Comparison of renal ablation with cryotherapy, dry radiofrequency, and saline augmented radiofrequency in a porcine model.

BACKGROUND: Needle ablative therapy has recently generated a lot of interest in the urologic community. We compare renal lesions produced in a porcine model using three forms of needle ablative energy: cryoablation (CR), dry radiofrequency (RF), and saline augmented radiofrequency (SARF). STUDY DESIGN: In 10 farm pigs, under ultrasonographic guidance, 40 laparoscopic renal lesions were produced: 825-mm CR lesions were produced with 2.4-mm cryoprobes (Endocare Inc, Irvine, CA), after 1-mL preinfusions of 14.6% saline, 12 SARF lesions were created with 22-gauge needles (2 mL/minute 14.6% saline, 50 W 510 kHz RF for 60 seconds), 12 RF lesions were created with a 2-cm array LeVeen electrode and an RF2000 generator using impedance limited 30 to 60 W double activations (Radiotherapeutics Corp, Mountain View, CA), and 8 RF lesions were produced using 22-gauge needles and double 10 W activations with the RF2000 generator. Eight animals were sacrificed after 1 week for acute pathology. An additional two animals were sacrificed at 8 weeks to provide chronic pathology results for the LeVeen dry RF and SARF modalities. RESULTS: CR produced a regular 18- to 22-mm zone of complete necrosis bordered by a 1.5- to 2.5-mm zone of partial necrosis. Acutely, LeVeen RF and single-needle RF produced lesions 25 to 45 mm and 6 to 10 mm wide, respectively. Acutely, SARF produced irregular cone-shaped lesions 15 to 31 mm wide. Only one of eight acute LeVeen RF lesions showed complete necrosis; none of the four 8-week LeVeen RF lesions displayed complete necrosis. Two of the four 8-week SARF lesions displayed complete necrosis. The remainder of the LeVeen RF, single-needle RF, and SARF lesions showed early, indeterminate tubular damage with relative glomerular sparing and bands of complete necrosis (0.5 to 1.5 mm) and inflammation (0.5 to 2 mm) at the periphery. Only CR could be consistently monitored with laparoscopic ultrasonography. CONCLUSIONS: Renal cryoablation produces well-defined, completely necrotic lesions that can be monitored reliably with ultrasonography. Longer followup may be required to characterize the full extent of renal necrosis produced by RF, but in the short run, none of the RF modalities reliably produced 100% necrosis in all cases.

Flexible ureteroscopic lithotripsy: first-line therapy for proximal ureteral and renal calculi in the morbidly obese and superobese patient.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: The surgical treatment of kidney and proximal ureteral stones in morbidly obese patients (>14 kg/m2) remains difficult because shockwave lithotripsy is precluded by weight limitations and percutaneous nephrolithotomy is associated with difficult access and a high (9%) rate of transfusion. We review our experience with retrograde ureteroscopic lithotripsy in morbidly obese patients with renal and proximal ureteral stones. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Between December 1992 and April 2000, five women and three men with a mean age of 46.5 years (range 33-68 years) and a mean body mass index of 54 (range 45-65.2) underwent 10 independent ureteroscopic procedures for urolithiasis. The average stone size was 11.1 mm (range 5-25 mm). Lithotripsy was performed with the holmium laser in eight patients (60%) the electrohydraulic lithotripter in four (30%), and the tunable-dye laser in the remaining patient. Stone-free status was defined as no stones visible on a plain film with nephrotomograms or CT scan at 3 months. RESULTS: The mean operation time was 101 minutes (range 45-160 minutes), and 60% of the procedures were done on an outpatient basis. After the initial procedure, the stone-free rate was 70%. Two patients had fragments <4 mm, and no further therapy was undertaken. There was one complication: transient renal insufficiency (serum creatinine concentration 3.7 mg/dL) secondary to aminoglycoside toxicity. No transfusions were needed. CONCLUSION: In the morbidly obese patient with symptomatic stones <1.5 cm, ureteroscopic lithotripsy is safe, successful, and efficient.

Assessment of optimal balloon size for rupture of the ureteropelvic junction and mid-ureter in a porcine model.

PURPOSE: Balloon dilation potentially represents a safer and simpler technique for the treatment of ureteropelvic junction (UPJ) obstruction and ureteral strictures. Using a porcine model, we sought to establish the optimal balloon size for endoballoon rupture of the UPJ and ureter. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The efficacy of endoballoon rupture of the proximal and middle ureter with 24F, 30F, and 36F balloon catheters was compared in 19 female minipigs. At the proximal ureter, the effect of the rate of dilation also was evaluated for each balloon size. Extravasation of methylene blue-stained contrast material was assessed with retrograde pyelograms and direct laparoscopic vision. After acute sacrifice, the dilated segments were evaluated histologically with hematoxylin and eosin and Masson's trichrome staining. RESULTS: At the proximal ureter, free extravasation of contrast was observed in 61% of the rapid inflation and 72% of the slow inflation trials; contained extravasation was noted in 28% of the rapid inflation and 17% of the slow inflation trials. Except for two of the 24F slow inflation trials, all of the proximal ureteral trials produced at least one full-thickness tear into the periureteral fat. Grossly, the tears appeared linear with various lengths and no consistent orientation. Rapid inflation and increasing balloon size tended to produce a ureterotomy with less damage to the ureter surrounding the tear. At the mid-ureter, none of the balloon sizes consistently produced a transmural tear. CONCLUSIONS: Rapid dilation and use of a 36F balloon capable of maintaining a low profile after inflation may result in a cleaner proximal ureterotomy with less distortion of the untorn neighboring proximal ureter. Both 36F and 30F balloons consistently produced a full-thickness proximal ureterotomy in normal porcine tissue. For mid-ureteral strictures, balloon dilation to even 36F may fail to create a suitable ureterotomy. However, it must be noted that dysplastic or scarred tissue may respond differently to dilation than the more elastic normal porcine tissues used in this study.

Evaluation of a chronic indwelling prototype mesh ureteral stent in a porcine model.

OBJECTIVES: Ureteral stents all share one general goal, drainage, and one major drawback, irritative symptoms in the kidney and bladder. In an effort to preserve drainage while minimizing irritation, a lightweight, self-expanding mesh stent was designed. Herein, we compare the in vivo tissue reaction and flow characteristics of the mesh stent to a standard 7F double-pigtail polyurethane stent. METHODS: Eight female Yucatan minipigs had bilateral stents placed: a mesh stent on one side and a standard 7F stent on the opposite side. Imaging and flow measurements were obtained in 4 pigs at 1 week and in another 4 pigs at 6 weeks. Following this procedure, the stents were removed, and the kidneys, ureters, and bladder were harvested en bloc for a blinded histopathologic analysis. RESULTS: The degree of stent-related tissue reactivity was low for both stents and appeared similar for the ureter and bladder. Overall, the mesh stent resulted in a decrease in inflammation along the urinary tract at 1 week, but this result was statistically insignificant (P = 0.55). Flow rate through the mesh stent tended to be greater than for the polyurethane stent both at 1 week and at 6 weeks. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, the mesh stent appeared to be well tolerated and provided for excellent flow.

Flow characteristics of 3 unique ureteral stents: investigation of a Poiseuille flow pattern.

PURPOSE: The pattern of flow in the stented ureter (intraluminal and/or extra luminal) has only been defined for the standard pigtail stent. No data are available on stent flow for any specialty stents. To our knowledge we present the first investigation characterizing the type of flow through a stent (Poiseuille versus nonPoiseuille flow). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Flow was measured in an unstented ureter, a standard 7Fr double pigtail stent and the 7/3Fr Tail stent, 7Fr Spirastent and 14/7Fr endopyelotomy stent using a previously developed stent flow model. In vitro pressure flow studies were also done in nonfenestrated 14/7Fr, Tail and standard 7Fr stents. These stents were infused at a constant flow rate of 2 to 10 ml. per minute with monitoring of the corresponding pressure gradients. Resistance to flow was determined for these stents using pressure flow plots and Poiseuille's law. RESULTS: In vivo the 7Fr pigtail, 14/7Fr endopyelotomy and 7/3Fr Tail stents had statistically similar flow rates. Flow through each of these stents exceeded the flow through an unstented ureter. The Spirastent had the least flow in all categories tested. There was no correlation of Poiseuille flow parameters measured in vitro for nonfenestrated stents with in vivo stent flow. CONCLUSIONS: In stented ureters fluid drains through and around the stent regardless of its design. The flow characteristics of these 3 specialty stents were not predictable according to lumen or stent size. In vitro Poiseuille's flow did not correlate with in vivo stent flow.

Laparoscopic renal ablation: an in vitro comparison of currently available electrical tissue morcellators.

OBJECTIVES: Morcellation with the Cook high-speed electrical laparoscopic (HSEL) morcellator in an impermeable nylon/plastic sack (LapSac) has remained unchanged since its inception nearly one decade ago. Sack deployment and specimen entrapment remain relatively difficult, and morcellation with this device is expensive and relatively slow. As such, in an effort to facilitate specimen entrapment and morcellation, we adapted two currently available electrical morcellators (the Steiner gynecologic morcellator and the electrical prostate morcellator [EPM]) for renal morcellation and compared them with the HSEL morcellator. METHODS: All morcellation was performed through a simulated abdominal wall under direct laparoscopic vision. Ten porcine kidneys were ablated with each of the following techniques: HSEL morcellation in a LapSac; HSEL morcellation in a fluid-filled LapSac; Steiner morcellation in an insufflated Endocatch sack; and EPM morcellation in a fluid-filled Endocatch sack. A modified laparoscopic trocar was constructed and used for the Steiner and EPM morcellation. The time to complete morcellation, morcellation product size, and entrapment sack integrity were evaluated for each technique. Cost data for each morcellator are also presented. RESULTS: The mean morcellation time for the Steiner, HSEL dry, HSEL wet, and EPM morcellation was 6.0, 15.9, 14.7, and 26.0 minutes, respectively. The mean fragment size for these morcellators was 2.97, 0.65, 0.62, and 0.013 g, respectively. A single entrapment sack perforation was documented in a LapSac during routine HSEL morcellation. CONCLUSIONS: Renal morcellation with all three morcellators is feasible. The Steiner morcellator combined with an Endocatch resulted in more rapid morcellation and larger morcellation products.

Flexible ureteroscopes: a single center evaluation of the durability and function of the new endoscopes smaller than 9Fr.

PURPOSE: Flexible ureteroscopes smaller than 9Fr are widely used in endourology. We systematically evaluated the functional durability of these instruments in the clinical setting. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We performed ureteronephroscopy 92 consecutive times in 84 patients at our hospital using a flexible Storz model 11274AA,double dagger Circon-ACMI model AUR-7, section sign Wolf model 7325.172 parallel and Olympus model URF/P3 ureteroscope paragraph sign. Preoperatively and postoperatively we evaluated all flexible ureteroscopes for luminosity, irrigant flow at 100 mm. Hg, number of broken image fibers and active deflection range. During the procedure a record was kept of the duration that the endoscope remained in the urinary tract, average irrigation pressure, method of insertion, various devices used within the working channel, need for lower pole access, and surgeon overall impression of visibility and maneuverability. RESULTS: The luminosity and irrigant flow of all endoscopes remained relatively unchanged during consecutive applications, while active deflection deteriorated 2% to 28%. Endoscopes were used for an average of 3 to 13 hours before they needed repair. The most fragile part of these instruments was the deflection unit. CONCLUSIONS: Small diameter flexible ureteroscopes are effective for diagnosing and treating upper urinary tract pathology but improved durability is required. Currently they represent a highly effective but high maintenance means of achieving retrograde access to the ureter and kidney with a need for repair after only 6 to 15 uses.

Laparoscopic midsagittal hemicystectomy and replacement of bladder wall with small intestinal submucosa and reimplantation of ureter into graft.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: A variety of biodegradable organic materials have been used for bladder wall replacement. In some instances, partial replacement has been done using laparoscopic reconstructive techniques. However, to date, this activity has been limited to small patches. Herein, we present the initial experience with laparoscopic sagittal hemicystectomy and the use of laparoscopic reconstructive techniques to replace half of the bladder with small-intestinal submucosa (SIS) and to reimplant the ureter into SIS. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Six female minipigs (20-25 kg) underwent transperitoneal laparoscopic sagittal hemicystectomy; the excised bladder wall was replaced with a 5 x 15-cm patch of SIS (Cook Biotechnology, Spencer, IN). The ipsilateral ureter was reimplanted through a small incision in the graft and secured with two sutures. Cystoscopy and cystometrograms were performed under general anesthesia preoperatively and at 6 and 12 weeks postoperatively. Tissues were harvested at 12 weeks. RESULTS: The procedure was successful in six animals (left three, right three). During cystoscopy at 12 weeks, the area of the graft was not distinguishable from normal mucosa. Cystometrograms revealed maintenance of volume and compliance, with volumes of 338, 343, and 369 mL and intravesical leak-point pressures of 37, 59, and 39 cm H2O at 0, 6, and 12 weeks, respectively. Antegrade ureterograms demonstrated extrinsic obstruction, minimal (two), moderate (three), or complete (one), at the ureterovesical junction. The kidney associated with the completely obstructed ureter was grossly hydronephrotic at sacrifice. Histologically, patchy epithelialization of the graft with a mixture of squamoid and mature transitional-cell epithelium was found. CONCLUSIONS: Laparoscopic hemicystectomy with replacement of the bladder wall and implantation of the ureter into the SIS graft is a feasible procedure. Clinical application awaits improvements in the method of ureteral reimplantation and longer follow-up to assess for ingrowth of muscle and nerve fibers.