Long-term care organizational challenges and strategies art vs. regulation.

1. Long-term residents of nursing homes, especially those with chronic deteriorating illnesses, may be at risk of overly rigorous treatment or abandonment because they do not fit the typical rehabilitative or terminal care planning models. 2. A proactive approach to care planning once rehabilitation is no longer an option emphasizes ongoing dialogue with the resident and family to determine their values and wishes for care, not merely determining the treatments they want withheld. 3. Although staff are enthusiastic about proactive, individualized, interdisciplinary planning for the care of residents, in actuality it is extremely difficult given current organizational constraints.

A prospective study of advance directives for life-sustaining care.

BACKGROUND: The use of advance directives is recommended so that people can determine the medical care they will receive when they are no longer competent, but the effectiveness of such directives is not clear. METHODS: In a prospective study conducted over a two-year period, 126 competent residents of a nursing home and 49 family members of incompetent patients were interviewed to determine their preferences with respect to hospitalization, intensive care, cardiopulmonary resuscitation, artificial ventilation, surgery, and tube feeding in the event of critical illness, terminal illness, or permanent unconsciousness. Advance directives, consisting of signed statements of treatment preferences, were placed in the medical record to assist in care in the nursing home and to be forwarded to the hospital if necessary. RESULTS: In an analysis of 96 outcome events (hospitalization or death in the nursing home), care was consistent with previously expressed wishes 75 percent of the time; however, the presence of the written advance directive in the medical record did not facilitate consistency. Among the 24 events in which inconsistencies occurred, care was provided more aggressively than had been requested in 6 cases, largely because of unanticipated surgery or artificial ventilation, and less aggressively than requested in 18, largely because hospitalization or cardiopulmonary resuscitation was withheld. Inconsistencies were more likely in the nursing home than in the hospital. CONCLUSIONS. The effectiveness of written advance directives is limited by inattention to them and by decisions to place priority on considerations other than the patient's autonomy. Since our study was performed in only one nursing home and one hospital, other studies are necessary to determine the generalizability of our findings.

Development of a model quality-of-care assessment program for adult preventive care in rural medical practices.

A four-year project of quality-of-care assessment for 37 practices in rural North Carolina used chart abstraction and formal feedback to practitioners to improve compliance standards for 13 adult health maintenance interventions. In 1987, performance of Papanicolaou (Pap) test within two years ranged from 20% to 100% (mean, 61%), mammogram 0% to 70% (mean, 20%), and influenza vaccination 0% to 90% (mean, 59%). Practices received individual results and remediation took place for those practices that performed poorly; a reaudit took place in 1989, with improvement in all measures for all practices, except the influenza vaccination. Compliance results for 1989 were 30% to 100% (mean, 67%) for the Pap test, 10% to 100% (mean, 40%) for the mammography screening, and 5% to 80% for the influenza vaccination. These results suggest that coordinated quality-of-care assessment for rural practices can be performed with a modest administrative burden and substantial benefit to the practices.

Custodial nursing home care. Setting realistic goals.

Despite concerted effort to rehabilitate and return patients to their homes, the majority of nursing home patients are destined to spend the remainder of their days in institutional settings. These custodial care patients are elderly, have many functional disabilities, and are often demented. The traditional medical approach to care, which emphasizes diagnosis and treatment of specific diseases, is often not appropriate for these patients. Instead, physicians should focus their attention on functional assessment and treatment, nontechnologic management of acute problems, humane terminal care, and the development of an efficient caregiving system within the nursing home.

Hypertension control in a rural biracial community: successes and failures of primary care.

Through a total community survey and a medical record review, we examined hypertension awareness, treatment, and control in a biracial rural community rich in primary care resources. The overall prevalence of hypertension among the 2,939 respondents was 20.5 per cent; 82 per cent of hypertensives were aware of their condition; 68 per cent were on treatment; and 55 per cent were under control. Comparison of data sources revealed discrepancies and misconceptions about diagnosis and treatment. Nearly one-third of the population reported a history of hypertension despite the fact that most of them were untreated and were normotensive. Conversely, one-third of "undetected" hypertensives had notation of the diagnosis in their medical records. Discontinuation of treatment accounted for over one-half of aware but untreated hypertension. Misconceptions about therapy contributed to failures of control in the treated group. These findings suggest that difficulties in the transmission of information about hypertension contribute importantly to failures of control.

Physician receptivity to nurse practitioners: a study of the correlates of the delegation of clinical responsibility.

A survey to measure physician receptivity to nurse practitioners was conducted in North Carolina in 1973. All North Carolina physicians were asked to rate a list of 35 clinical tasks of varying levels of difficulty and responsibility according to their willingness to delegate these tasks to nurse practitioners. Using eight items from this list that were good discriminants of physician attitudes towards delegating responsibility, task delegation scores were correlated with physician characteristics and their responses to questions about recruitment, training, reimbursement, and willingness to hire nurse practitioners. Thirty-four per cent of the respondents would hire a nurse practitioner, whereas 52% approved of the concept but would not hire one. Physicians who had previously worked with a nurse practitioner were more willing to hire one and had a higher task delegation score. Sixty-eight per cent of respondents would share their load with nurse practitioners in their offices, while 6% would have them work in satellite clinics away from the physicians' offices. Most physicians wanted their own nurse trained as a nurse practitioner in a program that combined a didactic course at a medical center with on-the-job training. The authors conclude that there is a potential demand for nurse practitioners in North Carolina and that the training program must prepare the nurse practitioners for the tasks physicians are willing to delegate to them.