ABSTRACT
Analysis of published data reveals that the introduction of more basic amino acid residues in the flexible N-terminal region of the human tumour necrosis factor alpha (TNF) molecule indicates a weak but consistent trend towards increased in vitro cytotoxicity, especially when the effect of N-terminal length is taken into account. In our laboratory, a series of TNF analogues with a charge modification in the tip region of the molecule was prepared, and cytotoxicity measured. Similar trends in cytotoxicity with increasing basicity of the TNF analogue were found in this study for two mouse cell lines, L929 and WEHI-164 clone 13-1, as well as for the human line KYM-1D4. For the series of analogues as a whole, a general increase in in vitro cytotoxicity with increasing pI values was not apparent, but some analogues with charge reversal in the tip region, for example, the LK-805 analogue (E107K), exhibited significantly increased cytotoxicity in comparison to native TNF in a range of cell lines, including L929, KYM-1D4-K, WEHI-164 clone 13-1, HEPA 1-6 and EAhy926 cell lines. Experiments with heparinase-pre-treated cells demonstrated that the increased in vitro cytotoxicity of LK-805 is most probably due to interactions with cell surface heparan sulphates that effectively concentrate it before binding to TNF receptors occurs. Examination of structural models of TNF bound to soluble TNF receptor 1 (TNFR1) indicates that simple mutations in the tip region most probably cannot interact with receptor binding sites, and therefore do not directly modulate cytotoxicity.
Subject(s)
Antineoplastic Agents/pharmacology , Tumor Necrosis Factor-alpha/pharmacology , Amino Acid Sequence , Animals , Antineoplastic Agents/chemistry , Cell Line, Tumor , Cell Survival/drug effects , Heparin Lyase/pharmacology , Heparitin Sulfate/chemistry , Humans , Isoelectric Point , Mice , Models, Molecular , Molecular Sequence Data , Receptors, Tumor Necrosis Factor, Type I/chemistry , Structure-Activity Relationship , Tumor Necrosis Factor-alpha/chemistryABSTRACT
The first essential step in TNF signal transduction is believed to be clustering of the membrane bound receptors around the trimeric TNF molecule. To check if one receptor binding site would be enough to trigger the signal, we tried to prepare several types of TNF dimer. For this purpose, two TNF analogs bearing different cysteine mutations at the inner subunit binding surfaces were designed, expressed in E. coli and prepared in pure form. By mixing equimolar quantities of these analogs under appropriate conditions, two different types of dimer were prepared. The first, Dim/S2, proved to be composed mainly of a disulfide-linked dimer, which was still capable of trapping the third subunit of either of the precursor analogs, thus showing relatively high residual cytotoxicity. To avoid trimeric structures, Dim/S2 was further transformed into Dim/Iaa2 by alkylation of -SH groups of the newly introduced cysteines, allowing binding of only two TNF subunits through native contact surfaces. These dimers showed substantially reduced cytotoxicity on the L929 cell line. In addition, it appears that Dim/Iaa2 is able to competitively inhibit cytotoxicity of native TNF, as assessed on the L-M cell line.
