Hydrogen Tag Shifts as Vibrational Reporters for Positional Isomers of Formylphenides: Surprising Mobility of the Carbanion Center upon Collisional Decarboxylation of the Parent Benzoates.

Infrared photodissociation of weakly bound "mass tags" is widely used to determine the structures of ions by analyzing their vibrational spectra. Molecular hydrogen is a common choice for tagging in cryogenic radio-frequency ion traps. Although the H2 molecules can introduce distortions in the target species, we demonstrate an advantage of H2 tagging in the analysis of positional isomers adopted by the molecular anions derived from decarboxylation of formylbenzoates. Attachment of H2 to the carbanion centers of three such isomers yields distinct shifts in the H2 stretch, which can be used to determine the distribution of isomers in an unknown sample. Electronic structure calculations indicate that the position-dependent shifts are due to different reactivities of the carbanion sites with respect to an intracluster proton-transfer reaction with the H2 molecule. We exploit this spectroscopic method to quantify the surprisingly facile migrations of the anionic center that have been previously reported for phenide rearrangements.

Structures and Chemical Rearrangements of Benzoate Derivatives Following Gas Phase Decarboxylation.

Decarboxylation of carboxylate ions in the gas phase provides a useful window into the chemistry displayed by these reactive carbanion intermediates. Here, we explore the species generated by decarboxylation of two benzoate derivatives: 2-formylbenzoate (2FBA) and 2-benzoylbenzoate (2BBA). The nascent product anions are transferred to a cryogenic ion trap where they are cooled to ∼15 K and analyzed by their pattern of vibrational bands obtained with IR photodissociation spectroscopy of weakly bound H2 molecules. The structures of the quenched species are then determined by comparison of these spectra with those predicted by electronic structure calculations for local minima on the potential energy surface. The 2-phenide carbanion generated by decarboxylation of 2FBA occurs in two isomeric forms that differ in the orientation of the formyl group, both of which yield a very large (∼110 cm-1) redshift in the stretching frequency of the H2 molecule attached to the anionic carbon center. Although calculated to be a local minimum, the analogous 2-phenide species could not be isolated upon decarboxylation of 2BBA. Rather, the anionic product adopts a ring-closed structure, indicating efficient nucleophilic attack on the pendant phenyl group by the nascent phenide. The barrier for ring closing is evaluated with electronic structure calculations.