulum with greatly distended cisternae. This cell type is probably the site for synthesis of the high molecular mass protein of secreted ink. The granulate cells, less common than RER cells, had nuclear and cell areas significantly larger than those of RER cells. In addition, granulate cells of red-algal-fed snails had 4-14 vacuoles that contained electron-dense material with staining characteristics similar to that of ink in mature ink-release vesicles. The granulate cell's plasma membrane was regularly modified into grated areas, which both localized and expanded the surface area for coated vesicle formation and provided a sieve structure that prevented large particles in the hemolymph either from being taken up by, or from occluding, the coated vesicles. Electron-dense particles within coated vesicles were similar in size to those in granulate vacuoles but larger (on average by approximately 1 nm) than those that make up the ink. In green-seaweed-fed snails, granulate cells and their vacuoles were present but the vacuoles were empty. The third cell type, the vesicle cell, expands markedly, with its nucleus enlarging concurrent with cell growth until it is on average 50 times larger in cross-sectional area than the nuclei of either RER or granulate cells; the cytoplasm eventually becomes filled with ink, which obscures the mitochondria, vacuoles and nucleus. Continued cell expansion ceases with the appearance of an encircling layer of muscle and 1-3 layers of cells of unknown origin, thereby becoming the ink-release vesicle itself. The absorption spectra of the soluble contents of mature ink-release vesicles from snails fed red algae had peaks characteristic of the red algal pigment r-phycoerythrin or/and phycoerythrobilin. Immunogold localization of r-phycoerythrin showed no statistical difference in the amount of label within the ink-release vesicles, RER or granulate cell types. Furthermore, there was no localization of phycoerythrin immunoreactivity within the various cellular compartments of either the RER or granulate cells (nucleus, endoplasmic reticulum, mitochondria, vacuoles). Immunogold labeling in the ink gland ranged from 11 to 16 % of that for the digestive vacuoles of the rhodoplast digestive cells lining the tubules of the digestive gland. Our observations suggest (a) that the main form of the ink pigment in the gland is phycoerythrobilin or/and a non-antigenic form of phycoerythrin, and (b) that separation of the bilin from phycoerythrin (or its modification so that it is no longer antigenic) occurs before it reaches the ink gland, probably within the vacuoles of the rhodoplast digestive cells of the digestive gland. We propose the following model. The ink pigment, phycoerythrobilin, is cleaved from its protein in rhodoplast digestive vacuoles in the digestive gland. (ABSTRACT TRUNCATED)

Changes of synaptic efficacy in the medial geniculate nucleus as a result of auditory classical conditioning.

In this study we examined inputs to neurons in the medial subnucleus of the medial geniculate nucleus (mMG) for changes of synaptic efficacy associated with heart-rate conditioning to an auditory conditioned stimulus (CS). Conditioning-related changes of synaptic efficacy were measured in awake animals by examining mMG single-unit responses evoked by stimulation of one of two areas that send auditory CS and nonauditory information monosynaptically to the mMG, the brachium of the inferior colliculus (BlC) and the superior colliculus (SC). Synaptic efficacy was measured before, immediately after, and 1 hr after one session of classical conditioning with a tone CS and a corneal airpuff unconditioned stimulus. To determine whether conditioning produced changes of synaptic efficacy on the auditory BlC inputs to mMG cells and not general changes of cellular excitability, analyses of synaptic efficacy were performed on the mMG units that exhibited short-latency evoked responses (< 3.5 msec) to both BlC and SC stimulation. Analyses revealed that the BlC but not the SC test stimulus-evoked unit activity from the same neurons exhibited the following changes immediately after conditioning: decreases in unit response latency, increases in unit response reliability, and increases in spike frequency. BlC-evoked unit responses after pseudoconditioning did not exhibit these changes in unit responding. These results suggest that the synapses carrying auditory CS information to mMG neurons increase in strength as the result of associative conditioning with an acoustic CS. Some of these changes of synaptic efficacy remained 1 hr after training.

Ontogeny of serotonin-immunoreactive neurons in juvenile Aplysia california: implications for the development of learning.

Serotonin has been implicated in both nonassociative learning (sensitization and dishabituation) as well as associative learning (classical conditioning) in Aplysia californica. Dishabituation and sensitization, and their underlying physiological analogs, emerge according to different developmental timetables--sensitization develops 4 to 6 weeks after dishabituation (Rankin & Carew, 1988; Nolen & Carew, 1988; Wright, McCance, Lu, & Carew, 1991). Since the late emergence of sensitization could result from the delayed expression of facilitatory neurotransmitters, we have examined the ontogeny of serotonin immunoreactivity in juvenile A. californica by means of indirect immunohistofluorescence. The purpose of these experiments was to describe the developmental timetable for the expression of serotonin immunoreactivity and to correlate the emergence of immunoreactive neurons with the ontogenetic expression of different forms of learning. While the addition of serotonin-immunoreactive cells tracked the growth of the central nervous system, juveniles contained a relatively higher proportion of immunoreactive cells than adults. Immunoreactive cell bodies were present in the abdominal, cerebral, and pedal ganglia as early as juvenile Stage 9, prior to the emergence of dishabituation in Stage 10. The posterior cerebral cluster (PCC) contained four pairs of immunoreactive cells by Stage 9, including the facilitator CB1, which, as shown in adults, heterosynaptically facilitates siphon sensory neurons. The PCC reached the adult complement of five pairs of cells, by Stage 10, long before the development of sensitization, but at the time corresponding to the emergence of dishabituation. These results suggest that the late emergence of sensitization is not simply a consequence of the late expression of serotonergic facilitatory interneurons.

Behavioral dissociation of dishabituation, sensitization, and inhibition in Aplysia.

Three forms of nonassociative learning (habituation, dishabituation, and sensitization) have commonly been explained by a dual-process view in which a single decrementing process produces habituation and a single facilitatory process produces both dishabituation and sensitization. A key prediction of this view is that dishabituation and sensitization should always occur together. However, we show that dishabituation and sensitization, as well as an additional process, inhibition, can be behaviorally dissociated in Aplysia by (i) their differential time of onset, (ii) their differential sensitivity to stimulus intensity, and (iii) their differential emergence during development. A simple dual-process view cannot explain these results; rather, a multiprocess view appears necessary to account for nonassociative learning in Aplysia.

Development of behavior and learning in Aplysia.

A set of fundamental issues in neuroethology concerns the neural mechanisms underlying behavior and behavioral plasticity. We have recently analyzed these issues by combining a simple systems approach in the marine mollusc Aplysia with a developmental analysis aimed at examining the emergence and maturation of different forms of behavior and learning. We have focussed on two kinds of questions: 1) How are specific neural circuits developmentally assembled to mediate different types of behaviors? and 2) how is plasticity integrated with these circuits to give rise to different forms of learning? From our analysis of the development of learning and memory in Aplysia, several themes have emerged: 1) Different forms of learning emerge according to different developmental timetables. 2) Cellular analogs of learning have the same developmental timetables as their respective forms of behavioral learning. 3) An analysis of non-decremented responses prior to the emergence of sensitization reveals a novel inhibitory process on both behavioral and cellular levels. 4) Sensitization emerges simultaneously in diverse response systems, suggesting an underlying general process. 5) A widespread proliferation of central neurons occurs in the same developmental stage as the emergence of sensitization, raising the possibility that some aspect of the trigger for neuronal proliferation may also contribute to the expression of sensitization.

The cellular analog of sensitization in Aplysia emerges at the same time in development as behavioral sensitization.

Recent studies examining the development of learning and memory in the gill and siphon withdrawal reflex of Aplysia have shown that different forms of learning emerge according to very different developmental timetables. For example, in the previous paper, Rankin and Carew (1988) showed that, whereas habituation and dishabituation emerge early in juvenile development (in stages 9 and 10, respectively), sensitization emerges at least 60 d later (in late stage 12). This developmental separation of different learning processes provides the opportunity to examine the unique contribution of specific cellular mechanisms to each form of learning. As a first step in this cellular analysis, in the present paper we have examined the development of the cellular analog of sensitization (facilitation of nondecremented EPSPs) in the identified giant neuron R2, which can serve as a monitor of the afferent input in the gill and siphon withdrawal reflex (Rayport and Camardo, 1984). We have found 2 striking parallels between the development of behavioral sensitization and the development of its cellular analog: (1) Behavioral sensitization, produced by tail shock, emerges very late in juvenile development (stage 12), and the cellular analog of sensitization (produced by activation of the tail pathway) emerges by exactly the same late juvenile stage; (2) prior to the emergence of behavioral sensitization, tail shock unexpectedly was found to produce significant reflex depression (Rankin and Carew, 1988), and prior to the emergence of the cellular analog of sensitization, activation of the tail pathway was found to produce significant depression of the synaptic input in the reflex pathway. Thus, the cellular analog of sensitization in the CNS develops and matures in close temporal register with the development of behavioral sensitization in juvenile Aplysia.

Postsynaptic inhibition mediates high-frequency selectivity in the cricket Teleogryllus oceanicus: implications for flight phonotaxis behavior.

The frequency selectivity of the identified auditory interneuron, Int-1, in the cricket Teleogryllus oceanicus was examined using intracellular recording and staining techniques. Previous behavioral assays showed that crickets discriminate the low frequencies of the species calling song (4-5 kHz) from the high frequencies contained in the vocalizations of insectivorous bats (Nolen and Hoy, 1986a). Int-1 was excited by frequencies between 3 and 40 kHz, being similar, therefore, to the tympal organ (ear) in its broad range sensitivity; however, it responded differentially to high and low frequencies in terms of the number of action potentials evoked per stimulus tone pulse, the average discharge rate, and the latency of response. It was especially responsive to ultrasound (greater than 20 kHz), discharging at rates up to 400 spikes/sec (average rate), with 10 msec latencies; its response to pulses of the calling song was less than 150 spikes/sec, with 30 msec latencies. Int-1's dynamic range for ultrasound was also quite large, about 50 dB, compared to 20 dB for the calling song frequency. In addition, it responded well to trains of short, batlike pulses of ultrasound. These results are consistent with previous behavioral experiments showing that during flight, Int-1 was both necessary and sufficient for the ultrasound avoidance steering behavior (Nolen and Hoy, 1984), as long as it discharged above a rate of 180 spikes/sec. Ultrasound readily produced such high rates, whereas calling song rarely did; ultrasound reliably evoked avoidance steering over a wide dynamic range, while tone pulses of the calling song rarely did so (Nolen and Hoy, 1986a). A unique source of ipsilaterally mediated inhibition, tuned to the calling song frequency, accounted for the poor response to calling song and hence the neuron's high-frequency selectivity, and the behavioral and physiological effects of 2-tone suppression of high frequencies by the calling song (Nolen and Hoy, 1986b). These results further strengthen Int-1's proposed role as a "bat-detector" during flight and suggest only a limited role in other contexts such as social behavior.

Development of learning and memory in Aplysia. III. Central neuronal correlates.

The defensive withdrawal reflex of the mantle organs of Aplysia californica has 2 major components, siphon withdrawal and gill withdrawal. In the previous paper of this series (Rankin and Carew, 1987), the development of 2 forms of nonassociative learning, habituation and dishabituation, was examined in the siphon withdrawal component of the reflex. In the present study we examined these same forms of learning in the gill withdrawal component of the reflex. The purpose of these experiments was 2-fold: to examine the development of learning in the other major component of the reflex; and to establish preparations in which it is possible to carry out a cellular analysis of the development of learning in the CNS. We first established that the gill withdrawal reflex in intact animals exhibited significant habituation in response to repeated tactile stimulation of the siphon and significant dishabituation in response to tail shock. We next determined the contribution of the CNS to the gill withdrawal reflex by surgically removing the abdominal ganglion from intact animals. Using the same stimulus intensity (4 mg) that produced habituation in the previous experiments, we found that the CNS accounted for approximately 95% of the reflex. Finally, we developed 2 preparations that allowed us to relate behavioral observations of learning directly to neural plasticity exhibited in the CNS. In a semi-intact preparation gill withdrawal was behaviorally measured as in the intact animal, but tactile stimulation of the siphon (to produce habituation) and shock to the tail (to produce dishabituation) were replaced by electrical stimulation of the siphon nerve and left connective, respectively. Stimulation parameters were matched to produce behavioral responses comparable with those in the intact animal. In an isolated CNS preparation the same nerve stimuli were used as in the semi-intact preparation, but the response measure used was the evoked neural discharge recorded in an efferent nerve innervating the gill. Both preparations exhibited response decrement and facilitation that was quantitatively as well as qualitatively similar to that observed in intact animals, indicating that 2 simple forms of learning exhibited by the gill withdrawal reflex in juvenile Aplysia can be localized to neural circuits within the abdominal ganglion.

Phonotaxis in flying crickets. I. Attraction to the calling song and avoidance of bat-like ultrasound are discrete behaviors.

The steering responses of three species of field crickets, Teleogryllus oceanicus, T. commodus, and Gryllus bimaculatus, were characterized during tethered flight using single tone-pulses (rather than model calling song) presented at carrier frequencies from 3-100 kHz. This range of frequencies encompasses the natural songs of crickets (4-20 kHz, Fig. 1) as well as the echolocation cries of insectivorous bats (12-100 kHz). The single-pulse stimulus paradigm was necessary to assess the aversive nature of high carrier frequencies without introducing complications due to the attractive properties of repeated pulse stimuli such as model calling songs. Unlike the natural calling song, single tone-pulses were not attractive and did not elicit positive phonotactic steering even when presented at the calling song carrier frequency (Figs. 2, 3, and 9). In addition to temporal pattern, phonotactic steering was sensitive to carrier frequency as well as sound intensity. Three discrete flight steering behaviors positive phonotaxis, negative phonotaxis and evasion, were elicited by appropriate combinations of frequency, temporal pattern and sound intensity (Fig. 12). Positive phonotactic steering required a model calling song temporal pattern, was tuned to 5 kHz and was restricted to frequencies below 9 kHz. Negative phonotactic steering, similar to the 'early warning' bat-avoidance behavior of moths, was produced by low intensity (55 dB SPL) tone-pulses at frequencies between 12 and 100 kHz (Figs. 2, 3, and 9). In contrast to model calling song, single tone-pulses of high intensity 5-10 kHz elicited negative phonotactic steering; low intensity ultrasound (20-100 kHz) produced only negative phonotactic steering, regardless of pulse repetition pattern. 'Evasive', side-to-side steering, similar to the 'last-chance' bat-evasion behavior of moths was produced in response to high intensity (greater than 90 dB) ultrasound (20-100 kHz). Since the demonstration of negative phonotactic steering did not require the use of a calling song temporal pattern, avoidance of ultrasound cannot be the result of systematic errors in localizing an inherently attractive stimulus when presented at high carrier frequencies. Unlike attraction to model calling song, the ultrasound-mediated steering responses were of short latency (25-35 ms) and were produced in an open loop manner (Fig. 4), both properties of escape behaviors.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Phonotaxis in flying crickets. II. Physiological mechanisms of two-tone suppression of the high frequency avoidance steering behavior by the calling song.

The effects of two-tone stimuli on the high frequency bat-avoidance steering behavior of flying crickets (Teleogryllus oceanicus) were studied during tethered flight. Similarly, the effects of two-tone stimuli on the ultrasound sensitive auditory interneuron, Int-1, which elicits this behavior, were studied using intracellular staining and recording techniques. When a low frequency tone (3-8 kHz) was presented simultaneously with an aversive high frequency tone (in a two-tone stimulus paradigm), the high frequency avoidance steering behavior was suppressed. Suppression was optimal when the low frequency tone was between 4 and 5 kHz and about 10-15 dB louder than the high frequency tone (Figs. 2, 3). Best suppression occurred when the low frequency tone-pulse just preceded or overlapped the high frequency tone-pulse, indicating that the suppressive effects of 5 kHz could last for up to 70 ms (Fig. 4). The threshold for avoidance of the bat-like stimulus was elevated when model bat biosonar (30 kHz) was presented while the animal was performing positive phonotaxis toward 5 kHz model calling song, but only if the calling song intensity was relatively high (greater than 70-80 dB SPL) (Fig. 1). However, avoidance steering could always be elicited as long as the calling song was not more than 10 dB louder than the ultrasound (Fig. 1). This suppressive effect did not require performance of positive phonotaxis to the calling song (Fig. 2) and was probably due to the persistence of the suppressive effects of the 5 kHz model calling song (Fig. 4). The requirement for relatively high intensities of calling song suggest that the suppression of bat-avoidance by the calling song is not likely to be of great significance in nature. The high frequency harmonics of the male cricket's natural calling song overlap the lower frequency range used by insectivorous bats (10-20 kHz) and are loud enough to elicit avoidance behavior in a flying female as she closely approaches a singing male (Fig. 5). The high frequency 'harmonics' of a model calling song were aversive even if presented with a normally attractive temporal pattern (pulse repetition rate of 16 pps) (Fig. 6A). When the 5 kHz 'fundamental' was added to one of the high frequency 'harmonics', in a two-tone stimulus paradigm, this complex model calling song was attractive; the high frequency 'harmonic' no longer elicited the avoidance behavior (Fig. 6) and the animals steered toward the model CS. Thus, addition of 5 kHz to a high frequency harmonic of the calling song 'masked' the aversive nature of this stimulus.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Dendritic sprouting and compensatory synaptogenesis in an identified interneuron follow auditory deprivation in a cricket.

We examined the effect of chronic afferent deprivation on an identified interneuron (Int-1) in the auditory system of the Australian field cricket Teleogryllus oceanicus. In normal intact crickets, the auditory afferents from each ear terminate ipsilaterally onto a single Int-1. Each bilaterally paired Int-1 is excited by ultrasound stimulation of its ipsilateral ear but not by the contralateral ear. Unilateral removal of an ear early in postembryonic development deprives the developing Int-1 of ipsilateral auditory innervation. Consequently, the ipsilateral dendrites of the deprived interneuron sprout, grow aberrantly across the ganglionic midline, and terminate specifically in the intact auditory neuropile of the contralateral (unlesioned) side, where they form functional synapses with the contralateral afferents. This unusual compensatory dendritic sprouting restores auditory function to the neuron. Thus, it is demonstrated that the dendritic shape of an identified Int, as well as its synaptic connectivity, is altered as a consequence of chronic sensory deprivation.

Initiation of behavior by single neurons: the role of behavioral context.

Flying crickets avoid sources of ultrasound, possibly echolocating bats, by making rapid steering movements that turn them away from the stimulus. Electrical stimulation of a single, identified sensory interneuron (Int-1) elicits avoidance steering; depressing its response to ultrasound abolishes avoidance steering. Int-1 is necessary and sufficient for this behavior but only while the cricket is in flight. Thus, the sufficiency of Int-1 for eliciting this behavior is contingent on behavioral context.