Experimental taphonomy of giant sulphur bacteria: implications for the interpretation of the embryo-like Ediacaran Doushantuo fossils.

The Ediacaran Doushantuo biota has yielded fossils interpreted as eukaryotic organisms, either animal embryos or eukaryotes basal or distantly related to Metazoa. However, the fossils have been interpreted alternatively as giant sulphur bacteria similar to the extant Thiomargarita. To test this hypothesis, living and decayed Thiomargarita were compared with Doushantuo fossils and experimental taphonomic pathways were compared with modern embryos. In the fossils, as in eukaryotic cells, subcellular structures are distributed throughout cell volume; in Thiomargarita, a central vacuole encompasses approximately 98 per cent cell volume. Key features of the fossils, including putative lipid vesicles and nuclei, complex envelope ornament, and ornate outer vesicles are incompatible with living and decay morphologies observed in Thiomargarita. Microbial taphonomy of Thiomargarita also differed from that of embryos. Embryo tissues can be consumed and replaced by bacteria, forming a replica composed of a three-dimensional biofilm, a stable fabric for potential fossilization. Vacuolated Thiomargarita cells collapse easily and do not provide an internal substrate for bacteria. The findings do not support the hypothesis that giant sulphur bacteria are an appropriate interpretative model for the embryo-like Doushantuo fossils. However, sulphur bacteria may have mediated fossil mineralization and may provide a potential bacterial analogue for other macroscopic Precambrian remains.

The active evolutionary lives of echinoderm larvae.

Echinoderms represent a researchable subset of a dynamic larval evolutionary cosmos. Evolution of echinoderm larvae has taken place over widely varying time scales from the origins of larvae of living classes in the early Palaeozoic, approximately 500 million years ago, to recent, rapid and large-scale changes that have occurred within living genera within a span of less than a million years to a few million years. It is these recent evolutionary events that offer a window into processes of larval evolution operating at a micro-evolutionary level of evolution of discrete developmental mechanisms. We review the evolution of the diverse larval forms of living echinoderms to outline the origins of echinoderm larval forms, their diversity among living echinoderms, molecular clocks and rates of larval evolution, and finally current studies on the roles of developmental regulatory mechanisms in the rapid and radical evolutionary changes observed between closely related congeneric species.

Evolutionary convergence in Otx expression in the pentameral adult rudiment in direct-developing sea urchins.

Convergence is a significant evolutionary phenomenon. Arrival at similar morphologies from different starting points indicates a strong role for natural selection in shaping morphological phenotypes. There is no evidence yet of convergence in the developmental mechanisms that underlie the evolution of convergent developmental phenotypes. Here we report the expression domains in sea urchins of two important developmental regulatory genes ( Orthodenticle and Runt), and show evidence of molecular convergence in the evolution of direct-developing sea urchins. Indirect development is ancestral in sea urchins. Evolutionary loss of the feeding pluteus stage and precocious formation of the radially symmetric juvenile has evolved independently in numerous sea urchin lineages, thus direct development is an evolutionary convergence. Indirect-developing species do not express Otx during the formation of their five primordial tube feet, the ancestral condition. However, each direct-developing urchin examined does express Otx in the tube feet. Otx expression in the radial arms of direct-developing sea urchins is thus convergent, and may indicate a specific need for Otx use in direct development, a constraint that would make direct development less able to evolve than if there were multiple molecular means for it to evolve. In contrast, Runt is expressed in tube feet in both direct- and indirect-developing species. Because echinoderms are closely related to chordates and postdate the protostome/deuterostome divergence, they must have evolved from bilaterally symmetrical ancestors. Arthropods and chordates use Otx in patterning their anterior axis, and Runt has multiple roles including embryonic patterning in arthropods, and blood and bone cell differentiation in vertebrates. Runt has apparently been co-opted in echinoderms for patterning of pentamery, and Otx in pentameral patterning among direct-developing echinoids. The surprisingly dynamic nature of Otx evolution reinvigorates debate on the role of natural selection vs shared ancestry in the evolution of novel features.

Wnt gene expression in sea urchin development: heterochronies associated with the evolution of developmental mode.

The Wnt genes encode a large family of conserved secreted proteins that are widely involved in animal development. The variety and ubiquity of this ancient family suggest that Wnt genes may have been important in the evolution of animal development, including early development. To test this hypothesis, we have characterized the expression of several Wnt genes in closely related sea urchins that exhibit radically different modes of early development. Wnt-1, -4, and -5 genes exhibit several conserved molecular and developmental characteristics, both within sea urchins and with Wnt genes examined in other animals (Ferkowicz et al. 1998). Here, we demonstrate that sea urchin Wnt-5 transcripts are specifically detected by in situ hybridization in discrete embryonic, larval, and developing adult tissues and processes: (1) in a band of vegetal ectoderm in mesenchyme blastula stage embryos, (2) in the larval ciliary bands, (3) in tissues that form the early adult rudiment (left coelomic pouch and overlying vestibular ectoderm), and (4) in the developing adult radial nervous system. We find that the sites of Wnt-5 transcript accumulation are conserved in species exhibiting either indirect- or direct-developmental modes, suggesting that Wnt-5 function(s) have been conserved in sea urchin development. However, dramatic heterochronic changes in Wnt-5 gene expression have occurred in the direct-developing species that parallel the accelerated morphological changes that occur during direct development. These results suggest that heterochronic changes in the expression of conserved developmental regulatory genes, such as the Wnt family members, are agents of evolutionary change in animal development.

Hox genes in a pentameral animal.

There is renewed interest in how the different body plans of extant phyla are related. This question has traditionally been addressed by comparisons between vertebrates and Drosophila. Fortunately, there is now increasing emphasis on animals representing other phyla. Pentamerally symmetric echinoderms are a bilaterian metazoan phylum whose members exhibit secondarily derived radial symmetry. Precisely how their radially symmetric body plan originated from a bilaterally symmetric ancestor is unknown, however, two recent papers address this subject. Peterson et al. propose a hypothesis on evolution of the anteroposterior axis in echinoderms, and Arenas-Mena et al. examine expression of five posterior Hox genes during development of the adult sea urchin.

Modularity and dissociation in the evolution of gene expression territories in development.

Modularity is a salient feature of development and crucial to its evolution. This paper extends modularity to include the concept of gene expression territory, as established for sea urchin embryos. Territories provide a mechanism for partitioning of the cells of a rapidly developing embryo into functional units of a feeding larva. Territories exhibit the characteristics of modules. The paper asks if the embryo and the nonfeeding larva of the direct-developing sea urchin Heliocidaris erythrogramma are organized into gene expression territories, and if its territories correspond to the canonical territories of the pluteus. An analysis of cell lineage and gene expression data for H. erythrogramma shows that skeletogenic cell, coelomic, and vegetal plate gene expression territories are conserved, although they arise from cell lineages distinct from those of the pluteus, and the overall morphology of the larva differs from that of a pluteus. The ectoderm, as in indirect developers, is divided into territories. However, the oral ectodermal territory characteristic of the pluteus is absent in H. erythrogramma. Oral ectoderm is restored in hybrids of H. erythrogramma eggs fertilized by Heliocidaris tuberculata sperm. This indicates that embryonic modules evolve by changes in expression of dominant regulatory genes within territories and that entire modules can be eliminated in evolution of embryos.

Evo-devo: the evolution of a new discipline.

The history of life documented in the fossil record shows that the evolution of complex organisms such as animals and plants has involved marked changes in morphology, and the appearance of new features. However, evolutionary change occurs not by the direct transformation of adult ancestors into adult descendants but rather when developmental processes produce the features of each generation in an evolving lineage. Therefore, evolution cannot be understood without understanding the evolution of development, and how the process of development itself blases or constrains evolution. A revolutionary synthesis of developmental biology and evolution is in progress.

Novel gene expression patterns in hybrid embryos between species with different modes of development.

Cross-species hybrids between eggs of the direct-developing sea urchin, Heliocidaris erythrogramma, and sperm from its congeneric indirect-developing species, Heliocidaris tuberculata, show restoration of features of the paternal feeding pluteus larva, including the gut, and pluteus spicular skeleton. Unlike other reported sea urchin cross-species hybrids, Heliocidaris hybrids express genes derived from both maternal and paternal species at high levels. Ectodermal cell types, which differ radically between the two parental species, are of intermediate form in the hybrids. Gene expression patterns in hybrid embryo tissues represent a number of combinations of parental gene expression patterns: genes that are not expressed in one paternal species, but are expressed in hybrids as in the expressing parent; genes that show additive expression patterns plus novel sites of expression; a gene that is misexpressed in the hybrids; and genes expressed identically in both parents and in hybrids. The results indicate that both conserved and novel gene regulatory interactions are present. Only one gene, CyIII actin, has lost cell-type-specific regulation in the hybrids. Hybrids thus reveal that disparate parental genomes, each with its own genic regulatory system, can produce in combination a novel gene expression entity with a unique ontogeny. This outcome may derive from conserved gene regulatory regions in downstream genes of both parental species responding in conserved ways to higher-level regulators that determine modular gene expression territories.

Apextrin, a novel extracellular protein associated with larval ectoderm evolution in Heliocidaris erythrogramma.

During the evolution of direct development in the sea urchin Heliocidaris erythrogramma major modifications occurred, which allowed the precocious formation of adult-specific structures and led to a novel larval body that surrounds these structures. The HeET-1 gene was isolated in a differential screen for transcripts enriched in the early embryos of H. erythrogramma relative to those of its indirect-developing congener, H. tuberculata. HeET-1 was unique among the three genes found in that no homologous transcript was detected in H. tuberculata total embryonic RNA blots. To verify this apparently extreme differential expression of the HeET-1 genes in Heliocidaris, we isolated the HeET-1 homologue from H. tuberculata genomic DNA and used it to probe blots of poly(A)+ RNA prepared from H. tuberculata embryos. It is expressed in H. tuberculata embryos at levels undetectable by this technique. The predicted amino acid sequence of HeET-1 suggested that it encodes a novel secreted protein. To assess the function of HeET-1, we raised polyclonal antisera to the HeET-1-encoded protein. We find that it is present in eggs in a type of secretory vesicle and that this maternal pool is gradually secreted after fertilization. As cells acquire apical-basal polarity in the blastula the protein becomes localized to the apical extracellular matrix, leading us to name the protein apextrin. The apical extracellular localization of apextrin is maintained in the columnar cells of the larval ectoderm until their internalization at metamorphosis. Ingressing mesenchyme cells rapidly endocytose apextrin upon leaving the vegetal plate. Comparison with fibropellin III, an apical lamina component, suggests that apextrin is an extracellular protein that is in tighter association with the plasma membrane than is the hyalin layer or apical lamina. We propose that apextrin is involved in apical cell adhesion and that its high level of expression may represent an adaptive cooption necessary for strengthening the large H. erythrogramma embryo.

Larval homologies and radical evolutionary changes in early development.

Larval forms are highly conserved in evolution, and phylogeneticists have used shared larval features to link disparate phyla. Despite long-term conservation, early development has in some cases evolved radically. Analysis of evolutionary change depends on identification of homologues, and this concept of descent with modification applies to embryo cells and territories as well. Difficulties arise because evolutionary changes in development can obscure homologies. Even more difficult, threshold effects can yield changes in process whereby apparently homologous features can arise from new precursors or pathways. We have observed phenomena of this type in closely related sea urchins that differ in developmental mode. A species developing via a complex feeding larva and its congener, which develops directly, have different embryonic cell lineages and divergent patterns of early development, but converge on the adult sea urchin body plan. Despite differences in embryonic developmental pathways, conserved gene expression territories are evident, as are territories whose homologies are in doubt. The highly derived development of the direct developer evidently arises from an interplay of novel organization of the egg, loss of expression of regulatory gene involved in production of feeding larval features, and changes in site and timing of expression of a number of genes.

A novel ontogenetic pathway in hybrid embryos between species with different modes of development.

To investigate the bases for evolutionary changes in developmental mode, we fertilized eggs of a direct-developing sea urchin, Heliocidaris erythrogramma, with sperm from a closely related species, H. tuberculata, that undergoes indirect development via a feeding larva. The resulting hybrids completed development to form juvenile adult sea urchins. Hybrids exhibited restoration of feeding larval structures and paternal gene expression that have been lost in the evolution of the direct-developing maternal species. However, the developmental outcome of the hybrids was not a simple reversion to the paternal pluteus larval form. An unexpected result was that the ontogeny of the hybrids was distinct from either parental species. Early hybrid larvae exhibited a novel morphology similar to that of the dipleurula-type larva typical of other classes of echinoderms and considered to represent the ancestral echinoderm larval form. In the hybrid developmental program, therefore, both recent and ancient ancestral features were restored. That is, the hybrids exhibited features of the pluteus larval form that is present in both the paternal species and in the immediate common ancestor of the two species, but they also exhibited general developmental features of very distantly related echinoderms. Thus in the hybrids, the interaction of two genomes that normally encode two disparate developmental modes produces a novel but harmonious ontongeny.

Maternal factors and the evolution of developmental mode: evolution of oogenesis in Heliocidaris erythrogramma.

Evolutionary change in developmental mode in sea urchins is closely tied to an increase in maternal provisioning. We examined the oogenic modifications involved in production of a large egg by comparison of oogenesis in congeneric sea urchins with markedly different sized oocytes and divergent modes of development. Heliocidaris tuberculata has small eggs (95 microm diameter) and the ancestral mode of development through feeding larvae, whereas H. erythrogramma has large eggs (430 microm diameter) and highly modified non-feeding lecithotrophic larvae. Production of a large egg in H. erythrogramma involved both conserved and divergent mechanisms. The pattern and level of vitellogenin gene expression is similar in the two species. Vitellogenin processing is also similar with the gonads of both species incorporating yolk protein from coelomic and hemal stores into nutritive cells with subsequent transfer of this protein into yolk granules in the developing vitellogenic oocyte. Immunocytology of the eggs of both Heliocidaris species indicates they incorporate similar levels of yolk protein. However, H. erythrogramma has evolved a highly divergent second phase of oogenesis characterised by massive deposition of non-vitellogenic material including additional maternal protein and lipid. Maternal provisioning in H. erythrogramma exhibits recapitulation of the ancestral vitellogenic program followed by a novel oogenic phase with hypertrophy of the lipogenic program being a major contributor to the increase in egg size.

Phylogenetic relationships and developmental expression of three sea urchin Wnt genes.

The Wnt genes comprise a family of secreted glycoproteins involved in cell-cell signaling and pattern formation during the development of a variety of organisms. We have begun to examine Wnt gene expression in sea urchins that exhibit alternative modes of larval development but produce similar adults. Here we describe the isolation of five Wnt sequences from indirect- and direct-developing sea urchin species using a PCR-based strategy and library screening. Phylogenetic and distance analyses indicate that the five sequences represent sea urchin Wnt-1, -4, and -5 orthologs. Wnt-5 sequences were isolated from three sea urchin species and show a significantly faster rate of evolution than do their counterparts in jawed vertebrates. The genomic structure of the Wnt-5 locus was also examined, and its organization is similar to that of Wnt genes from insects and vertebrates. The temporal expression of all three sea urchin Wnt orthologs during sea urchin development was examined by RNA gel blots or RNase protection assays. Transcripts from all three sea urchin Wnts are detected at various developmental stages of both indirect- and direct-developing species. These data support the view that sea urchin Wnt genes exhibit many conserved aspects and at least three orthologs are developmentally regulated in both indirect- and direct-developing sea urchin embryos.

Isolation and characterization of three mRNAs enriched in embryos of the direct-developing sea urchin Heliocidaris erythrogramma: evolution of larval ectoderm.

The Australian sea urchin Heliocidaris erythro-gramma utilizes a derived direct developmental mode that evolved 8-12 million years ago. From a differential screen we have isolated a small set of cDNAs corresponding to genes more greatly expressed in embryos of H. erythrogramma than in those of its indirect-developing nearest relative, H. tuberculata. The method was biased towards abundant transcripts and did not allow detection of modifications of usage of highly conserved gene family members. Three differentially expressed abundant transcripts were found that potentially encode secreted proteins. Two of these, the arylsulfatase HeARS and the putative lectin HeEL-1, were identifiable as homologues of known proteins. Another gene, HeET-1, may be exclusively expressed in the H. erythrogramma embryo. In situ hybridization experiments demonstrate that all three transcripts are localized to the ectoderm. Two of them, HeET-1 and HeEL-1, are transcribed in an identical domain comprising the larval ectoderm. This region of gene expression has acquired a novel columnar cytology during the evolution of the H. erythrogramma embryo. The third sequence, HeARS, encodes an arylsulfatase homologue. Its expression is uniform in the gastrula, but as the rudiment develops it accumulates to the greatest extent in the invaginating vestibular ectoderm. Through comparisons with indirect-developing species, we show that this concentration of arylsulfatase mRNA in the rudiment is a novel feature of H. erythrogramma development. These data suggest that H. erythrogramma has a unique arrangement of ectodermal gene expression territories. We propose that these reflect larval adaptations that have occurred in the lineage leading to H. erythrogramma, and enabled the evolution of direct development.

Evolutionary changes in sites and timing of actin gene expression in embryos of the direct- and indirect-developing sea urchins, Heliocidaris erythrogramma and H. tuberculata.

We describe an evolutionary comparison of expression of the actin gene families of two congeneric sea urchins. Heliocidaris tuberculata develops indirectly via a planktonic feeding pluteus that forms a juvenile rudiment after a long period of larval development. H. erythrogramma is a direct developer that initiates formation of a juvenile rudiment immediately following gastrulation. The developmental expression of each actin isoform of both species was determined by in situ hybridization. The observed expression patterns are compared with known expression patterns in a related indirect-developing sea urchin, Strongylocentrotus purpuratus. Comparisons reveal unexpected patterns of conserved and divergent expression. Cytoplasmic actin, CyIII, is expressed in the aboral ectoderm cells of the indirect developers, but is an unexpressed pseudogene in H. erythrogramma, which lacks aboral ectoderm. This change is correlated with developmental mode. Two CyII actins are expressed in S. purpuratus, and one in H. erythrogramma, but no CyII is expressed in H. tuberculata despite its great developmental similarity to S. purpuratus. CyI expression differs slightly between Heliocidaris and Strongylocentrotus with more ectodermal expression in Heliocidaris. Evolutionary changes in actin gene expression reflect both evolution of developmental mode as well as a surprising flexibility in gene expression within a developmental mode.

Rapid evolution in a conserved gene family. Evolution of the actin gene family in the sea urchin genus Heliocidaris and related genera.

Camarodont sea urchins possess a rapidly evolving actin gene family whose members are expressed in distinct cell lineages in a developmentally regulated fashion. Evolutionary changes in the actin gene family of echinoids include alterations in number of family members, site of expression, and gene linkage, and a dichotomy between rapidly and slowly evolving isoform-specific 3' untranslated regions. We present sequence comparisons and an analysis of the actin gene family in two congeneric sea urchins that develop in radically different modes, Heliocidaris erythrogramma and H. tuberculata. The sequences of several actin genes from the related species Lytechinus variegatus are also presented. We compare the features of the Heliocidaris and Lytechinus actin genes to those of the the actin gene families of other closely related sea urchins and discuss the nature of the evolutionary changes among sea urchin actins and their relationship to developmental mode.