Possible molecular evolution of biomembranes: from single-chain to double-chain lipids.

We have studied a possible evolution process permitting a 'primitive' membrane to evolve towards a membrane structure with an outer wall, similar to that of bacteria. We have investigated whether a polysaccharide bearing hydrophobic phytyl or cholesteryl chains coats giant vesicles made of single- or double-chain lipids. Phytyl-pullulan 5b was found to bind to the surface of vesicles made of either single- or double-chain lipids. In contrast, cholesteryl-pullulan 5a only coated the surface of vesicles made of double-chain lipids. These results indicate that there must be a close match between the size and shape of membrane constituents and the hydrophobic molecules to be inserted. This process could, thus, provide a selection mechanism of lipid-membrane constituents during the course of biomembrane evolution. The presence of the above 'hydrophobized' polysaccharides on the surface of different giant vesicles was identified by lectin binding. Both concanavalin A and annexin V were shown by fluorescence microscopy to bind spontaneously to vesicles made of double-chain lipids. Our experiments exemplify that self-organization of amphiphiles into closed vesicles in aqueous solution automatically leads to the coating of vesicles by 'hydrophobized' polysaccharides, which then permit lectin binding. This is a possible mechanism for the evolution of primitive membranes towards 'proto-cells'.

"Primitive" membrane from polyprenyl phosphates and polyprenyl alcohols.

Polyprenyl phosphates, as well as polyprenyl alcohols bearing different isopentenyl C(5) units, have been synthesized. The pH range of spontaneous vesicle formation of polyprenyl phosphates with or without polyprenyl alcohols was defined by fluorescence microscopy. A variety of the acyclic or monocyclic polyprenyl phosphates studied formed stable vesicles in water over a wide range of pHs, and the addition of polyprenyl alcohols allowed the vesicle formation of polyprenyl phosphates at higher pHs. Osmotic swelling of a suspension of unilamellar vesicles using the stopped-flow/light-scattering method enabled us to evaluate the water permeability of polyprenyl phosphate vesicles with or without 10 mol% of free polyprenyl alcohol. The addition of many polyprenyl alcohols to polyprenyl phosphate vesicles decreased the water permeability, and some reduced it even more efficiently than cholesterol.

A novel type of membrane based on cholesteryl phosphocholine, cholesteryl phosphate, or sitosteryl phosphate, and dimyristoylglycerol.

Mixtures of amphiphilic cholesteryl phosphate (CP), sitosteryl phosphate (SP), or cholesteryl phosphocholine (CPC) with the nonphosphoryl diacyl lipid dimyristoylglycerol (DMG) or with cholesterol give self-organized systems (giant vesicles) in a wide range of pH, as demonstrated by fluorescence microscopy, differential scanning calorimetry, and small-angle X-ray scattering. The water permeability of a 1 : 1 molar mixture of CPC and DMG was also measured by a stopped-flow/light-scattering method. The novel self-organized systems are akin to natural eukaryotic ones, the only difference being the site of the phosphate-containing head-group, located on cholesterol instead of DMG. They might be present in some organisms not yet studied for the composition of their membranes.

Membrane properties of branched polyprenyl phosphates, postulated as primitive membrane constituents.

We have postulated earlier that the highly branched isoprenoid alkanes, which are distributed widely in many sediments, may have been derived from the corresponding branched polyprenyl phosphates, potentially present in biomembranes in primitive organisms. These polyprenyl-branched polyprenyl phosphates might be derived by a simple alkylation from non-substituted polyprenyl phosphates, which we postulate to be the precursors of all membrane terpenoids. We have now synthesized a series of 6-(poly)prenyl-substituted polyprenyl phosphates and studied the formation of vesicles from these phosphates, as a function of the substituted-chain length, the position of the double bond, and pH. Nine of the branched polyprenyl phosphates containing 20-30 C-atoms do form vesicles at a 'physiological' pH; the lipophilicity/hydrophilicity ratio is as expected an important factor. We have also studied the water permeability through membranes of these branched polyprenyl phosphate vesicles by our stopped-flow/light-scattering method. These highly branched polyprenyl phosphates can more effectively reduce the water permeability than non-substituted polyprenyl phosphates: the vesicles formed by the former are more stable against mechanical stress. This reinforces our hypothesis about the origin of the sedimentary polyprenyl-substituted polyprene hydrocarbons.

Monolayer studies of single-chain polyprenyl phosphates.

The monolayer properties of some single-chain polyprenyl phosphates (phytanyl, phytyl, and geranylgeranyl phosphates), which we regard as hypothetical primitive membrane lipids, were investigated at the air-water interface by surface pressure-area (pi-A) isotherm measurements. The molecular area/ pressure at various pH conditions dependence revealed the acid dissociation constants (pKa values) of the phosphate. The pKa values thus obtained at the air-water interface (pKa1 = 7.1 and pKa2 = 9.4 for phytanyl phosphate) were significantly shifted to higher pH than those observed in the bilayer state in water (pKa1 = 2.9 and pKa2 = 7.8). The difference in pKa values leads to a stability of the phosphate as both monolayer and bilayer states in a pH range of 2-6. In addition, the presence of ions such as sodium, magnesium, calcium, and lanthanum in the subphase significantly altered the stability of the polyprenyl phosphate monolayers, as shown by the determination of monolayer collapse and compression/expansion hysteresis. Although sodium ions in the subphase showed only a weak effect on the stabilization of the monolayer, addition of magnesium ions or of a small amount of calcium ions significantly suppressed the dissolution of the monolayer into the subphase and increased its mechanical stability against collapse. In contrast, the presence of larger amounts of calcium or of lanthanum ions induced collapse of the monolayers. Based on these experimental facts, a plausible scenario for the formation of primitive cell membrane by transformation of a monolayer to vesicle structures is proposed.

A novel type of membranes based on cholesteryl phosphate.

Mixtures of the rigid amphiphile disodium cholesteryl phosphate (DCP) with the non-phosphorylated diacyl amphiphile dimyristoylglycerol (DMG) give self-organized systems in a wide range of pH, as demonstrated by differential microcalorimetry. These systems can be closed bilayer vesicles, as shown by optical microscopy (Nomarski and confocal). Neither DMG nor DCP, taken alone, give vesicles in these conditions but 10% DMG is enough to lead to the formation of vesicles from pH 5.8 to 9.3. These novel self-organized systems are akin to the classical eucaryotic ones, built on a phosphorylated diacylglycerol and free cholesterol (or analogues), the only difference being the site of the phosphate head-group.

Regioselective photolabeling of glycoprotein A in membranes.

We have developed a chemical method for directly identifying the amino acid residues of the transmembrane domain of a protein that are located right in the center of the membrane. Glycophorin A (GPA), the major sialoglycoprotein of human erythrocytes, was the first membrane protein whose primary sequence was elucidated, but its three-dimensional structure is still not known. GPA has been reconstituted into liposomes formed from dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine, dimyristoylphosphatidylserine, cholesterol, and a bola-amphiphilic phospholipidic photoactivatable probe (radioactive probe 1) by a detergent-mediated method. Electron microscopy confirmed the formation of spherical vesicular structures, and sucrose-density gradients revealed that the proteoliposomes comprised only one membrane fraction. Proteinase-K digestion of GPA in the proteoliposomes suggested that the orientation of GPA in reconstituted proteoliposomes was virtually identical to that observed in natural erythrocyte membranes. After photo-irradiation of the reconstituted proteoliposomes and in situ tryptic digestion, the photolabeled amino acid residues were analyzed by Edman degradation and their radioactivity was measured. Val80 and Met81, which had been assumed to be located near the center of the transmembrane domain of GPA, were indeed highly selectively photolabeled by probe 1. The new method might be applied to analyze the three-dimensional arrangement of the transmembrane domain of protein complexes that are made up from several subunits.

Mid-Membrane Photolabeling of the Transmembrane Domain of Glycophorin A in Phospholipid Vesicles.

The tandem use of the photosensitive bola-amphiphile 1 (X=3 H) and cholesterol enabled the determination of the center of the transmembrane domain of glycophorin A (131 amino acid residues) in a membrane by selective functionalization of the protein within a phospholipid bilayer.

Synthesis of Deuterium-Labeled Plant Sterols and Analysis of Their Side-Chain Mobility by Solid State Deuterium NMR.

The plant sterols sitosterol and stigmasterol exert very different effects on plant model membranes, the first one being a "reinforcer" like cholesterol, the second one not. 25-(2)H-Stigmasterol has been synthesized by coupling of the 22-aldehyde derived from stigmasterol by ozonolysis, with the proper sulfone labeled in position 25. The configuration of the ethyl side chain at C-24 was controlled by separation of the diastereomers introduced via a chiral sulfoxide. This synthetic scheme allowed the introduction of a labeled side chain in plant sterols in eight steps for stigmasterol and nine for sitosterol (overall yield ca. 15%). Using both diastereomers, the 24-epimers of sitosterol (clionasterol) and stigmasterol (poriferasterol) have also been synthesized. Deuterium NMR on oriented lipid bilayers made of soybean phosphatidylcholine and containing these four labeled plant sterols clearly reveals the difference of orientation and mobility of the four side chains.