Clonal anergy induced in a CD8+ hapten-specific cytotoxic T-cell clone by an altered hapten-peptide ligand.

Clonal T-cell anergy has been proposed as a mechanism to ensure peripheral tolerance in vivo. Anergy has been reported to result from T cell activation with inappropriate antigen-presenting cells (APC) or, in the case of CD4+ T cells, also by altered peptide ligands. This study reveals that altered hapten ligands can also induce anergy in CD8+ T cells. The Kb-restricted, trinitrophenyl (TNP) specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clone E6 was found to lyse target cells presenting the TNP-modified peptides M4L-TNP (derived from mouse serum albumin) or O4TNP (derived from chicken ovalbumin), but not the corresponding dinitrophenol (DNP)-modified peptides. However, whereas M4L-DNP was found totally unreactive, O4DNP antagonistically inhibited M4L-TNP-mediated kill if expressed on the same target cell. Moreover, when presented alone on APC, O4DNP, but not M4L-DNP, induced anergy in clone E6 by preventing its subsequent proliferative response to M4L-TNP. The anergic state did not affect agonist-specific cytolysis or T-cell receptor (TCR) down-modulation by the anergized CTL, and proliferative responses were regained upon addition of interleukin (IL)-2 or IL-12 plus IL-18. These findings substantiate the similarity between hapten-and peptide-recognition by T cells. The induction as well as the reversal of anergy in CD8+ CTL may thus be of relevance not only in autoimmunity or tumour rejection, but also in contact hypersensitivity reactions to haptens.

Carrier-independent hapten recognition and promiscuous MHC restriction by CD4 T cells induced by trinitrophenylated peptides.

The elucidation of mechanisms underlying the recognition of haptens by class II MHC-restricted T cells is instrumental for the understanding of chemical- and drug-induced allergies. We have previously demonstrated that trinitrophenyl (TNP) peptides represent dominant antigenic epitopes for CD8+ and CD4+ mouse T cells triggered by chemically TNP-modified APC. Here, we report the characterization of TNP-specific, CD4+ mouse T cell lines and hybridomas that were induced in vivo and in vitro by defined hapten-conjugated peptides. These peptides, which we had previously shown to induce contact sensitivity to picryl chloride in vivo regardless of sequence homologies to mouse proteins, were found to activate carrier-independent TNP-specific T cells in vitro. We interpret these findings to support our view that carrier-independent T cells, reactive to particularly repetitive hapten epitopes, may play a crucial role in allergies to chemicals and drugs. In addition to carrier independence, one of our hybridomas (IT-H6/A11) exhibited a striking promiscuity of MHC restriction. Although absolutely dependent in its TNP reactivity on the presence of MHC class II molecules, the IT H6/A11 hybridoma completely ignored class II polymorphism and even reacted to TNP peptides presented on human DR molecules. Regarding hapten allergies in humans with a heterozygous situation for three types of class II molecules (DR, DP, and DQ), such promiscuous MHC restriction should lead to the presentation of even higher epitope densities to the respective T cell clones. Hybridoma IT-H6/A11, reacting to TNP independent of carrier peptide and of MHC haplotype, also allowed for an unusually systematic study of the minimal requirements for TNP recognition. Despite an almost complete ignorance of amino acid side chains on the carrier peptide, our data indicate a clearly position-specific interaction of hapten and TCR.

Analysis of major histocompatibility complex class I-restricted hapten recognition by mutation of the V-J joining of T cell receptor alpha chains.

Hapten-specific T cell responses are responsible for chemically induced immune disorders. However, the molecular details of hapten interactions with T cell receptors (TCR) are poorly understood. Recent studies of trinitrophenyl (TNP)-specific responses revealed major histocompatibility complex-associated TNP-peptides as dominant epitopes for CD8+ and CD4+ T cells. The present study is based on the observation that two H-2Kb/TNP-specific CTL clones (II/7 and III/1), differing exclusively in two amino acids of their TCR alpha chains, also differed in their carrier specificities for various TNP-peptides. The genes of the two alpha chains and the common beta chain were cloned into expression vectors. Transfection of the TCR alpha chain of clone III/1 into a hybridoma of clone II/7 also transferred the fine specificity of clone III/1, indicating that the small alpha chain variations were indeed responsible for the different carrier specificities. Point mutations bridging the difference between the alpha chains of clones II/7 and III/1 and functional studies of the respective TCR alpha beta transfectants into a TCR-negative hybridoma revealed an unexpected result: the two receptors did not represent examples of structural complementarity for different sets of hapten-peptide conjugates; rather, they resembled two structures of principally similar specificity but of significantly different overall affinity. This was demonstrated more directly by comparing the fine specificities of III/1 transfectants expressing or not expressing the co-receptor CD8: the CD8-negative III/1 transfectant assumed a specificity pattern indistinguishable from that of a CD8-expressing, II/7-derived transfectant. Hence, comparable alterations of antigen recognition may be induced either by subtle TCR alterations or by removal of CD8, i.e. by the presence or absence of a non-polymorphic adhesion molecule.

Carrier-reactive hapten-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte clones originate from a highly preselected T cell repertoire: implications for chemical-induced self-reactivity.

We have recently described trinitrophenyl (TNP)-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones from C57BL/6 mice specific for hapten-modified peptides bearing a TNP-lysine in a peripheral position, i.e. in position 7 of H-2Kb-bound octapeptides. CTL recognition of such determinants is always sequence-dependent due to co-recognition of TNP as well as amino acid side chains of the carrier peptide. By the use of glycine-based designer peptides for primary induction of CTL in vitro, we have identified two sub-epitopes on individual position 7-haptenated peptides that form two TcR contact points and which can be independently recognized by cloned CTL. One of these sub-epitopes is represented by the hapten itself, the other by the amino acids tyrosine and lysine in positions 3 and 4 of the carrier peptide, respectively. Immunization with such TNP-modified peptides frequently results in the specific induction of CTL also reacting with the unmodified carrier peptides. DNA sequence analyses of the TcR revealed an extraordinary similarity of several independent TcR of CTL from individual mice and induced with different TNP-peptides. These receptor similarities clearly correlate with structural elements common to the immunizing peptides and suggest their origin from positive thymic selection of TcR on Kb-associated associated self-peptides bearing Tyr in position 3. Our data provide additional information concerning the topology of TcR binding to peptide/MHC complexes with, but also without, TNP. They also indicate a mechanism which might explain the potential of chemicals or drugs to induce autoimmune phenomena.

Cross-reactive trinitrophenylated peptides as antigens for class II major histocompatibility complex-restricted T cells and inducers of contact sensitivity in mice. Limited T cell receptor repertoire.

The induction of contact sensitivity in mice by hapten reagents such as trinitrochlorobenzene (TNCB) involves the activation of class II major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-restricted, hapten-specific, CD4+ T cells. Reports from different laboratories have indicated that the relevant antigenic epitopes in such reactions might include hapten-conjugated, MHC class II-associated peptides. This study for the first time directly demonstrates that hapten-peptides account for the majority of determinants recognized by trinitrophenyl (TNP)-specific CD4+ T lymphocytes. The sequences of those TNP carrier peptides do not have to be related to mouse proteins. Thus, we show that TNP-modified peptides derived from mouse IgG, pigeon cytochrome c or staphylococcal nuclease known to bind to I-Ab or from lambda repressor with specificity to I-Ad as well as TNP-proteins such as bovine serum albumin, ovalbumin or keyhole limpet hemocyanin all create class II-restricted hapten determinants for a number of TNP-specific T cell clones and hybridomas. All of these cells were induced with cells modified by trinitrobenzene sulfonic acid (TNBS). In addition, we present arguments indicating that individual TNP-specific helper T cells may cross-react with different TNP-peptides bound to identical class II molecules. Chemical treatment of antigen-presenting cells with TNCB or TNBS may thus result in a limited number of particularly repetitive immunodominant hapten epitopes. Immunodominant epitopes were also indicated by an overrepresentation of the TCR elements V beta 2 and V alpha 10 in I-Ab/TNP-specific T cells. Most importantly, however, we demonstrate that TNP attached to lysine 97 in the staphylococcal nuclease peptide 93-105 (i.e. a clearly "non-self" sequence) is able to prime mice for subsequent elicitation of contact sensitivity by TNCB in the absence of foreign protein. We take this to indicate that those TNP-peptide determinants defined by us as immuno-dominant are responsible for the induction of contact sensitivity to haptens.

Structural complexity of antigenic determinants for class I MHC-restricted, hapten-specific T cells. Two qualitatively differing types of H-2Kb-restricted TNP epitopes.

The understanding of chemically induced allergic or autoimmune disorders requires a detailed structural analysis of the antigenic determinants produced by chemical modification of cells. Using H-2Kb-restricted, TNP-specific cytotoxic mouse T cells and synthetic, Kb-associating TNP-peptides, we define at least two types of functionally distinguishable TNP epitopes. The first one contains TNP in position 4 of different Kb-binding octapeptides and is detected by the majority of in vitro-induced TNP/Kb-specific CTL. This immunodominant structure could be imitated by oligo-glycine based "designer peptides," containing only the Kb "anchor-residues" and TNP-Lys in position 4. A second, qualitatively different determinant is created by TNP-Lys in position 7. T cells of such specificity are rare and recognize TNP only in context of unique peptide sequences. In this case, designer peptides revealed a complex antigenic determinant comprised of TNP-7 and unmodified amino acids in positions 3 and 4. Chances to form a particular determinant of this type by chemical modification are small and, thus, each clone will detect only few epitopes per cell. In contrast, the dominant TNP-4 epitope on differing peptides results in highly repetitive determinants. TCR specific for the rare TNP-7 structure were found to simultaneously contact TNP in position 7 and unmodified amino acids in positions 3 and 4. However, they may also react individually with either the peptide or the hapten part of these complex determinants. This implies a potentially important role of such structures in the induction of autoimmunities: resting T cells, bearing low affinity receptors to self peptides may be activated by peptide/hapten complexes and allow recall responses to the isolated peptide epitope of the unmodified self peptide.

Role of hapten-anchoring peptides in defining hapten-epitopes for MHC-restricted cytotoxic T cells. Cross-reactive TNP-determinants on different peptides.

Synthetic hapten-peptide conjugates selectively modify cell-bound MHC class I molecules in a haplotype-specific way. We investigated the contribution of the carrier peptides to the structural specificity of T cell-antigenic TNP epitopes, using different H-2Kb-binding TNP-peptides and a collection of TNP/Kb-specific CTL clones. Adjustment of peptide sequences to the proposed Kb-specific "motif" (octamers with F or Y and L in positions 5 and 8, respectively) enhanced Kb-binding and antigenicity by many orders of magnitude. Moreover, several clones reacted to peptides, containing the "motif" and TNP-lysine in position 4 but were otherwise unrelated by sequence. TNP in other positions was not recognized by these cells, but other CTL reacted to TNP in position 7. This points to the positioning of hapten determinants within the MHC binding groove as a major role of the anchoring peptide. However, determination of the limiting amounts of TNP peptides that elicit antigenicity or inhibit other Kb-restricted CTL reactions revealed that TCR also recognize variations in the sequences of carrier peptides. This contribution is low for TNP in position 4 but high in position 7, indicating lysine in position 4 as a particularly dominant and cross-reactive hapten-anchoring site in Kb-associated peptides. This implies that cell modification with lysine-reactive TNP reagents results in immunodominant, highly repetitive TNP epitopes, which may explain the strong antigenicity and the allergenic properties of TNP, as well as the restricted TCR repertoire directed against this hapten. Our data further recommend hapten peptides for general studies of TCR-Ag interactions because in contrast to pure protein Ag, hapten epitopes tolerate substantial structural variations in the MHC-anchoring peptide, and can be located by hapten-specific antibodies.

Antigen contact sites in class I major histocompatibility complex-restricted, trinitrophenyl-specific T cell receptors.

Cloned trinitrophenyl (TNP)-specific cytotoxic T cells (CTL) were obtained from mice transgenic for the beta chain of the antigen-specific receptor (TcR) of a Kb-restricted, TNP-specific CTL clone (BT7.4.1). The transgene-expressing CTL, specific for TNP/Kb were found to select for TcR alpha chains highly similar to that of the transgene donor clone BT7.4.1. In that way, two clones (II/7 and III/1) were identified whose TcR differed from the BT7.4.1 receptor only in their N alpha- and J alpha-sequences, i.e. within the third complementarity-determining regions of their alpha chains (CDR3 alpha). Moreover, the TcR of clones II/7 and III/1 had both rearranged the same J alpha element, thus differing from each other by only two amino acids in their V alpha/J alpha junctional regions. Functionally, however, clone III/1 exhibited unique cytolytic specificities for synthetic, Kb-binding TNP-peptides as well as for chemically TNP-modified allogeneic (H-2k) target cells. These findings demonstrate that (a) similar to "conventional" peptide antigens, synthetic hapten-peptide determinants are contacted by CDR3 alpha-determined amino acids of the TcR and (b) in contrast to current models, CDR alpha also appears to influence the major histocompatibility complex restriction specificity of a given TcR.

Lipopolysaccharide-induced immunomodulation of the generation of cell-mediated cytotoxicity. I. Suppression of the development of cytotoxic lymphocytes.

Bacterial lipopolysaccharide from a variety of Gram-negative organisms suppresses the development of cytotoxic killer cells in the murine MLC. Cytotoxic T lymphocytes were generated in vitro by incubating BALB/c responder spleen cells with irradiated C57BL/6 stimulator cells for 5 days in mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC). The addition of LPS at the initiation of MLC suppressed killing of 51Cr-labeled target cells in a dose-dependent manner. LPS was active only during the afferent phase of CMC, since it did not interfere with the efferent phase of the assay. Furthermore, timed addition and timed removal studies suggested that the presence of LPS during the first 48 hr of MLC was critical for maximal suppression of CMC. Lipid A extracted from LPS, which had been shown to be highly suppressive when added to the sensitization phase of the CMC assay, was also inhibitory. Moreover, when LPS was added to MLC in the presence of tritiated thymidine, the proliferative activity of the responder cells increased markedly after 72 hr of culture. These data suggest that LPS, a known B cell mitogen, can modulate the complex sequence of cellular interactions that leads to the generation of cell-mediated cytotoxicity.