ABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE: Beryllium mine and ore extraction mill workers have low rates of beryllium sensitization and chronic beryllium disease relative to the level of beryllium exposure. The objective was to relate these rates to the solubility and composition of the mine and mill materials. METHOD: Medical surveillance and exposure data were summarized. Dissolution of BeO, ore materials and beryllium hydroxide, Be(OH)(2) was measured in synthetic lung fluid. RESULT: The ore materials were more soluble than BeO at pH 7.2 and similar at pH 4.5. Be(OH)(2) was more soluble than BeO at both pH. Aluminum dissolved along with beryllium from ore materials. CONCLUSION: Higher solubility of beryllium ore materials and Be(OH)(2) at pH 7.2 might shorten particle longevity in the lung. The aluminum content of the ore materials might inhibit the cellular immune response to beryllium.
Subject(s)
Air Pollutants, Occupational/chemistry , Berylliosis/etiology , Beryllium/chemistry , Hypersensitivity/etiology , Mining , Occupational Diseases/etiology , Occupational Exposure/adverse effects , Solubility , Air Pollutants, Occupational/adverse effects , Air Pollutants, Occupational/immunology , Aluminum Silicates/adverse effects , Aluminum Silicates/chemistry , Aluminum Silicates/immunology , Beryllium/adverse effects , Beryllium/immunology , Cell Proliferation , Cells, Cultured , Humans , Lymphocytes/drug effects , Risk FactorsABSTRACT
Various Be-containing micro-particle suspensions were equilibrated with simulated lung fluid (SLF) to examine their dissolution behavior as well as the potential generation of nanoparticles. The motivation for this study was to explore the relationship between dissolution/particle generation behaviors of Be-containing materials relevant to Be-ore processing, and their epidemiologically indicated inhalation toxicities. Limited data suggest that BeO is associated with higher rates of beryllium sensitization (BS) and chronic beryllium disease (CBD) relative to the other five relevant materials studied: bertrandite-containing ore, beryl-containing ore, frit (a processing intermediate), Be(OH)2 (a processing intermediate), and silica (control). These materials were equilibrated with SLF at two pH values (4.5 and 7.2) to reflect inter- and intra-cellular environments in lung tissue. Concentrations of Be, Al, and Si in SLF increased linearly during the first 20 days of equilibration, and then rose slowly, or in some cases reached a maximum, and subsequently decreased. Relative to the other materials, BeO produced relatively low Be concentration in solution at pH 7.2; and relatively high Be concentration in solution at pH 4.5 during the first 20 days of equilibration. For both pH values, however, the Be concentration in SLF normalized to Be content of the material was lowest for BeO, demonstrating that BeO was distinct among the four other Be-containing materials in terms of its persistence as a source of Be to the SLF solution. Following 149 days of equilibration, the SLF solutions were fractionated using flow-field flow fractionation (FlFFF) with detection via ICP-MS. For all materials, nanoparticles (which were formed during equilibration) were dominantly distributed in the 10-100 nm size range. Notably, BeO produced the least nanoparticle-associated Be mass (other than silica) at both pH values. Furthermore, BeO produced the highest Be concentrations in the size range corresponding to < 3 kDa (determined via centrifugal ultrafiltration), indicating that in addition to persistence, the BeO produced the highest concentrations of truly dissolved (potentially ionic) Be relative to the other materials. Mass balance analysis showed reasonable sample recoveries during FFF fractionation (50-100%), whereas recoveries during ICP-MS (relative to acidified standards) were much lower (5-10%), likely due to inefficiencies in nebulizing and ionizing the nanoparticles.
