Predictors of intubation success and therapeutic value of paramedic airway management in a large, urban EMS system.

BACKGROUND: Endotracheal intubation (ETI) is commonly used by paramedics for definitive airway management. The predictors of success and therapeutic value with regard to oxygenation are not well studied. OBJECTIVES: 1) To explore the relationship between intubation success and perfusion status, Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) score, and end-tidal carbon dioxide (EtCO2); 2) to describe the incidence of unrecognized esophageal intubations with use of continuous capnometry; and 3) to document the incremental benefit of invasive versus noninvasive airway management techniques in correcting hypoxemia. METHODS: This was a prospective, observational study conducted in a large urban emergency medical services system. Paramedics completed a telephone debriefing interview with quality assurance personnel following delivery of all patients in whom invasive airway management had been attempted. Continuous capnometry was used for confirmation of tube position in all patients. Descriptive statistics were used to document airway management performance, including first-attempt ETI success, overall ETI success, and Combitube insertion (CTI) success. In addition, the incidence of unrecognized esophageal intubation was recorded. The relationship between intubation success and perfusion status, GCS score, and initial EtCO2 value was explored using logistic regression. Finally, recorded SpO2 values and the incidence of hypoxemia (SpO2 < 90%) at baseline, following noninvasive airway maneuvers, and after invasive airway management were compared for perfusing patients. RESULTS: A total of 703 patients were enrolled over 12 months. First-attempt ETI success was 61%, and overall ETI success was 81%; invasive airway management (ETI or CTI) was unsuccessful in 11% of patients. A single unrecognized esophageal intubation was observed (0.1%). A clear relationship between airway management success and perfusion status, GCS score, and initial EtCO2 value was observed. Only EtCO2 demonstrated an independent association with ETI success after adjusting for the other variables. Significant improvements in mean SpO2 and the incidence of hypoxemia over baseline were observed with both noninvasive and invasive airway management techniques in 168 perfusing patients. CONCLUSIONS: A relationship between intubation success and perfusion status, GCS score, and initial EtCO2 value was observed. Capnometry was effective in eliminating unrecognized esophageal intubations. Both noninvasive and invasive airway management strategies were effective in increasing SpO2 values and decreasing the incidence of hypoxemia, with additional benefit observed with invasive airway maneuvers in some patients.

The ability of paramedics to predict aspiration in patients undergoing prehospital rapid sequence intubation.

One of the purported benefits to invasive prehospital airway management is the prevention of aspiration; however, aspiration events may occur before the arrival of prehospital personnel. We explore the timing of aspiration in patients with severe traumatic brain injury (TBI) undergoing paramedic rapid sequence intubation (RSI). Severely head-injured (Glasgow Coma Scale [GCS] score 3-8) adults were prospectively enrolled into the San Diego Paramedic RSI Trial. As part of the prehospital data collection tool, paramedics prospectively assessed for clinical evidence of aspiration before RSI (pre-intubation), aspiration events occurring during RSI (peri-RSI), and regurgitation of vomitus or blood after intubation (post-intubation). Data were abstracted from work sheets used during the RSI procedure, a telephone debriefing by one of the principal investigators immediately after delivery of the patient, and San Diego County prehospital and trauma databases. The incidence of pre-intubation aspiration, peri-RSI aspiration, and post-intubation regurgitation of vomitus or blood were determined. Patients with and without pre-intubation aspiration were compared with regard to pre- and post-intubation hypoxia and the rate of aspiration pneumonia. Logistic regression was used to explore the association between pre-intubation aspiration and various demographic and clinical factors. The results showed that pre-intubation aspiration was noted by paramedics in 72/269 patients in whom complete data were available. Peri-RSI aspiration was reported in one patient; there were no reported cases of post-intubation regurgitation of vomitus or blood. Patients in the pre-intubation aspiration group required more intubation attempts, had a higher incidence of desaturations and lower pre- and post-intubation SaO(2) values, and were more frequently diagnosed with aspiration pneumonia. Pre-intubation aspiration was associated with severe TBI, GCS score of 3, younger age, and the absence of alcohol intoxication despite controlling for age, gender, GCS, Head AIS (Abbreviated Injury Score), and serum ethanol. It is concluded that paramedics seem to be able to accurately assess for aspiration in patients undergoing prehospital RSI. The vast majority of aspiration events seem to occur before the arrival of prehospital personnel. Alteration in consciousness from TBI may carry a higher risk of aspiration than with other causes, such as alcohol intoxication.

The association between field Glasgow Coma Scale score and outcome in patients undergoing paramedic rapid sequence intubation.

Early intubation is standard for treating severe traumatic brain injury (TBI). Aeromedical crews and select paramedic agencies use rapid sequence intubation (RSI) to facilitate intubation after TBI, with Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) score commonly used as a screening tool. To explore the association between paramedic GCS and outcome in patients with TBI undergoing prehospital RSI, paramedics prospectively enrolled adult major trauma victims with GCS 3-8 and clinical suspicion for head trauma to undergo succinylcholine-assisted intubation as part of the San Diego Paramedic RSI Trial. The following data were abstracted from paramedic debriefing interviews and the county trauma registry: demographics, mechanism, vital signs including GCS score, clinical evidence of aspiration before RSI, arrival laboratory values, hospital course, and outcome. Paramedic GCS calculations were confirmed during debriefing interviews. Patients were stratified by GCS score, with chi-square and receiver-operator-curve (ROC) analysis used to explore the relationship between GCS and hypoxia, head injury severity, aspiration, intensive care unit (ICU) length of stay, and outcome. Cohort analysis was used to explore potential reasons for early extubation and discharge from the ICU in some patients. A total of 412 patients were included in this analysis. A total of 81 patients (20%) were extubated and discharged from the ICU in 48 h or less; these patients had higher pre-RSI oxygen saturation (SaO(2)) values and higher arrival serum ethanol levels. Paramedic and physician GCS calculations had high agreement (kappa=0.995). A statistically significant relationship was observed between GCS score and Head Abbreviated Injury Score (AIS), survival, and pre-RSI SaO(2) values. However, ROC analysis revealed a limited ability of GCS to predict the presence of severe TBI, injury severity, desaturation, aspiration, ICU length of stay, or ultimate survival. In conclusion, paramedics seem to accurately calculate GCS values before prehospital RSI. Although a relationship between paramedic GCS and outcome exists, the ability to predict the severity of injury, airway-related complications, ICU length of stay, and overall survival is limited using this single variable. Other factors should be considered to screen TBI patients for prehospital RSI.

The association between operator confidence and accuracy of ultrasonography performed by novice emergency physicians.

The variable accuracy of emergency department (ED) ultrasound described in the literature has limited its utility as the sole imaging modality in critical decision making. Although ultrasound accuracy is highly dependent upon the technical abilities of the operator and conditions unique to each patient, no previous study of ED ultrasound has included estimates of operator confidence. This prospective observational study explores the association between operator confidence and the accuracy of ED ultrasound. Ultrasound was not performed in our ED until a formal training module was instituted. Patients were enrolled prospectively for the first year following the training module if they underwent one of the following ultrasound studies: abdominal examination for intraperitoneal fluid, right upper quadrant examination for gallstones, renal examination for hydronephrosis, pelvic examination for intrauterine pregnancy, abdominal examination for aorta diameter > 3 cm, or cardiac examination for pericardial fluid. In addition, formal ultrasound, computed tomography, magnetic resonance imaging, or an invasive procedure was required as a "gold standard" for each patient. Operators recorded their interpretation of the ED ultrasound and rated their confidence with the analysis before the formal imaging study or procedure. Test performance characteristics for each examination type and for all studies together were determined. The association between operator confidence and accuracy was explored using logistic regression and by determining test performance characteristics with patients stratified by confidence value. A total of 276 ED ultrasound studies were included. There were no significant differences in accuracy between ED attendings and residents. Overall accuracy, sensitivity, specificity, LR+, and LR- were 90%, 92%, 86%, 6.8, and 0.09, respectively. With confidence scores of 9 or 10 (n = 113), these values improved to 96%, 99%, 90%, 9.6, and 0.01, respectively. Logistic regression revealed an association between confidence and ED ultrasound accuracy (p < 0.001). It is concluded that a significant association exists between operator confidence and the accuracy of ED ultrasound. High confidence values are associated with clinically useful test performance characteristics.

Ventilation patterns in patients with severe traumatic brain injury following paramedic rapid sequence intubation.

INTRODUCTION: Inadvertent hyperventilation has been documented during aeromedical transports but has not been studied following paramedic rapid sequence intubation (RSI). The San Diego Paramedic RSI Trial was designed to study the impact of paramedic RSI on outcome in patients with severe head injury. This analysis explores ventilation patterns in a cohort of trial patients undergoing end-tidal CO2 (ETCO2) monitoring. METHODS: Adult patients with severe head injury (Glasgow Coma Score: 3-8) unable to be intubated without RSI were prospectively enrolled in the trial. Midazolam and succinylcholine were used for RSI; rocuronium was administered following tube confirmation. Standardized ventilation protocols were used by most paramedics; however, one agency instituted ETCO2 monitoring during the second trial year, with paramedics instructed to target ETCO2 values of 30 to 35 mmHg. The incidence and duration of inadvertent hyperventilation (ETCO2: <30 mmHg) and severe hyperventilation (ETCO2: <25 mmHg) were explored for patients undergoing ETCO2 monitoring. The initial, final, minimum, and maximum values for ETCO2 and the maximum and minimum ventilatory rate values were also calculated using descriptive statistics (95% confidence interval). The pattern of ETCO2 values over time and distribution of recorded ventilatory rate values were explored graphically. RESULTS: A total of 76 trial patients had adequate ETCO2 data for this analysis. The mean values for initial, final, maximum, and minimum ETCO2 were 40.8 (range: 37.5-44.2), 28.4 (range: 25.4-31.4), 45.1 (range: 41.4-48.8), and 23.5 mmHg (range: 21.4-25.5), respectively. The mean maximum and minimum ventilatory rate values were 36.0/minute (range: 33.5-38.5) and 12.8/minute (range: 11.9-13.7), respectively. ETCO2 values less than 30 and 25 mmHg were documented in 79% and 59% of patients, respectively, with mean durations of 485 (range: 378-592) and 390 seconds (range: 285-494). CONCLUSION: Inadvertent hyperventilation is common following paramedic RSI, despite ETCO2 monitoring and target parameters.

The safety and efficacy of prehospital needle and tube thoracostomy by aeromedical personnel.

BACKGROUND: Aeromedical crews routinely use needle thoracostomy (NT) and tube thoracostomy (TT) to treat major trauma victims (MTVs) with potential tension pneumothorax; however, the efficacy of prehospital NT and TT is unclear. OBJECTIVES: To explore the efficacy of aeromedical NT and TT in MTVs. METHODS: A retrospective chart review was performed using prehospital medical records and the county trauma registry over a seven-year period. All MTVs undergoing placement of NT or TT by aeromedical personnel were included; patients with incomplete data were excluded. Descriptive statistics were used to report the incidence of air release, clinical improvement (improved breath sounds or compliance if intubated, decreased dyspnea if nonintubated), and vital signs improvements (systolic blood pressure [SBP] increase to =90 mm Hg or increase by 5 mm Hg if < 90 mm Hg; heart rate improvement to 60-100 beats/min, increase by 10 beats/min if < 60 BPM, or decrease by 10 beats/min if > 100 beats/min; oxygen saturation increase if < 95%) for both NT and TT as documented in prehospital medical records. Survival and improvement in SBP based on trauma registry data were recorded for patients stratified by initial SBP. RESULTS: A total of 136 procedures (89 NTs and 47 TTs) in 81 patients were identified using prehospital medical records over a four-year period. Response rates to NT (60% overall, 32% vital signs) and TT (75% overall, 60% vital signs) were high. Vital signs improvements were observed more often in patients with a pulse and in nonintubated patients. A total of 168 patients were identified in the trauma registry over the seven-year study period. Normalization of SBP was observed in two-thirds of patients with a field SBP = 90 mm Hg and one-third of patients in whom field SBP could not be obtained. A small but significant proportion of patients undergoing prehospital NT and TT, including some with prehospital hypotension and high injury severity, survived to hospital discharge. The incidence of complications was low. CONCLUSIONS: Aeromedical crews appear to appropriately select MTVs to undergo field NT or TT. A low incidence of complications and a small but significant group of unexpected survivors support continued use of this procedure by aeromedical personnel.

Hospital bed surge capacity in the event of a mass-casualty incident.

INTRODUCTION: Traditional strategies to determine hospital bed surge capacity have relied on cross-sectional hospital census data, which underestimate the true surge capacity in the event of a mass-casualty incident. OBJECTIVE: To determine hospital bed surge capacity for the County more accurately using physician and nurse manager assessments for the disposition of all in-patients at multiple facilities. METHODS: Overnight- and day-shift nurse managers from each in-patient unit at four different hospitals were approached to make assessments for each patient as to their predicted disposition at 2, 24, and 72 hours post-event in the case of a mass-casualty incident, including transfer to a hypothetical, onsite nursing facility. Physicians at the two academic institutions also were approached for comparison. Age, gender, and admission diagnosis also were recorded for each patient. RESULTS: A total of 1,741 assessments of 788 patients by 82 nurse managers and 25 physicians from the four institutions were included. Nurse managers assessed approximately one-third of all patients as dischargeable at 24 hours and approximately one-half at 72 hours; one-quarter of the patients were assessed as being transferable to a hypothetical, on-site nursing facility at both time points. Physicians were more likely than were nurse managers to send patients to such a facility or discharge them, but less likely to transfer patients out of the intensive care unit (ICU). Inter-facility variability was explained by differences in the distribution of patient diagnoses. CONCLUSIONS: A large proportion of in-patients can be discharged within 24 and 72 hours in the event of a mass-casualty incident (MCI). Additional beds can be made available if an on-site nursing facility is made available. Both physicians and nurse managers should be included on the team that makes patient dispositions in the event of a MCI.

The three-phase model of cardiac arrest as applied to ventricular fibrillation in a large, urban emergency medical services system.

BACKGROUND: Cardiac arrest is responsible for significant morbidity and mortality, with consistently poor outcomes despite the rapid availability of prehospital personnel for defibrillation attempts in patients with ventricular fibrillation (VF). Recent evidence suggests a period of cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) prior to defibrillation attempts may improve outcomes in patients with moderate time since collapse (4-10 min). OBJECTIVES: To determine cardiac arrest outcomes in our community and explore the relationship between time since collapse, performance of bystander CPR, and survival. METHODS: Non-traumatic cardiac arrest data were collected prospectively over an 18-month period. Patients were excluded for: age <18 years, a "Do Not Attempt Resuscitation" (DNAR) directive, determination of a non-cardiac etiology for arrest, and an initially recorded rhythm other than VF. Patients were stratified by time since collapse (<4, 4-10, > 10 min, and unknown) and compared with regard to survival and neurological outcome. In addition, patients with and without bystander CPR were compared with regard to survival. RESULTS: : A total of 1141 adult non-traumatic cardiac arrest victims were identified over the 18-month study period. This included 272 patients with VF as the initially recorded rhythm. Of these, 185 had a suspected cardiac etiology for the arrest; survival to hospital discharge was 15% in this group, with 82% of these having a good outcome or only moderate disability. Survival was highest among patients with time since collapse of less than 4 min and decreased with increasing time since collapse. There were no survivors among patients with time since collapse greater than 10 min. Among patients with time since collapse of 4 min or longer, survival was significantly higher with the performance of bystander CPR; there was no survival advantage to bystander CPR among patients with time since collapse less than 4 min. CONCLUSIONS: The performance of bystander CPR prior to defibrillation by EMS personnel is associated with improved survival among patients with time since collapse longer than 4 min but not less than 4 min. These data are consistent with the three-phase model of cardiac arrest.

The UCSD Research Associate Program: a recipe for successfully integrating undergraduates with emergency medicine research.

Previous reports have documented the successful integration of undergraduates into the Emergency Department (ED) to assist in data collection for various research projects, with resultant improvements in departmental academic productivity. These reports have not detailed the exact procedures required to institute such a program. Over 100 undergraduates from three institutions currently participate in the UCSD Research Associate Program. Here we document our experience with the inception of such a program and define the various components required to successfully conduct an ED undergraduate research associate program, defining the roles of key personnel, detailing the administrative component, discussing the selection of appropriate research projects and the design of data and instruction sheets, addressing issues related to training and didactics, and suggesting strategies for recruitment and upkeep of interest.

The impact of hypoxia and hyperventilation on outcome after paramedic rapid sequence intubation of severely head-injured patients.

BACKGROUND: An increase in mortality has been documented in association with paramedic rapid sequence intubation (RSI) of severely head-injured patients. This analysis explores the impact of hypoxia and hyperventilation on outcome. METHODS: Adult severely head-injured patients (Glasgow Coma Scale score of 3-8) unable to be intubated without neuromuscular blockade underwent paramedic RSI using midazolam and succinylcholine; rocuronium was administered after confirmation of tube position. Standard ventilation parameters were used for most patients; however, one agency instituted use of digital end-tidal carbon dioxide (ETCO2) and oxygen saturation (Spo2) monitoring during the trial. Each patient undergoing digital ETCO2/Spo2 monitoring was matched to three historical nonintubated controls on the basis of age, gender, mechanism, and Abbreviated Injury Scale scores for each of six body regions. Logistic regression was used to explore the impact of oxygen desaturation during laryngoscopy and postintubation hypocapnia and hypoxia on outcome. The relationship between hypocapnia and ventilatory rate was explored using linear regression and univariate analysis. In addition, trial patients and controls were compared with regard to mortality and the incidence of "good outcomes" using an odds ratio analysis. RESULTS: Of the 426 trial patients, a total of 59 had complete ETCO2/Spo2 monitoring data; these were matched to 177 controls. Logistic regression revealed an association between the lowest ETCO2 value and final ETCO2 value and mortality. Matched-controls analysis confirmed an association between hypocapnia and mortality. A statistically significant association between ventilatory rate and ETCO2 value was observed (r = -0.13, p < 0.0001); the median ventilatory rate associated with the lowest recorded ETCO2 value was significantly higher than for all other ETCO2 values (27 mm Hg vs. 19 mm Hg, p < 0.0001). In addition, profound desaturations during RSI and hypoxia after intubation were associated with higher mortality than matched controls. Overall mortality was 41% for trial patients versus 22% for matched controls (odds ratio, 2.51; 95% confidence interval, 1.33-4.72; p = 0.004). CONCLUSIONS: Hyperventilation and severe hypoxia during paramedic RSI are associated with an increase in mortality.

Air medical transport of severely head-injured patients undergoing paramedic rapid sequence intubation.

INTRODUCTION: The San Diego Paramedic Rapid Sequence Intubation (RSI) Trial documented an increase in mortality with paramedic RSI of patients with severe traumatic brain injury. This analysis explores the impact of air medical transport of trial patients on outcome. METHODS: Adult trauma victims with severe traumatic brain injury (Glasgow Coma Scale score of 3 to 8) were prospectively enrolled. Paramedics performed RSI using midazolam and succinylcholine; air medical crews could be called at the discretion of ground paramedics, generally for anticipated prolonged transports. Patients were matched to historical controls using the following parameters: age, gender, mechanism, injury of severity score, and abbreviated injury scale scores for each body system. Patients transported by air and ground were compared with regard to demographics, clinical parameters, vital signs, arterial blood gas data, and outcome. RESULTS: A total of 336 patients were included (79 air medical and 257 ground transports). No significant differences arose between the groups with regard to demographic, clinical, vital sign, and arterial blood gas data. Air medical patients had decreased mortality (28% vs 31%, OR 0.9), and ground patients had increased mortality versus matched controls (33% vs 22%, OR 1.8). Discordant groups analysis revealed a statistically significant effect of transport personnel on outcome (P=.009). Neither advanced procedures nor the use of mannitol accounted for the improved outcomes; air medical crews used capnometry to guide ventilation on all study patients. CONCLUSION: Air medical transport of severely head-injured patients undergoing paramedic RSI was associated with improved outcomes. Improved ventilation by capnometry may account for part of these improvements.