A multirater validation study to assess the reliability of acne lesion counting.

BACKGROUND: Despite widespread use of acne lesion counting, little has been published on its reliability, particularly for multiple raters. OBJECTIVE: Our purpose was to assess reliability of acne lesion counting with the use of a five-segment facial template. METHODS: After training, 12 raters each evaluated 12 patients in randomized order, in the morning and again in the afternoon, and recorded counts for different types of lesions on a five-segment facial template. RESULTS: Individual raters could reproduce their total lesion counts (reliability estimates, 0.81 to 0.97). Variability between raters was high, and overall reliability estimated across raters was 0.61. For a subgroup of commonly trained raters, overall reliability was higher (0.80). CONCLUSION: The reliability of acne lesion counting is excellent when performed by the same trained rater over time. The high variability between raters appears to be reduced by standardized training. Because fewer lesions are counted with less variation, use of a template may have contributed to the high within-rater reliability.

Acne vulgaris in premenarchal girls. An early sign of puberty associated with rising levels of dehydroepiandrosterone.

BACKGROUND: This study examined the relationships of pubertal maturation and sex steroid hormones to the development of acne in young girls. Black (n = 317) and white (n = 306) premenarchal girls with a mean age of 9.97 +/- 0.62 years were evaluated for acne prevalence and severity, pubic hair and areolar maturation, and sex steroid hormone levels. RESULTS: Overall, 77.8% of the girls had some acne; of the whole group, 48.3% had only comedonal acne, 2.2% had only inflammatory acne, and 27.3% had both types. Although black girls matured at an earlier age than white girls, racial differences in acne were minimal when adjusted for pubertal maturation. Acne increased with advancing maturation; at Tanner pubic hair stages 1, 2, and 3, the prevalence of acne rose from 73.1% to 84.0% and to 90.6%, respectively. Acne lesion counts at seven facial locations revealed a predominance of midfacial acne on the middle aspect of the forehead, nose, and chin. Sex steroid hormone levels measured in 365 of the girls were found to increase significantly during maturation from prepuberty to early puberty. Testosterone-estrogen-binding globulin and the ratio of testosterone to estradiol decreased. In 118 prepubertal girls, estradiol, total and free testosterone, progesterone, testosterone to estradiol ratio, and testosterone-estrogen-binding globulin levels were no different whether in subjects with acne or without acne. However, the level of dehydroepiandrosterone sulfate, an androgen of adrenal origin, was significantly higher in prepubertal girls with acne. CONCLUSION: Acne, especially the comedonal type, can be the first sign of pubertal maturation in girls, even preceding pubic hair and areolar development. Concentration of dehydroepiandrosterone sulfate is significantly and specifically associated with the initiation of acne in young girls.