The effect of hypoxia on the functional and structural development of the chick brain.

Decreased oxygen availability during gestation is linked with altered structural development of the brain and cognitive deficits after birth. Prehatch hypoxia can induce gross neuropathology such as brain lesions or more subtle injury including selective neuronal cell loss, white matter injury and gliosis. In the current study we used the developing chick embryo to determine whether 24h of hypoxia at different prehatch ages, embryonic day 10, 12 or 14 (E10, E12 or E14), resulted in an alteration in neuronal cell number or astrocyte density in brain areas associated with learning and memory. Twenty-four hours of hypoxia (14% oxygen) commencing at E10 resulted in an increase in the density of GFAP-positive astrocytes in the medial striatum (MSt) (P<0.05) and a significant reduction in the number of NeuN-positive neuronal nuclei in the intermediate medial mesopallium (IMM) (P<0.02). Hypoxia at E14 resulted in an increase in GFAP immunoreactivity in the hippocampus (P < or = 0.02) and a significant decrease in the number of NeuN-positive cells in the IMM (P<0.04). Memory was tested soon after hatch using a bead discrimination learning task and results showed that E10 hypoxia significantly reduced short-term memory, which subsequently affected all stages of memory formation (P<0.001), whereas 24h of hypoxia at E14 did not alter short-term memory, but impaired consolidation into long-term memory (P<0.02). Interestingly, 24h of hypoxia at E12 did not alter GFAP immunoreactivity or NeuN-positive cells, nor did it result in memory deficits. We find that an alteration in the number or a disruption in the normal development of astrocytes and neurons significantly affects memory formation and consolidation in the young chick.

Importance of adrenergic receptors in prenatally induced cognitive impairment in the domestic chick.

In the domestic chick, mild hypoxia (24h of 14% oxygen) at two stages of embryonic development results in post-hatch memory deficiencies tested using a discriminated bead avoidance task. The nature of the memory loss depends on the gestational age at which the hypoxia occurs. Hypoxia on embryonic day 10 (E10) of a 21 day incubation results in chicks with no short-term memory 10 min after training, whereas hypoxia on day 14 (E14) results in chicks with good labile memory 30 min after training but no consolidation of memory into permanent storage (120 min). Hypoxia at E14 is associated with increased plasma levels of noradrenaline and therefore we suggest that altered catecholamine exposure within the brain contributes to cognitive problems by modifying the responsiveness of brain beta-adrenoceptors. In ovo administration of noradrenaline, or the beta(2)-adrenoceptor agonist formoterol, at E14 had the same effect on memory consolidation as hypoxia. Following hypoxia at E14, memory could be rescued after training by central injection of a beta(3)-adrenoceptor agonist, but not by a beta(2)-adrenoceptor agonist. The differences in the responsiveness of memory processing to beta(2)-adrenoceptor agonists suggests alterations to the receptors or downstream of the receptor activation. However, both types of beta-adrenoceptor agonists rescued memory in E10 treated chicks implying that at this age hypoxia does not affect the receptors. In summary, hypoxia or increased levels of stress hormones during incubation alters beta-adrenoceptor responsiveness; the outcome of the insult depends upon the cellular developmental processes at a given embryonic stage.

The effect of hypoxia at different embryonic ages on impairment of memory ability in chicks.

Hypoxia during the prenatal period is a principal antecedent to cognitive impairment after birth. In this study we have investigated the duration, severity and timing of acute hypoxia during chick embryonic development to elucidate the relative importance of these factors. Our results show that 24h of hypoxia (exposure to 14% oxygen) at embryonic day 10 (E10) results in significant impairment of intermediate and long-term memory in the post-hatch chick, which is the same as we observed with 4 days of hypoxia. At E14, 24h of hypoxia, 5min of anoxia, but not 1h of hypoxia, resulted only in impaired long-term memory; the same as 4 days of hypoxia from E14. Corticosterone levels, measured post-hatch as an indicator of a stress response, were significantly elevated in response to E10 hypoxia, and E14 hypoxia (both 1 and 24h) and anoxia. In a separate experiment we exposed embryos to 24h of hypoxia from E6 to E16, and found that memory deficits resulted from hypoxia at E9 and E10, and E13-E15, while corticosterone concentrations at hatch were significantly raised following E10-E16 hypoxia. These results demonstrate that the developmental age when the insult occurs determines the nature of the cognitive deficit and, if the severity of the insult is sufficient, then the outcome, or deficits in memory ability, are consistent whether the insult is acute or chronic. Importantly, there are two critical stages in development, which in the chick are around E10 and E14, when acute hypoxia results in significant adverse cognitive effects after hatch. These time-points correspond to two different stages in growth and development.

The role of corticosterone in prehatch-induced memory deficits in chicks.

We have previously shown that prehatch hypoxia (14% oxygen for 24 h), at E10 or E14 of chick embryonic development, produces significant memory deficits, with E10 hypoxia significantly affecting short-term memory and the subsequent formation of long-term memory, whereas E14 hypoxia only affects long-term memory. One of the consequences of hypoxia is the release of stress hormones and we found in this study that hypoxia at E10 or E14 induced a significant increase in circulating corticosterone immediately after the cessation of hypoxia (E11 and E15, respectively). Corticosterone levels remained significantly elevated at hatch in the E14 hypoxia group. This study describes the effect of a single, in ovo, injection of corticosterone on subsequent memory ability in hatched chicks. It was found that corticosterone (0.2 nmol/egg) at E10 or E14 mimicked the memory deficits produced by hypoxia at the same prehatch ages. Embryos treated with corticosterone at E10 had poor short-term memory at hatch, whereas corticosterone administration at E14 resulted in poor long-term memory. Embryos treated with corticosterone at E16 had raised circulating corticosterone levels at hatch, but did not have impaired memory. Treatment with corticosterone at E10, E12, E14 and E16 produced the same cognitive outcomes as hypoxia at the same prehatch ages. However, elevated plasma corticosterone levels at hatch did not necessarily cause the impaired memory processing. Raised levels were observed after treatment at E14 when memory processing was impaired, at E16 when memory was not impaired and not at E10 when memory was impaired. This suggests that an acute rather than sustained increase in plasma corticosterone at particular developmental ages is the cause of impaired memory processing seen at hatch.

The effect of prenatal hypoxia and malnutrition on memory consolidation in the chick.

The contribution of hypoxia and malnutrition to cognitive impairments was investigated in chicks incubated in conditions of reduced gas exchange. Previous research has shown that reducing gas exchange during incubation by wrapping half the eggshell with an impermeable membrane results in impaired cognitive ability in young chicks. The results were interpreted within a three stage sequential model of memory using discriminated bead avoidance learning. Reducing gas exchange for 4 days from day 10 or 14, of the 21-day incubation, inhibits memory formation and consolidation into permanent storage. The nature of the cognitive deficit depended on the timing of the insult. Environmental hypoxia (14% oxygen), induced from days 10 to 14 and from days 14 to 18, replicated the memory deficits found previously when eggs were partially wrapped with a membrane. Oxygen is necessary to break down food and to provide energy to build tissue proteins, and therefore hypoxia (partial wrapping or environmental incubation) may indirectly cause malnutrition. Malnutrition, induced by removing 5%, 7.5% or 10% albumin from the egg prior to incubation, had no significant effect on memory consolidation. Raised corticosterone levels occurred in chicks malnourished by 5% and 7.5%, but brain sparing was only evident in chicks with 7.5% albumin removal. Hatch rates were very low in 10% malnourished chicks. Using the chick as a model of prenatal stress, we have been able to isolate the effects of hypoxia from contributing maternal factors.