A comparison of catalytic site intermediates of cytochrome c oxidase and peroxidases.

Compounds I and II of peroxidases such as horseradish peroxidase and cytochrome c peroxidase are relatively well understood catalytic intermediates in terms of their structures and redox states of iron, heme, and associated radical species. The intermediates involved in the oxygen reduction chemistry of the cytochrome c oxidase superfamily are more complicated because of the need for four reducing equivalents and because of the linkage of the oxygen chemistry with vectorial proton translocations. Nevertheless, two of these intermediates, the peroxy and ferryl forms, have characteristics that can in many ways be considered to be counterparts of peroxidase compounds I and II. We explore the primary factors that minimize the generation of unwanted reactive oxygen species products and ensure that the principal enzymological function becomes either that of a peroxidase or an oxidase. These comparisons can provide insights into the nature of biological oxygen reduction chemistry and guidance for the engineering of biomimetic synthetic materials.

A study of the horseradish peroxidase catalytic site by FTIR spectroscopy.

Vibrational changes in the catalytic site of horseradish peroxidase were investigated by FTIR (Fourier-transform infrared) spectroscopy in the 1000-2500 cm(-1) range. Difference spectra were generated by photolysis of the haemII-CO compound at different pH/pD values. The spectra report on the fine structure around the catalytic site and show vibrational changes of protein backbone, amino acid residues and cofactors. Assignments of the FTIR vibrations can be made based upon known crystal structures, comparisons with absorption frequencies and extinction coefficients of model amino acids and cofactors, effects of H2O/2H2O exchange and changes of pH/pD. Concomitant with the photolysis of the CO ligand are changes due to haem and protein vibrations, predominant among which are arginine and histidine residue vibrations.

The molecular machinery of Keilin's respiratory chain.

Keilin's classic paper of 1925 [Keilin (1925) Proc. R. Soc. London Ser. B 100, 129-151], achieved with simple, but elegant, techniques, describes the cytochrome components of the respiratory chain and their roles in intracellular respiration and oxygen consumption. Since that time, a tremendous amount of work has clarified the intricate details of the prosthetic groups, cofactors and proteins that comprise the respiratory chain and associated machinery for ATP synthesis. The work has culminated in advanced crystallographic and spectroscopic methods that provide structural and mechanistic details of this mitochondrial molecular machinery, in many instances to atomic level. I review here the current state of understanding of the mitochondrial respiratory chain in terms of structures and dynamics of the component proteins and their roles in the biological electron and proton transfer processes that result in ATP synthesis. These advances, together with emerging evidence of further diverse roles of mitochondria in health and disease, have prompted a new era of interest in mitochondrial function.

The sites of interaction of triphenyltetrazolium chloride with mitochondrial respiratory chains.

The inability of cells and microorganisms to reduce the colourless electron acceptor triphenyltetrazolium chloride (TTC) to a red formazan precipitate is commonly used as a means of screening for cells that have a dysfunctional respiratory chain. The site of reduction of TTC is often stated to be at the level of cytochrome c oxidase where it is assumed to compete with oxygen for reducing equivalents. However, we show here that TTC is reduced not by cytochrome c oxidase but instead by dehydrogenases, particularly complex I, probably by accepting electrons directly from low potential cofactors. The reduction rate is fastest in coupled membranes because of accumulation in the matrix of the positively charged TTC+ cation. However, the initial product of TTC reduction is rapidly reoxidised by molecular oxygen, so that generation of the stable red formazan product from this intermediate occurs only under strictly anaerobic conditions. Colonies of mutants defective in cytochrome oxidase do not generate sufficiently anaerobic conditions to allow the intermediate to form the stable red formazan. This revision of the mode of interaction of TTC with respiratory chains has implications for the types of respiratory-defective mutants that might be detected by TTC screening.

FTIR studies of the CO and cyanide adducts of fully reduced bovine cytochrome c oxidase.

Photolysis spectra of the CO and cyanide adducts of reduced bovine cytochrome c oxidase have been studied by FTIR difference spectroscopy. Bound CO is predominantly in a single 1963 cm(-1) form whereas cyanide is bound in at least two forms (2058/2045 cm(-1)). These forms are pH-independent between pH 6.5 and 8.5, indicating that there is no titratable protonatable group that influences significantly their binding in this pH range. Photolysis spectra of the cyanide adduct have a positive band around 2090 cm(-1) in H(2)O due at least in part to free HCN and at 1880 cm(-1) in D(2)O due to free DCN. The frequency of the positive band around 2090 cm(-1), and its persistence in D(2)O media, raises the possibility that a transient cyanide-Cu(B) adduct also contributes to this signal, equivalent to the CO-Cu(B) species that is formed when CO is photolyzed. Photolysis produces changes throughout the 1000-1800 cm(-1) region. Reduced minus (reduced + CO) photolysis spectra in H(2)O exhibit a pH-independent and symmetrical peak/trough at 1749/1741 cm(-1). A related feature in homologous oxidases has been suggested to arise from a conserved glutamic acid. However, only around one-third of the feature is shifted to lower frequencies by incubation in D(2)O media, and an additional fraction is shifted if catalytic turnover occurs in D(2)O. Reduced minus (reduced + cyanide) photolysis spectra exhibit multiple features in H(2)O in this region with peaks at 1752, 1725, and 1708 cm(-1) and troughs at 1740, 1715, and 1698 cm(-1). Again, only a part of these features shift in D(2)O, even with catalytic turnover. A variety of additional H/D-sensitive features in the 1700-1000 cm(-1) region of the spectra can be discerned, one of which in cyanide photolysis spectra is tentatively assigned to a conserved tyrosine, Y244. Data are discussed in relation to the structure of the binuclear center and protonatable groups in its vicinity.

Two Menkes-type atpases supply copper for photosynthesis in Synechocystis PCC 6803.

Synechocystis PCC 6803 contains four genes encoding polypeptides with sequence features of CPx-type ATPases, two of which are now designated pacS and ctaA. We show that CtaA and PacS (but not the related transporters, ZiaA or CoaT) facilitate switching to the use of copper (in plastocyanin) as an alternative to iron (in cytochrome c(6)) for the carriage of electrons within the thylakoid lumen. Disruption of pacS reduced copper tolerance but enhanced silver tolerance, and pacS-mediated restoration of copper tolerance was used to select transformants. Disruption of ctaA caused no change in copper tolerance but reduced the amount of copper cell(-1). In cultures supplemented with 0.2 microm copper, photooxidation of cytochrome c(6) (PetJ) was depressed in wild-type cells but remained elevated in both Synechocystis PCC 6803(ctaA) and Synechocystis PCC 6803(pacS). Conversely, plastocyanin transcripts (petE) were less abundant in both mutants at this [copper]. Synechocystis PCC 6803(ctaA) and Synechocystis PCC 6803(pacS) showed increased iron dependence with impaired growth in deferoxamine mesylate (iron chelator)-containing media. Double mutants also deficient in cytochrome c(6), Synechocystis PCC 6803(petJ,ctaA) and Synechocystis PCC 6803(petJ,pacS), were viable, but the former had increased copper dependence with severely impaired growth in the presence of bathocuproinedisulfonic acid (copper chelator). Analogous transporters are likely to supply copper to plastocyanin in chloroplasts.

Protonation reactions in relation to the coupling mechanism of bovine cytochrome c oxidase.

Identification of the locations of protonatable sites in cytochrome c oxidase that are influenced by reactions in the binuclear centre is critical to assessment of proposed coupling mechanisms, and to controversies on where the pumping steps occur. One such protonation site is that which governs interconversion of the isoelectronic 607 nm 'P(M)' and 580 nm 'F' forms of the two-electron-reduced oxygen intermediate. Low pH favours protonation of a site that is close to an electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR)-silent radical species in P(M), and this induces a partial electronic redistribution to form an EPR-detectable tryptophan radical in F. A further protonatable group that must be close to the binuclear centre has been detected in bacterial oxidases by Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy from pH-dependent changes in the haem-bound CO vibration frequency at low temperatures. However, in bovine cytochrome c oxidase under similar conditions of measurement, haem-bound CO remains predominantly in a single 1963 cm(-1) form between pH 6.5 and 8.5, indicating that this group is not present. Lack of pH dependence extends to the protein region of the CO photolysis spectra and suggests that both the reduced and the reduced/CO states do not have titratable groups that affect the binuclear centre strongly in the pH range 6.5-8.5. This includes the conserved glutamic acid residue E242 whose pK appears to be above 8.5 even in the fully oxidised enzyme. The results are discussed in relation to recent ideas on coupling mechanism.

Reaction of bovine cytochrome c oxidase with hydrogen peroxide produces a tryptophan cation radical and a porphyrin cation radical.

Oxidized bovine cytochrome c oxidase reacts with hydrogen peroxide to generate two electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) free radical signals (Fabian, M., and Palmer, G. (1995) Biochemistry 34, 13802-13810). These radicals are associated with the binuclear center and give rise to two overlapped EPR signals, one signal being narrower in line width (DeltaHptp = 12 G) than the other (DeltaHptp = 45 G). We have used electron nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) spectrometry to identify the two different chemical species giving rise to these two EPR signals. Comparison of the ENDOR spectrum associated with the narrow signal with that of compound I of horseradish peroxidase (formed by reaction of that enzyme with hydrogen peroxide) demonstrates that the two species are virtually identical. The chemical species giving rise to the narrow signal is therefore identified as an exchange-coupled porphyrin cation radical similar to that formed in horseradish peroxidase compound I. Comparison of the ENDOR spectrum of compound ES (formed by the reaction of hydrogen peroxide with cytochrome c peroxidase) with that of the broad signal indicates that the chemical species giving rise to the broad EPR signal in cytochrome c oxidase is probably an exchange coupled tryptophan cation radical. This is substantiated using H(2)O/D(2)O solvent exchange experiments where the ENDOR difference spectrum of the broad EPR signal of cytochrome c oxidase shows a feature consistent with hyperfine coupling to the exchangeable N(1) proton of a tryptophan cation radical.

A motif for quinone binding sites in respiratory and photosynthetic systems.

Many of the membrane-bound protein complexes of respiratory and photosynthetic systems are reactive with quinones. To date, no clear structural relationship between sites that bind quinone has been defined, apart from that in the homologous family of "type II" photosynthetic reaction centres. We show here that a structural element containing a weak sequence motif is common to the Q(A) and Q(B) sites of bacterial reaction centres and the Q(i) site of the mitochondrial bc(1) complex. Analyses of sequence databases indicate that this element may also be present in the PsaA/B subunits of photosystem I, in the ND4 and ND5 subunits of complex I and, possibly, in the mitochondrial alternative quinol oxidase. This represents a first step in the structural classification of quinone binding sites.

The reactions of hydrogen peroxide with bovine cytochrome c oxidase.

Oxidised cytochrome c oxidase is known to react with two molecules of hydrogen peroxide to form consecutively 607 nm 'Peroxy' and 580-nm 'Ferryl' species. These are widely used as model compounds for the equivalent P and F intermediates of the catalytic cycle. However, kinetic analysis of the reaction with H(2)O(2) in the pH range 6.0-9.0 reveals a more complex situation. In particular, as the pH is lowered, a 580-nm compound can be formed by reaction with a single H(2)O(2). This species, termed F(&z.rad;), is spectrally similar, but not identical, to F. The reactions are equivalent to those previously reported for the bo type quinol oxidase from Escherichia coli (T. Brittain, R.H. Little, C. Greenwood, N.J. Watmough, FEBS Lett. 399 (1996) 21-25) where it was proposed that F(&z.rad;) is produced directly from P. However, in the bovine oxidase F(&z.rad;) does not appear in samples of the 607-nm form, P(M), produced by CO/O(2) treatment, even at low pH, although this form is shown to be identical to the H(2)O(2)-derived P state, P(H), on the basis of spectral characteristics and kinetics of reaction with H(2)O(2). Furthermore, lowering the pH of a sample of P(M) or P(H) generated at high pH results in F(&z.rad;) formation only on a minutes time scale. It is concluded that P and F(&z.rad;) are not in a rapid, pH-dependent equilibrium, but instead are formed by distinct pathways and cannot interconvert in a simple manner, and that the crucial difference between them lies in their patterns of protonation.

Effects of mutation of the conserved glutamic acid-286 in subunit I of cytochrome c oxidase from Rhodobacter sphaeroides.

We have studied the effects of mutations, E286Q and E286D, of the conserved glutamate in subunit I of cytochrome c oxidase from Rhodobacter sphaeroides with a view to evaluating the role of this residue in redox-linked proton translocation. The mutation E286D did not have any dramatic effects on enzyme properties and retained 50% of wild-type catalytic activity. For E286Q a fraction of the binuclear center was trapped in an unreactive, spectrally distinct form which is most likely due to misfolded protein, but the majority of E286Q reacted normally with formate and cyanide in the oxidized state, and with carbon monoxide and cyanide in the dithionite-reduced form. The mutation also had little effect on the pH-dependent redox properties of haem a in the reactive fraction. However, formation of the P state from oxidized enzyme with hydrogen peroxide or by aerobic incubation with carbon monoxide was inhibited. In particular, only an F-type product was obtained, at less than 25% yield, in the reaction with hydrogen peroxide. The aerobic steady state in the presence of ferrous cytochrome c was characterized by essentially fully reduced haem a and ferric haem a3, suggesting that the mutation hinders electron transfer from haem a to the binuclear center. Under these conditions or after reoxidation, on a seconds time scale, of haem a3 following anaerobiosis, there was no indication of accumulation of significant amounts of P state. We propose that the glutamate is implicated in several steps in the catalytic cycle, O --> R, P --> F, and, possibly, F --> O. The results are discussed in relation to the "glutamate trap" model for proton translocation.

Second-site reversion analysis is not a reliable method to determine distances in membrane proteins: an assessment using mutations in yeast cytochrome c oxidase subunits I and II.

We have examined deficiency mutations and reversions in subunits I and II of yeast cytochrome c oxidase in order to test the reliability of second-site reversion analysis in prediction of tertiary structure of a membrane protein complex. It appears that the method can not provide information on distance between residues, since reversions can be up to 30 A from the primary mutations. However, the reversions are not randomly located in the structure but reveal regions essential for assembly or functional units.

On the mechanism of quinol oxidation in the bc1 complex.

The question of whether significant levels of a semiquinone can be generated in the Qo site of the bc1 complex under conditions of oxidant-induced reduction is relevant to the mechanism of bifurcation of electron transfer in this site. It has already been reported that beef heart submitochondrial particles under such conditions exhibit an EPR-detectable semiquinone, which is distinct from Q-i and which was attributed to a semiquinone in the Qo site (de Vries, S., Albracht, S. P. J., Berden, J. A., and Slater, E. C. (1981) J. Biol. Chem. 256, 11996-11998). However, we show here that this signal, which can be generated to a level of around 0.1 per bc1 monomer, is insensitive to the Qo site inhibitors myxothiazol, E-beta-methoxyacrylate-stilbene, and stigmatellin, indicating that it does not arise from a Q-o species. Based on sensitivities to inhibitors of other Q sites, up to 60% of the signal may arise from semiquinones of complexes I and II. We further show that the iron-sulfur center remains EPR silent under oxidant-induced reduction conditions. Overall, the results indicate that, under conditions of oxidant-induced reduction, the Qo site is occupied primarily by quinol with the iron-sulfur center oxidized, or, possibly, by an antiferromagnetically coupled semiquinone/reduced iron-sulfur center pair, which are EPR silent. This is discussed in relation to proposed mechanisms of quinol oxidation in the Qo site, and we describe a minimal intermediate-controlled bifurcation model based on rate constants by which bifurcated electron transfer at the Qo site might occur.

Quantitation and characterization of cytochrome c oxidase in complex systems.

Quantitation of cytochrome c oxidase in complex systems such as tissue homogenates is often hampered by the presence of other hemoproteins. Cyanide can bind to reduced cytochrome c oxidase from diverse sources with a dissociation constant in the range of 0.1-0.5 mM and induces a characteristic optical change. This contrasts with the very weak binding of cyanide to reduced forms of many other hemoproteins, including hemoglobin and myoglobin. Hence, difference spectra of cyanide binding to reduced samples can provide an improved method to resolve and quantitate cytochrome c oxidase. In addition, the cyanide compound of cytochrome c oxidase is photolabile. This property can be exploited to further enhance the sensitivity of detection and analysis of cytochrome c oxidase.

Protonmotive mechanism of heme-copper oxidases.

The mechanism of coupling of proton and electron transfer in oxidases is reviewed and related to the structural information that is now available. A "glutamate trap" mechanism for proton/electron coupling is described.

The reaction of halides with pulsed cytochrome bo from Escherichia coli.

Cytochrome bo forms complexes with chloride, bromide and iodide in which haem o remains high-spin and in which the '630 nm' charge-transfer band is red-shifted by 7-8 nm. The chloride and bromide complexes each have a characteristic set of integer-spin EPR signals arising from spin coupling between haem o and CuB. The rate and extent of chloride binding decreases as the pH increases from 5.5 to 8.5. At pH 5.5 the dissociation constant for chloride is 2 mM and the first-order rate constant for dissociation is 2 x 10(-4) s-1. The order of rate of binding, and of affinity, at pH 5.5 is chloride (1) > bromide (0.3) >iodide (0.1). It is suggested that the halides bind in the binuclear site but, unlike fluoride, they are not direct ligands of the iron of haem o. In addition, both the stability of the halide complexes and the rate of halide binding seem to be increased by the co-binding of a proton.

Effects of mutation of residue I67 on redox-linked protonation processes in yeast cytochrome c oxidase.

We describe effects of a mutation, Ile-67-->Asn, in subunit I of yeast cytochrome c oxidase on redox-linked protonation processes within the protein. The mutation lowers the midpoint potential of haem a and weakens its pH dependency, but has little effect on the potential of haem a3. The residue is close to a conserved glutamate (Glu-243) in the crystal structure. We propose that protonation of Glu-243 is redox-linked to haem a, that Asn-167 perturbs its pK and that redox-linked protonation in this location is essential for the catalytic reactions of the binuclear centre. These proposals are discussed in terms of a 'glutamate trap' mechanism for proton translocation in the haem/copper oxidases.

Redox- and anion-linked protonation sites in horseradish peroxidase: analysis of distal haem pocket mutants.

We have investigated the effects of mutations at residues His-42, Arg-38 and Phe-41 in the distal haem pocket of horseradish peroxidase on the changes in protonation state that accompany redox- and ligand-linked changes to the haem group. The mutations H42L and R38L result in the loss of a characteristic pH dependency in the visible spectrum of the ferrous form and a diminished dependency of the midpoint redox potential of the haem group on pH. The results support the view that His-42, with its pK probably modulated by Arg-38, provides the protonation site on the reduced enzyme that is responsible for these pH dependencies. The mutations H42L and R38L also have major effects on the binding of cyanide to the haem. We have already reported that binding of cyanide to the ferrous forms of these mutants becomes too weak to be measurable [Meunier, Rodriguez-Lopez, Smith, Thorneley and Rich (1995) Biochemistry 34, 14687-14692]. The pH dependency of the rate constants for binding of cyanide to the oxidized form of H42L suggests that CN- is the kinetically active species, in contrast with wild-type horseradish peroxidase, where HCN is the binding form. For the R38L variant, the pH dependency of cyanide binding suggests that the pK of His-42 in the absence of Arg-38 is raised to 7.5-8, in the oxidized form. In contrast with these changes, the mutant F41A exhibits cyanide-binding behaviour that is similar to that of the wild type, both in its oxidized and reduced forms. However, the rate constant for carbon monoxide recombination increases substantially, suggesting that the access route for carbon monoxide, but not for cyanide, is perturbed by this amino acid substitution.

Effects of mutation of the conserved lysine-362 in cytochrome c oxidase from Rhodobacter sphaeroides.

We describe the effects of a mutation, K362M, of the conserved lysine in cytochrome c oxidase from Rhodobacter sphaeroides, a residue located in a putative proton channel that may convey substrate protons to the binuclear center. Spectra of the "as prepared", ferricyanide-oxidized, and dithionite-reduced forms of the mutant protein confirm that the redox centers remain intact. Ligand binding kinetics of the ferricyanide-oxidized enzyme and of the dithionite-reducible fraction are similar to those of the wild type, indicating that the K channel is not the major route for CO, cyanide, formate, or peroxide entry into the structure. Protonation of the lysine residue is not redox-linked to heme a or CuB as judged from the essentially unaltered midpoint potentials of these centers in the cyanide-ligated enzyme. A difficulty in electron transfer from heme a to the binuclear center is indicated by the slow and only partial reduction of heme a3 by dithionite or ferrocytochrome c and by the presence of some reduced heme a in the as prepared mutant enzyme and under steady-state conditions. Further characterization of the K362M enzyme in the steady state shows that up to one electron, but not two, can enter the binuclear center easily. It is this inability to form the two-electron-reduced, oxygen-reactive R state that prevents activity. A model is proposed where the K channel serves as a dielectric well of high dielectric strength and low proton conductivity, rather than as a pathway for proton entry to the binuclear center. The function of this structure would be to decrease the cost of introducing a transiently uncompensated charge into the binuclear center prior to formation of a stable, charge-compensated R-state.

Effects of decyl-aurachin D and reversed electron transfer in cytochrome bd.

Decyl-aurachin D is a near-stoichiometric inhibitor of cytochrome bd from Azotobacter vinelandii. Interaction of decyl-aurachin D with the oxidase induces a redshift of the alpha-band and Soret band of a b-type cytochrome, probably b-558, suggesting close proximity of the inhibitor binding site to this haem and hence to the proposed quinol binding domain. The compound does not affect the oxygen binding site directly as judged from unchanged CO recombination kinetics to haem d in dithionite-reduced enzyme. Although in the presence of ubiquinol-1 a decyl-aurachin D containing sample generates levels of haem reduction and catalytic intermediates similar to the control, the approach to this steady state is severely inhibited. In addition to the spectral effect on b-558, decyl-aurachin D raises the midpoint potential of haem b-558, but also lowers that of haem b-595. Consistent with the shift in midpoint potentials, electron backflow from haem d to the b-type haems can be observed in decyl-aurachin D inhibited samples following photolysis of the mixed-valence CO-ligated form of the enzyme. The data show that decyl-aurachin D acts on the donor side of haem b-558 without substantially affecting internal electron transfer rates or the oxygen reduction site.