Management practices for gastrointestinal hemorrhage related to portal hypertension in cirrhotic patients: evaluation of the impact of the Paris consensus workshop.

OBJECTIVES: The purpose of this before-after observational survey was to evaluate compliance with good clinical practice guidelines for gastrointestinal hemorrhage related to portal hypertension and the impact of the French Consensus Workshop held in Paris in 2003. METHODS: Data were recorded concerning episodes of gastrointestinal hemorrhage occurring in cirrhotic patients using a survey questionnaire in 2003 before the workshop and again in 2004. RESULTS: Seventy-six index episodes were included in 2003 and 84 in 2004 in patients attending French hospitals. Before hospital admission, primary prophylaxis was similar in 2003 and 2004, but beta blockers were used alone more often in 2004 for secondary prophylaxis (42% vs 19%, P=0.018). The time from onset of bleeding to hospital admission was greater than 12 hours for 43 and 42% of patients and was not shorter in the event of recurrent hemorrhage. At admission, vasoactive drugs were given earlier in 2004 (<2h: 68% vs 35%, P<0.001). Use of antibiotic prophylaxis was similar in 2003 and 2004 (70% vs 61%, P=0.098), and was more common for Child-Pugh B or C patients (P=0.044). CONCLUSION: The Paris Consensus Workshop enabled improved clinical practices. Weak points were insufficient screening for cirrhosis, long delay before admission, insufficient use of antibiotic prophylaxis which should be systematic.

Management of digestive bleeding related to portal hypertension in cirrhotic patients: A French multicenter cross-sectional practice survey.

AIM: To investigate the conformity of management practices of gastrointestinal hemorrhage in cirrhotic patients with relevant guidelines. METHODS: A questionnaire on the management of digestive bleeding was completed for all consecutive cirrhotic patients admitted to 31 French hospitals. RESULTS: One hundred and twenty-six bleeding events were recorded. It was the first bleeding episode in 79 patients (63%), of whom 40 (51%) had a prior diagnosis of cirrhosis and 25 (32%) had previously undergone an endoscopy. The bleeding episode was a recurrence in 46 patients (37%). The median time between onset and admission was 4 h, but exceeded 12 h in 42% of cases. There was an agreement between centers for early vasoactive drug administration (87% of cases), association with ligation (42%) more often than sclerosis (21%) at initial endoscopy, and antibiotic prophylaxis (64%). By contrast, prescription of beta-blockade alone or in combination (0 to 100%, P = 0.003) for secondary prophylaxis and lactulose (26% to 86%, P = 0.04), differed among centers. CONCLUSION: In French hospitals, management of bleeding related to portal hypertension in cirrhotic patients is generally in keeping with the consensus. Broad variability still remains concerning beta-blockade use for secondary prophylaxis. Screening for esophageal varices, the use of antibiotic prophylaxis and patients information need to be improved.