Method development for pharmaceutics: some solutions for tuning selectivity in reversed phase and hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography.

In LC method development, the choice of suitable experimental conditions is often challenging for the analyst because of the huge diversity of stationary phases, mobile phase pH and organic modifiers, that could significantly alter the selectivity. The influence of these parameters on selectivity was experimentally tested in both RPLC and HILIC conditions for the analysis of 45 pharmaceutical compounds covering a wide range of physico-chemical properties. Principal component analysis (PCA) models were built to assess the resulting multivariate dataset. The complementarity between RPLC and HILIC was clearly demonstrated. The importance of mobile phase pH as one of the main experimental factors to be considered was confirmed. The RPLC and HILIC methods were thus employed for the analysis of a drug cocktail containing two substrates and their numerous desmethylated metabolites. All the compounds were finally resolved in both modes, with a very distinct elution order. In addition, the possibility to combine columns of different selectivity was highlighted using a column coupler set-up and found to be extremely promising. The same type of experiments was also carried out for the impurity profiling of an antihistaminic drug. In this example, compounds of very distinct polarity were satisfactorily eluted in both RPLC and HILIC modes, using suitable conditions of pH and stationary phase. In conclusion, this study demonstrates the complementary and interest of RPLC and HILIC in the case of pharmaceutical method development.

Evaluation of columns packed with shell particles with compounds of pharmaceutical interest.

The commercial C18 columns packed with sub-3 µm shell particles were tested and compared to a reference UHPLC column, in terms of kinetic performance as well as selectivity, retention capability, peak shape and loading capacity. For this purpose, a set of pharmaceutically relevant molecules was selected, including acidic, neutral and basic drugs. Regarding kinetic performance, h(opt) values for the shell particles were found between 1.7 and 2, while the UHPLC column provided a value of approximately 2.5. However, this impressive performance should be considered with caution, particularly for the construction of kinetic plots since h(opt) values were sometimes related to the column dimensions, depending on the provider (h(opt) comprised between 1.8 and 2.6 for longer columns of 150 mm packed with shell particles). Despite the non-porous inner core of the shell particles representing between 25 and 36% of the particle, we demonstrated that the decrease in retention was on the maximum equal to 15% for Ascentis column while Acquity and Poroshell were strictly equivalent in terms of retention. Concerning loading capacity, it remains comparable to that of fully porous sub-2 µm particles and always more pronounced with 0.1% formic acid vs. phosphate buffer. The loading capacity of the different columns was found to be better correlated to the pore volume or surface coverage than the shell thickness. Experimentally, the most pronounced overloading was observed with the Poroshell. Finally, the selectivity and peak shape were evaluated using a mixture of basic and acidic drugs. It appears that results were very similar between sub-3 µm shell particles and fully porous sub-2-µm particles for our mixture of compounds, showing the ability to transfer existing methods to shell particles, with only limited adjustments. This study confirms the potential of columns packed with shell particles and demonstrates the interest of such column technology with pharmaceutical compounds.

A systematic investigation of the effect of sample diluent on peak shape in hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography.

The aim of this study was to evaluate the importance of sample diluents to improve peak shapes in hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC), using low molecular weight (<1000 Da) analytes as well as peptides (with MW ranging between 1000 and 6000 Da) as model compounds. Various solvents were tested including water, acetonitrile, methanol, ethanol, propan-2-ol, dimethyl sulfoxide, and a number of combinations of them. For the analysis of small MW compounds, best peak shapes were obtained with sample dissolved in pure ACN but, IPA or a mixture of ACN/IPA (50:50, v/v) could represent a viable alternative in the case of solubility issues with pure ACN. For drug discovery applications, DMSO can be employed but in combination with at least 80% of ACN. For peptides analysis, acetonitrile, EtOH and IPA as sample diluents, provided similar chromatographic profiles, but pure EtOH or IPA were recommended to limit denaturation and samples solubility issues. Finally, whatever the nature of the compounds, it is recommended to add the lowest amount of water to the sample diluent, to maintain suitable peak shapes.

Comparison of columns packed with porous sub-2 microm particles and superficially porous sub-3 microm particles for peptide analysis at ambient and high temperature.

The objective of this study was to evaluate various chromatographic approaches for peptide analysis. Initially, the ultra-HPLC (UHPLC) strategy, which consists of using columns packed with sub-2 microm particles at a maximal pressure of 1000 bar, was tested. To limit the backpressure generated by small particles, columns packed with superficially porous sub-3 microm particles (fused-core technology) that should theoretically improve mass transfer, particularly beneficial for large biomolecules, were investigated. To evaluate these claims, kinetic plots were constructed in both isocratic and gradient modes at ambient and elevated temperature (up to 90 degrees C). For peptide analysis, both UHPLC and fused-core technologies showed a significant gain in peak capacity when compared with conventional HPLC using 5 mum particles and monolithic supports. Additionally, it has been shown that high temperature was of utmost interest to further improve kinetic performance and peak shape due to the improvement of secondary interaction kinetics. Finally, the best conditions developed for UHPLC using the gradient kinetic plot methodology were applied to the analysis of a complex tryptic digest of various proteins. The expected and experimental peak capacity values obtained were similar. In addition, the resolving power of UHPLC at 60 degrees C was appropriate for resolving complex mixtures of peptides.

New trends in fast and high-resolution liquid chromatography: a critical comparison of existing approaches.

Recent developments in chromatographic supports and instrumentation for liquid chromatography (LC) are enabling rapid and highly efficient separations. Various analytical strategies have been proposed, for example the use of silica-based monolithic supports, elevated mobile phase temperatures, and columns packed with sub-3 microm superficially porous particles (fused core) or with sub-2 microm porous particles for use in ultra-high-pressure LC (UHPLC). The purpose of this review is to describe and compare these approaches in terms of throughput and resolving power, using kinetic data gathered for compounds with molecular weights ranging between 200 and 1300 g mol(-1) in isocratic and gradient modes. This study demonstrates that the best analytical strategy should be selected on the basis of the analytical problem (e.g., isocratic vs. gradient, throughput vs. efficiency) and the properties of the analyte. UHPLC and fused-core technologies are quite promising for small-molecular-weight compounds, but increasing the mobile phase temperature is useful for larger molecules, for example peptides.

Noncompetitive fluorescence polarization aptamer-based assay for small molecule detection.

In this paper, a new fluorescence polarization (FP) assay strategy is described reporting the first demonstration of a noncompetitive FP technique dedicated to the small molecule sensing. This approach was based on the unique induced-fit binding mechanism of nucleic acid aptamers which was exploited to convert the small target binding event into a detectable fluorescence anisotropy signal. An anti-L-tyrosinamide DNA aptamer, labeled by a single fluorescent dye at its extremity, was employed as a model functional nucleic acid probe. The DNA conformational change generated by the L-tyrosinamide binding was able to induce a significant increase in the fluorescence anisotropy signal. The method allowed enantioselective sensing of tyrosinamide and analysis in practical samples. The methodology was also applied to the L-argininamide detection, suggesting the potential generalizability of the direct FP-based strategy. Such aptamer-based assay appeared to be a sensitive analytical system of remarkable simplicity and ease of use.

Aptamer-modified micellar electrokinetic chromatography for the enantioseparation of nucleotides.

In this paper, a new aptamer-based capillary electrophoresis (CE) method, which was able to separate the enantiomers of an anionic target (adenosine monophosphate, AMP) displaying the same electrophoretic mobility as that of the oligonucleotidic chiral selector, is reported. The design of the aptamer-modified micellar electrokinetic chromatography (MEKC) mode consisted of nonionic micelles which acted as a pseudostationary phase and a hydrophobic cholesteryl group-tagged aptamer (Chol-Apt) which partitioned into the uncharged micellar phase. Under partial-filling format and suppressed electroosmotic flow conditions, the strong mobility alteration of Chol-Apt permitted AMP enantiomers to pass through the micelle-anchored aptamer zone and promoted the target enantioseparation. The influence of several electrophoretic parameters (such as concentration and nature of the nonionic surfactant, preincubation of the Chol-Apt and surfactant, capillary temperature, and applied voltage) on the AMP enantiomer migration was investigated in order to define the utilization conditions of the aptamer-modified MEKC mode. The chiral resolution, in a single run, of three adenine nucleotides, i.e., AMP, ADP (adenosine diphosphate), and ATP (adenosine triphosphate), was further accomplished using such methodology. This approach demonstrates the possibility to extend the CE applicability of aptamer chiral selectors to potentially any target, without restriction on its charge-to-mass ratio.

Competitive affinity capillary electrophoresis assay based on a "hybrid" pre-incubation/on-capillary mixing format using an enantioselective aptamer as affinity ligand.

In this paper, we describe an aptamer-based competitive affinity CE (ACE) assay involving (i) the pre-incubation of the target (D-arginine) and the specific ligand (anti-D-arginine-L-RNA aptamer) before (ii) the competition with the labeled target (dansylated D-arginine) through an on-capillary mixing strategy. The effects of some critical operating parameters such as the applied voltage and the sample-aptamer mixture plug length on the assay sensitivity were investigated. The ACE assay appeared particularly dependent on the plug length of the pre-incubated sample-aptamer solution. It was shown that this "hybrid" strategy significantly improved the assay sensitivity relative to that obtained with a "full" on-capillary mixing approach.

Covalently bonded DNA aptamer chiral stationary phase for the chromatographic resolution of adenosine.

In this work, a target-specific aptamer chiral stationary phase (CSP) based on the oligonucleotidic selector binding to silica particles through a covalent linkage was developed. An anti-D-adenosine aptamer was coupled, using an in-situ method, by way of an amide bond to macroporous carboxylic acid based silica. Frontal chromatography analysis was performed to evaluate the column properties, i.e., determination of the stationary phase binding capacity and the dissociation constant of the target-immobilized aptamer complex. It was found that such covalent immobilization was able to maintain the aptamer binding properties at a convenient level for an efficient enantioseparation. Subsequently, the separation of adenosine enantiomers was investigated under different operating conditions, including changes in the eluent's ionic strength and the proportion of organic modifiers as well as column temperatures. It was demonstrated that, under various conditions of use and storage, the present CSP was stable over time.

Aptamer-based enantioselective competitive binding assay for the trace enantiomer detection.

The development of highly enantioselective assays and sensors has received much attention for the determination of enantiomeric impurities at a low level. For chiral compounds, the efficient monitoring of the in selection procedure has allowed the isolation of nucleic acid aptamers which are able to strongly discriminate the target enantiomers. In this paper, we demonstrated for the first time that an aptamer can be successfully used to design a highly enantioselective tool for the trace enantiomer detection. The aptamer-based stereoselective assay was developed using an affinity capillary electrophoresis-based competitive, homogeneous format and an on-capillary mixing approach. Detection of as low as 0.01% of the minor enantiomer in a nonracemic mixture can be achieved, in a short analysis time (<5 min).

Chiral resolution of histidine using an anti-D-histidine L-RNA aptamer microbore column.

In this paper, we report a new anti-amino acid aptamer chiral stationary phase (CSP). The enantiomers of histidine were separated using an immobilized histidine-specific L-RNA aptamer (40-mer) and an aqueous buffer as mobile phase. The effects of the variation of different operating parameters, including the mobile phase pH and the MgCl2 concentration as well as the column temperature, on the solute retention were assessed. The results suggested that (i) the protonated form of histidine was involved in the stereospecific RNA binding and (ii) Mg2+ was essential for the target enantiomer binding to the specific aptamer sites. From a practical point of view, it appeared that the baseline resolution in a minimum analysis time can be achieved at a column temperature of 35 degrees C for an eluent containing 10 mM of MgCl2, pH 5.5.

Enantiomeric separation using an l-RNA aptamer as chiral additive in partial-filling capillary electrophoresis.

In this paper, we report the chiral resolution of arginine using an anti-arginine l-RNA aptamer chiral selector in partial-filling CE. The effects of the capillary temperature, sample load, and aptamer plug length on the enantiomeric separation were assessed. Very high chiral resolving capability was observed at low or moderate capillary temperatures (the target peak being not detected in the separation window), whereas the practical chiral resolution was achieved only at high enough temperatures (50-60 degrees C). Over this high-temperature range, the electrophoretic behavior of the target enantiomer appeared to result from a combination of binding site heterogeneity, slow desorption kinetics, and concentration overload of aptamer binding sites. From additional thermal UV melting experiments, three RNA conformations were identified for the 50-60 degrees C temperatures. It was suggested that the presence of these different RNA conformations was a plausible source of the binding site heterogeneity.