2'-O-(2-Methoxyethyl) Nucleosides Are Not Phosphorylated or Incorporated Into the Genome of Human Lymphoblastoid TK6 Cells.

Nucleoside analogs with 2'-modified sugar moieties are often used to improve the RNA target affinity and nuclease resistance of therapeutic oligonucleotides in preclinical and clinical development. Despite their enhanced nuclease resistance, oligonucleotides could slowly degrade releasing nucleoside analogs that have the potential to become phosphorylated and incorporated into cellular DNA and RNA. For the first time, the phosphorylation and DNA/RNA incorporation of 2'-O-(2-methoxyethyl) (2'-O-MOE) nucleoside analogs have been investigated. Using liquid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry, we showed that enzymes in the nucleotide salvage pathway including deoxycytidine kinase (dCK) and thymidine kinase (TK1) displayed poor reactivity toward 2'-O-MOE nucleoside analogs. On the other hand, 2'-fluoro (F) nucleosides, regardless of the nucleobase, were efficiently phosphorylated to their monophosphate forms by dCK and TK1. Consistent with their efficient phosphorylation by dCK and TK1, 2'-F nucleoside analogs were incorporated into cellular DNA and RNA while no incorporation was detected with 2'-O-MOE nucleoside analogs. In conclusion, these data suggest that the inability of dCK and TK1 to create the monophosphates of 2'-O-MOE nucleoside analogs reduces the risk of their incorporation into cellular DNA and RNA.

The Lack of Mutagenic Potential of a Guanine-Rich Triplex Forming Oligonucleotide in Physiological Conditions.

Triplex forming oligonucleotides (TFOs) bind in the major groove of DNA duplex in a sequence-specific manner imparted by Hoogsteen hydrogen bonds. There have been several reports demonstrating the ability of guanine-rich TFOs to induce targeted mutagenesis on an exogenous plasmid or an endogenous chromosomal locus. In particular, a 30mer guanine-rich triplex forming oligonucleotide, AG30, optimally designed to target the supFG1 reporter gene was reported to be mutagenic in the absence of DNA reactive agents in cultured cells and in vivo Here, we investigated the mutagenic potential of AG30 using the supFG1 shuttle vector forward mutation assay under physiological conditions. We also assessed the triplex binding potential of AG30 alongside cytotoxic and mutagenic assessment. In a cell free condition, AG30 was able to bind its polypurine target site in the supFG1 gene in the absence of potassium chloride and also aligned with a 5-fold increase in the mutant frequency when AG30 was pre-incubated with the supFG1 plasmid in the absence of potassium prior to transfection into COS-7 cells. However, when we analyzed triplex formation of AG30 and the supFG1 target duplex at physiological potassium levels, triplex formation was inhibited due to the formation of competing secondary structures. Subsequent assessment of mutant frequency under physiological conditions, by pre-transfecting COS-7 cells with the supFG1 plasmid prior to AG30 treatment led to a very small increase (1.4-fold) in the mutant frequency. Transfection of cells with even higher concentrations of AG30 did result in an elevated mutagenic response but this was also seen with a scrambled sequence, and was therefore considered unlikely to be biologically relevant as an associated increase in cytotoxicity was also apparent. Our findings also provide further assurance on the low potential of triplex-mediated mutation as a consequence of unintentional genomic DNA binding by therapeutic antisense oligonucleotides.

OSWG Recommendations for Genotoxicity Testing of Novel Oligonucleotide-Based Therapeutics.

The Oligonucleotide Safety Working Group subcommittee on genotoxicity testing considers therapeutic oligonucleotides (ONs) unlikely to be genotoxic based on their properties and on the negative results for ONs tested to date. Nonetheless, the subcommittee believes that genotoxicity testing of new ONs is warranted because modified monomers could be liberated from a metabolized ON and incorporated into DNA and could hypothetically cause chain termination, miscoding, and/or faulty replication or repair. The standard test battery as described in Option 1 of International Conference on Harmonisation S2(R1) is generally adequate to assess such potential. However, for the in vitro assay for gene mutations, mammalian cells are considered more relevant than bacteria for most ONs due to their known responsiveness to nucleosides and their greater potential for ON uptake; on the other hand, bacterial assays may be more appropriate for ONs containing non-ON components. Testing is not recommended for ONs with only naturally occurring chemistries or for ONs with chemistries for which there is documented lack of genotoxicity in systems with demonstrated cellular uptake. Testing is recommended for ONs that contain non-natural chemical modifications and use of the complete drug product (including linkers, conjugates, and liposomes) is suggested to provide the most clinically relevant assessment. Documentation of uptake into cells comparable to those used for genotoxicity testing is proposed because intracellular exposure cannot be assumed for these large molecules. ONs could also hypothetically cause mutations through triple helix formation with genomic DNA and no tests are available for detection of such sequence-specific mutations across the entire genome. However, because the potential for triplex formation by therapeutic ONs is extremely low, this potential can be assessed adequately by sequence analysis.

Evaluation of 4,4'-diaminodiphenyl ether in the rat comet assay: Part of the Japanese Center for the Validation of Alternative Methods (JaCVAM)-initiative international validation study of in vivo rat alkaline comet assay.

As a part of the Japanese Center for the Validation of Alternative Methods (JaCVAM)-initiative international validation study of the in vivo rat alkaline comet assay, 4,4'-diaminodiphenyl ether (DPE), a known rodent genotoxic carcinogen, was tested in this laboratory. Sprague Dawley rats (7-9 weeks of age) were given three oral doses of DPE, 24 and 21 h apart and liver or stomach sampled 3h after the final dose. Under the conditions of the test, no increases in DNA damage in liver and stomach were observed with DPE (up to 200 mg/kg/day). A dose-dependent decrease in DNA migration, compared to vehicle controls, was noted for DPE in rat stomach. Further analysis is required to elucidate fully whether this decrease is a consequence of the mode of action or due to the toxicity of DPE. What is perhaps surprising is the inability of the comet assay to detect a known rat genotoxic carcinogen in liver. Further investigation is needed to clarify whether this apparent lack of response results from limited tissue exposure or metabolic differences between species. This finding highlights a need for careful consideration of study design when evaluating assay performance as a measure of in vivo genotoxicity.

Re-evaluation of the Mutagenic Response to Phosphorothioate Nucleotides in Human Lymphoblastoid TK6 Cells.

The degradation of phosphorothioate oligonucleotides (PS-ONDs) and the release of potentially genotoxic modified mononucleotides raise a safety concern for OND-based therapeutics. Deoxyadenosine monophosphorothioate (dAMPαS), a PS nucleotide analog, has been reported to be a potent in vitro mutagen at the thymidine kinase (TK) locus in human TK6 lymphoblastoid cells. This led us to explore the mechanism behind the apparent positive response induced by dAMPαS in the TK gene-mutation assay in TK6 cells. In this work, treatment of TK6 cells with dAMPαS produced a dose-dependent increase in cytotoxicity and mutant frequency at the TK locus. Surprisingly, when the colonies from dAMPαS were re-challenged with the selective agent trifluorothymidine (TFT), the TFT-resistant phenotype was lost. Moreover, dAMPαS-induced colonies displayed distinct growth kinetics and required longer incubation time than 4-nitroquinoline-1-oxide-induced colonies to start growing. Treatment of TK6 cells with dAMPαS induced cell cycle arrest at the G1 phase, enabling cells to grow, and form a colony after the efficacy of TFT in the culture medium was lost. Our findings suggest that a fraction of parental "nonmutant" TK6 cells escaped the toxicity of TFT, possibly via G1 arrest, and resumed growth after the degradation of TFT. We conclude that dAMPαS did not induce real TFT-resistant mutants and caution should be taken with interpretation of mutation data from TK gene-mutation assay in TK6 cells when assessing modified nucleotides.

A comparative performance test of standard, medium- and high-throughput comet assays.

A serious limitation of the conventional comet assay (single cell gel electrophoresis) is the restriction on the number of samples that can be processed in one experiment, imposed by the size of the electrophoresis platform. One approach to increasing throughput is to reduce the size of gels. We here compare the conventional system of two large gels on a microscope slide, with two recent developments, namely 12 minigels per slide, and a format with 96 minigels on GelBond® film. We used cells treated with X-rays or methylmethanesulphonate (MMS). The level of damage detected (% tail DNA) in X-irradiated or MMS-treated cells was not affected by the format used. Parallel experiments, using all three formats, were performed with MMS-treated cells in two independent laboratories; the difference in results between the two laboratories was of borderline significance. The potential problem of anomalous comets seen at the border of the gel, the so-called 'edge effects', has been addressed. A reliable, high throughput comet assay has applications in genotoxicity testing (particularly for in vivo studies with samples from different organs) as well as ecogenotoxicology and human biomonitoring, where the numbers of samples collected can be considerable.

Mutagenesis by an antisense oligonucleotide and its degradation product.

The European Medicines Agency has expressed concern regarding (1) the potential for antisense oligonucleotide (ASO) therapeutics to induce sequence-specific mutation at genomic DNA and (2) the capability of ASO degradation products (nucleotide analogues) to incorporate into newly synthesized genomic DNA via DNA polymerase and cause mutation if base pairing occurs with reduced fidelity. Treating human lymphoblastoid cells with a biologically active antisense molecule induced sequence-specific mutation within genomic DNA over fourfold, in a system where RAD51 protein expression was induced. This finding has implications for ASO therapeutics with individuals with an induced DNA damage response, such as cancer patients. Furthermore, a phosphorothioate nucleotide analogue potently induced mutation at genomic DNA two orders of magnitude above control. This study shows that a biologically active ASO molecule can induce heritable sequence alterations, and if degraded, its respective analogue may incorporate into genomic DNA with mutagenic consequences.

A triple-helix forming oligonucleotide targeting genomic DNA fails to induce mutation.

Purine tracts in duplex DNA can bind oligonucleotide strands in a sequence specific manner to form triple-helix structures. Triple-helix forming oligonucleotides (TFOs) targeting supFG1 constructs have previously been shown to be mutagenic raising safety concerns for oligonucleotide-based pharmaceuticals. We have engineered a TFO, TFO27, to target the genomic Hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT) locus to define the mutagenic potential of such structures at genomic DNA. We report that TFO27 was resistant to nuclease degradation and readily binds to its target motif in a cell free system. Contrary to previous studies using the supFG1 reporter construct, TFO27 failed to induce mutation within the genomic HPRT locus. We suggest that it is possible that previous reports of triplex-mediated mutation using the supFG1 reporter construct could be confounded by DNA quadruplex formation. Although the present study indicates that a TFO targeting a genomic locus lacks mutagenic activity, it is unclear if this finding can be generalised to all TFOs and their targets. For the present, we suggest that it is prudent to avoid large purine stretches in oligonucleotide pharmaceutical design to minimise concern regarding off-target genotoxicity.

The genotoxic potential of methapyrilene using the alkaline Comet assay in vitro and in vivo.

The genotoxicity of methapyrilne (MP) has been evaluated in a number of assays since it was found to be a rat hepatocarcinogen with subsequent withdrawal as an over-the-counter antihistamine. Whilst it has not been classified as a genotoxin, there are reports of positive findings from mammalian cell gene mutation and transformation assays. To investigate further the genotoxic potential of MP, the alkaline Comet assay was used to evaluate DNA damage both in primary hepatocytes in culture and in vivo in the rat. To confirm bioactivation was required to induce the hepatotoxic mechanism, aminobenzotriazole, a broad spectrum cytochrome P450 enzyme inhibitor was used as a pre-treatment. The levels of glutathione and glutathione disulfide were determined in both hepatocytes in culture and in the liver following in vivo exposure. MP showed significant increases in DNA damage in freshly isolated male rat hepatocyte suspensions that could be significantly reduced by pre-incubation of aminobenzotriazole (ABT). DNA damage showed a marked sex difference, with male hepatocytes being more susceptible, and showing a concurrent depletion of glutathione (GSH) compared with female hepatocytes. Modulation of the GSH levels by diethylmaleate and γ-glutamylcysteinylethyl ester, elevated and reduced the levels of DNA damage, respectively. In the in vivo Comet assay, there was no evidence of DNA damage following MP (150mg/kg p.o) treatment for three consecutive days, although histological and liver enzyme changes were seen. Total protein GSH content was elevated in MP-treated animals and superoxide dismutase levels were increased specifically in periportal regions. Taken together, these data support the potential for MP to induce oxidative stress. The differences in DNA damage detected by the Comet assay in vitro, and in rat liver in vivo, could be attributed to differences in metabolism and response to oxidant insult or the inability of the assay to discriminate damage in a small number of individual cells in the whole liver.

The ability of the mouse lymphoma TK assay to detect aneugens.

There is some evidence that the mouse lymphoma TK assay (MLA) can detect aneugens, and this is accepted in the current International Conference on Harmonisation guidance for testing pharmaceuticals. However, whether or not it can be used as a reliable screen for aneugenicity has been the subject of debate. Consequently, aneugens with diverse mechanisms of action were tested in the MLA using 24-h exposure. No evidence of increased mutant frequency was seen with noscapine, diazepam or colchicine and increases were seen with taxol, carbendazim, econazole and chloral hydrate only at high levels of toxicity (for all but one taxol concentration survival reduced to ≤10% of control). None of these agents would be unequivocally classified as positive using currently accepted criteria. The largest increases in mutant number were seen with taxol and carbendazim; therefore, trifluorothymidine (TFT)-resistant clones resulting from treatment with them were cultured and analysed for chromosome 11 copy number using fluorescent in situ hybridisation (FISH) and loss of heterozygosity (LOH). High concentrations of these aneugens induced LOH at all loci examined indicating only one chromosome 11 was present but, perhaps surprisingly, all were found to have two copies of chromosome 11 using FISH. This would be consistent with loss of the tk(+) chromosome 11b with concomitant duplication of chromosome 11a, which has been proposed as a likely mechanism for induction of TFT-resistant clones. However, it was also surprising that analysis of centromere size showed that almost all the clones had both small and large centromeres, i.e. suggesting the presence of both chromosomes 11a and 11b. In conclusion, it appears that the TFT-resistant mutants resulting from treatment with toxic concentrations of some aneugens such as taxol and carbendazim have undergone complex genetic changes. However, these data show that the MLA cannot be used as a routine screen to detect aneugens.

Optimization of a radiolabel DNA-binding assay in cultured mammalian cells.

An improved protocol for the radiolabel DNA-binding assay, which gives a high yield of highly pure DNA has been developed by use of mouse lymphoma cells. The critical difference from previously published methods is the use of enzymatic degradation of proteins in the later DNA purification steps rather than during the homogenisation procedure. Different DNA-purification methodologies were first compared and the protocol of choice was optimized later on; both steps were performed with [(35)S]-labelled amino acids for labelling of cellular protein, which enabled both the quantification of cellular protein contaminating the DNA sample and the distinction between cellular and enzyme-derived protein. The assay was later evaluated and shown to give reproducible results based on the data obtained with benzo[a]pyrene (B[a]P) and doxorubicin in two different laboratories. In addition, two further reference compounds, dopamine and diazepam and one proprietary AstraZeneca compound were also tested in mouse lymphoma cells in one laboratory. The two compounds B[a]P and doxorubicin were identified as suitable positive controls for routine testing in the presence and absence of S9, respectively. Exposing 90-100×10(6) cells to (14)C-labelled compound with a molar radioactivity of 2MBq/µmol, yields approximately 500µg DNA with <3% total protein contamination, of which approximately 7% is of cellular origin (<0.2%). The detection level is approximately 2adducts/10(8) dNTP.

Anomalous genotoxic responses induced in mouse lymphoma L5178Y cells by potassium bromate.

Potassium bromate (KBrO3) is a well-established rodent kidney carcinogen and its oxidising activity is considered to be a significant factor in its mechanism of action. Although it has also been shown to be clearly genotoxic in a range of in vivo and in vitro test systems, surprisingly, it is not readily detected in several cell lines using the standard alkaline Comet assay. However, previous results from this laboratory demonstrated huge increases in tail intensity by modifying the method to include incubation with either human 8-oxodeoxyguanosine DNA glycosylase-1 (hOGG1) or bacterial formamidopyrimidine DNA glycosylase (FPG) indicating that, as expected, significant amounts of 8-oxodeoxyguanosine (8-OHdG) were induced. The purpose of this work, therefore, was to investigate why KBrO3, in contrast to other oxidising agents, gives a relatively poor response in the standard Comet assay. Results confirmed that it is a potent genotoxin in mouse lymphoma L5178Y cells inducing micronuclei and mutation at the tk and hprt loci at relatively non-cytotoxic concentrations. Subsequent time-course studies demonstrated that substantial amounts of 8-OHdG appear to remain in cells 24h after treatment with KBrO3 but result in no increase in frank stand breaks (FSB) even though phosphorylated histone H2AX (gamma-H2AX) antibody labelling confirmed the presence of double-strand breaks. Using bromodeoxyuracil (BrdU) incorporation together with measured increases in cell numbers, L5178Y cells also appeared to go through the cell cycle with unrepaired hOGG1-recognisable damage. Since unrepaired 8-OHdG can give rise to point mutations through G:C-->T:A transversions, it was also surprising that mutation could not be detected at the Na+/K+ATPase locus as determined by ouabain resistance. Some increases in strand breakage could be seen in the Comet assay by increasing the unwinding time, but only at highly toxic concentrations and to a much smaller extent than would be expected from the magnitude of the other genotoxic responses. It was considered unlikely that these anomalous observations were due to the inability of L5178Y cells to recognise 8-OHdG because these cells were shown to express mOGG1 and have functional cleavage activity at the adducted site. It appears that the responses of L5178Y cells to KBrO3 are complex and differ from those induced by other oxidising agents.