Ignoring a basic pathophysiological mechanism of heart failure progression will not make it go away.

A link between heart failure (HF) and low thyroid hormone (TH) function has been known for over a century. Nonetheless, there is a general belief that TH treatment of patients with HF may not be worth the risk. This is largely based on two clinical trials where heart patients were treated with excessive doses of TH analogs, not actual THs. Further complicating the matter is the fact that normalization of THs in noncardiac patients can often be challenging. This issue is not going away as noted by a steady increase in TH-HF citations in recent years. In this article, we discuss what we know and how we may move the field forward.

Hormone resuscitation therapy for brain-dead donors - is insulin beneficial or detrimental?

Hormonal replacement therapy to brain-dead potential organ donors remains controversial. A retrospective study was carried out of hormonal therapy on procurement of organs in 63 593 donors in whom information on thyroid hormone therapy (triiodothyronine or levothyroxine [T3 /T4 ]) was available. In 40 124 donors, T3 /T4 and all other hormonal therapy were recorded. The percentage of all organs procured, except livers, was greater when T3 /T4 had been administered. An independent beneficial effect of antidiuretic hormone (ADH) was also clear. Corticosteroids were less consistently beneficial (most frequently when T3 /T4 had not been administered), although never detrimental. Insulin was almost never beneficial and at times was associated with a reduced yield of organs, particularly of the pancreas and intestine, an observation that does not appear to have been reported previously. In addition, there was reduced survival at 12 months of recipients of pancreases from T3 /T4 -treated donors, but not of pancreas grafts. The possibly detrimental effect observed following insulin therapy is discussed.

Thyroid hormone therapy and procurement of livers from brain-dead donors.

Hormonal therapy to brain-dead potential organ donors remains controversial. A retrospective study was carried out of hormonal therapy on procurement of organs in 63,593 donors in whom information on T3/T4 therapy was available. In 40,124 donors, T3/T4 and all other hormonal therapy was recorded. The percentages of all organs procured, except livers, were greater in T3/T4-treated donors. Nevertheless, if T3/T4 therapy had been administered to the donor, liver transplantation was associated with significantly increased graft and recipient survival at 1 month and 12 months. The potential reasons for the lack of effect of T3/T4 therapy on the number of livers procured are discussed.

Increased Procurement of Thoracic Donor Organs After Thyroid Hormone Therapy.

Hormonal therapy to the brain-dead organ donor can include thyroid hormone (triiodothyronine [T3] or levothyroxine [T4]), antidiuretic hormone, corticosteroids, or insulin. There has been a controversy on whether thyroid hormone enables more organs to be procured. Data on 63,593 donors of hearts and lungs (2000-2009) were retrospectively reviewed. Documentation on T3/T4 was available in all donors (study 1), and in 40,124 details of all 4 hormones were recorded (study 2). In this cohort, group A (23,022) received T3/T4 and group B (17,102) no T3/T4. Univariate analyses and multiple regressions were performed. Posttransplant graft and recipient survival at 1 and 12 months were compared. In study 1, 30,962 donors received T3/T4, with 36.59% providing a heart and 20.05% providing 1 or both lungs. Of the 32,631 donors who did not receive T3/T4, only 29.62% provided a heart and 14.61% provided lungs, an increase of 6.97% hearts and 5.44% lungs from T3/T4-treated donors (both P < 0.0001). In study 2, 34.99% of group A provided a heart and 20.99% provided lungs. In group B only 25.76% provided a heart and 15.09% provided lungs, an increase of 9.23% (hearts) and 5.90% (lungs), respectively, in group A (both P < 0.0001). The results of multiple regression analyses indicated a beneficial effect of T3/T4 on heart (P < 0.0001) and lung (P < 0.0001) procurement independent of other factors. T3/T4 therapy to the donor was associated with either improved posttransplant graft and recipient survival or no difference in survival. T3/T4 therapy results in more transplantable hearts and lungs, with no detriment to posttransplant graft or recipient survival.

The optimal hormonal replacement modality selection for multiple organ procurement from brain-dead organ donors.

The management of brain-dead organ donors is complex. The use of inotropic agents and replacement of depleted hormones (hormonal replacement therapy) is crucial for successful multiple organ procurement, yet the optimal hormonal replacement has not been identified, and the statistical adjustment to determine the best selection is not trivial. Traditional pair-wise comparisons between every pair of treatments, and multiple comparisons to all (MCA), are statistically conservative. Hsu's multiple comparisons with the best (MCB) - adapted from the Dunnett's multiple comparisons with control (MCC) - has been used for selecting the best treatment based on continuous variables. We selected the best hormonal replacement modality for successful multiple organ procurement using a two-step approach. First, we estimated the predicted margins by constructing generalized linear models (GLM) or generalized linear mixed models (GLMM), and then we applied the multiple comparison methods to identify the best hormonal replacement modality given that the testing of hormonal replacement modalities is independent. Based on 10-year data from the United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS), among 16 hormonal replacement modalities, and using the 95% simultaneous confidence intervals, we found that the combination of thyroid hormone, a corticosteroid, antidiuretic hormone, and insulin was the best modality for multiple organ procurement for transplantation.

Thyroid hormone therapy in the management of 63,593 brain-dead organ donors: a retrospective analysis.

BACKGROUND: Hormonal therapy to the brain-dead potential organ donor can include thyroid hormone (triiodothyronine [T3] or levothyroxine [T4]), corticosteroids, antidiuretic hormone, and insulin. METHODS: Data on 66,629 donors (2000-2009) were retrospectively reviewed. Documentation on T3/T4 was available in 63,593 (study 1), but 23,469 had incomplete documentation of other hormones. In 40,124, details of all four hormones were recorded (study 2). In this cohort, group A (received T3/T4) consisted of 23,022, and group B (no T3/T4) consisted of 17,102 donors. A multivariate analysis was performed to determine whether age, sex, ethnicity, cause of death, body mass index, Organ Procurement Organization region, or other hormonal therapy influenced procurement. Posttransplantation organ graft survival at 1 and 12 months was compared. RESULTS: In study 1, 30,962 (48.69%) received T3/T4, providing a mean of 3.35 organs per donor, and 32,631 (51.31%) did not receive T3/T4, providing a mean of 2.97 organs per donor, an increase of 12.8% of organs from T3/T4-treated donors (P<0.0001). In study 2, group A provided a mean of 3.31 organs per donor and group B provided a mean of 2.87 organs per donor, an increase of 15.3% in group A (P<0.0001). T3/T4 therapy was associated with procurement of significantly greater numbers of hearts, lungs, kidneys, pancreases, and intestines, but not livers. Multivariate analysis indicated a beneficial effect of T3/T4 independent of other factors (P<0.0001). T3/T4 therapy of the donor was associated with improved posttransplantation graft survival or no difference in survival, except for pancreas recipient (but not graft) survival at 12 months in study 2. CONCLUSION: T3/T4 therapy results in more transplantable organs, with no detriment to posttransplantation graft survival.

Thyroid hormone and the stunned myocardium.

Acute critically ill patients experience a rapid decline in plasma free thyroid hormone levels (free triiodothyronine (FT3) and free levothyroxine (FT4)), with a marked elevation of reverse T3, recognized as the euthyroid sick syndrome (ESS) or low-T3 syndrome. The ESS is also often associated with depressed myocardial function, sometimes referred to as the 'stunned myocardium'. Its clinical effects may vary from minimal hemodynamic impairment to cardiogenic shock. Medical management may range from aspirin alone to placement of a left ventricular assist device. With adequate supportive therapy, recovery usually occurs within days or weeks. The effect of T3/T4 therapy has been studied in three conditions in which the ESS and myocardial functional depression have been documented - i) transient regional myocardial ischemia and reperfusion, ii) transient global myocardial ischemia in patients undergoing cardiac surgery on cardiopulmonary bypass, and iii) transient inadequate global myocardial perfusion in brain-dead potential organ donors. Under all three conditions, myocardial ischemia leads to rapid loss of high-energy phosphates, accumulation of myocardial tissue lactate, and probably loss of homeostasis of cytosolic calcium, which may further increase cell injury. There is an inability to generate ATP through the Krebs cycle, which reduces the high-energy phosphate pool essential for all cell ATPases. Under all three conditions, following administration of T3/T4, the myocardial dysfunction was rapidly reversed. We, therefore, cautiously advocate the use of thyroid hormonal therapy to any patient with the ESS and/or a stunned myocardium.

Off-Pump coronary artery bypass surgery is associated with worse arterial and saphenous vein graft patency and less effective revascularization: Results from the Veterans Affairs Randomized On/Off Bypass (ROOBY) trial.

BACKGROUND: The Department of Veterans Affairs Randomized On/Off Bypass (ROOBY) trial compared clinical and angiographic outcomes in off-pump versus on-pump coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) surgery to ascertain the relative efficacy of the 2 techniques. METHODS AND RESULTS: From February 2002 to May 2007, the ROOBY trial randomized 2203 patients to off-pump versus on-pump CABG. Follow-up angiography was obtained in 685 off-pump (62%) and 685 on-pump (62%) patients. Angiograms were analyzed (blinded to treatment) for FitzGibbon classification (A=widely patent, B=flow limited, O=occluded) and effective revascularization. Effective revascularization was defined as follows: All 3 major coronary territories with significant disease were revascularized by a FitzGibbon A-quality graft to the major diseased artery, and there were no new postanastomotic lesions. Off-pump CABG resulted in lower FitzGibbon A patency rates than on-pump CABG for arterial conduits (85.8% versus 91.4%; P=0.003) and saphenous vein grafts (72.7% versus 80.4%; P<0.001). Fewer off-pump patients were effectively revascularized (50.1% versus 63.9% on-pump; P<0.001). Within each major coronary territory, effective revascularization was worse off pump than on pump (all P≤0.001). The 1-year adverse cardiac event rate was 16.4% in patients with ineffective revascularization versus 5.9% in patients with effective revascularization (P<0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Off-pump CABG resulted in significantly lower FitzGibbon A patency for arterial and saphenous vein graft conduits and less effective revascularization than on-pump CABG. At 1 year, patients with less effective revascularization had higher adverse event rates. CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRATION: URL: http://www.clinicaltrials.gov. Unique identifier: NCT00032630.

Outcomes after conversion in the Veterans Affairs randomized on versus off bypass trial.

BACKGROUND: The Randomized On versus Off Bypass trial reported conversion of 12.4% (n = 137) off-pump coronary artery bypass (OPCAB) patients and 3.6% (n = 40) on-pump cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) patients. This paper explored outcomes after conversions. METHODS: Elective and urgent CABG patients (n = 2,203) at 18 sites were studied. Randomization within 54 participating surgeons occurred preoperatively, after which conversion occurred if clinically indicated. Conversion reasons and outcomes were captured prospectively with additional details retrospectively extracted from patient records by a core clinical group. RESULTS: Conversion rates varied considerably across participating surgeons. Converted OPCAB patients had more right coronary disease and coronary targets less than 1.5 mm. Conversions were elective in 49.3% of cases, urgent in 27.2%, or emergent in 23.5%. Elective conversions were mainly for poor exposure-intramyocardial vessel (35.8%). Urgent and emergent conversions were usually for hemodynamic instability (89.2% and 75.0%, respectively). Compared with CPB and OPCAB patients, OPCAB-converted patients had more 30-day complications and deaths (composite outcome rate of 5.7% and 5.5% vs 17.5% respectively, p < 0.001). Thirty-day outcomes for OPCAB-converted patients trended worse for emergent versus elective conversions (31.3% vs 13.4%, respectively, p = 0.05). One-year composite outcome rate (death, nonfatal myocardial infarction or revascularization) in OPCAB-converted patients was worse than in CPB patients (13.5% vs 7.1%, p = 0.02), but similar to OPCAB-nonconverted (9.4%). CONCLUSIONS: The OPCAB patients requiring conversion had worse 30-day and 1-year outcomes. The OPCAB patients with right coronary artery disease or small targets were more often converted. The 30-day composite outcome trended worst for emergent OPCAB conversions.

Impact of endoscopic versus open saphenous vein harvest technique on late coronary artery bypass grafting patient outcomes in the ROOBY (Randomized On/Off Bypass) Trial.

OBJECTIVE: In the Randomized On/Off Bypass (ROOBY) Trial, the efficacy of on-pump versus off-pump coronary artery bypass grafting was evaluated. This ROOBY Trial planned subanalysis compared the effects on postbypass patient clinical outcomes and graft patency of endoscopic vein harvesting and open vein harvesting. METHODS: From April 2003 to April 2007, the technique used for saphenous vein graft harvesting was recorded in 1471 cases. Of these, 894 patients (341 endoscopic harvest and 553 open harvest) also underwent coronary angiography 1 year after coronary artery bypass grafting. Univariate and multivariable analyses were used to compare patient outcomes in the endoscopic and open groups. RESULTS: Preoperative patient characteristics were statistically similar between the endoscopic and open groups. Endoscopic vein harvest was used in 38% of the cases. There were no significant differences in both short-term and 1-year composite outcomes between the endoscopic and open groups. For patients with 1-year catheterization follow-up (n=894), the saphenous vein graft patency rate for the endoscopic group was lower than that in the open harvest group (74.5% vs 85.2%, P<.0001), and the repeat revascularization rate was significantly higher (6.7% vs 3.4%, P<.05). Multivariable regression documented no interaction effect between endoscopic approach and off-pump treatment. CONCLUSIONS: In the ROOBY Trial, endoscopic vein harvest was associated with lower 1-year saphenous vein graft patency and higher 1-year revascularization rates, independent of the use of off-pump or on-pump cardiac surgical approach.

Cognitive outcomes after on- versus off-pump coronary artery bypass surgery.

BACKGROUND: The Randomized On versus Off Bypass trial found no difference for a global cognitive outcome measure for patients receiving on-pump versus off-pump coronary artery bypass graft surgery (CABG). In this report, we present the baseline patient characteristics that were predictive of post-CABG cognitive decline as well as compare cognitive outcomes between treatment arms. METHODS: A neuropsychological battery was administered preoperatively and at 1 year after undergoing CABG. Stepwise regression was used to identify demographic or clinical risk factors associated with cognitive decline. Neuropsychological data were converted to demographically corrected T scores to provide impairment levels. RESULTS: Overall 1,156 patients (581 on-pump, 575 off-pump) completed match-paired neuropsychological assessments at baseline and 1-year follow-up. Baseline cognitive score, age, education level, and ethnicity predicted cognitive decline after CABG. Only 20% of either group had mild impairment at baseline on three of the test scores, and less than 10% had severe impairment on individual tests at either time. Few subjects in either group transitioned to clinically impaired levels at follow-up on individual tests. CONCLUSIONS: At baseline, lower cognitive function, older age, lower education, and ethnicity other than white were predictive of cognitive decline after CABG. Patients in both groups demonstrated low frequencies of cognitive impairment on individual tests at baseline and follow- up, and few patients in either group were classified as impaired at 1-year follow-up on individual tests. In general, the Randomized On versus Off Bypass study documented that neither on-pump nor off-pump CABG adversely impacts long-term brain function.

Chylopericardium presenting with tamponade and cardiogenic shock.

We are presenting a rare case of cardiogenic shock caused by chylopericardium. After the initial pericardial drainage and failed conservative treatment, thoracic duct ligation was performed with good long-term outcome. Literature on the subject is reviewed.

On-pump versus off-pump coronary-artery bypass surgery.

BACKGROUND: Coronary-artery bypass grafting (CABG) has traditionally been performed with the use of cardiopulmonary bypass (on-pump CABG). CABG without cardiopulmonary bypass (off-pump CABG) might reduce the number of complications related to the heart-lung machine. METHODS: We randomly assigned 2203 patients scheduled for urgent or elective CABG to either on-pump or off-pump procedures. The primary short-term end point was a composite of death or complications (reoperation, new mechanical support, cardiac arrest, coma, stroke, or renal failure) before discharge or within 30 days after surgery. The primary long-term end point was a composite of death from any cause, a repeat revascularization procedure, or a nonfatal myocardial infarction within 1 year after surgery. Secondary end points included the completeness of revascularization, graft patency at 1 year, neuropsychological outcomes, and the use of major resources. RESULTS: There was no significant difference between off-pump and on-pump CABG in the rate of the 30-day composite outcome (7.0% and 5.6%, respectively; P=0.19). The rate of the 1-year composite outcome was higher for off-pump than for on-pump CABG (9.9% vs. 7.4%, P=0.04). The proportion of patients with fewer grafts completed than originally planned was higher with off-pump CABG than with on-pump CABG (17.8% vs. 11.1%, P<0.001). Follow-up angiograms in 1371 patients who underwent 4093 grafts revealed that the overall rate of graft patency was lower in the off-pump group than in the on-pump group (82.6% vs. 87.8%, P<0.01). There were no treatment-based differences in neuropsychological outcomes or short-term use of major resources. CONCLUSIONS: At 1 year of follow-up, patients in the off-pump group had worse composite outcomes and poorer graft patency than did patients in the on-pump group. No significant differences between the techniques were found in neuropsychological outcomes or use of major resources. (ClinicalTrials.gov number, NCT00032630.).

Cardiac autotransplantation for removal of left atrial hemangioma and a review of the literature.

We describe the management of a patient who presented with symptoms of severe congestive heart failure. A 48-year-old man was initially seen in the emergency room, admitted to the hospital, and worked up with a transthoracic echocardiogram, a transesophageal echocardiogram, and a computer tomography scan of the chest. All cardiac valves were normal, as was the left ventricular ejection fraction. A mobile left atrial tumor measuring 6 x 4 x 5 cm was found attached to the left atrial dome, left atrial cuff, and left pulmonary veins. With each systolic atrial contraction, the mass prolapsed into the left ventricle across the mitral valve annulus, inducing a gradient of 19 mm Hg. The workup of the patient was negative for malignancy. The only feasible therapy for this patient was to excise the mass on cardiopulmonary bypass and cardioplegic arrest. At the time of surgery, the findings confirmed that the mass was attached broadly to the left atrial dome wall-epicardium, and the attachments were similar to those of the transesophageal echocardiographic findings. Atrial attachments extended from the base of the heart, along the atrioventricular groove, the left dome of the left atrium, the left atrial cuff, and the anterior aspect of both left pulmonary veins. The tumor could not be adequately excised, and reconstruction of the defect was not feasible with the heart in situ. We therefore decided to explant the heart and excise the tumor with a 0.5-cm margin of healthy tissue. The broad left atrial defect was reconstructed with bovine pericardium. The reconstruction encompassed the dome of the left atrium, the left atrial cuff, and the pulmonary veins. The heart was reimplanted back into the pericardial cavity. The superior vena cava with the retained sinus node was also anastomosed. The pathology diagnosis was a benign cavernous hemangioma. The sinus rhythm recovered following removal of the aortic cross-clamp and reperfusion of the heart. The patient had a rapid recovery and was discharged home on the 12th postoperative day. Placement of a pacemaker was not required because the patient retained the sinus rhythm. A review of the literature on cardiac autotransplantation revealed that this type of surgery has been performed frequently in centers that have a cardiac transplantation program or a surgeon who has cardiac transplantation experience. To our knowledge, this report is the first of cardiac autotransplantation for benign hemangioma.

A review of studies relating to thyroid hormone therapy in brain-dead organ donors.

An acute decrease in cardiac performance can result from a reduced free triiodothyronine (FT3) level following (i) brain death (euthyroid sick syndrome), (ii) a period of cardiopulmonary bypass, and possibly (iii) regional or global myocardial ischemia. The two major pathophysiologic effects of brain death are (i) vascular injury associated with the hemodynamic consequences of the autonomic 'storm', and (ii) a generalized inhibition of mitochondrial function, which results in diminished organ function from the loss of energy stores from a rapid loss of circulating FT3. Deterioration of donor organ function can be reversed by hormonal replacement therapy, in which T3 plays a critical role. This results in (i) an increased number of organs being functionally acceptable, and (ii) increased early and intermediate graft survival. Cardiopulmonary bypass is associated with a reduction in the circulating level of FT3, and this can be associated with deterioration in cardiac function. The administration of T3 at the time of discontinuation of cardiopulmonary bypass reverses this state. In patients undergoing heart transplantation, T3 therapy to both donor and recipient is beneficial.

Trasplante cardíaco / Heart Transplant

En 1985, en el Tampa General Hospital se inició el Programa de Trasplante Cardíaco. Hasta la fecha se realizaron 815 trasplantes en 795 pacientes, 17 de los cuales fueron sometidos a un retrasplante. La sobrevida actuarial al mes es del 94,5%, al año del 87%, a los 3 años alcanza el 81%, a los 5 años el 74% y a los 10 años el 52%. El Medical Review Board se reúne semanalmente para un seguimiento de la presentación de pacientes y la selección de los candidatos adecuados para el programa. Dentro de las varias Organ Procurement Organizations of the Region, la institución de terapia hormonal para el donante y el receptor está ampliamente aceptada. En el Tampa General Hospital también se le administra levotiroxina al receptor, en la sala de operaciones y en la sala de cuidados intensivos en la situación de un bajo volumen minuto. La mayoría de los trasplantes se efectúan en pacientes con estado 1A o 1B. La inmunosupresión es indicada por especialistas cardiólogos, lo mismo que la realización de la biopsia endomiocárdica con el fin de ajustar la medicación inmunosupresora. En esta revisión se presentan los resultados generales del programa, la selección de pacientes, los procedimientos quirúrgicos, la inmunosupresión y la asistencia que requieren los ventrículos.

In 1985 the Heart Transplant Program was initiated at the Tampa General Hospital. Up to date 815 transplants have been performed in 795 patients, of which 17 were re-transplanted. The survival rate at one month was 94.5%, one year 87%, 3 years 81%, 5 years 74%, and 10 years 52%. The Medical Review Board meets weekly for patient follow up and selection of the appropriate candidates for the program. Within the several Organ Procurement Organizations of the Region, institution of hormonal therapy for the donor and the receptor is widely accepted. At the Tampa General Hospital, levotiroxine is also administered to the receptor at the operating room and the intensive care unit under conditions of low minute volume. Most transplants are performed in patients of status 1A or 1B. Immunosupression is indicated by cardiologists, as well as the performance of endomyocardial biopsy in order to adjust immunosuppressant therapy. In this review, the general results of the program are being presented, as well as patient selection, surgical procedures, Immunosupression and required ventricle assistance.

A study design to assess the safety and efficacy of on-pump versus off-pump coronary bypass grafting: the ROOBY trial.

BACKGROUND: Since the late 1960s, coronary artery bypass graft (CABG-only) procedures were traditionally performed using a heart-lung machine on an arrested heart (on-pump). Over the past decade, an increasing number CABG-only procedures were performed on a beating heart (off-pump). Advocates of the off-pump approach expect to reduce many of the adverse side effects related to using the heart-lung machine, while advocates for the on-pump procedure raise concerns related to graft patency rates and long-term event-free survival for the off-pump technique. PURPOSE: The U.S. Department of Veteran Affairs (VA) Cooperative Studies Program funded a randomized, multicenter clinical trial comparing the clinical and resource-related outcomes following on-pump versus off-pump techniques for veterans undergoing a non-emergent CABG-only procedure. The planning committee was faced with several critically important challenges to assure feasibility of study costs and required sample size; generalizability to non-VA surgical practices; and comparability of clinically meaningful results. These challenges are discussed. METHODS: This study is a prospective, randomized, multicenter, single blinded (patient) clinical trial that compares on-pump and off-pump techniques for veterans requiring non-emergent CABG-only procedures. There will be 2200 patients randomized at 17 VA Medical Centers when the five-year recruitment period ends on 15 April 2007. There are two primary objectives: a short-term objective to assess the immediate impact of the two techniques on 30-day mortality/morbidity and a long-term objective to assess one-year mortality/morbidity. Major secondary outcomes are one-year graft patency rates and change in neuropsychological assessments from baseline to one year. All patients are assessed at 30 days post-surgery or discharge from the hospital, whichever is latest, and at one-year post-surgery. RESULTS: During planning, several key issues had to be decided. These included 1) choosing primary objectives: a short-term (30-day) and a long-term (one-year) objective were chosen; 2) choosing primary outcome measures: composite measures were selected to ensure sufficient end-points; 3) standardization of surgical techniques: minimal standardization required but guidelines and continuing discussions on both techniques provided; 4) establishing criteria for surgeons and residents for participation: surgeons required to have completed 20 off-pump procedures prior to doing study procedures and residents, in presence of study surgeon, capable of doing either procedure; 5) identifying metrics of cognitive dysfunction sensitive to treatment: a neuropshychologist hired who centrally monitors cognitive functioning testing; and 6) blinding participants of surgical procedure: attempt to blind participants. LIMITATIONS: Areas of concern are whether all surgeons sufficiently experienced on the off-pump procedure, should residents have been allowed to do study surgeries, should techniques have been standardized more and were the best neurocognitive tests selected. CONCLUSION: The study design presented allows for a balanced and fair assessment of the on-pump and off-pump CABG procedures across a diversity of clinical outcomes and resource use metrics. Its results have the potential to influence clinical cardiac surgical practice in the future.