Evaluation of the short-term impact of counseling in general practice.

This paper describes the findings of a randomised controlled trial of the short-term impact of counseling in the general practice setting. Compared with patients who received usual advice from their general practitioner for acute problems such as relationship difficulties, anxiety and depression, those who received counseling from qualified counselors working within the primary health care context showed greater improvement in psychological health as measured by the General Health Questionnaire. Significantly fewer of those counselled were prescribed anti-depressant drugs by the general practitioners in the study, or were referred to psychiatrists or clinical psychologists for care. In addition those patients who attended sessions with the practice counselor were more likely to report that they were satisfied with their treatment and more expressed feelings of well-being.

Family survivors of suicide and accidental death: consequences for widows.

The impact of completed suicide on the surviving family was studied. Thirteen widows whose husbands had died through suicide were compared with 13 widows whose husbands had died in accidents. The widows' views of their families' functioning, and the extent of life stress and psychiatric symptoms experienced by the widows, were assessed. Interview data suggested more guilt and blaming in suicide survivor families. However, on standardized questionnaires, suicide survivors showed no more family dysfunction, life stress, or psychiatric symptomatology than accident survivors. Both groups acknowledged clinically significant levels of symptoms. The findings raise questions about the validity of generalizations based on the clinical literature regarding the uniquely pathogenic impact of suicide on family functioning.