Generative design approach to combine architected Voronoi foams with porous collagen scaffolds to create a tunable composite biomaterial.

Regenerative biomaterials for musculoskeletal defects must address multi-scale mechanical challenges. Repairing craniomaxillofacial bone defects, which are often large and irregularly shaped, requires close conformal contact between implant and defect margins to aid healing. While mineralized collagen scaffolds can promote mesenchymal stem cell osteogenic differentiation in vitro and bone formation in vivo, their mechanical performance is insufficient for surgical translation. We report a generative design approach to create scaffold-mesh composites by embedding a macro-scale polymeric Voronoi mesh into the mineralized collagen scaffold. The mechanics of architected foam reinforced composites are defined by a rigorous predictive moduli equation. We show biphasic composites localize strain during loading. Further, planar and 3D mesh-scaffold composites can be rapidly shaped to aid conformal fitting. Voronoi-based composites overcome traditional porosity-mechanics relationship limits while enabling rapid shaping of regenerative implants to conformally fit complex defects unique for individual patients. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Biomaterial strategies for (craniomaxillofacial) bone regeneration are often limited by the size and complex geometry of the defects. Voronoi structures are open-cell foams with tunable mechanical properties which have primarily been used computationally. We describe generative design strategies to create Voronoi foams via 3D-printing then embed them into an osteogenic mineralized collagen scaffold to form a multi-scale composite biomaterial. Voronoi structures have predictable and tailorable moduli, permit stain localization to defined regions of the composite, and permit conformal fitting to effect margins to aid surgical practicality and improve host-biomaterial interactions. Multi-scale composites based on Voronoi foams represent an adaptable design approach to address significant challenges to large-scale bone repair.

Generative design approach to combine architected Voronoi foams with porous collagen scaffolds to create a tunable composite biomaterial.

Regenerative biomaterials for musculoskeletal defects must address multi-scale mechanical challenges. We are developing biomaterials for craniomaxillofacial bone defects that are often large and irregularly shaped. These require close conformal contact between implant and defect margins to aid healing. While we have identified a mineralized collagen scaffold that promotes mesenchymal stem cell osteogenic differentiation in vitro and bone formation in vivo, its mechanical performance is insufficient for surgical translation. We report a generative design approach to create scaffold-mesh composites by embedding a macro-scale polymeric Voronoi mesh into the mineralized collagen scaffold. The mechanics of architected foam reinforced composites are defined by a rigorous predictive moduli equation. We show biphasic composites localize strain during loading. Further, planar and 3D mesh-scaffold composites can be rapidly shaped to aid conformal fitting. Voronoi-based composites overcome traditional porosity-mechanics relationship limits while enabling rapid shaping of regenerative implants to conformally fit complex defects unique for individual patients.

Inclusion of a 3D-printed Hyperelastic Bone mesh improves mechanical and osteogenic performance of a mineralized collagen scaffold.

Regenerative repair of craniomaxillofacial bone injuries is challenging due to both the large size and irregular shape of many defects. Mineralized collagen scaffolds have previously been shown to be a promising biomaterial implant to accelerate craniofacial bone regeneration in vivo. Here we describe inclusion of a 3D-printed polymer or ceramic-based mesh into a mineralized collagen scaffold to improve mechanical and biological activity. Mineralized collagen scaffolds were reinforced with 3D-printed Fluffy-PLG (ultraporous polylactide-co-glycolide co-polymer) or Hyperelastic Bone (90wt% calcium phosphate in PLG) meshes. We show degradation byproducts and acidic release from the printed structures have limited negative impact on the viability of mesenchymal stem cells. Further, inclusion of a mesh formed from Hyperelastic Bone generates a reinforced composite with significantly improved mechanical performance (elastic modulus, push-out strength). Composites formed from the mineralized collagen scaffold and either Hyperelastic Bone or Fluffy-PLG reinforcement both supported human bone-marrow derived mesenchymal stem cell osteogenesis and new bone formation. This was observed by increased mineral formation in Fluffy-PLG composites and increased cell viability and upregulation of RUNX2, Osterix, and COL1A2 genes in both composites. Strikingly, composites reinforced with Hyperelastic Bone mesh elicited significantly increased secretion of osteoprotegerin, a soluble glycoprotein and endogenous inhibitor of osteoclast activity. These results suggest that architectured meshes can be integrated into collagen scaffolds to boost mechanical performance and actively instruct cell processes that aid osteogenicity; specifically, secretion of a factor crucial to inhibiting osteoclast-mediated bone resorption. Future work will focus on further adapting the polymer mesh architecture to confer improved shape-fitting capacity as well as to investigate the role of polymer reinforcement on MSC-osteoclast interactions as a means to increase regenerative potential.

Anisotropic mineralized collagen scaffolds accelerate osteogenic response in a glycosaminoglycan-dependent fashion.

Regeneration of critically-sized craniofacial bone defects requires a template to promote cell activity and bone remodeling. However, induced regeneration becomes more challenging with increasing defect size. Methods of repair using allografts and autografts have inconsistent results, attributed to age-related regenerative capabilities of bone. We are developing a mineralized collagen scaffold to promote craniomaxillofacial bone regeneration as an alternative to repair. Here, we hypothesize modifying the pore anisotropy and glycosaminoglycan content of the scaffold will improve cell migration, viability, and subsequent bone formation. Using anisotropic and isotropic scaffold variants, we test the role of pore orientation on human mesenchymal stem cell (MSC) activity. We subsequently explore the role of glycosaminoglycan content, notably chondroitin-6-sulfate, chondroitin-4-sulfate, and heparin sulfate on mineralization. We find that while short term MSC migration and activity was not affected by pore orientation, increased bone mineral synthesis was observed in anisotropic scaffolds. Further, while scaffold glycosaminoglycan content did not impact cell viability, heparin sulfate and chondroitin-6-sulfate containing variants increased mineral formation at the late stage of in vitro culture, respectively. Overall, these findings show scaffold microstructural and proteoglycan modifications represent a powerful tool to improve MSC osteogenic activity.