TUNEL labeling with BrdUTP/anti-BrdUTP greatly underestimates the level of sperm DNA fragmentation in semen evaluation.

Many studies have now confirmed that sperm DNA fragmentation (SDF) is associated with a poorer outcome of some forms of assisted reproduction technology. For this reason, SDF is an important parameter to evaluate in male fertility assessment. TUNEL (terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase dUTP nick end labeling) assay coupled to flow cytometry is one of the most promising methods for SDF quantification. Several kits for the detection of DNA fragmentation are currently available on the market and all are recommended as equally appropriate to quantify SDF. In this work we compared for the first time the efficacy of two different types of TUNEL kits for SDF quantification: one using an indirect antibody-based labeling system (BrdUTP/fluorescein-anti-BrdUTP) and another using a direct labeling system (fluorescein-dUTP). We demonstrated that TUNEL indirect labeling system largely underestimates SDF when compared with the direct labeling, the differences ranging from 19.2% to 85.3% (p<0.05, n = 22). We observed that these differences were most pronounced among dead spermatozoa where indirect labeling stained 40.1% [23.6%, 58.2%] and the direct system 65.7% [36.5%, 90.9%] (n = 10, p<0.05). Interestingly, we found that both systems stained the living spermatozoa with the same efficiency. We showed that the differences are due to the steric hindrance of the antibody during its binding to the BrdUTP. Indeed, after sperm DNA decondensation, the percentages of TUNEL positivity increased significantly from 46.3% [31.8%, 61.7%] to 97.5% [96.1%, 98.8%] (p<0.05, n = 5). Our results are important for future use of TUNEL in clinical practice. Laboratories relying on the use of an antibody-based system heavily underestimate SDF, most particularly in infertile patients with reduced sperm motility. As a consequence, the kit using BrdUTP/fluorescein-anti-BrdUTP should not be recommended as a method to assay DNA damage in semen. This study represents one further step in the standardization of TUNEL among laboratories.

Isolation of spermatozoa with low levels of fragmented DNA with the use of flow cytometry and sorting.

OBJECTIVE: To develop a method to select spermatozoa with low DNA fragmentation rates for assisted reproduction technologies (ART). DESIGN: Multistep prospective cohort study. SETTING: University hospital. PATIENT(S): Semen samples of 34 infertile men were prepared in parallel with swim-up and fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS), and 11 semen samples were used for testing the staining strategy. INTERVENTION(S): Flow cytometric sorting of YO-PRO-stained spermatozoa. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S): Assessment of recovery of spermatozoa and purity after sorting, quantification of sperm DNA fragmentation and viability after sorting and after swim up preparation. RESULT(S): Staining with YO-PRO could be performed successfully in regular culture medium, both dead and apoptotic spermatozoa were labeled without the dye entering the viable spermatozoa. Compared with the conventional swim-up method, the sorted viable population showed a significantly reduced number of spermatozoa with fragmented DNA. CONCLUSION(S): A novel method has been developed, which not only might improve the outcome of ART, but can also help to clarify the ongoing controversy of the role of DNA fragmentation in male infertility.

Gene delivery to human bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells by microporation.

Electroporation has been considered one of the most efficient non-viral based methods to deliver genes regardless of frequently observed high cell mortality. In this study we used a microporation technique to optimise the delivery of plasmid DNA encoding green fluorescence protein (GFP) to human bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells (BM-MSC). Using resuspension buffer (RB) and as low as 1.5 x 105 cells and 1 µg of DNA, we achieved 40% of cells expressing the transgene, with cell recovery and cell viabilities of 85% and 90%, respectively. An increase in DNA amount did not significantly increase the number of transfected cells but clearly reduced cell recovery. A face-centered composite design was used to unveil the conditions giving rise to optimal plasmid delivery efficiencies when using a sucrose based microporation buffer (SBB). The BM-MSC proliferation kinetics were mainly affected by the presence of plasmid and not due to the microporation process itself although no effect was observed on their immunophenotypic characteristics and differentiative potential. Based on the data shown herein microporation demonstrated to be a reliable and efficient method to genetically modify hard-to-transfect cells giving rise to the highest levels of cell survival reported so far along with superior gene delivery efficiencies.

Evidence for the in vivo expression of a distant downstream gene under the control of ColE1 replication origin.

ColE1-like plasmids are widely used as expression vectors and as gene delivery vehicles. We have recently described a naturally occurring plasmid deletion phenomenon in the ColE1-type plasmid, pCI-neo, which leads to the detectable expression of an apparently promotorless kanamycin resistance gene. In the current work, we found that the expression of that aminoglycoside phosphotransferase (aph) gene is regulated by an RNAII preprimer promoter located within the plasmid ColE1 replication origin, as a consequence of the extension of the RNA II species for at least 1.5 kb, up to the aph gene. This mechanism is dependent on the nonformation and/or dissociation of the hybrid between plasmid DNA and RNA II preprimer transcript. This is the first in vivo description of RNA II transcription beyond ori in wild-type Escherichia coli strains and nonmutated RNAII plasmid sequences resulting in productive transcription of distant downstream genes. Our results raise questions about unwanted expression of genes from expression or cloning vectors of ColE1 type and highlight the importance of a more careful design of ColE1-derived plasmid vectors.

High frequency plasmid recombination mediated by 28 bp direct repeats.

The stability in Escherichia coli of a mammalian expression vector (pCIneo) and its derivative candidate DNA vaccine (pGPV-PV) is described. These multicopy pMB1-type plasmids were found to recombine in several recA E. coli strains due to the presence of two 28 bp direct repeats flanking intervening sequences of 1.6 kb (pCIneo) and 3.2 kb (pGPV-PV). In this recombination event, one of the direct repeats and the intervening sequence were deleted or duplicated, originating monomeric or/and hetero-dimeric plasmid forms, respectively. Additionally, the plasmid rearrangement led to the acquisition of a kanamycin resistance phenotype. Recombination frequencies between 7.8 x 10(-7) and 3.1 x 10(-5) were determined for DH5alpha and JM109(DE3) strains, respectively. Higher recombination frequencies were found in cells previously grown up to stationary growth phase being the monomeric plasmid form the prevalent one. Real-time PCR quantification revealed the presence of approximately 1.5 x 10(4) recombined molecules per 2 x 10(5 )cells pre-kanamycin exposure. Under selective pressure of this antibiotic, the number of recombined molecules increased approximately 2,000-fold in a 48-h period replacing the original plasmid form. The high frequency, at which deletion-duplication occurred in the absence of kanamycin selective pressure, should be regarded as a safety concern. This work highlights the impact of mutational hot spots on expression and cloning plasmid vectors and the need to carefully design plasmid vectors.

The impact of polyadenylation signals on plasmid nuclease-resistance and transgene expression.

BACKGROUND: Efficient delivery and expression of plasmids (pDNA) is a major concern in gene therapy and DNA vaccination using non-viral vectors. Besides the use of adjuvants, the pDNA vector itself can be designed to maximize survival in nuclease-rich environments. Homopurine-rich tracts in polyadenylation sequences have been previously shown to be especially important in pDNA resistance. METHODOLOGY: The effect of modifications in the poly A sequence of a model pDNA vector (pVAX1GFP) on nuclease resistance and transgene expression was investigated. Four poly A sequences were studied: bovine growth hormone (BGH), mutant BGH, SV40 and a synthetic poly A. Plasmid resistance (half-life) was assessed through in vitro incubations with mammalian nucleases. The impact in transgene expression was studied by quantifying pDNA, mRNA, and GFP expression in CHO, hybridoma and HeLa cells. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: In vitro and cell culture studies indicate that plasmids containing the SV40 and the synthetic poly A sequences present significant improvements in nuclease resistance (up to two-fold increase in half-life). However, RT-PCR analysis demonstrated that significant reduction in mRNA steady-state levels were responsible for a decrease in transgene expression and detected transfection level of CHO and hybridoma cells when using the more resistant plasmids. Interestingly, transfection of HeLa cells demonstrated that both poly A efficiency and plasmid resistance interfere significantly in transgene expression. The results strongly suggest that the choice of the poly A is important, not only for mRNA maturation/stability, but also for pDNA resistance, and should thus be taken into consideration in the design and evaluation of pDNA vectors.

The role of polyadenylation signal secondary structures on the resistance of plasmid vectors to nucleases.

BACKGROUND: Nuclease degradation of plasmid DNA (pDNA) vectors after delivery and during trafficking to the nucleus is a barrier to gene expression. This barrier may be circumvented by shielding the pDNA from the nuclease-rich cell environment with adjuvants or by using nuclease inhibitors. A different alternative that is explored in this work is to make pDNA vectors more nuclease-resistant a priori. METHODS AND RESULTS: The hypothesis that a significant part of nuclease attack is directed towards certain labile sequences in a pDNA model (pVAX1/lacZ) was first tested. Homopurine-rich tracts in the bovine growth hormone polyadenylation signal (BGH poly A) were identified as labile sequences using S1 nuclease as a probe. Two pDNA variants were then created by replacing the BGH poly A region with the SV40 or a synthetic poly A signal. A study of plasmid degradation in eukaryotic cell lysates and mice plasma showed that the half-life of the supercoiled isoforms of the new vectors was always higher when compared with the control plasmid. An in vitro assay of the reporter beta-galactosidase in transfected CHO cells further showed that gene expression with the new pDNA variants was not affected negatively by the plasmid modifications. CONCLUSIONS: The replacement of labile sequences in plasmid DNA vectors improves resistance towards nuclease attack as shown by the increased half-lives of supercoiled plasmid isoforms incubated with endo/lysosomal, cytoplasmatic and blood plasma enzymes.