Clinical audit of intra-partum care at secondary health facilities in Nigeria.

OBJECTIVE: Intra-partum care has a significant influence on birth outcomes. Gap however exists between evidence and practice. This study documented pattern of intra-partum monitoring among birth attendants in public secondary healthcare facilities and related findings to quality of care provided. METHOD: Intra-partum monitoring records of vaginal examination, fetal heart and blood pressure were reviewed. Research assistants extracted information and documented same in appropriate section of Safe Motherhood Needs Assessment forms. Monitoring records were categorized into optimal and sub-optimal care. Proportions were calculated for parturients who received either optimal or sub-optimal care. Chi-square test of statistics was used to explore differences. Level of significance was p < 0.05. RESULT: Areview of 349 records of paturients was carried out. Their mean age was 23.4 +/- 3.3 years. Pregnancy outcome was a live-birth in 329 (97.3%). Optimal care of vaginal examination, fetal heart monitoring and blood pressure measurement was provided in 243 (71.9%), 73 (21.6%) and 52 (15.4%) parturients respectively and diminished significantly as labour progressed. CONCLUSION: Intra-partum care provided by birth attendants was generally sub-optimal and use of the monitoring records to influence birth outcome is doubtful. Improvement in record keeping practices and skills in intra-partum monitoring for decision making, are suggested.

The effect of training on the reporting of notifiable diseases among health workers in Yobe State, Nigeria.

The generation of data through disease surveillance and notification system is critical to appropriate planning and implementation of disease control programmes, outbreak investigation, emergency preparedness and response. Health workers therefore need to be trained, retrained and updated on the principles and practice of disease surveillance and notification. This quasi-experimental study compared a study and control group "before and after" an intervention (training programme) in the study group. The Experimental and control LGA's were selected using a multistage, stratified random sampling technique. Overall, three LGA's were selected and enrolled in each of the groups. In each of the selected LGA's, all functional health facilities and personnel that fulfilled the inclusion criteria were then included in the study. The total number of participants in the experimental and control groups were 73 and 71 respectively at baseline. The proportion of personnel who were aware of the surveillance system increased from 35.6% to 91.9% (p=0.00) and the mean knowledge score increased from 0.85+/-1.38SD to 6.152.64SD (p=0.00) post intervention in the experimental group. The percentage completeness was 2.3% before and 52.0% after (p-0.00), while the percentage timeliness was 0.0% before and 42.9% after (p=0.00) in the experimental group. These statistically significant differences were however not demonstrated in the control group. Training therefore had a positive effect on health personnel knowledge, reporting requirement and the timeliness and completeness of the disease surveillance and notification system.

Patient satisfaction with the services provided at a general outpatients' clinic, Ibadan, Oyo State, Nigeria.

Patient-based assessments of medical care are increasingly being used to measure the quality of health care. A variety of methods - qualitative and quantitative - are available. However, patient satisfaction surveys are frequently used. Triangulation of methods increases both the validity and reliability of data. This study assessed patients' perception of care provided at an outpatient clinic using triangulation of methods. No evaluation of care provided at this clinic has been carried out since established. Four hundred and seven adult patients selected by systematic sampling technique were interviewed, 10 focus group discussion sessions (FGD) were held and observations were made at the record clerks' desk, nurses' desk and waiting hall. Also, 35 consultations were observed. Generally, all methods revealed high level of satisfaction with the different aspects of care assessed. However, assessment of satisfaction using survey method concealed a variety of negative experiences reported at FGD and observation. These discrepancies were related to satisfaction with the organization of the clinic, attitude of record clerks' and consultation process. The study provided valuable information to assist in improving the quality of care at the clinic; specifically, the long waiting time, attitude of the record clerks, the dearth of basic amenities, deficient patient-doctor communication skills and health promotion services.

The knowledge, attitude and practices of the reporting of notifiable diseases among health workers in Yobe State, Nigeria.

Effective surveillance is the key to effective disease control in the community. In Nigeria, it is weak with duplication of data collection and multiple reporting channels. There is also lack of clarity with regards to data submission responsibilities. However, the knowledge of reporting requirements and responsibilities among health personnel has not been examined adequately as a cause of under reporting. This study was designed to assess the knowledge of health workers about disease surveillance. A cross sectional study was conducted in six randomly selected local government areas in Yobe State, North Eastern Nigeria. A total of 144 health personnel from 88 health facilities were administered a pre-tested semi-structured questionnaire and a checklist by trained research assistants. The result showed that only fifty-five (38.2%) of the respondents were aware of the national disease surveillance system. Their mean score regarding immediate notifiable diseases was 0.8 +/- 1.23 SD (maximum of 10). Thirty nine (70.9%) reported to have ever reported, while 16 (29.1%) have never reported any of the notifiable conditions. Only 12 (21.8%) of the respondents claimed to have ever received feedback on the reports they forward to higher authorities and more than 92% of the health facilities lack the DSN 001 and 002 forms. Most of the respondents 47 (85.5%) that were aware of the reporting requirements listed lack of training on disease surveillance as one of the factors affecting disease reporting. This shows that lack of knowledge of reporting requirement was identified as a major factor affecting disease surveillance among the respondents. The training and retraining of health workers responsible for data generation, collection and forwarding in health facilities on disease notification, regular feedback on diseases reported and provision of forms were recommended in order to improve the disease surveillance system.

Village health workers' and traditional birth attendants' record keeping practices in two rural LGAs in Oyo State, Nigeria.

Village health workers (VHWs) and Traditional Birth attendants (TBAs) provide health care services to the communities in which they live, improving access to health care as well as serving as an important link between the periphery (the communities) and the health sector. The data this category of workers generates about their communities will strengthen primary health care management information system in Nigeria. The objective of this study was to assess the knowledge, attitude and practices of VHWs and TBAs regarding record keeping in Ibarapa Central and Akinyele local government areas (LGAs) of Oyo State, Nigeria. Using a pre-tested, semi structured questionnaire and an observation checklist, trained research assistants visited and interviewed all the active, registered VHWs and TBAs in the two LGAs. Results showed that there were a total of 62 and 102 active VHWs/TBAs in Ibarapa Central and Akinyele LGAs respectively with most of them being farmers aged between 30-59 years. Over two-thirds in both LGAs knew the uses of record keeping for monitoring and evaluation purposes and most of them felt that keeping records was easy. Sixty-one percent of the respondents in Ibarapa Central and 96% of those in Akinyele LGA reported keeping records of their health activities. Of those who kept records, two thirds in Ibarapa Central and almost all (96%) in Akinyele LGA reported forwarding the records they keep. The type of records they keep was mostly on patients' treatment and (in Akinyele) delivery records using an exercise book. Most did not have the VHW/TBA record of work or the community profiles (wall chats) developed and recommended by the Federal Ministry of Health (FMOH) because they were not supplied. The factors associated with record keeping included duration as a VHW/TBA, previous training on record keeping, receiving feedback. Recommendations made included ensuring availability of materials and periodic training and re-training of the VHWs/TBAs by the LGAs, and regular provision of feedback by the National Primary Health Care Development Agency (NPHCDA).

A survey of the medical and dental consultants' management skills in University College Hospital, Ibadan, Nigeria.

Good management/administration is vital in the realisation of any business objective whether in a private or public establishment. The aims of this study were to assess the level of knowledge and ability on management/administrative skills by Medical/Dental consultants as perceived by themselves; to stimulate more interest in management/administrative skills acquisition, and to suggest possible ways in achieving such skills by doctors. A self-evaluation questionnaire was distributed to the doctors and 88 of them completed and returned their forms. They consisted of 55 (62.5%) males and 33 (37.5%) females cutting across all the specialities in medicine and dentistry in the University College Hospital, Ibadan, Nigeria. In all, 42 (47.7%) of the respondents reported that they had good ability of management/administration while 46 (52.3%) were below average. Of the 55 males, 28 (31.8%) had good ability while 27 (30.7%) were below average. Fourteen (15.9%) of the females had good ability while (21.6%) were below average. Good knowledge was assumed by 41 (46.6%) of the respondents while 47 (53.4%) were below average. Twenty-seven (30.7%) of the males showed good knowledge as against 14 (15.9%) of the females. Twenty-eight (31.8%) of the males were below average as against 19 (21.6%) of the female respondents. The sex differences were not statistically significant (P>0.05). The surgeons significantly (P<0.05) claimed better knowledge of management/administrative skills than physicians though their claim of ability to perform was higher too but significant (P>0.05). The percentage of the consultants with good knowledge and ability was found to increase with increasing age except for those under 40 years of age. The differences were not significant (P>0.05). A strong positive correlation (r=0.948; P<0.001) was found between ability and knowledge. Knowledge of the respondents was found to be good predictor of the ability using the regression equation: Ability = 11.151 + 0.835 (Knowledge). Suggestions on possible way forward were made. It was concluded that improving the knowledge of the doctors while in training on management/administrative skills will positively affect their performance abilities.

Voluntary health workers' knowledge, attitude and practices regarding record keeping in Akinyele LGA of Oyo State, Nigeria.

Lack of basic health data for monitoring and evaluation of health services continue to affect the planning, implementation and evaluation of health services in Nigeria. This has contributed to the poor health status and inefficient health services in the country. In the primary health care management information system (PHCMIS), Voluntary Village Health Workers (VHWs) and Traditional Birth Attendants (TBAs) are responsible for collecting information at the community/village level. Trained research assistants administered a pretested semi structured questionnaire and filled an observation checklist to all the voluntary health workers in Akinyele LGA of Oyo State in a cross-sectional survey conducted to assess their record keeping practices as well as their knowledge of and attitude towards it. Results showed that almost half of the respondents had no formal education and a similar proportion had been VHWs for between over 10 years. Over eighty per cent knew the uses of record keeping for monitoring and evaluation purposes. Their attitude towards it was positive and almost all felt it was easy to keep records. Ninety six percent keep records of their health activities and most forward them. It was observed that only 11 (10.8%) respondents had the VHW/TBA record of work produced and recommended by the Federal Ministry of Health because they were reportedly not supplied to them. The factors that were associated with record keeping practices were positive attitude towards record keeping, duration of work as a VHW/TBA, prior training on record keeping and receiving feedback on records kept. Recommendations made included periodic training and retraining of the VHWs on record keeping, ensuring consistent supply of record forms and providing regular feedback on records kept to the VHWs.

Morbidity in rural southwestern Nigeria: a one year follow up of voluntary health worker consultations in Idere, Oyo State, Nigeria.

There is paucity of information on morbidity pattern at the community level in Nigeria. Available literature shows that most are based on hospital data from which rates cannot be generated. In addition, the low access to hospitals in the country especially in rural areas, coupled with inappropriate health care seeking behaviour in the community limits the usefulness of information derived from hospital data. This study was aimed at determining disease patterns in a rural community in Nigeria using the records of voluntary health workers. We followed up a well-defined rural community for one year and collated records of active voluntary health workers (VHWs) who provide health care to these communities. Results showed that Malaria, upper respiratory tract infections (URTI), diarrhoea, measles and accidents were the most common ailments for which the community members sought health care. The annual morbidity rates were malaria 25.4%, URTI 6.0%, accidents 3.2%, and diarrhoea 2.7%. Rates generally decrease with increasing age, except for accidents, for which the rates were highest amongst school-aged children (5-14 years) and lowest amongst adults. Recommendations made include strengthening malaria control efforts, improving routine immunization coverage and providing health education regarding accident prevention.

Outbreak of cholera in Ibadan, Nigeria.

The changing epidemiology of cholera in Ibadan, Nigeria, has become a public health challenge, and outbreaks of the disease have been occurring with increasing frequency since the first outbreak in modern times in 1970. In this outbreak, 1384 persons were seen, diagnosed and treated for the disease at the cholera unit, Ibadan from January to December 1996. The outbreak lasted for a whole year. No child under one year was seen. The age adjusted case fatality rate was 5.3%. Diarrhoea and vomiting were the most common combination of symptoms present in 97.3% of all cases, followed by diarrhoea, vomiting and dehydration (84.3%). The median number of days spent on admission was only 2 days. Cholera cases were clustered within the densely populated and poorly planned areas of the city. Though significantly more cases were seen during the rainy season than during the dry season (p<0.01), the deaths were not seasonally related (p = 0.67). Contamination of otherwise potable sources of water, late presentation to the cholera treatment unit and low levels of knowledge about diseases need to be addressed in order to effectively control this disease in the community. Progress should also be made towards developing a suitable vaccine for the control of this internationally important public health disease so that the responsibility of its control is not left entirely to individuals and communities, particularly in developing countries.

An assessment of national needs for community physician manpower in Nigeria: staff training needs and programmes.

This second part of a national survey was designed to identify the training needs and programmes considered most appropriate by the most senior health management staff of the state governments for the field practice of community medicine in Nigeria. The operation of the current primary health care programme and the field practice of community medicine although constitutionally a local government responsibility, effectively rests on the state governments at present because of economic and political constraints at the LG level. The main needs identified in the study are for a certifiable and appropriate generalist community physician training programme as well as the relative levels of emphasis needed in the different sub-specialty areas. While holders of the current fellowship diploma in public health of the National Postgraduate Medical College of Nigeria are welcome to practice in the field if they are available, many state governments and officials consider the programme ill-suited to the needs of field practice community physicians. Thirteen (68.4% of the) respondents, consider it suitable only for jobs at state employment levels and higher up. Twelve of the 17 physician respondents considered clinical practice essential for all community physicians. Eighteen of the 21 state governments would be ready to sponsor their physician candidates to local training programmes in public health as identified in this study, if different from the current postgraduate fellowship. Maternal and child health was the area of sub-specialty training considered most needed in the states. This was followed by epidemiology, environmental health, health education, health and biostatistics, health management, and occupational health in that order.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

The distribution of hepatitis B surface antigen in Africa and the tropics: report of a population study in Nigeria.

This preliminary study was designed to examine the distribution of hepatitis B surface antigen (HBsAg) in two contrasting groups in an urban area situated in the tropical forest belt. The sample from the traditional area represents a population of low socio-economic status, living in the central slum areas of the city, and the sample from the peripheral area represents a population of high socio-economic status living in clean modern estates. The prevalence rate of HBsAg by complement fixation (CF) was 12-6 per cent in both areas. There was no statistically significant difference between the two groups with respect to prevalence of the antigen. When both groups were combined, no significant relationship was found between the presence of the antigen and sex, age, marital status, level of education, occupation, income, and a presumed exposure to the antigen from injections, dental treatment, blood tests, surgical operations, blood donations, tribal, (medicinal), tattoo and cosmetic marking, insanitary disposal of faeces, doubtful sources of water supply, and exposure to mosquitoes. No association with genotype was found.