Frequency, characteristics, and clinical significance of transient ST segment elevation in patients with acute coronary syndromes.

BACKGROUND: Prior investigations of transient myocardial ischaemia have focused on ST depression events. Therefore, the purpose of this analysis was to determine the frequency, characteristics, and clinical significance of transient ST segment elevation in patients with acute coronary syndromes. METHODS: A secondary analysis from two prospective studies utilizing 12-lead ST segment monitoring was used to compare ST elevation vs ST depression events. RESULTS: Of 868 patients, 177 (20%) had 574 events (242, ST elevation; 332, ST depression). Patients with ST elevation were more likely to have single vessel coronary artery disease, whereas patients with ST depression were more likely to have triple vessel coronary artery disease. ST elevation events were of shorter duration, more often associated with chest pain, and had greater ST changes than ST depression events. There was no difference in clinical outcome between patients with ST elevation vs depression; however, those with ST events were more likely to have adverse hospital outcomes (OR, 3.67) or death (OR, 2.03) than patients without ST events. After controlling for clinical prognostic factors, transient ST events observed with continuous ST monitoring predicted hospital death independently from signs of ischaemia on the initial standard 12-lead ECG. CONCLUSIONS: Transient ST elevation is nearly as prevalent as transient ST depression in patients with acute coronary syndromes. Since the vast majority of ST events are brief and otherwise clinically silent, ST segment monitoring is more efficacious in detecting ischaemic events and in predicting adverse clinical outcomes than patients' symptoms or the initial standard 12-lead ECG.

Frequency of silent myocardial ischemia with 12-lead ST segment monitoring in the coronary care unit: are there sex-related differences?

BACKGROUND: Ischemia that occurs in the coronary care unit (CCU), whether symptomatic or silent, is associated with significant in-hospital and out-of-hospital complications. Studies have reported that more than 90% of ischemic episodes are silent in patients with unstable angina who are treated in the CCU with maximal medical therapy. Prior reports indicate that women complained more frequently of chest pain than men did. PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to compare the frequency of silent myocardial ischemia in men versus women with use of continuous 12-lead ST segment monitoring in the CCU. A secondary goal was to determine whether silent ischemia was associated with less ST segment deviation as compared with symptomatic ischemia. METHOD: Patients admitted for treatment of acute coronary syndrome in the CCU and who subsequently had 1 or more ischemic events during their monitoring period were selected for this analysis. All patients were continuously monitored (42.5 hours +/- 37.6) in the CCU with the EASI (Zymed Medical Instruments, Camarillo, Calif) 12-lead electrocardiogram (ECG) system that derives 12 leads with use of 3 information channels and 5 electrodes. RESULTS: Of 491 patients, 128 (91 men and 37 women) had at least 1 episode of transient myocardial ischemia. Men and women did not differ in their proportion of chest pain during ischemia (men 27% and women 21%, NS). For both men and women, ST segment deviation was significantly greater during symptomatic ischemia compared with silent ischemia. CONCLUSION: There are no sex-related differences in ischemic events in the CCU in regards to the variables of chest pain and ST magnitude. Therefore, because chest pain is not a reliable indicator of myocardial ischemia in the CCU, regardless of sex, patients should be adequately monitored for ischemic events.

Accuracy of the EASI 12-lead electrocardiogram compared to the standard 12-lead electrocardiogram for diagnosing multiple cardiac abnormalities.

This study was performed to compare a derived 12-lead electrocardiogram (ECG) using a simple 5-electrode lead configuration (EASI 12-lead) with the standard ECG for multiple cardiac diagnoses. Accurate diagnosis of arrhythmias and ischemia often require analysis of multiple (ideally, 12) ECG leads; however, continuous 12-lead monitoring is impractical in hospital settings. EASI and standard ECGs were compared in 540 patients, 426 of whom also had continuous 12-lead ST segment monitoring with both lead methods. Independent standards relative to a correct diagnosis were used whenever possible, for example, echocardiographic data for chamber enlargement-hypertrophy, and troponin levels for acute infarction. Percent agreement between the 2 methods were: cardiac rhythm, 100%; chamber enlargement-hypertrophy, 84%-99%; right and left bundle branch block, 95% and 97%, respectively; left anterior and posterior fascicular block, 97% and 99%, respectively; prior anterior and inferior infarction, 95% and 92%, respectively. There was very little variation between the 2 lead methods in cardiac interval measurements; however, there was more variation in P, QRS, and T-wave axes. Of the 426 patients with ST monitoring, 138 patients had a total of 238 ST events (26, acute infarction; 62, angioplasty-induced ischemia; 150, spontaneous transient ischemia). There was 100% agreement between the 2 methods for acute infarction, 95% agreement for angioplasty-induced ischemia, and 89% agreement for transient ischemia. EASI and standard 12-lead ECGs are comparable for multiple cardiac diagnoses; however, serial ECG changes (eg, T-wave changes) should be assessed using one consistent 12-lead method.

Peak time of occurrence of myocardial ischemia in the coronary care unit.

BACKGROUND: The onset of acute myocardial infarction and sudden cardiac death has a circadian variation, with the peak occurrence between 6 AM and 12 noon. OBJECTIVES: To determine if a circadian variation exists for transient myocardial ischemia in patients admitted to the coronary care unit with unstable coronary syndromes. METHODS: The sample was selected from patients enrolled in a prospective clinical trial who had had ST-segment monitoring for at least 24 hours and had had at least one episode of transient ischemia. The 24-hour day was divided into 6-hour periods, and comparisons were made between the 4 periods. RESULTS: In 99 patients, 61 with acute myocardial infarction and 38 with unstable angina, a total of 264 (mean +/- SD, 3 +/- 2) ischemic events occurred. Patients were more likely to have ischemic events between 6 AM and noon than at other times. A greater proportion of patients complained of chest pain between 6 AM and noon than during the other 3 periods. However, more than half the patients never complained of chest pain during ischemia between 6 AM and noon. CONCLUSION: Transient ischemia occurs throughout the 24-hour day; however, ischemia occurs more often between 6 AM and noon. An important nursing intervention for detecting ischemia is continuous electrocardiographic monitoring of the ST segment, even during routine nursing care activities, which are often at a peak during the vulnerable morning hours.

12-lead ST-segment monitoring vs single-lead maximum ST-segment monitoring for detecting ongoing ischemia in patients with unstable coronary syndromes.

BACKGROUND: 12-lead ECG monitoring of the ST segment is more sensitive than patients' symptoms for detecting ischemia after thrombolytic therapy or catheter-based interventions, but it is unclear whether monitoring of the single lead showing maximum ST deviation would be as efficacious. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether monitoring all 12 ECG leads for changes in the ST segment is necessary to detect ongoing ischemia in patients with unstable coronary syndromes. METHODS: Continuous 12-lead ST segment monitoring was performed in 422 patients from the onset of myocardial infarction or during balloon inflation in catheter-based interventions until the patient's discharge from the cardiac care unit. Computer-assisted techniques were used to determine (1) which lead showed the maximum ST deviation at the onset of myocardial infarction or during balloon inflation and (2) what proportion of later ischemic events were associated with ST deviation in this lead. RESULTS: The lead with the maximum ST deviation could be determined in 312 patients (74%). The remaining 110 (26%) had non-Q wave infarction without ST deviation or no ST changes during balloon inflation. During 18,394 hours of 12-lead ST monitoring, 118 (28%) of the 312 patients had a total of 463 ischemic events, 80% of which were silent. Of 377 ischemic events in which a maximum ST lead was detected, 159 (42%) did not show ST deviation in this lead (sensitivity, 58%; 95% CI, 53%-63%). Routine monitoring of leads V1 and II showed ST deviation in only 152 of the 463 events (sensitivity, 33%; 95% CI, 29%-37%). CONCLUSIONS: Monitoring of all 12 ECG leads for changes in the ST segment is necessary to detect ongoing ischemia in patients with unstable coronary syndromes.

Bedside diagnosis of myocardial ischemia with ST-segment monitoring technology: measurement issues for real-time clinical decision making and trial designs.

Monitoring of the ST segment is a valuable tool for guiding clinical decision making and evaluating anti-ischemia interventions in clinical trials; however, measurement issues hamper its diagnostic accuracy. This study reports the frequency and type of false positives and other measurement issues we have encountered during 12-lead ST-segment monitoring of patients in a cardiac care unit. Of 292 patients, 117 (40%) had one or more false positive events during an average of 41 hours of ST-segment monitoring, for a total of 506 false positive events. The 506 false positive events included 167 (36%) due to body positional change; 132 (26%) due to sudden increase in QRS complex/ST-segment voltage; 96 (19%) due to transient arrhythmia or pacing; 80 (16%) due to heart rate change in steeply sloped ST-segment contours; 26 (5%) due to a noisy signal; and 5 (1%) due to lead misplacement. It is concluded that many conditions in addition to myocardial ischemia can cause transient ST-segment deviation in patients with unstable coronary syndromes. Accurate ST-segment monitoring requires expertise in electrocardiogram interpretation, an understanding of the patient's clinical situation, and knowledge of the functions and limitations of the ST-segment monitoring system.

Computer versus manual measurement of ST-segment deviation.

Total ST scores (sum of absolute deviations in all 12 electrocardiographic [ECG] leads) have been used for research purposes to estimate total ischemic burden and to predict reperfusion after thrombolytic therapy. Computerized monitoring systems are capable of measuring ST deviation to the 10-microV level, whereas humans are incapable of such precise resolution. The purpose of this study was to compare computer versus manual ST scores in 12-lead ECGs exhibiting ischemia and to compare interrater reliability of manual measurements between two experts. A total of 58 subjects with 100 microV or more ST deviation in one or more leads during percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty balloon inflation were selected for analysis. ST measurements were made at J + 80 ms, using the isoelectric line as a reference, and summed across all 12 leads. Manual measurements were made to a minimum of 50 microV by two independent reviewers blinded to the computer scores. Total ST scores were compared using paired t-tests, and Pearson coefficients were used to test the correlations. A high correlation was observed between the manual and computer measurements (r = .96, P < .00) and between the two reviewers (r = .96, P < .00). A high degree of interrater reliability is possible with manual measurements of ST deviation. Computer measurements are consistently greater than manual measurements, presumably because humans "round down" to the nearest 50 microV. As such, computers may detect ischemia that is missed by humans. However, computer and manual measurements of ST deviation should not be mixed when used as a variable for research.

Comparison of standard and derived 12-lead electrocardiograms for diagnosis of coronary angioplasty-induced myocardial ischemia.

To determine whether a derived 12-lead electrocardiogram (ECG) would demonstrate typical ST-segment changes of ischemia during percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA), 207 patients were monitored with continuous 12-lead ST-segment monitoring during angioplasty. Additionally, to compare the derived and standard ECGs during known periods of ischemia with PTCA balloon inflation, 151 patients were recorded with both electrocardiographic methods during the procedure. Of the 207 patients recorded with the derived ECG, 171 (83%) had typical ischemic ST-segment changes during PTCA balloon inflation. The amplitudes of these ST deviations were similar to those observed during transient myocardial ischemia observed in clinical settings (median peak ST deviation, 225 microV). There was agreement regarding presence or absence of ischemia in 150 of the 151 patients recorded with both derived and standard electrocardiographic methods (> 99% agreement). With use of the standard ECG as the "gold standard" for ischemia diagnosis, there were no false-positive results and only 1 false-negative result with the derived ECG. Furthermore, there was nearly perfect agreement between the two 12-lead methods in terms of anterior versus inferior wall patterns of ischemia. Future studies are required to determine whether continuous monitoring with a derived ECG would improve diagnosis and lead to better patient outcomes.

Chest pain is an unreliable measure of ischemia in men and women during PTCA.

OBJECTIVE: To investigate the differences between men and women in ischemia-induced pain, the amount of ST-segment deviation (the "ST deviation score"), and the relation between pain intensity and ST deviation score. DESIGN: Retrospective, comparative descriptive. SETTING: Cardiac catheterization laboratory of a large, urban, university-affiliated medical center with full cardiac services. PATIENTS: Adults who underwent percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA) and had electrocardiographic (ECG) evidence of myocardial ischemia during balloon inflation. METHODS: Continuous 12-lead ECGs were recorded during balloon inflation in patients undergoing PTCA. Patients rated pain on a scale of 0 to 10. The total ST deviation score equaled baseline ECG ST minus maximal ST deviation; absolute deviations were totaled. Frequencies, measures of central tendency, or chi-square or t tests were used for data analysis with significance established at p < 0.05. RESULTS: There were no difference in the degree of chest pain between men and women during balloon inflation, nor was ST deviation score associated with pain in either gender. Pain intensity did not correlate with total ST deviation in men (r = 0.02) or women (r = -0.07). CONCLUSIONS: In this study, pain was a poor indicator of ischemia in both sexes during PTCA, and the degree of pain did not correlate with the magnitude of ST deviation. More than one third of men and more than one fourth of women experienced no chest pain during balloon inflation. Clinicians should consider continuous ST-segment monitoring and patient symptoms to monitor accurately for ischemia.

ST segment monitoring with a derived 12-lead electrocardiogram is superior to routine cardiac care unit monitoring.

BACKGROUND: Prior studies have shown that a derived 12-lead electrocardiogram with a simple electrode configuration is comparable with the standard electrocardiogram for arrhythmia analysis. METHODS: A prospective, comparative, within subjects design was used to compare the value of the derived 12-lead electrocardiogram with that of routine monitoring of leads V1 and II for detection of transient myocardial ischemia in 250 patients treated for unstable angina or myocardial infarction. RESULTS: During 11,532 hours of derived 12-lead ST segment monitoring, 55 (22%) of 250 patients had 176 episodes of ischemia. Of the 55 patients with ischemia, 75% reported no chest pain and 64% had no ischemic ST changes with routine monitoring leads. All five patients who developed angiographically confirmed abrupt reocclusion after percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty had ischemic ST changes with the derived electrocardiogram (sensitivity, 100%), compared with only two patients with routine monitoring (sensitivity, 40%). Serious complications occurred in 17% of angina patients with ischemic events compared to 3% of those without ischemia. Length of stay in the cardiac care unit was twice as long in angina patients who had ischemic events. In patients with acute myocardial infarction, ischemic events were not associated with a more complicated hospital course; however, length of stay in the cardiac care unit was longer in patients with recurrent ischemia. CONCLUSIONS: The findings show that derived 12-lead ST monitoring is superior to routine monitoring of leads V1 and II for detecting transient myocardial ischemia. ST monitoring of the derived 12-lead electrocardiogram may identify high-risk patients with unstable angina and provide prognostic information that would not be otherwise available from the usual clinical measures.

ST segment deviation during myocardial ischemia: are there gender differences?

UNLABELLED: Prior research indicates that women have greater ST segment shifts at the time of percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA) balloon inflation than men. However, ST deviation in men and women has not been compared during balloon occlusion of the same coronary vessel. METHODS: To determine whether there is a gender difference in degree of ST deviation, 12-lead electrocardiographic (ECG) recordings were made in 45 subjects undergoing PTCA (25 men, 20 women). A total ST score was obtained by summing absolute deviations across all 12 leads. All patients had single vessel coronary artery lesions in the proximal half of one of the major epicardial arteries without evidence of collateral circulation. RESULTS: There were no differences between men and women in terms of age, left ventricular hypertrophy, ejection fraction, or the Norris Coronary Prognostic Index, which combines age, history of infarction, and evidence of heart failure on chest X-ray. When comparing mean ST segment deviation in men and women, vessel to vessel, no gender differences were found. CONCLUSION: When matched for coronary vessel, men and women have comparable ST deviation patterns during coronary occlusion with PTCA balloon inflation. Therefore, detection of myocardial ischemia related to coronary occlusion with continuous ST segment monitoring should be equally sensitive in men and women.

Computer versus manual measurement of ST-segment deviation.

Total ST scores (sum of absolute deviations in all 12 electrocardiographic [ECG] leads) have been used for research purposes to estimate total ischemic burden and to predict reperfusion after thrombolytic therapy. Computerized monitoring systems are capable of measuring ST deviation to the 10-microV level, whereas humans are incapable of such precise resolution. The purpose of this study was to compare computer versus manual ST scores in 12-lead ECGs exhibiting ischemia and to compare interrater reliability of manual measurements between two experts. A total of 58 subjects with 100 microV or more ST deviation in one or more leads during percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty balloon inflation were selected for analysis. ST measurements were made at J + 80 ms, using the isoelectric line as a reference, and summed across all 12 leads. Manual measurements were made to a minimum of 50 microV by two independent reviewers blinded to the computer scores. Total ST scores were compared using paired t-tests, and Pearson coefficients were used to test the correlations. A high correlation was observed between the manual and computer measurements (r = .96, P < .00) and between the two reviewers (r = .96, P < .00). A high degree of interrater reliability is possible with manual measurements of ST deviation. Computer measurements are consistently greater than manual measurements, presumably because humans "round down" to the nearest 50 microV. As such, computers may detect ischemia that is missed by humans. However, computer and manual measurements of ST deviation should not be mixed when used as a variable for research.