Delayed and deficient establishment of the long-term bone marrow plasma cell pool during early life.

Early life antibody responses are characterized by a rapid decline, such that antigen-specific IgG antibodies decline to baseline levels within months following infant immunization. This generic observation remains unexplained. Here, we have analyzed the induction and organ-localization of antigen-specific IgG antibody-secreting cells (ASC) following immunization of 1-week-old or adult BALB/c mice with tetanus toxoid (TT), a T-dependent antigen. Early life priming induced only slightly lower numbers of TT-specific IgG ASC in the spleen, and these reached adult levels following repeat immunization. In contrast, early life immunization generated much fewer bone marrow plasma cells than in adults, even after boosting. A similar limitation of the natural development of the bone marrow pool of ASC was observed. Transfer experiments with adult or early life spleen ASC indicated limited homing of TT-specific adult ASC to the bone marrow of 4-week-old mice as compared to adult recipients, whereas homing patterns were similar when early life or adult ASC were transferred into adult recipients. These observations suggest that a limited bone marrow B cell homing capacity and, as a result, relatively deficient bone marrow ASC responses, are critical factors which may explain the limited persistence of IgG antibodies to T-dependent antigens in early life.

Limitations of in vivo IL-12 supplementation strategies to induce Th1 early life responses to model viral and bacterial vaccine antigens.

The limited induction of Th1 and cytotoxic immune responses is regarded as the main reason for the increased susceptibility to intracellular microorganisms in early life. Recently, in vitro IL-12 supplementation was shown to enhance the limited IFN-gamma release of measles-specific infant T cells. Using a series of IL-12 delivery systems, we show here that in vivo IL-12 supplementation may enhance early life murine Th1 responses to two model vaccine antigens, measles virus hemagglutinin and tetanus toxin peptide. However, this required multiple repeat injections of recombinant rIL-12, which were poorly tolerated in young mice. Local IL-12 delivery by an IL-12 expressing canarypox vector proved safe but failed to modulate vaccine responses. An IL-12 DNA plasmid or a CD40L DNA plasmid efficiently enhanced neonatal Th1 responses to measles hemagglutinin DNA vaccine. However, both plasmids only enhanced Th1 responses to DNA and not to peptide, protein, or live viral vaccines. Thus, inducing adult-like Th1 responses may be achieved in vivo by inducing (CD40L) or substituting for (IL-12 supplementation) optimal activation of neonatal APC. However, these immunomodulatory effects appear limited to certain antigen-presentation approaches and may not be broadly applicable to vaccines.

Characterization at the single-cell level of naive and primed CD8 T cell cytokine responses.

The aim of this study was to characterize differences between naive and primed CD8 T cells. Our results show that (i) naive and primed CD8 T cells display similar activation thresholds, with no direct evidence for a difference in their TCR signals, and (ii) primed cells differ mainly in their capacity to secrete IFN-gamma. A comparison of the two populations at the single-cell level demonstrated that the increased production of IFN-gamma by the primed cell subset is due to a larger proportion of single cells that are able to synthesize this cytokine early following activation. These results indicate that the intrinsic effector capabilities of individual CD8 T cells expressing the same TCR are heterogeneous and that cells with identical antigen specificity but increased effector capacities are generated or selected during the primary response.

Effects of T3R alpha 1 and T3R alpha 2 gene deletion on T and B lymphocyte development.

Thyroid hormones bind to several nuclear receptors encoded by T3R alpha and T3R beta genes. There is now accumulating evidence that thyroid hormones act on the immune system. Indeed, mice deficient for thyroid hormones show a reduction in lymphocyte production. However, the mechanisms involved and, in particular, the role of the different thyroid hormone receptors in lymphocyte development have not been investigated. To address that question, we have studied lymphocyte development in mice deficient for the T3R alpha 1 and T3R alpha 2 gene products. A strong decrease in spleen cell numbers was found compared with wild-type littermates, B lymphocytes being more severely affected than T lymphocytes. A significant decrease in splenic macrophage and granulocyte numbers was also found. In bone marrow, a reduction in CD45+/IgM- pro/pre-B cell numbers was found in these mice compared with wild-type littermates. This decrease seems to result from a proliferation defect, as CD45+/IgM- cells incorporate less 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine in vivo. To define the origin of the bone marrow development defect, chimeric animals between T3R alpha-/- and Rag1-/- mice were generated. Results indicate that for B cells the control of the population size by T3R alpha 1 and T3R alpha 2 is intrinsic. Altogether, these results show that T3R alpha 1 or T3R alpha 2 gene products are implicated in the control of the B cell pool size.

Death by neglect as a deletional mechanism of peripheral tolerance.

In contrast to most organs, the anatomy of the liver may allow naive CD8(+) T cells to make direct contact with liver parenchymal cells. We have previously shown, using a combination of TCR transgenic T cells specific for H-2 K(b) and hepatocytes expressing a transgenic H-2 K(b) molecule, that hepatocytes can induce antigen-specific activation and proliferation of naive CD8(+) T cells independently of CD28 co-stimulation. However, T cell activation by hepatocytes leads to premature T cell death and tolerance, both in vivo and in vitro. In this study, we investigated the mechanisms of T cell death induced by hepatocytes in vitro using primary hepatocytes to activate purified CD8(+) T cells. Neither Fas nor tumor necrosis factor receptor were involved, indicating that hepatocyte- induced death was distinct from activation-induced cell death. Before they started to divide, T cells activated by hepatocytes expressed lower levels of the bcl-x(L) survival gene and 30 times less IL-2 mRNA than CD8(+) cells activated by splenic antigen-presenting cells. Since CD28 co-stimulation increases both IL-2 and bcl-x(L) expression, this suggests that hepatocyte-activated T cells die by neglect because they fail to receive effective co-stimulatory signals. In agreement with this model, premature death promoted by hepatocytes could be prevented by cross-linking CD28. Survival after CD28 cross-linking correlated with increased IL-2 and bcl-x(L) expression, and sustained T cell proliferation, while cytotoxic T lymphocyte activity was prolonged as compared with cells stimulated without CD28 co-stimulation. This study confirms that high- affinity TCR transgenic antigen-specific CD8(+) T cells can be activated to proliferate and differentiate into cytotoxic effector cells. However, prolonged T cell survival and cytotoxicity required CD28 co-stimulation as well. To our knowledge, this is the first report suggesting that tolerance in the context of lack of CD28 co-stimulation can result from Fas-independent peripheral deletion rather than from anergy.

Memory CD44(int) CD8 T cells show increased proliferative responses and IFN-gamma production following antigenic challenge in vitro.

F5 TCR transgenic mice challenged in vivo with peptide generate long-lived primed CD8 T cells that hyper-proliferate in response to peptide in vitro. These primed CD8 T cells can be subdivided into three distinct populations on the basis of CD44 cell surface expression. In this report, we show that among primed CD8 T cells, those expressing intermediate levels of CD44 appear to be true memory T cells by the measurement of a variety of characteristics. Indeed, these cells hyper-proliferate in response to peptide re-stimulation in vitro, and produce IFN-gamma with faster kinetics and at higher levels than naive populations in vitro. We also show that CD8 T cells expressing high levels of CD44 express several activation markers and cycle in vivo in the absence of antigen. However, this population is unable to respond to peptide stimulation in vitro as measured by both proliferation and IFN-gamma secretion. The origin and specificity of these cells is unknown. These results provide evidence that memory CD8 T cells are functionally different from naive CD8 T cells both in terms of proliferation and cytokine secretion. They identify the CD8/CD44(int) T cells as the population responsible for hyper-reactivity in vitro.

CpG oligodeoxynucleotides can circumvent the Th2 polarization of neonatal responses to vaccines but may fail to fully redirect Th2 responses established by neonatal priming.

Neonatal murine responses to a panel of conventional vaccines differ qualitatively from adult responses by a particular polarization toward a Th2 pattern and a frequent limitation of the Th1 and CTL responses required for protection against intracellular microorganisms. In contrast, DNA vaccines induce adult-like Th1/CTL neonatal responses against the same vaccine Ags. In this report, we show that this can be related to their content in unmethylated CpG motifs. Oligodeoxynucleotides (ODN) containing CpG motifs activate neonatal APCs to produce IL-12 in vitro and induce adult-like Th1 responses to tetanus toxoid and measles Ags in vivo, with production of IgG2a-specific Abs and adult-like secretion of IFN-gamma and IL-5 by Ag-specific T cells. However, in spite of their capacity to trigger neonatal B cell proliferation in vitro, CpG-ODN only partially enhanced early life Ab responses. Finally, using Th1-driving CpG-ODN with the boosting dose of a protein vaccine was sufficient to redirect adult but not neonatally primed Th2 responses. These observations could be important for the development of novel vaccines that will have to be effective early in life.

Tolerant CD8 T cells induced by multiple injections of peptide antigen show impaired TCR signaling and altered proliferative responses in vitro and in vivo.

The mechanisms responsible for peripheral CD8 T cell tolerance to foreign Ags remain poorly understood. In this study we have characterized the state of CD8 T cell tolerance induced in F5 TCR transgenic mice by multiple peptide injections in vivo. The tolerant state of CD8 T cells is characterized by impaired proliferative responses, increased sensitivity to cell death, and failure to acquire cytotoxic effector function after in vitro antigenic challenge. In vivo monitoring of CD8 T cell proliferation using 5-carboxyfluorescein diacetate succinimidyl ester showed that a large subset of the tolerant T cell population failed to divide in response to peptide. TCR down-regulation could not account for this loss of responsiveness to Ag since recombination-activating gene-1 (RAG-1)-/-F5 CD8 T cell responses were similar to those of RAG-1(-/-)F5 x RAG-1(-/-)F1 T lymphocytes, which express lower levels of the transgenic TCR. Analysis of early signal transduction in tolerant CD8 T cells revealed high basal levels of cytoplasmic calcium as well as impaired calcium mobilization and tyrosine phosphorylation after cross-linking of CD3epsilon and CD8alpha. Together these data indicate that repeated exposure to soluble antigenic peptide in vivo can induce a state of functional tolerance characterized by defective TCR signaling, impaired proliferation, and increased sensitivity to cell death.

Resting memory CD8+ T cells are hyperreactive to antigenic challenge in vitro.

The characteristics of CD8+ T cells responsible for memory responses are still largely unknown. Particularly, it has not been determined whether different activation thresholds distinguish naive from memory CD8+ T cell populations. In most experimental systems, heterogeneous populations of primed CD8+ T cells can be identified in vivo after immunization. These cells differ in terms of cell cycle status, surface phenotype, and/or effector function. This heterogeneity has made it difficult to assess the activation threshold and the relative role of these subpopulations in memory responses. In this study we have used F5 T cell receptor transgenic mice to generate a homogeneous population of primed CD8+ T cells. In the F5 transgenic mice, peptide injection in vivo leads to activation of most peripheral CD8+ T cells. In vivo BrdU labeling has been used to follow primed T cells over time periods spanning several weeks after peptide immunization. Our results show that the majority of primed CD8+ T cells generated in this system are not cycling and express increased levels of CD44 and Ly6C. These cells remain responsive to secondary peptide challenge in vivo as evidenced by short term upregulation of activation markers such as CD69 and CD44. The activation thresholds of naive and primed CD8+ T cells were compared in vitro. We found that CD8+ T cells from primed mice are activated by peptide concentrations 10-50-fold lower than naive mice. In addition, the kinetics of interleukin 2R alpha chain upregulation by primed CD8+ T cells differ from naive CD8+ T cells. These primed hyperresponsive CD8+ T cells might play an important role in the memory response.

Expression in vivo of CD45RA, CD45RB and CD44 on T cell receptor-transgenic CD8+ T cells following immunization.

We used mice transgenic for a major histocompatibility complex class I-restricted T cell receptor to study the changes of phenotype in vivo which follow priming by antigen of CD8 T cells. We show that following priming with peptide, CD44 on CD8 T cells is up-regulated. The change of phenotype was relatively stable, as primed CD8 cells isolated from thymectomized mice 6 weeks after priming still expressed increased levels of CD44. CD8 T cells in these mice are still responsive to peptide and could represent long-lived primed cells. No down-regulation in vivo of the CD45RA or CD45RB isoforms was found, indicating that there is a differential regulation of the expression of CD44 and CD45RB by activated CD8 transgenic T cells. These results contradict earlier studies in vitro which showed that CD8 T cells which have been primed earlier belong to the CD45RA- or CD45RB- subset.