Electrostatic origin of a stabilizing synergistic interaction among b-, c-, and f-residues in a trimeric coiled coil.

Coiled coils are one of most common protein quaternary structures and represent the best understood relationship between amino acid sequence and protein conformation. Whereas the roles of residues at the canonical heptad positions the a, d, e, and g are understood in precise detail, conventional approaches often assume that the solvent-exposed b-, c-, and f-positions can be varied broadly for application-specific purposes with minimal consequences. However, a growing body of evidence suggests that interactions among these b, c, and f residues can contribute substantially to coiled-coil conformational stability. In the trimeric coiled coil described here, we find that b-position Glu10 engages in a stabilizing long-range synergistic interaction with c-position Lys18 (ΔΔΔGf = -0.65 ± 0.02 kcal/mol). This favorable interaction depends strongly on the presence of two nearby f-position residues: Lys 7 and Tyr14. Extensive mutational analysis of these residues in the presence of added salt vs. denaturant suggests that this long-range synergistic interaction is primarily electrostatic in origin, but also depends on the precise location and acidity of a side-chain hydrogen-bond donor within f-position Tyr14.

Exploring biocompatible chemistry to create stapled and photoswitchable variants of the antimicrobial peptide aurein 1.2.

Antibiotic resistance is an escalating global health threat. Due to their diverse mechanisms of action and evasion of traditional resistance mechanisms, peptides hold promise as future antibiotics. Their ability to disrupt bacterial membranes presents a potential strategy to combat drug-resistant infections and address the increasing need for effective antimicrobial treatments. Amphipathic α-helical peptides possess a distinctive molecular structure with both charged/hydrophilic and hydrophobic regions that interact with the bacterial cell membrane, disrupting its structural integrity. The α-helical amphipathic peptide aurein 1.2, secreted by the Australian frog Litoria aurea, is one of the shortest known antimicrobial peptides, spanning only 13 amino acids. The primary objective of this study was to investigate stapled and photoswitchable modifications of short helical peptides employing biocompatible chemistry, utilising aurein 1.2 as a model system. We developed various stapled versions of aurein 1.2 using biocompatible conjugation chemistry between dicyanopyridine and 1,2-aminothiols. While the commonly employed stapling pattern for longer staples is i, i + 7, we observed superior helicity in peptides stapled at positions i, i + 8. Molecular dynamics simulations confirmed both stapling patterns to support an α-helical peptide conformation. Additionally, we utilised a cysteine-selective photosensitive staple, perfluoro azobenzene, to explore photoswitchable variants of aurein 1.2. A double-cysteine variant stapled at i, i + 7 indeed exhibited a change in overall helicity induced by light. We further demonstrated the applicability of this staple to attach to cysteine residues in i, i + 7 positions of a helix in a model protein. While some of the stapled variants displayed substantial increase in helicity, minimal inhibitory concentration assays revealed that none of the stapled aurein 1.2 variants exhibited increased antimicrobial activity compared to the wildtype.

A probabilistic view of protein stability, conformational specificity, and design.

Various approaches have used neural networks as probabilistic models for the design of protein sequences. These "inverse folding" models employ different objective functions, which come with trade-offs that have not been assessed in detail before. This study introduces probabilistic definitions of protein stability and conformational specificity and demonstrates the relationship between these chemical properties and the [Formula: see text] Boltzmann probability objective. This links the Boltzmann probability objective function to experimentally verifiable outcomes. We propose a novel sequence decoding algorithm, referred to as "BayesDesign", that leverages Bayes' Rule to maximize the [Formula: see text] objective instead of the [Formula: see text] objective common in inverse folding models. The efficacy of BayesDesign is evaluated in the context of two protein model systems, the NanoLuc enzyme and the WW structural motif. Both BayesDesign and the baseline ProteinMPNN algorithm increase the thermostability of NanoLuc and increase the conformational specificity of WW. The possible sources of error in the model are analyzed.

Structural guidelines for stabilization of α-helical coiled coils via PEG stapling.

Macrocyclization or stapling is one of the most well-known and generally applicable strategies for enhancing peptide/protein conformational stability and target binding affinity. However, there are limited structure- or sequence-based guidelines for the incorporation of optimal interhelical staples within coiled coils: the location and length of an interhelical staple is either arbitrarily chosen or requires significant optimization. Here we explore the impact of interhelical PEG stapling on the conformational stability and proteolytic resistance of a model disulfide-bound heterodimeric coiled coil. We demonstrate that (1) interhelical PEG staples are more stabilizing when placed farther from an existing disulfide crosslink; (2) e/g' staples are more stabilizing than f/b' or b/c' staples; (3) PEG staples between different positions have different optimal staple lengths; (4) PEG stapling tolerates variation in the structure of the PEG linker and in the mode of conjugation; and (5) the guidelines developed here enable the rational design of a stabilized PEG-stapled HER-2 affibody with enhanced conformational stability and proteolytic resistance.

Prerequisites for Stabilizing Long-Range Synergistic Interactions among b-, c-, and f-Residues in Coiled Coils.

Coiled coils are among the most abundant tertiary and quaternary structures found in proteins. A growing body of evidence suggests that long-range synergistic interactions among solvent-exposed residues can contribute substantially to coiled-coil conformational stability, but our understanding of the key sequence and structural prerequisites of this effect is still developing. Here, we show that the strength of synergistic interaction involving a b-position Glu (i), an f-position Tyr (i + 4), and a c-position Lys (i + 8) depends on the identity of the f-position residue, the length and stability of the coiled coil, and its oligomerization stoichiometry/surface accessibility. Combined with previous observations, these results map out predictable sequence- and structure-based criteria for enhancing coiled-coil stability by up to -0.58 kcal/mol per monomer (or -2.32 kcal/mol per coiled-coil tetramer). Our observations expand the available tools for enhancing coiled coil stability by sequence variation at solvent-exposed b-, c-, and f-positions and suggest the need to exercise care in the choice of substitutions at these positions for application-specific purposes.

PEGylation Increases the Strength of a Nearby NH-π Hydrogen Bond in the WW Domain.

Here we show that an NH-π interaction between a highly conserved Asn and a nearby Trp stabilizes the WW domain of the human protein Pin1. The strength of this NH-π interaction depends on the structure of the arene, with NH-π interactions involving Trp or naphthylalanine being substantially more stabilizing than those involving Tyr or Phe. Calculations suggest arene size and polarizability are key structural determinants of NH-π interaction strength. Methylation or PEGylation of the Asn side-chain amide nitrogen each strengthens the associated NH-π interaction, though likely for different reasons. We hypothesize that methylation introduces steric clashes that destabilize conformations in which the NH-π interaction is not possible, whereas PEGylation strengthens the NH-π interaction via localized desolvation of the protein surface.

Context-Dependent Stabilizing Interactions among Solvent-Exposed Residues along the Surface of a Trimeric Helix Bundle.

Here we show that a solvent-exposed f-position (i.e., residue 14) within a well-characterized trimeric helix bundle can facilitate a stabilizing long-range synergistic interaction involving b-position Glu10 (i.e., i - 4 relative to residue 14) and c-position Lys18 (i.e., i + 4), depending the identity of residue 14. The extent of stabilization associated with the Glu10-Lys18 pair depends primarily on the presence of a side-chain hydrogen-bond donor at residue 14; the nonpolar or hydrophobic character of residue 14 plays a smaller but still significant role. Crystal structures and molecular dynamics simulations indicate that Glu10 and Lys18 do not interact directly with each other but suggest the possibility that the proximity of residue 14 with Lys18 allows Glu10 to interact favorably with nearby Lys7. Subsequent thermodynamic experiments confirm the important role of Lys7 in the large synergistic stabilization associated with the Glu10-Lys18 pair. Our results highlight the exquisite complexity and surprising long-range synergistic interactions among b-, c-, and f-position residues within helix bundles, suggesting new possibilities for engineering hyperstable helix bundles and emphasizing the need to consider carefully the impact of substitutions at these positions for application-specific purposes.

Long-range PEG Stapling: Macrocyclization for Increased Protein Conformational Stability and Resistance to Proteolysis.

We previously showed that long-range stapling of two Asn-linked O-allyl PEG oligomers via olefin metathesis substantially increases the conformational stability of the WW domain through an entropic effect. The impact of stapling was more favorable when the staple connected positions that were far apart in primary sequence but close in the folded tertiary structure. Here we validate these criteria for identifying new stabilizing PEG-stapling sites within the WW domain and the SH3 domain, both ß-sheet proteins. We find that stapling via olefin metathesis vs. the copper(I)-catalyzed azide/alkyne cycloaddition (CuAAC) results in similar energetic benefits, suggesting that olefin and triazole staples can be used interchangeably. Proteolysis assays of selected WW variants reveal that the observed staple-based increases in conformational stability lead to enhanced proteolytic resistance. Finally, we find that an intermolecular staple dramatically increases the quaternary structural stability of an α-helical GCN4 coiled-coil heterodimer.

PEGylation near a Patch of Nonpolar Surface Residues Increases the Conformational Stability of the WW Domain.

Many proteins have one or more surface-exposed patches of nonpolar residues; our observations here suggest that PEGylation near such locations might be a useful strategy for increasing protein conformational stability. Specifically, we show that conjugating a PEG-azide to a propargyloxyphenylalanine via the copper(I)-catalyzed azide-alkyne cycloaddition can increase the conformational stability of the WW domain due to a favorable synergistic effect that depends on the hydrophobicity of a nearby patch of nonpolar surface residues.

Influence of PEGylation on the Strength of Protein Surface Salt Bridges.

Conjugation of polyethylene glycol (PEGylation) is a well-known strategy for extending the serum half-life of protein drugs and for increasing their resistance to proteolysis and aggregation. We previously showed that PEGylation can increase protein conformational stability; the extent of PEG-based stabilization depends on the PEGylation site, the structure of the PEG-protein linker, and the ability of PEG to release water molecules from the surrounding protein surface to the bulk solvent. The strength of a noncovalent interaction within a protein depends strongly on its microenvironment, with salt-bridge and hydrogen-bond strength increasing in nonpolar versus aqueous environments. Accordingly, we wondered whether partial desolvation by PEG of the surrounding protein surface might result in measurable increases in the strength of a salt bridge near a PEGylation site. Here we explore this possibility using triple-mutant box analysis to assess the impact of PEGylation on the strength of nearby salt bridges at specific locations within three peptide model systems. The results indicate that PEG can increase the nearby salt-bridge strength, though this effect is not universal, and its precise structural prerequisites are not a simple function of secondary structural context, of the orientation and distance between the PEGylation site and salt bridge, or of salt-bridge residue identity. We obtained high-resolution X-ray diffraction data for a PEGylated peptide in which PEG enhances the strength of a nearby salt bridge. Comparing the electron density map of this PEGylated peptide versus that of its non-PEGylated counterpart provides evidence of localized protein surface desolvation as a mechanism for PEG-based salt-bridge stabilization.

Stapling of two PEGylated side chains increases the conformational stability of the WW domain via an entropic effect.

Hydrocarbon stapling and PEGylation are distinct strategies for enhancing the conformational stability and/or pharmacokinetic properties of peptide and protein drugs. Here we combine these approaches by incorporating asparagine-linked O-allyl PEG oligomers at two positions within the ß-sheet protein WW, followed by stapling of the PEGs via olefin metathesis. The impact of stapling two sites that are close in primary sequence is small relative to the impact of PEGylation alone and depends strongly on PEG length. In contrast, stapling of two PEGs that are far apart in primary sequence but close in tertiary structure provides substantially more stabilization, derived mostly from an entropic effect. Comparison of PEGylation + stapling vs. alkylation + stapling at the same positions in WW reveals that both approaches provide similar overall levels of conformational stability.

Polyethylene Glycol Based Changes to ß-Sheet Protein Conformational and Proteolytic Stability Depend on Conjugation Strategy and Location.

The development of chemical strategies for site-specific protein modification now enables researchers to attach polyethylene glycol (PEG) to a protein drug at one or more specific locations (i.e., protein PEGylation). However, aside from avoiding enzyme active sites or protein-binding interfaces, distinguishing the optimal PEGylation site from the available alternatives has conventionally been a matter of trial and error. As part of a continuing effort to develop guidelines for identifying optimal PEGylation sites within proteins, we show here that the impact of PEGylation at various sites within the ß-sheet model protein WW depends strongly on the identity of the PEG-protein linker. The PEGylation of Gln or of azidohomoalanine has a similar impact on WW conformational stability as does Asn-PEGylation, whereas the PEGylation of propargyloxyphenylalanine is substantially stabilizing at locations where Asn-PEGylation was destabilizing. Importantly, we find that at least one of these three site-specific PEGylation strategies leads to substantial PEG-based stabilization at each of the positions investigated, highlighting the importance of considering conjugation strategy as an important variable in selecting optimal PEGylation sites. We further demonstrate that using a branched PEG oligomer intensifies the impact of PEGylation on WW conformational stability and also show that PEG-based increases to conformational stability are strongly associated with corresponding increases in proteolytic stability.

Bulky Dehydroamino Acids Enhance Proteolytic Stability and Folding in ß-Hairpin Peptides.

The bulky dehydroamino acids dehydrovaline (ΔVal) and dehydroethylnorvaline (ΔEnv) can be inserted into the turn regions of ß-hairpin peptides without altering their secondary structures. These residues increase proteolytic stability, with ΔVal at the (i + 1) position having the most substantial impact. Additionally, a bulky dehydroamino acid can be paired with a d-amino acid (i.e., d-Pro) to synergistically enhance resistance to proteolysis. A link between proteolytic stability and peptide structure is established by the finding that a stabilized ΔVal-containing ß-hairpin is more highly folded than its Asn-containing congener.

An Anion-π Interaction Strongly Stabilizes the ß-Sheet Protein WW.

Anions have long been known to engage in stabilizing interactions with electron-deficient arenes. However, the precise nature and energetic contribution of anion-π interactions to protein stability remains a subject of debate. Here, we show that placing a negatively charged Asp in close proximity to electron-rich Phe in a reverse turn within the WW domain results in a favorable interaction that increases WW conformational stability by -1.3 kcal/mol.

Enhancing a long-range salt bridge with intermediate aromatic and nonpolar amino acids.

The interaction of a positively charged amino acid residue with a negatively charged residue (i.e. a salt bridge) can contribute substantially to protein conformational stability, especially when two ionic groups are in close proximity. At longer distances, this stabilizing effect tends to drop off precipitously. However, several lines of evidence suggest that salt-bridge interaction could persist at longer distances if an aromatic amino acid residue were positioned between the anion and cation. Here we explore this possibility in the context of a peptide in which a Lys residue occupies the i + 8 position relative to an i-position Glu on the solvent-exposed surface of a helix-bundle homotrimer. Variable temperature circular dichroism (CD) experiments indicate that an i + 4-position Trp enables a favorable long-range interaction between Glu and the i + 8 Lys. A substantial portion of this effect relies on the presence of a hydrogen-bond donor on the arene; however, non-polar arenes, a cyclic hydrocarbon, and an acyclic Leu side-chain can also enhance the long-range salt bridge, possibly by excluding water and ions from the space between Glu and Lys.

How PEGylation influences protein conformational stability.

PEGylation is an important strategy for enhancing the pharmacokinetic properties of protein therapeutics. The development of chemoselective side-chain modification reactions has enabled researchers to PEGylate proteins with high selectivity at defined locations. However, aside from avoiding active sites and binding interfaces, there are few guidelines for the selection of optimal PEGylation sites. Because conformational stability is intimately related to the ability of a protein to avoid proteolysis, aggregation, and immune responses, it is possible that PEGylating a protein at sites where PEG enhances conformational stability will result in PEG-protein conjugates with enhanced pharmacokinetic properties. However, the impact of PEGylation on protein conformational stability is incompletely understood. This review describes recent advances toward understanding the impact of PEGylation on protein conformational stability, along with the development of structure-based guidelines for selecting stabilizing PEGylation sites.

Conjugation Strategy Strongly Impacts the Conformational Stability of a PEG-Protein Conjugate.

Site-specific PEGylation is an important strategy for enhancing the pharmacokinetic properties of protein drugs, and has been enabled by the recent development of many chemoselective reactions for protein side-chain modification. However, the impact of these different conjugation strategies on the properties of PEG-protein conjugates is poorly understood. Here we show that the ability of PEG to enhance protein conformational stability depends strongly on the identity of the PEG-protein linker, with the most stabilizing linkers involving conjugation of PEG to planar polar groups near the peptide backbone. We also find that branched PEGs provide superior stabilization relative to their linear counterparts, suggesting additional applications for branched PEGs in protein stabilization.

Cys(i)-Lys(i+3)-Lys(i+4) triad: a general approach for PEG-based stabilization of α-helical proteins.

PEGylation is an important strategy for enhancing the pharmacokinetic properties of protein drugs. Modern chemoselective reactions now enable specific placement of a single PEG at any site on a protein surface. However, few rational structure-based guidelines exist for selecting optimal PEGylation sites. Here, we explore the impact of PEGylation on the conformational stability of α-helices using an α-helical coiled coil as a model system. We find that maleimide-based PEGylation of a solvent-exposed i position Cys can stabilize coiled-coil quaternary structure when Lys residues occupy both the i + 3 and i + 4 positions, due to favorable interactions between the PEG-maleimide and the Lys residues. Applying this Cys(i)-Lys(i+3)-Lys(i+4) triad to a solvent-exposed position within the C-terminal helix of the villin headpiece domain leads to similar PEG-based increases in conformational stability, highlighting the possibility of using the Cys(i)-Lys(i+3)-Lys(i+4) triad as a general strategy for PEG-based stabilization of helical proteins.

Criteria for selecting PEGylation sites on proteins for higher thermodynamic and proteolytic stability.

PEGylation of protein side chains has been used for more than 30 years to enhance the pharmacokinetic properties of protein drugs. However, there are no structure- or sequence-based guidelines for selecting sites that provide optimal PEG-based pharmacokinetic enhancement with minimal losses to biological activity. We hypothesize that globally optimal PEGylation sites are characterized by the ability of the PEG oligomer to increase protein conformational stability; however, the current understanding of how PEG influences the conformational stability of proteins is incomplete. Here we use the WW domain of the human protein Pin 1 (WW) as a model system to probe the impact of PEG on protein conformational stability. Using a combination of experimental and theoretical approaches, we develop a structure-based method for predicting which sites within WW are most likely to experience PEG-based stabilization, and we show that this method correctly predicts the location of a stabilizing PEGylation site within the chicken Src SH3 domain. PEG-based stabilization in WW is associated with enhanced resistance to proteolysis, is entropic in origin, and likely involves disruption by PEG of the network of hydrogen-bound solvent molecules that surround the protein. Our results highlight the possibility of using modern site-specific PEGylation techniques to install PEG oligomers at predetermined locations where PEG will provide optimal increases in conformational and proteolytic stability.

Two structural scenarios for protein stabilization by PEG.

PEGylation, or addition of poly(ethylene glycol) chains to proteins, is widely used to improve delivery in pharmaceutical applications. Recent studies suggest that stabilization of a protein by PEG, and hence its proteolytic degradability, is sequence-dependent and requires only short PEG chains. Here we connect stabilization by short PEG chains directly to the structural dynamics of the protein and PEG chain. We measured the stability of human Pin1 WW domain with PEG-4 at asparagine 19 for a full mutant cycle at two positions thought to influence PEG-protein interaction: Ser16Ala and Tyr23Phe. We then performed explicit solvent molecular dynamics simulations on all PEGylated and PEG-free mutants. The mutant cycle yields a nonadditive stabilization effect where the pseudo-wild type and double mutant are more stabilized relative to unPEGylated proteins than are the two single mutants. The simulation reveals why: the double mutant suffers loss of ß-sheet structure, which PEGylation restores even though the PEG extends as a coil into the solvent. In contrast, in one of the single mutants, PEG preferentially interacts with the protein surface while disrupting the interactions of its asparagine host with a nearby methionine side chain. Thus, PEG attachment can stabilize a protein differentially depending on the local sequence, and either by interacting with the surface or by extending into the solvent. A simulation with PEG-45 attached to asparagine 19 shows that PEG even can do both in the same context.