ABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Alcoholic or biliary acute pancreatitis may need different therapeutic approaches. AIM: Assessing the validity of lipase/amylase ratio in differentiating biliary from alcoholic acute pancreatitis/acutized chronic pancreatitis. METHODS: Nine male patients (mean age and standard deviation: 39.8 +/- 7.0 years) with alcoholic acute pancreatitis/acutized chronic pancreatitis (group I) and 29 patients, 8 male and 21 female (mean age: 43.6 +/-19.9 years), with biliary acute pancreatitis (group II) were evaluated. Serum lipase and amylase levels were measured in patients with symptoms for no more than 48 hours. The lipase/amylase ratio was calculated based on serum lipase and amylase levels and expressed as multiples of their respective superior reference values. RESULTS: Mean levels of serum lipase (4,814 +/- 3,670 U/L) and amylase (1,282 +/- 777 U/L) in patients of group I were comparable to group II (2,697 +/- 2,391 and 1,878 +/- 1,319 U/L, respectively), but the mean lipase/amylase ratio was significantly higher in group I (4.4 +/- 3.6) than in group II (2.2 +/- 2.2). Lipase/amylase ratio >3 occurred at significantly higher proportions in patients of group I (66.7%) than of group II (24.1%), differentiating the two groups with sensitivity of 67% and specificity of 76%. CONCLUSIONS: 1) Amylase and lipase serum levels did not differ in the two groups evaluated; 2) the lipase/amylase ratio >3 was more often seen in alcoholic acute pancreatitis/acutized chronic pancreatitis than biliary acute pancreatitis, and it may be useful in differentiating these two causes of pancreatitis.
Subject(s)
Amylases/blood , Biliary Tract Diseases/complications , Lipase/blood , Pancreatitis/diagnosis , Acute Disease , Adolescent , Adult , Aged , Aged, 80 and over , Clinical Enzyme Tests , Diagnosis, Differential , Female , Humans , Male , Middle Aged , Pancreatitis/etiology , Pancreatitis, Alcoholic/diagnosis , Pancreatitis, Alcoholic/enzymology , Pancreatitis, Chronic/diagnosis , Pancreatitis, Chronic/enzymology , Predictive Value of Tests , Sensitivity and SpecificityABSTRACT
RACIONAL: Pancreatites agudas de causas alcoólica ou biliar podem necessitar de abordagens terapêuticas diferentes. OBJETIVO: Verificar a validade da relação lipase/amilase em diferenciar as causas alcoólica ou biliar na pancreatite aguda/pancreatite crônica agudizada. MÉTODOS: Foram avaliados nove pacientes com pancreatite aguda/pancreatite crônica agudizada alcoólica, todos homens, com idade média (desvio padrão) de 39,8 ± 7,0 anos (grupo I) e 29 com pancreatite aguda biliar, sendo 8 homens e 21 mulheres, com idade média de 43,6 ± 19,9 anos (grupo II). As amilasemias e lipasemias foram determinadas em pacientes com sintomatologia há, no máximo, 48 horas. A relação lipase/amilase foi calculada utilizando-se valores de amilasemia e lipasemia expressas como múltiplos de seus respectivos valores superiores de referência. RESULTADOS: As médias das lipasemias (4.814 ± 3.670 U/L) e amilasemias (1.282 ± 777 U/L) no grupo I foram semelhantes às do grupo II (2.697 ± 2.391 e 1.878 ± 1.319 U/L, respectivamente), mas a média das relações lipase/amilase foi significantemente maior no grupo I (4,4 ± 3,6) do que no grupo II (2,2 ± 2,2). Relação lipase/amilase >3 foi significantemente mais freqüente no grupo I (66,7 por cento) do que no grupo II (24,1 por cento) e diferenciou os dois grupos com sensibilidade de 67 por cento e especificidade de 76 por cento. CONCLUSÕES: 1) as amilasemias e lipasemias não diferenciaram os dois grupos avaliados; 2) relação lipase/amilase >3 é mais freqüente na pancreatite aguda/pancreatite crônica agudizada alcoólica do que na pancreatite aguda biliar, e pode ser útil na diferenciação destas duas causas de pancreatite.
BACKGROUND: Alcoholic or biliary acute pancreatitis may need different therapeutic approaches. AIM: Assessing the validity of lipase/amylase ratio in differentiating biliary from alcoholic acute pancreatitis/acutized chronic pancreatitis. METHODS: Nine male patients (mean age and standard deviation: 39.8 ± 7.0 years) with alcoholic acute pancreatitis/acutized chronic pancreatitis (group I) and 29 patients, 8 male and 21 female (mean age: 43.6 ± 19.9 years), with biliary acute pancreatitis (group II) were evaluated. Serum lipase and amylase levels were measured in patients with symptoms for no more than 48 hours. The lipase/amylase ratio was calculated based on serum lipase and amylase levels and expressed as multiples of their respective superior reference values. RESULTS: Mean levels of serum lipase (4,814 ± 3,670 U/L) and amylase (1,282 ± 777 U/L) in patients of group I were comparable to group II (2,697 ± 2,391 and 1,878 ± 1,319 U/L, respectively), but the mean lipase/amylase ratio was significantly higher in group I (4.4 ± 3.6) than in group II (2.2 ± 2.2). Lipase/amylase ratio >3 occurred at significantly higher proportions in patients of group I (66.7 percent) than of group II (24.1 percent), differentiating the two groups with sensitivity of 67 percent and specificity of 76 percent. CONCLUSIONS: 1) Amylase and lipase serum levels did not differ in the two groups evaluated; 2) the lipase/amylase ratio >3 was more often seen in alcoholic acute pancreatitis/acutized chronic pancreatitis than biliary acute pancreatitis, and it may be useful in differentiating these two causes of pancreatitis.
Subject(s)
Adolescent , Adult , Aged , Aged, 80 and over , Female , Humans , Male , Middle Aged , Amylases/blood , Biliary Tract Diseases/complications , Lipase/blood , Pancreatitis/diagnosis , Acute Disease , Clinical Enzyme Tests , Diagnosis, Differential , Predictive Value of Tests , Pancreatitis, Alcoholic/diagnosis , Pancreatitis, Alcoholic/enzymology , Pancreatitis, Chronic/diagnosis , Pancreatitis, Chronic/enzymology , Pancreatitis/etiology , Sensitivity and SpecificityABSTRACT
RACIONAL: Várias doenças abdominais podem cursar com aumento de amilasemia e lipasemia. OBJETIVO: Avaliar a validade da amilasemia e lipasemia para os diagnósticos diferenciais entre pancreatite aguda/pancreatite crônica agudizada, doenças das vias biliares, úlcera gastroduodenal perfurada e apendicite aguda. PACIENTES E MÉTODOS: Foram avaliados, prospectivamente, 38 pacientes com pancreatite aguda/pancreatite crônica agudizada, 35 com doenças das vias biliares, 17 com úlcera gastroduodenal perfurada e 44 com apendicite aguda, com idade média (desvio padrão) de 42,4 ± 17,7, 46,7 ± 18,3, 47,8 ± 12 e 33,7 ± 17,8 anos, respectivamente. A amilasemia e a lipasemia foram determinadas à admissão no pronto-socorro. RESULTADOS: Para o diagnóstico de pancreatite aguda/pancreatite crônica agudizada, quando o nível de corte da amilasemia variou entre o limite superior de referência e 5 vezes este limite, a sensibilidade diminuiu de 92 por cento para 74 por cento, a especificidade aumentou de 85 por cento para 99 por cento, o valor preditivo positivo aumentou de 71 por cento para 97 por cento e o valor preditivo negativo diminuiu de 96 por cento para 91 por cento. Para a lipasemia valores semelhantes foram obtidos para sensibilidade e valor preditivo negativo, mas a especificidade e o valor preditivo positivo foram mais baixos. Quando se considerou amilasemia ou lipasemia elevadas, houve pequeno aumento na sensibilidade e no valor preditivo negativo. CONCLUSÕES: Para o diagnóstico de pancreatite aguda/pancreatite crônica agudizada, 1) o melhor nível de corte para ambos os testes foi o de duas vezes o limite superior de referência; 2) as sensibilidades da amilasemia e da lipasemia foram semelhantes; 3) a especificidade e o valor preditivo positivo da amilasemia foram ligeiramente maiores do que as da lipasemia; 4) a sensibilidade, mas não a especificidade, aumentou quando pelo menos uma das enzimas estava elevada.
Subject(s)
Humans , Male , Female , Adolescent , Adult , Middle Aged , Abdominal Pain/diagnosis , Abdominal Pain/enzymology , Amylases/blood , Lipase/blood , Pancreatitis/diagnosis , Pancreatitis/enzymology , Acute Disease , Abdominal Pain/etiology , Appendicitis/complications , Appendicitis/diagnosis , Appendicitis/enzymology , Bile Duct Diseases/complications , Bile Duct Diseases/diagnosis , Bile Duct Diseases/enzymology , Chronic Disease , Diagnosis, Differential , Prospective Studies , Pancreatitis/complications , Peptic Ulcer Perforation/complications , Peptic Ulcer Perforation/diagnosis , Peptic Ulcer Perforation/enzymology , Sensitivity and SpecificityABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Raised serum amylase and lipase levels are observed in several abdominal diseases. AIM: Assessing the validity of serum amylase and lipase for the differential diagnosis between acute pancreatitis/acutized chronic pancreatitis, biliary tract disease, perforated gastroduodenal ulcer and acute appendicitis. PATIENTS E METHODS: Prospective study including 134 individuals: 38 with acute pancreatitis/acutized chronic pancreatitis, 35 with biliary tract disease, 17 with perforated gastroduodenal ulcer and 44 with acute appendicitis, mean age (standard deviation) of 42.4 +/- 17.7, 46.7 +/- 18.3, 47.8 +/- 12 and 33.7 +/- 17.8 years, respectively. Serum amylase and lipase were determined at admission to the emergency department. RESULTS: For the diagnosis of acute pancreatitis/acutized chronic pancreatitis, when the cutt-off levels of serum amylase were set at the upper normal range level or up to 5-fold as high, the sensitivity decreased from 92% to 74%, the specificity increased from 85% to 99%, the positive predictive value increased from 71% to 97%, and the negative predictive value decreased from 96% to 91%. For serum lipase levels similar figures were obtained for sensitivity and negative predictive value, but the specificity and positive predictive value were lower. When the combination of raised serum amylase or lipase were analyzed, a minor increase was observed in sensitivity and negative predictive value. CONCLUSIONS: For the diagnosis of acute pancreatitis/acutized chronic pancreatitis: 1) the best cut-off level for both tests was 2-times the upper normal range; 2) the sensitivities of serum amylase and lipase were similar; 3) the specificity and positive predictive value of serum amylase were slightly higher than observed for serum lipase; 4) the sensitivity but not the specificity increased when at least one between amylase or lipase was raised.
