ABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: High-energy pulsed or computer-scanned continuous-wave carbon dioxide (CO2) laser resurfacing has gained popularity as a wrinkle treatment because of its minimal thermal injury and precise control of tissue vaporization depth. Manual tumescent dermabrasion has also been effective for treating facial wrinkles. This is, to our knowledge, the first study comparing the use of CO2 laser to manual tumescent dermabrasion for the treatment of wrinkles on the upper lip. OBJECTIVE: To compare prospectively the clinical efficacy of the 950 microsec dwell time CO2 laser to that of manual tumescent dermabrasion in the treatment of upper lip wrinkles. METHODS: Twenty female subjects with moderate to severe upper lip wrinkles were randomly treated with the 950 microsec dwell time CO2 laser on one side of the upper lip and manual tumescent dermabrasion on the other. RESULTS: The average upper lip laser-treated wrinkle score (0 = none to 5 = severe) decreased from 4.3 +/- 0.2 before treatment to 1.8 +/- 0.3 at 6 months after treatment. The average upper lip dermabrasion-treated wrinkle score decreased from 4.4 +/- 0.2 to 1.5 +/- 0.3. The degree to which the wrinkle score improved after laser treatment compared with that after dermabrasion was not statistically significant (P =.216). CONCLUSION: Manual tumescent dermabrasion and 950 microsec dwell time CO2 laser resurfacing are equally effective for the treatment of upper lip wrinkles.
Subject(s)
Dermabrasion , Laser Therapy , Lip , Skin Aging , Aged , Carbon Dioxide , Dermabrasion/adverse effects , Dermabrasion/methods , Female , Humans , Middle Aged , Severity of Illness IndexABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: The high energy, pulsed, or computer-scanned continuous wave carbon dioxide laser (CO2 laser) has gained popularity as a wrinkle treatment because of its minimal thermal injury and precise control of tissue vaporization depth. Chemical peels such as phenol have also been effective in treating facial wrinkles. This is, to our knowledge, the first study comparing the use of CO2 laser to phenol for treatment of wrinkles on the upper lip. OBJECTIVE: To compare the effectiveness and side effect profile of the 950 microsec dwell time CO2 laser to that of unoccluded Baker's phenol chemical peel in the treatment of upper lip wrinkles. METHODS: Twenty female subjects with moderate to severe upper lip wrinkles were randomly treated with Baker's phenol on one side of the upper lip and the 950 microsec dwell time CO2 laser on the other side. RESULTS: The average upper lip laser-treated wrinkle score (0 = none to 5 = severe) decreased from 4.30+/-0.20 before treatment to 1.11+/-0.28 at 6 months after treatment. The average upper lip phenol-treated wrinkle score decreased from 4.20+/-0.20 to 0.47+/-0.12. The degree in which the wrinkle score improved after phenol treatment compared with that after laser treatment was statistically significant (p<0.03). CONCLUSION: Treatment of upper lip wrinkles with Baker's phenol resulted in greater improvement than treatment with the 950 microsec dwell time CO2 laser.
