Gene amplification mutations originate prior to selective stress in Acinetobacter baylyi.

The controversial theory of adaptive amplification states gene amplification mutations are induced by selective environments where they are enriched due to the stress caused by growth restriction on unadapted cells. We tested this theory with three independent assays using an Acinetobacter baylyi model system that exclusively selects for cat gene amplification mutants. Our results demonstrate all cat gene amplification mutant colonies arise through a multistep process. While the late steps occur during selection exposure, these mutants derive from low-level amplification mutant cells that form before growth-inhibiting selection is imposed. During selection, these partial mutants undergo multiple secondary steps generating higher amplification over several days to multiple weeks to eventually form visible high-copy amplification colonies. Based on these findings, amplification in this Acinetobacter system can be explained by a natural selection process that does not require a stress response. These findings have fundamental implications to understanding the role of growth-limiting selective environments on cancer development. We suggest duplication mutations encompassing growth factor genes may serve as new genomic biomarkers to facilitate early cancer detection and treatment, before high-copy amplification is attained.

Mechanisms of gene duplication and amplification.

Changes in gene copy number are among the most frequent mutational events in all genomes and were among the mutations for which a physical basis was first known. Yet mechanisms of gene duplication remain uncertain because formation rates are difficult to measure and mechanisms may vary with position in a genome. Duplications are compared here to deletions, which seem formally similar but can arise at very different rates by distinct mechanisms. Methods of assessing duplication rates and dependencies are described with several proposed formation mechanisms. Emphasis is placed on duplications formed in extensively studied experimental situations. Duplications studied in microbes are compared with those observed in metazoan cells, specifically those in genomes of cancer cells. Duplications, and especially their derived amplifications, are suggested to form by multistep processes often under positive selection for increased copy number.

Recombination and annealing pathways compete for substrates in making rrn duplications in Salmonella enterica.

Tandem genetic duplications arise frequently between the seven directly repeated 5.5-kb rrn loci that encode ribosomal RNAs in Salmonella enterica. The closest rrn genes, rrnB and rrnE, flank a 40-kb region that includes the purHD operon. Duplications of purHD arise by exchanges between rrn loci and form at a high rate (10(-3)/cell/division) that remains high in strains blocked for early steps in recombination (recA, recB, and/or recF), but drops 30-fold in mutants blocked for later Holliday junction resolution (ruvC recG). The duplication defect of a ruvC recG mutant was fully corrected by an added mutation in any one of the recA, recB, or recF genes. To explain these results, we propose that early recombination defects activate an alternative single-strand annealing pathway for duplication formation. In wild-type cells, rrn duplications form primarily by the action of RecFORA on single-strand gaps. Double-strand breaks cannot initiate rrn duplications because rrn loci lack Chi sites, which are essential for recombination between two separated rrn sequences. A recA or recF mutation allows unrepaired gaps to accumulate such that different rrn loci can provide single-strand rrn sequences that lack the RecA coating that normally inhibits annealing. A recB mutation activates annealing by allowing double-strand ends within rrn to avoid digestion by RecBCD and provide a new source of rrn ends for use in annealing. The equivalent high rates of rrn duplication by recombination and annealing pathways may reflect a limiting economy of gaps and breaks arising in heavily transcribed, palindrome-rich rrn sequences.

Multiple pathways of duplication formation with and without recombination (RecA) in Salmonella enterica.

Duplications are often attributed to "unequal recombination" between separated, directly repeated sequence elements (>100 bp), events that leave a recombinant element at the duplication junction. However, in the bacterial chromosome, duplications form at high rates (10(-3)-10(-5)/cell/division) even without recombination (RecA). Here we describe 1800 spontaneous lac duplications trapped nonselectively on the low-copy F'(128) plasmid, where lac is flanked by direct repeats of the transposable element IS3 (1258 bp) and by numerous quasipalindromic REP elements (30 bp). Duplications form at a high rate (10(-4)/cell/division) that is reduced only about 11-fold in the absence of RecA. With and without RecA, most duplications arise by recombination between IS3 elements (97%). Formation of these duplications is stimulated by IS3 transposase (Tnp) and plasmid transfer functions (TraI). Three duplication pathways are proposed. First, plasmid dimers form at a high rate stimulated by RecA and are then modified by deletions between IS3 elements (resolution) that leave a monomeric plasmid with an IS3-flanked lac duplication. Second, without RecA, duplications occur by single-strand annealing of DNA ends generated in different sister chromosomes after transposase nicks DNA near participating IS3 elements. The absence of RecA may stimulate annealing by allowing chromosome breaks to persist. Third, a minority of lac duplications (3%) have short (0-36 bp) junction sequences (SJ), some of which are located within REP elements. These duplication types form without RecA, Tnp, or Tra by a pathway in which the palindromic junctions of a tandem inversion duplication (TID) may stimulate deletions that leave the final duplication.

Pathways of genetic adaptation: multistep origin of mutants under selection without induced mutagenesis in Salmonella enterica.

In several bacterial systems, mutant cell populations plated on growth-restricting medium give rise to revertant colonies that accumulate over several days. One model suggests that nongrowing parent cells mutagenize their own genome and thereby create beneficial mutations (stress-induced mutagenesis). By this model, the first-order induction of new mutations in a nongrowing parent cell population leads to the delayed accumulation of visible colonies. In an alternative model (selection only), selective conditions allow preexisting small-effect mutants to initiate clones that grow and give rise to faster-growing mutants. By the selection-only model, the delay in appearance of revertant colonies reflects (1) the time required for initial clones to reach a size sufficient to allow the second mutation plus (2) the time required for growth of the improved subclone. We previously characterized a system in which revertant colonies accumulate slowly and contain cells with two mutations, one formed before plating and one after. This left open the question of whether mutation rates increase under selection. Here we measure the unselected formation rate and the growth contribution of each mutant type. When these parameters are used in a graphic model of revertant colony development, they demonstrate that no increase in mutation rate is required to explain the number and delayed appearance of two of the revertant types.

Duplication frequency in a population of Salmonella enterica rapidly approaches steady state with or without recombination.

Tandem duplications are among the most common mutation events. The high loss rate of duplication suggested that the frequency of duplications in a bacterial population (1/1000) might reflect a steady state dictated by relative rates of formation (k(F)) and loss (k(L)). This possibility was tested for three genetic loci. Without homologous recombination (RecA), duplication loss rate dropped essentially to zero, but formation rate decreased only slightly and a steady state was still reached rapidly. Under all conditions, steady state was reached faster than predicted by formation and loss rates alone. A major factor in determining steady state proved to be the fitness cost, which can exceed 40% for some genomic regions. Depending on the region tested, duplications reached 40-98% of the steady-state frequency within 30 generations-approximately the growth required for a single cell to produce a saturated overnight culture or form a large colony on solid medium (10(9) cells). Long-term bacterial populations are stably polymorphic for duplications of every region of their genome. These polymorphisms contribute to rapid genetic adaptation by providing frequent preexisting mutations that are beneficial whenever imposed selection favors increases in some gene activity. While the reported results were obtained with the bacterium Salmonella enterica, the genetic implications seem likely to be of broader biological relevance.

Multiple pathways of selected gene amplification during adaptive mutation.

In a phenomenon referred to as "adaptive mutation," a population of bacterial cells with a mutation in the lac operon (lac-) accumulates Lac+ revertants during prolonged exposure to selective growth conditions (lactose). Evidence was provided that selective conditions do not increase the mutation rate but instead favor the growth of rare cells with a duplication of the leaky lac allele. A further increase in copy number (amplification) improves growth and increases the likelihood of a sequence change by adding more mutational targets to the clone (cells and lac copies per cell). These duplications and amplifications are described here. Before selection, cells with large (134-kb) lac duplications and long junction sequences (>1 kb) were common (0.2%). The same large repeats were found after selection in cells with a low-copy-number lac amplification. Surprisingly, smaller repeats (average, 34 kb) were found in high-copy-number amplifications. The small-repeat duplications form when deletions modify a preexisting large-repeat duplication. The shorter repeat size allowed higher lac amplification and better growth on lactose. Thus, selection favors a succession of gene-amplification types that make sequence changes more probable by adding targets. These findings are relevant to genetic adaptation in any biological systems in which fitness can be increased by adding gene copies (e.g., cancer and bacterial drug resistance).

Origin of mutations under selection: the adaptive mutation controversy.

Growth under selection causes new genotypes to predominate in a population. It is difficult to determine whether selection stimulates formation of new mutations or merely allows faster growth of mutants that arise independent of selection. In the practice of microbial genetics, selection is used to detect and enumerate pre-existing mutants; stringent conditions prevent growth of the parent and allow only the pre-existing mutants to grow. Used in this way, selection detects rare mutations that cause large, easily observable phenotypic changes. In natural populations, selection is imposed on growing cells and can detect the more common mutations that cause small growth improvements. As slightly improved clones expand, they can acquire additional mutational improvements. Selected sequential clonal expansions have huge power to produce new genotypes and have been suggested to underlie tumor progression. We suggest that the adaptive mutation controversy has persisted because the distinction between these two uses of selection has not been appreciated.

Selection for gene clustering by tandem duplication.

In prokaryotic genomes, related genes are frequently clustered in operons and higher-order arrangements that reflect functional context. Organization emerges despite rearrangements that constantly shuffle gene and operon order. Evidence is presented that the tandem duplication of related genes acts as a driving evolutionary force in the origin and maintenance of clusters. Gene amplification can be viewed as a dynamic and reversible regulatory mechanism that facilitates adaptation to variable environments. Clustered genes confer selective benefits via their ability to be coamplified. During evolution, rearrangements that bring together related genes can be selected if they increase the fitness of the organism in which they reside. Similarly, the benefits of gene amplification can prevent the dispersal of existing clusters. Examples of frequent and spontaneous amplification of large genomic fragments are provided. The possibility is raised that tandem gene duplication works in concert with horizontal gene transfer as interrelated evolutionary forces for gene clustering.

Gene amplification involves site-specific short homology-independent illegitimate recombination in Acinetobacter sp. strain ADP1.

A system for studying gene amplification in the bacterium Acinetobacter sp. strain ADP1 was used to isolate 105 spontaneous mutants. The method selects for the elevated expression of neighboring transcriptional units in a parent strain lacking its normal transcriptional activators. Gene amplification can compensate for the activator loss by increasing the copy number of seven weakly expressed genes. Mutant colonies arose from the parent strain at a frequency of 10(-8) within three weeks. All but one of these mutants carried tandem head-to-tail repeats of a chromosomal segment (amplicon). These amplicons varied in size from approximately 12-290 kb and ranged in copy number from 3 to more than 30. Gene amplification involved a two-step process in which duplications formed independently of recA. Illegitimate recombination fused normally distant chromosomal regions to create novel DNA duplication junctions. These junctions were isolated from amplification mutants using an assay that exploits Acinetobacter natural transformability. Sequence analysis of 72 junctions revealed little identity in the recombining regions. Furthermore, multiple independently isolated mutants contained identical junctions. Six different junctions, each found in two to six mutants, revealed that some recombination events are site-specific. Several recurring junctions were studied using PCR. In each case, the identical duplication present in the mutant was estimated to have occurred in as many as one in a million cells in populations of strains never exposed to selective conditions. These duplications appeared to form spontaneously by a novel type of short homology-independent, site-specific process. However, in the absence of recA, mutant colonies were not selected from parent cells containing these duplications. Thus, the second gene amplification step most likely depends on homologous recombination to increase amplicon copy number. These studies support the theory that gene amplification is a driving force in the evolution of functionally related gene clusters.

Transcriptional cross-regulation of the catechol and protocatechuate branches of the beta-ketoadipate pathway contributes to carbon source-dependent expression of the Acinetobacter sp. strain ADP1 pobA gene.

Transcriptional control of carbon source preferences by Acinetobacter sp. strain ADP1 was assessed with a pobA::lacZ fusion during growth on alternative substrates. The pobA-encoded enzyme catalyzes the first step in the degradation of 4-hydroxybenzoate, a compound consumed rapidly as a sole carbon source. If additional aromatic carbon sources are available, 4-hydroxybenzoate consumption is inhibited by unknown mechanisms. As reported here, during growth on aromatic substrates, pobA was not expressed despite the presence of 4-hydroxybenzoate, an inducer that normally causes the PobR regulator to activate pobA transcription. Growth on organic acids such as succinate, fumarate, and acetate allowed higher levels of pobA expression. In each case, pobA expression increased at the end of the exponential growth phase. Complex transcriptional regulation controlled 4-hydroxybenzoate catabolism in multisubstrate environments. Additional studies focused on the wild-type preference for benzoate consumption prior to 4-hydroxybenzoate consumption. These compounds are degraded via the catechol and protocatechuate branches of the beta-ketoadipate pathway, respectively. Here, mutants were characterized that degraded benzoate and 4-hydroxybenzoate concurrently. These mutants lacked the BenM and CatM transcriptional regulators that normally activate genes for benzoate catabolism. A model is presented in which BenM and CatM prevent pobA expression indirectly during growth on benzoate. These regulators may affect pobA expression by lowering the PcaK-mediated uptake of 4-hydroxybenzoate. Consistent with this model, BenM and CatM bound in vitro to an operator-promoter fragment controlling the expression of several pca genes, including pcaK. These studies provide the first direct evidence of transcriptional cross-regulation between the distinct but analogous branches of the beta-ketoadipate pathway.

Genome plasticity in Acinetobacter: new degradative capabilities acquired by the spontaneous amplification of large chromosomal segments.

In Acinetobacter sp. ADP1, growth on benzoate requires regulation of the cat genes by two transcriptional activators. Here, mutants were obtained from a strain lacking both activators by selecting for growth on benzoate medium. The mutants, which arose within 3 weeks at a frequency of approximately 10-8, carried amplified chromosomal regions (amplicons) encompassing the cat genes. Multiple occurrences of low-level expression of catA and the catBCIJFD operon provided sufficient transcription for growth. The amplicons of four independently isolated mutants varied in size from approximately 30-100 kbp of the normally 3.8 Mbp chromosome. Mutants had approximately 10-20 copies of an amplicon in adjacent head-to-tail orientations. At the amplicon's chromosomal endpoint, an atypical junction juxtaposed normally distant DNA regions from opposite sides of the cat genes. The sequences of these junctions revealed the precise recombination sites underlying amplification. Additionally, amplicon stability was evaluated in the absence of selective pressure. The natural competence of Acinetobacter for transformation by linear DNA has allowed the development of a powerful new model system for investigating chromosomal rearrangements and for engineering DNA amplifications for wide-ranging applications. The frequent spontaneous amplification of these large chromosomal segments demonstrated the importance of supra-operonic gene clustering in the evolution of catabolic pathways.