Chaperonin Mechanisms: Multiple and (Mis)Understood?

The chaperonins are ubiquitous and essential nanomachines that assist in protein folding in an ATP-driven manner. They consist of two back-to-back stacked oligomeric rings with cavities in which protein (un)folding can take place in a shielding environment. This review focuses on GroEL from Escherichia coli and the eukaryotic chaperonin-containing t-complex polypeptide 1, which differ considerably in their reaction mechanisms despite sharing a similar overall architecture. Although chaperonins feature in many current biochemistry textbooks after being studied intensively for more than three decades, key aspects of their reaction mechanisms remain under debate and are discussed in this review. In particular, it is unclear whether a universal reaction mechanism operates for all substrates and whether it is passive, i.e., aggregation is prevented but the folding pathway is unaltered, or active. It is also unclear how chaperonin clients are distinguished from nonclients and what are the precise roles of the cofactors with which chaperonins interact.

Differential Sensitivity of Mycobacteria to Isoniazid Is Related to Differences in KatG-Mediated Enzymatic Activation of the Drug.

Isoniazid (INH) is a cornerstone of antitubercular therapy. Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex bacteria are the only mycobacteria sensitive to clinically relevant concentrations of INH. All other mycobacteria, including M. marinum and M. avium subsp. paratuberculosis are resistant. INH requires activation by bacterial KatG to inhibit mycobacterial growth. We tested the role of the differences between M. tuberculosis KatG and that of other mycobacteria in INH sensitivity. We cloned the M. boviskatG gene into M. marinum and M. avium subsp. paratuberculosis and measured the MIC of INH. We recombinantly expressed KatG of these mycobacteria and tested in vitro binding to, and activation of, INH. Introduction of katG from M. bovis into M. marinum and M. avium subsp. paratuberculosis rendered them 20 to 30 times more sensitive to INH. Analysis of different katG sequences across the genus found KatG evolution diverged from RNA polymerase-defined mycobacterial evolution. Biophysical and biochemical tests of M. bovis and nontuberculous mycobacteria (NTM) KatG proteins showed lower affinity to INH and substantially lower enzymatic capacity for the conversion of INH into the active form in NTM. The KatG proteins of M. marinum and M. avium subsp. paratuberculosis are substantially less effective in INH activation than that of M. tuberculosis, explaining the relative INH insensitivity of these microbes. These data indicate that the M. tuberculosis complex KatG is divergent from the KatG of NTM, with a reciprocal relationship between resistance to host defenses and INH resistance. Studies of bacteria where KatG is functionally active but does not activate INH may aid in understanding M. tuberculosis INH-resistance mechanisms, and suggest paths to overcome them.

MapB Protein is the Essential Methionine Aminopeptidase in Mycobacterium tuberculosis.

M. tuberculosis (Mtb), which causes tuberculosis disease, continues to be a major global health threat. Correct identification of valid drug targets is important for the development of novel therapeutics that would shorten the current 6-9 month treatment regimen and target resistant bacteria. Methionine aminopeptidases (MetAP), which remove the N-terminal methionine from newly synthesized proteins, are essential in all life forms (eukaryotes and prokaryotes). The MetAPs contribute to the cotranslational control of proteins as they determine their half life (N-terminal end rule) and facilitate further modifications such as acetylation and others. Mtb (and M. bovis) possess two MetAP isoforms, MetAP1a and MetAP1c, encoded by the mapA and mapB genes, respectively. Conflicting evidence was reported in the literature on which of the two variants is essential. To resolve this question, we performed a targeted genetic deletion of each of these two genes. We show that a deletion mutant of mapA is viable with only a weak growth defect. In contrast, we provide two lines of genetic evidence that mapB is indispensable. Furthermore, construction of double-deletion mutants as well as the introduction of point mutations into mapB resulting in proteins with partial activity showed partial, but not full, redundancy between mapB and mapA. We propose that it is MetAP1c (mapB) that is essentially required for mycobacteria and discuss potential reasons for its vitality.

Degradation of Bcl-2 by XIAP and ARTS Promotes Apoptosis.

We describe a mechanism by which the anti-apoptotic B cell lymphoma 2 (Bcl-2) protein is downregulated to induce apoptosis. ARTS (Sept4_i2) is a tumor suppressor protein that promotes cell death through specifically antagonizing XIAP (X-linked inhibitor of apoptosis). ARTS and Bcl-2 reside at the outer mitochondrial membrane in living cells. Upon apoptotic induction, ARTS brings XIAP and Bcl-2 into a ternary complex, allowing XIAP to promote ubiquitylation and degradation of Bcl-2. ARTS binding to Bcl-2 involves the BH3 domain of Bcl-2. Lysine 17 in Bcl-2 serves as the main acceptor for ubiquitylation, and a Bcl-2 K17A mutant has increased stability and is more potent in protection against apoptosis. Bcl-2 ubiquitylation is reduced in both XIAP- and Sept4/ARTS-deficient MEFs, demonstrating that XIAP serves as an E3 ligase for Bcl-2 and that ARTS is essential for this process. Collectively, these results suggest a distinct model for the regulation of Bcl-2 by ARTS-mediated degradation.

Synthetic, structural mimetics of the ß-hairpin flap of HIV-1 protease inhibit enzyme function.

Small-molecule mimetics of the ß-hairpin flap of HIV-1 protease (HIV-1 PR) were designed based on a 1,4-benzodiazepine scaffold as a strategy to interfere with the flap-flap protein-protein interaction, which functions as a gated mechanism to control access to the active site. Michaelis-Menten kinetics suggested our small-molecules are competitive inhibitors, which indicates the mode of inhibition is through binding the active site or sterically blocking access to the active site and preventing flap closure, as designed. More generally, a new bioactive scaffold for HIV-1PR inhibition has been discovered, with the most potent compound inhibiting the protease with a modest K(i) of 11 µM.

An Intrinsically Disordered Region in the Proapoptotic ASPP2 Protein Binds to the Helicobacter pylori Oncoprotein CagA.

The leading risk factor for gastric cancer in humans is infection by Helicobacter pylori strains that express and translocate the oncoprotein CagA into host epithelial cells. Once inside host cells, CagA interacts with ASPP2, which specifically stimulates p53-mediated apoptosis and reverses its pro-apoptotic function to promote ASPP2-dependent degradation of p53. The X-ray crystal structure of a complex between the N-terminal domain of CagA and a 56-residue fragment of ASPP2, of which 22 residues were resolved, was recently described. Here, we present biochemical and biophysical analyses of the interaction between the additional regions of CagA and ASPP2 potentially involved in this interaction. Using size exclusion chromatography-multiangle laser light scattering, circular dichroism, and nuclear magnetic resonance analyses, we observed that the ASPP2 region spanning residues 331-692, which was not part of the ASPP2 fragment used for crystallization, is intrinsically disordered in its unbound state. By surface plasmon resonance analysis and isothermal titration calorimetry, we found that a portion of this disordered region in ASPP2, residues 448-692, binds to the N-terminal domain of CagA. We also measured the affinity of the complex between the ASPP2 fragment composed of residues 693-918 and inclusive of the fragment used for crystallization and CagA. Additionally, we mapped the binding regions between ASPP2 and CagA using peptide arrays, demonstrating interactions between CagA and numerous peptides distributed throughout the ASPP2 protein sequence. Our results identify previously uncharacterized regions distributed throughout the protein sequence of ASPP2 as determinants of CagA binding, providing mechanistic insight into apoptosis reprogramming by CagA and potential new drug targets for H. pylori-mediated gastric cancer.

Characterization of the translocation-competent complex between the Helicobacter pylori oncogenic protein CagA and the accessory protein CagF.

CagA is a virulence factor that Helicobacter pylori inject into gastric epithelial cells through a type IV secretion system where it can cause gastric adenocarcinoma. Translocation is dependent on the presence of secretion signals found in both the N- and C-terminal domains of CagA and an interaction with the accessory protein CagF. However, the molecular basis of this essential protein-protein interaction is not fully understood. Herein we report, using isothermal titration calorimetry, that CagA forms a 1:1 complex with a monomer of CagF with nM affinity. Peptide arrays and isothermal titration calorimetry both show that CagF binds to all five domains of CagA, each with µM affinity. More specifically, a coiled coil domain and a C-terminal helix within CagF contacts domains II-III and domain IV of CagA, respectively. In vivo complementation assays of H. pylori with a double mutant, L36A/I39A, in the coiled coil region of CagF showed a severe weakening of the CagA-CagF interaction to such an extent that it was nearly undetectable. However, it had no apparent effect on CagA translocation. Deletion of the C-terminal helix of CagF also weakened the interaction with CagA but likewise had no effect on translocation. These results indicate that the CagA-CagF interface is distributed broadly across the molecular surfaces of these two proteins to provide maximal protection of the highly labile effector protein CagA.

Mapping the Vif-A3G interaction using peptide arrays: a basis for anti-HIV lead peptides.

Human apolipoprotein-B mRNA-editing catalytic polypeptide-like 3G (A3G) is a cytidine deaminase that restricts retroviruses, endogenous retro-elements and DNA viruses. A3G plays a key role in the anti-HIV-1 innate cellular immunity. The HIV-1 Vif protein counteracts A3G mainly by leading A3G towards the proteosomal machinery and by direct inhibition of its enzymatic activity. Both activities involve direct interaction between Vif and A3G. Disrupting the interaction between A3G and Vif may rescue A3G antiviral activity and inhibit HIV-1 propagation. Here, mapping the interaction sites between A3G and Vif by peptide array screening revealed distinct regions in Vif important for A3G binding, including the N-terminal domain (NTD), C-terminal domain (CTD) and residues 83-99. The Vif-binding sites in A3G included 12 different peptides that showed strong binding to either full-length Vif, Vif CTD or both. Sequence similarity was found between Vif-binding peptides from the A3G CTD and NTD. A3G peptides were synthesized and tested for their ability to counteract Vif action. A3G 211-225 inhibited HIV-1 replication in cell culture and impaired Vif dependent A3G degradation. In vivo co-localization of full-length Vif with A3G 211-225 was demonstrated by use of FRET. This peptide has the potential to serve as an anti-HIV-1 lead compound. Our results suggest a complex interaction between Vif and A3G that is mediated by discontinuous binding regions with different affinities.

Peptides mimicking the unique ARTS-XIAP binding site promote apoptotic cell death in cultured cancer cells.

PURPOSE: XIAP [X-linked inhibitor of apoptosis (IAP) protein] is the best characterized mammalian caspase inhibitor. XIAP is frequently overexpressed in a variety of human tumors, and genetic inactivation of XIAP in mice protects against lymphoma. Therefore, XIAP is an attractive target for anticancer therapy. IAP antagonists based on a conserved IAP-binding motif (IBM), often referred to as "Smac-mimetics," are currently being evaluated for cancer therapy in the clinic. ARTS (Sept4_i2) is a mitochondrial proapoptotic protein which promotes apoptosis by directly binding and inhibiting XIAP via a mechanism that is distinct from all other known IAP antagonists. Here, we investigated the ability of peptides derived from ARTS to antagonize XIAP and promote apoptosis in cancer cell lines. EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN: The ability of synthetic peptides, derived from the C-terminus of ARTS, to bind to XIAP, stimulate XIAP degradation, and induce apoptosis was examined. We compared the response of several cancer cell lines to different ARTS-derived peptides. Pull-down assays were used to examine binding to XIAP, and apoptosis was evaluated using terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated dUTP nick end labeling, caspase activation, and Western blot analyses of caspase substrates. RESULTS: The C-terminus of ARTS contains a unique sequence, termed ARTS-IBM (AIBM), which is important for binding to XIAP and cell killing. AIBM peptides can bind to XIAP-BIR3, penetrate cancer cells, reduce XIAP levels, and promote apoptosis. CONCLUSIONS: Short synthetic peptides derived from the C-terminus of ARTS are sufficient for binding to XIAP and can induce apoptosis in cancer cells. These results provide proof-of-concept for the feasibility of developing ARTS-based anticancer therapeutics.

Mechanism of the interaction between the intrinsically disordered C-terminus of the pro-apoptotic ARTS protein and the Bir3 domain of XIAP.

ARTS (Sept4_i2) is a mitochondrial pro-apoptotic protein that functions as a tumor suppressor. Its expression is significantly reduced in leukemia and lymphoma patients. ARTS binds and inhibits XIAP (X-linked Inhibitor of Apoptosis protein) by interacting with its Bir3 domain. ARTS promotes degradation of XIAP through the proteasome pathway. By doing so, ARTS removes XIAP inhibition of caspases and enables apoptosis to proceed. ARTS contains 27 unique residues in its C-terminal domain (CTD, residues 248-274) which are important for XIAP binding. Here we characterized the molecular details of this interaction. Biophysical and computational methods were used to show that the ARTS CTD is intrinsically disordered under physiological conditions. Direct binding of ARTS CTD to Bir3 was demonstrated using NMR and fluorescence spectroscopy. The Bir3 interacting region in ARTS CTD was mapped to ARTS residues 266-274, which are the nine C-terminal residues in the protein. Alanine scan of ARTS 266-274 showed the importance of several residues for Bir3 binding, with His268 and Cys273 contributing the most. Adding a reducing agent prevented binding to Bir3. A dimer of ARTS 266-274 formed by oxidation of the Cys residues into a disulfide bond bound with similar affinity and was probably required for the interaction with Bir3. The detailed analysis of the ARTS - Bir3 interaction provides the basis for setting it as a target for anti cancer drug design: It will enable the development of compounds that mimic ARTS CTD, remove IAPs inhibition of caspases, and thereby induce apoptosis.

Structural disorder in the HIV-1 Vif protein and interaction-dependent gain of structure.

The HIV-1 Vif protein (192 residues) is required for HIV-1 infection of many target cells. Vif overcomes the anti-viral cellular defense by antagonizing the cellular cytosine deaminase APOBEC-3G through impairing APOBEC-3G production, inhibiting its enzymatic activity and targeting it for degradation. Vif interacts with several viral and cellular molecules, particularly via its C-terminal domain (residues 100-192). The structure of full-length Vif has not yet been determined. The structure of Vif and its domains was studied using computational and experimental methods. Computational predictions resulted in two suggested homology models for the full length protein. Experimental studies have shown that the Vif C-terminal domain is mainly unstructured. Residues 108-139 have mainly random coil conformation in the unbound state. This region includes an HCCH Zn(2+)-binding motif that also mediates Vif binding to Cul5, a protein in the E3 ubiquitin ligase complex. The C-terminal domain residues 141-192, which mediate interactions with both ElonginC and Cul5, are intrinsically disordered. This region also includes several phosphorylation sites and regions associated with the ability of Vif to undergo self-oligomerization. The unstructured nature of these regions enables them to interact with several ligands, and probably adopt various conformations as is typical for intrinsically disordered proteins. This was demonstrated by a conformational change induced by Zn(2+) binding to the HCCH motif and a conformational change that the C-terminal domain underwent in the presence of dodecylphosphocholine. The only available crystal structure of Vif includes residues 140-155, which are helical when bound to the ElonginBC complex. Overall, empirical structures, predictions and other experimental data for Vif did not always indicate the same degree or type of structure for any given region. This ambiguity is likely to be the tenet of structurally unfolded proteins, which have the propensity to adopt a multitude of biologically relevant and active conformations.

The C-terminal domain of the HIV-1 Vif protein is natively unfolded in its unbound state.

The human immunodeficiency virus type-1 (HIV-1) Vif protein neutralizes the cellular defense mechanism against the virus. The C-terminal domain of Vif (CTD, residues 141-192) mediates many of its interactions. Full-length Vif is difficult to purify in large amounts, hence the only available structure of Vif is of residues 140-155 within the ElonginBC complex. Other structural information, derived from modeling and indirect experiments, indicates that the Vif CTD may be unstructured. Here, we chemically synthesized the Vif CTD using pseudo-proline-building blocks, studied its solution structure in the unbound state using biophysical techniques and found that it is unstructured under physiological conditions. The circular dichroism (CD) spectrum of Vif CTD showed a pattern of random coil with residual helical structure. The (15)N-HSQC nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectrum was characteristic of natively unfolded peptides. Vif CTD eluted from an analytical gel filtration column earlier than expected, indicating an extended conformation. Disorder predictions found the CTD to be unstructured, in agreement with our experimental results. CD experiments showed that Vif CTD underwent a conformational change upon interacting with membrane-mimicking DPC micelles, but not upon binding to a peptide derived from its binding region in ElonginC. Our results provide direct evidence for the unfolded structure of the free Vif CTD and indicate that it may gain structure upon binding its natural ligands.