ABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Active involvement of patients in clinical research is increasingly demanded in Germany. It has great potential to increase the quality and relevance of research and to contribute to patient empowerment. However, patients, researchers and research funders have experienced that the implementation of patient involvement is accompanied by cultural, practical and personal challenges. The aim of this article is to discuss the opportunities and challenges of patient involvement in Germany from the perspective of the stakeholders involved. METHOD: A patient representative, a clinical researcher and two staff members from research funding management were invited to discuss the opportunities and challenges of patient involvement. Their perspectives were recorded in two written open survey rounds. The answers were analyzed using qualitative content analysis. RESULT: In the opinion of the stakeholders involved, the increasing involvement of patients in clinical research is an opportunity to promote the practical relevance of research and the implementation of studies, to increase their acceptance by the target group and to improve the uptake of research results in practice. However, the implementation of patient involvement was also perceived as challenging. They described problems with regard to the acquisition and selection of patients, the training of the patients and the specifications and support structures for the implementation of patient involvement. DISCUSSION: While patient involvement in clinical research offers great potential, the development of appropriate structures and framework conditions for its implementation is still virtually unestablished in Germany. This needs to include, among other things, creating a broader awareness of the potential of patient involvement, developing training programs for patients and researchers, providing sufficient, mainly project-independent resources and ensuring regular evaluations.
Subject(s)
Patient Advocacy , Patient Participation , Germany , HumansABSTRACT
INTRODUCTION: Patient involvement in health research is an integral part of health care in many countries. It promotes the relevance and quality of research and increases the meaningfulness of research results. Meanwhile, the value of patient involvement has also been recognised in Germany. The lack of a common understanding of patient involvement and appropriate methods make implementation difficult. In Germany, patients are still rarely involved in the planning and conduct of health research. Vulnerable patient groups such as the elderly and the very old are considered particularly challenging for researchers in active patient involvement due to their special needs, which is why they are often neglected. Especially nursing home residents suffer from a variety of health impairments which are accompanied by a high number of prescription drugs and adverse events and can therefore make patient involvement more difficult. The present project aims to test the method of patient advisory boards for the involvement of nursing home residents. Using the design of a clinical trial to optimise medication for nursing home residents as a case study, we will assess the feasibility of the method for this target group. We will also install a patient advocate as moderator of the advisory board. The study plan is described in the present study protocol. METHODS: Two patient advisory boards with nursing home residents will be established. With a patient advocate acting as moderator, the essential elements of a clinical trial to optimise medication will be discussed and passed on to the study planning team via the patient advocate. The overall topic of the clinical trial is the optimisation of medication in cardiovascular disease. The nursing home residents are informed about the contents and ideas of the study to be planned and the interests of the researchers, respectively, and will discuss the proposals of the study planning team. Nursing home residents', the patient advocate's and the researchers' expectations and experiences will be examined in individual interviews. DISCUSSION: The study will provide a potentially suitable method to involve nursing home residents in the research process. The jointly developed study design will be incorporated into a new project proposal. The results will be used to inform the development of a German handbook on active public and patient involvement.
Subject(s)
Advisory Committees , Nursing Homes , Patient Participation , Aged , Germany , HumansABSTRACT
Usually, patients participating in clinical trials have a passive role as test persons. This creates a risk that patients' needs and interests are not reflected in clinical research. The aim of the present paper is to give an introduction to patient involvement in clinical research. It is based on an exploratory literature research and our own experiences with patient involvement. By actively involving patients in the design, conduct and translation of clinical trials, research and healthcare can be better tailored to meet the patients' needs. Patient involvement has the potential to enhance the quality and relevance of research, support patient empowerment and contribute to the democratisation of research processes. There are different methods to involve patients in research, which are often differentiated as consultation, cooperation and user-led research. Methods, time of involvement and persons to be involved should be chosen to fit the aims of the involvement. While cultural, practical and personal barriers could hinder patient involvement, there are several strategies that enable effective involvement: defining the aims of the involvement, clarifying motivation and expectations as well as roles and the form of cooperation, offering training, planning sufficient resources, involving patients from the start and communicating the benefits of involvement.