Interruption of the internal water chain of cytochrome f impairs photosynthetic function.

The structure of cytochrome f includes an internal chain of five water molecules and six hydrogen-bonding side chains, which are conserved throughout the phylogenetic range of photosynthetic organisms from higher plants, algae, and cyanobacteria. The in vivo electron transfer capability of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii cytochrome f was impaired in site-directed mutants of the conserved Asn and Gln residues that form hydrogen bonds with water molecules of the internal chain [Ponamarev, M. V., and Cramer, W. A. (1998) Biochemistry 37, 17199-17208]. The 251-residue extrinsic functional domain of C. reinhardtii cytochrome f was expressed in Escherichia coli without the 35 C-terminal residues of the intact cytochrome that contain the membrane anchor. Crystal structures were determined for the wild type and three "water chain" mutants (N168F, Q158L, and N153Q) having impaired photosynthetic and electron transfer function. The mutant cytochromes were produced, folded, and assembled heme at levels identical to that of the wild type in the E. coli expression system. N168F, which had a non-photosynthetic phenotype and was thus most affected by mutational substitution, also had the greatest structural perturbation with two water molecules (W4 and W5) displaced from the internal chain. Q158L, the photosynthetic mutant with the largest impairment of in vivo electron transfer, had a more weakly bound water at one position (W1). N153Q, a less impaired photosynthetic mutant, had an internal water chain with positions and hydrogen bonds identical to those of the wild type. The structure data imply that the waters of the internal chain, in addition to the surrounding protein, have a significant role in cytochrome f function.

Tryptophan-heme pi-electrostatic interactions in cytochrome f of oxygenic photosynthesis.

Cytochrome f of oxygenic photosynthesis has an unprecedented structure, including the N-terminus being a heme ligand. The adjacent N-terminal heme-shielding domain is enriched in aromatic amino acids. The atomic structures of the chloroplast and cyanobacterial cytochromes f were compared to explain spectral and redox differences between them. The conserved aromatic side chain in the N-terminal heme-shielding peptide at position 4, Phe and Tyr in plants and algae, respectively, and Trp in cyanobacteria, is in contact with the heme. Mutagenesis of cytochrome f from the eukaryotic green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii showed that a Phe4 --> Trp substitution in the N-terminal domain was unique in causing a red shift of 1 and 2 nm in the cytochrome Soret (gamma) and Q (alpha) visible absorption bands, respectively. The resulting alpha band peak at 556 nm is characteristic of the cyanobacterial cytochrome. Conversely, a Trp4 --> Phe mutation in the expressed cytochrome from the cyanobacterium Phormidium laminosum caused a blue shift to the 554 nm alpha band peak diagnostic of the chloroplast cytochrome. Residue 4 was found to be the sole determinant of this 60 cm(-)(1) spectral shift, and of approximately one-half of the 70 mV redox potential difference between cytochrome f of P. laminosum and C. reinhardtii (E(m7) = 297 and 370 mV, respectively). The proximity of Trp-4 to the heme implies that the spectral and redox potential shifts arise through differential interaction of its sigma- or pi-electrostatic potential with the heme ring and of the pi-potential with the heme Fe orbitals, respectively. The dependence of the visible spectrum and redox potential of cytochrome f on the identity of aromatic residue 4 provides an example of the use of the relatively sharp cytochrome spectrum as a "spectral fingerprint", and of the novel structural connection between the heme and a single nonliganding residue.

Movement of the Rieske iron-sulfur protein in the p-side bulk aqueous phase: effect of lumenal viscosity on redox reactions of the cytochrome b6f complex.

Based on the atomic structures of the mitochondrial cytochrome bc(1) complex, it has been proposed that the soluble domain of the [2Fe-2S] Rieske iron-sulfur protein (ISP) must rotate by ca. 60 degrees and translate through an appreciable distance between two binding sites, proximal to cytochrome c(1) and to the lumen-side quinol binding site. Such motional freedom implies that the electron-transfer rate should be affected by the lumenal viscosity. The flash-induced oxidation of cytochrome f, the chloroplast analogue of cytochrome c(1), was found to be inhibited reversibly by increased lumenal viscosity, as was the subsequent reduction of both cytochrome b(6) and cytochrome f. The rates of these three redox reactions correlated inversely with lumenal viscosity over a viscosity range of 1-10 cP. Reduction of cytochrome b(6) and cytochrome f was not concerted. The rate of cytochrome f reduction was observed to be approximately half that of cytochrome b(6) regardless of the actual viscosity, implying that the path length traversed by the ISP in reduction of cytochrome f is twice that of cytochrome b(6). This suggests that upon initiation of electron transfer by a light flash, cytochrome b(6) reduction requires movement of reduced ISP from an initial position predominantly proximal to cytochrome f, apparently favored by the reduced ISP, to the quinol binding site at which the oxidant-induced reduction of cytochrome b(6) is initiated. Subsequent reduction of cytochrome f requires the additional movement of the ISP back to a site proximal to cytochromef. There is no discernible viscosity dependence for cytochrome b(6) reduction under oxidizing conditions, presumably because the oxidized ISP preferentially binds proximal to the quinone binding niche. The dependence of the cytochrome redox reaction on ambient viscosity implies that the tethered diffusional motion of the ISP is part of the rate limitation for charge transfer through the b(6)f complex.

Comparison of the cytochrome bc1 complex with the anticipated structure of the cytochrome b6f complex: Le plus ça change le plus c'est la même chose.

Structural alignment of the integral cytochrome b6-SU IV subunits with the solved structure of the mitochondrial bc1 complex shows a pronounced asymmetry. There is a much higher homology on the p-side of the membrane, suggesting a similarity in the mechanisms of intramembrane and interfacial electron and proton transfer on the p-side, but not necessarily on the n-side. Structural differences between the bc1 and b6f complexes appear to be larger the farther the domain or subunit is removed from the membrane core, with extreme differences between cytochromes c1 and f. A special role for the dimer may involve electron sharing between the two hemes b(p), which is indicated as a probable event by calculations of relative rate constants for intramonomer heme b(p) --> heme b(n), or intermonomer heme b(p) --> heme b(p) electron transfer. The long-standing observation of flash-induced oxidation of only approximately 0.5 of the chemical content of cyt f may be partly a consequence of the statistical population of ISP bound to cytfon the dimer. It is proposed that the p-side domain of cyt f is positioned with its long axis parallel to the membrane surface in order to: (i) allow its large and small domains to carry out the functions of cyt c1 and suVIII, respectively, of the bc1 complex, and (ii) provide maximum dielectric continuity with the membrane. (iii) This position would also allow the internal water chain ("proton wire") of cyt f to serve as the p-side exit port for an intramembrane H+ transfer chain that would deprotonate the semiquinol located in the myxothiazol/MOA-stilbene pocket near heme b(p). A hypothesis is presented for the identity of the amino acid residues in this chain.

Perturbation of the internal water chain in cytochrome f of oxygenic photosynthesis: loss of the concerted reduction of cytochromes f and b6.

The 1.96 A structure of turnip cytochrome f revealed a linear internal chain of H2O molecules with the oxygen atoms of the chain having occupancies and "B" factors comparable to those of neighboring atoms [Martinez et al. (1996) Protein Sci. 5, 1081-1092. ]. Four waters extend 11 A from the heme toward Lys66 on the cytochrome surface. All residues that contribute an atom to the 15 H-bonds of five internal H2O molecules are essentially conserved in 23 cytochrome sequences. With only Gln and Asn side chains involved in H-bonding, the water chain resembles a "proton wire". The function of the conserved H2O chain was tested through site-directed mutagenesis of these Asn and Gln residues. Four of the five conserved Asn/Gln residues were changed in six mutants generated in the green alga, Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. Except for the N168F mutant, all grew photosynthetically. Although the rates of oxidation of cyt f oxidation and of reduction of cyt b6 (5-6 ms in the wild type) were not significantly affected, the rates of cyt f reduction and generation of the slow electrochromic band shift (Deltapsis) were markedly decreased, the half-times increasing to as much as 38 and 18 ms, respectively. Thus, in these mutants, reduction of cyt b6 reduction clearly precedes that of cyt f. Retardation of Deltapsis in the absence of an observable change in the rate of cyt b6 reduction implied that the rate of H+ translocation decreased in the mutants, and electron transfer was concomitantly retarded, most likely between the ISP and cyt f. The following was concluded: (i) proton and electron transfer are coupled in reduction of cyt f, and the cyt f water chain functions in H+ transfer; (ii) reduction of the high- and low-potential chains in the b6f complex is not concerted in the water chain mutants; and (iii) quinol deprotonation and electron transfer from reduced quinone are initiated by an early event, probably the movement of the ISP triggered by oxidation of cyt f.

Identification of the basic residues of cytochrome f responsible for electrostatic docking interactions with plastocyanin in vitro: relevance to the electron transfer reaction in vivo.

The prominent basic patch seen in the atomic structure of the lumen-side domain of turnip cytochrome f, consisting of Arg209 and Lys187, 58, 65, and 66, was proposed to be an electrostatically complementary docking site for its physiological electron acceptor, plastocyanin [Martinez, S. E., Huang, D., Szczepaniak, A., Cramer, W. A., and Smith, J. L. (1994) Structure 2, 95-105]. This proposal agrees with solution studies on the cytochrome f/plastocyanin electron-transfer reaction that showed a major contribution of electrostatic interactions to the docking, but not with studies on the oxidation rate of cyt f in vivo using mutants in which the basic patch of cyt f was neutralized. The apparent contradiction might be explained by an unknown electron acceptor protein for cyt f. However, (i) flash-induced oxidation of cyt f is absent in a PC-deficient mutant. (ii) Lys58, 65, and 66 in the large domain and Lys188 and 189 in the small domain are major contributors to the ionic strength dependence of the electron-transfer reaction in solution. Replacement of Lys58 and 65 by neutral residues and of Lys66 by the acidic residue Glu66 resulted in a >10-fold decrease in the rate of electron transfer in solution and complete loss of its ionic strength dependence. Replacement of Lys188 and Lys189 in the small domain of cyt f resulted in a 3-4-fold decrease in the second-order rate constant and a smaller dependence of the overall rate of electron transfer on ionic strength, corresponding to a loss of two positive charges. (iii) Acidification of the thylakoid lumen cannot explain the absence of electrostatic interactions. (iv) Changing the five lysines to acidic residues did not result in any significant retardation of the rate of cyt f oxidation in vivo. If the docking of cyt f and plastocyanin in vivo is mediated by basic residues of cyt f, they are different from those that mediate electron transfer in vitro or that are implicated by simulations of electrostatic interactions of the docking. Alternatively, docking of cyt f/PC in vivo is limited by spatial constraints or release of PC from P700 that precludes a rate-limiting mediation of the cyt f/PC reaction by specific electrostatic interactions. The cyt f/PC system in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii is the first electron-transfer couple for which the role of electrostatics in mediating the docking reaction has been studied both in vitro and in vivo.

Effect of the interdomain basic region of cytochrome f on its redox reactions in vivo.

The prominent interdomain basic surface region seen in the high-resolution structure of the active lumen-side C-terminal fragment of turnip cytochrome f, containing the conserved Lys58,65,66 (large domain) and Lys187 (small domain), has been inferred from in vitro studies to be responsible for docking of its physiological oxidant, plastocyanin. The effect of the putative docking region of cyt f on its reactivity in vivo was tested by site-directed mutagenesis in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. Three charge-neutralizing mutants were constructed involving: (i)the two lysines (Lys188Asn-Lys189Gln) in the small domain, (ii) the three lysines (Lys58Gln-Lys65Ser-Lys66Glu) in the large domain, and (iii) all five of these lysines spanning both domains. All mutants grew phototrophically. The mutants displayed a 20-30% increase in average generation time, and comparable decreases in rates of steady-state oxygen evolution and the slow (millisecond) electrochromic 515 nm band shift. The magnitude of the changes was greatest in the 5-fold Lys-minus mutant (Lys58Gln-Lys65Ser-Lys66Glu-Lys188Asn-Lys189G ln). The mutants showed a small increase (approximately 25%) in the t1/2, from 0.2 to 0.25 ms, of cyt f photooxidation, far less than anticipated (ca. 100-fold) from in vitro studies of the effect of high ionic strength on the cyt f-PC interaction. The t1/2 of cyt f dark reduction via the Rieske protein increased from 5-6 ms in the wild type to 11-12 ms in the 5-fold Lys-minus mutant. Cells grown phototrophically in the absence of Cu, where cyt c6 is the electron acceptor of cyt f, displayed net rates of cytochrome photooxidation that were slightly faster than those in the presence of Cu, which also decreased by a factor of < or = 25% in the Lys-minus mutants. It was concluded that (a) the net effect of electrostatic interaction between cytochrome f and its electron acceptor in vivo is much smaller than measured in vitro and is not rate-limiting. This may be a consequence of a relatively high ionic strength environment and the small diffusional space available for collision and docking in the internal thylakoid lumen of log phase C. reinhardtii. (b) The efficiency of electron transfer to cytochrome f from the Rieske protein is slightly impaired by the neutralization of the lysine-rich domain.