Comparative studies of apoptosis in Xenopus laevis and mouse thymoma cell lines.

With the use of in vitro methods and cell lines, functional aspects of apoptosis in the Xenopus laevis B3/B7 and mouse EL4 thymoma cell lines are revealed. Moreover, by using information gleaned from digital imaging and immunocytochemistry, changes in locations of key proteins implicated in apoptotic anti-cancer responses, e.g. p53 and Mdm2, are shown. Suggestions are offered as to what these results might mean with respect to the evolutionary conservation of the function and structure of these two molecules and to cancer resistance in amphibians. Finally, studies are described on resveratrol as an anti-cancer therapeutic reagent in the two thymoma cell lines and in normal X. laevis thymocytes.

Resistance to cancer in amphibians: a role for apoptosis?

The rarity of spontaneous cancer in amphibians, and the difficulty of inducing cancer in these lower vertebrates, suggest that they possess an effective system for resistance to the development of cancer. The first part of this narrative presents evidence for cancer resistance in amphibians, and then a variety of studies designed to help understand the physiological basis for this resistance are reviewed. Here, our emphasis is on evidence with regard to the role that apoptosis might play.

Cancer resistance in amphibians.

While spontaneous tumours may occasionally develop in inbred and isogenic strains of Xenopus laevis, the South African clawed toad, they are extremely rare in natural and laboratory populations. Only two amphibian neoplasms, the renal adenocarcinoma of Rana pipiens and the lymphosarcoma of Xenopus laevis, have been extensively explored. Amphibians are resistant to the development of neoplasia, even following exposure to "direct-acting" chemical carcinogens such as N-methyl-N-nitrosourea, that are highly lymphotoxic, thus diminishing immune reactivity. Regenerative capacity in adults, and a dramatic metamorphosis which remodels much of the larval body to produce the adult form, are unique to amphibian vertebrates, and the control mechanisms involved may protect against cancer. For example, naturally rising corticosteroid titres during metamorphosis will impair some T-cell functions, and the removal of T-regulatory (suppressor) functions inhibits the induction of altered-self tolerance. Altered-self tolerance is not as effectively induced in adult Xenopus laevis as in mammals, so cancer cells with new antigenicity are more likely be rejected in amphibians. Amphibian immunocytes tend to undergo apoptosis readily in vitro, and, unlike mammalian immunocytes, undergo apoptosis without entering the cell cycle. Cells not in the cell cycle that die from nuclear damage (apoptosis), will have no opportunity to express genetic instability leading to cell transformation. We suggest that all these factors, rather than any one of them, may reduce susceptibility to cancer in amphibians.

Bleomycin-induced DNA damage and repair in Xenopus laevis and Xenopus tropicalis.

Microgel cell electrophoresis has been used with various species to measure breakage of DNA and DNA repair following exposure to the radiomimetic antibiotic, bleomycin. With humans, a high degree of DNA damage is considered to be predictive of cancer susceptibility. Non-isogeneic Xenopus laevis, the South African clawed toad, rarely develop spontaneous or induced cancers. Here, we investigate bleomycin-induced DNA damage and repair in splenic lymphocytes of this species to test consistency with cancer predictability. As X. laevis is pseudotetraploid in nature, while Xenopus tropicalis is diploid, we additionally explore the effect of polyploidy on DNA damage and repair in these vertebrates. The results show that higher doses of bleomycin are required to induce comparable levels of DNA damage in both Xenopus species, than in humans. X. tropicalis, the diploid, is more bleomycin-sensitive than is X. laevis. Additionally, repair rates of damaged DNA of X. laevis lymphocytes are more rapid than those of X. tropicalis, although both are hours slower than human leukocytes. While no data exist on cancer susceptibility in X. tropicalis, the results suggest greater susceptibility to cancer than X. laevis, but less than in humans. Thus, polyploidy serves as a protection against DNA damage and allows more rapid repair.