Genetic confounds of transgenerational epigenetic inheritance in mice.

Transgenerational epigenetic inheritance in mammals remains a controversial phenomenon. A recent study by Takahashi et al. provides evidence for this mode of inheritance in mice by using a CRISPR/Cas9-based epigenetic editing technique to modify DNA methylation levels at specific promoters and then demonstrating the inheritance of the gain in methylation in offspring. In this technical commentary, we argue that the method used in the original study inherently amplifies the likelihood of genetic changes that thereafter lead to the heritability of epigenetic changes. We provide evidence that genetic changes from multiple sources do indeed occur in these experiments and explore several avenues by which these changes could be causal to the apparent inheritance of epigenetic changes. We conclude a genetic basis of inheritance cannot be ruled out and thus transgenerational epigenetic inheritance has not been adequately established by the original study.

Methyl-CpG binding domain 2 (Mbd2) is an epigenetic regulator of autism-risk genes and cognition.

The Methyl-CpG-Binding Domain Protein family has been implicated in neurodevelopmental disorders. The Methyl-CpG-binding domain 2 (Mbd2) binds methylated DNA and was shown to play an important role in cancer and immunity. Some evidence linked this protein to neurodevelopment. However, its exact role in neurodevelopment and brain function is mostly unknown. Here we show that Mbd2-deficiency in mice (Mbd2-/-) results in deficits in cognitive, social and emotional functions. Mbd2 binds regulatory DNA regions of neuronal genes in the hippocampus and loss of Mbd2 alters the expression of hundreds of genes with a robust down-regulation of neuronal gene pathways. Further, a genome-wide DNA methylation analysis found an altered DNA methylation pattern in regulatory DNA regions of neuronal genes in Mbd2-/- mice. Differentially expressed genes significantly overlap with gene-expression changes observed in brains of Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) individuals. Notably, downregulated genes are significantly enriched for human ortholog ASD risk genes. Observed hippocampal morphological abnormalities were similar to those found in individuals with ASD and ASD rodent models. Hippocampal Mbd2 knockdown partially recapitulates the behavioral phenotypes observed in Mbd2-/- mice. These findings suggest that Mbd2 is a novel epigenetic regulator of genes that are associated with ASD in humans. Mbd2 loss causes behavioral alterations that resemble those found in ASD individuals.

Increasing Specificity of Targeted DNA Methylation Editing by Non-Enzymatic CRISPR/dCas9-Based Steric Hindrance.

As advances in genome engineering inch the technology towards wider clinical use-slowed by technical and ethical hurdles-a newer offshoot, termed "epigenome engineering", offers the ability to correct disease-causing changes in the DNA without changing its sequence and, thus, without some of the unfavorable correlates of doing so. In this review, we note some of the shortcomings of epigenetic editing technology-specifically the risks involved in the introduction of epigenetic enzymes-and highlight an alternative epigenetic editing strategy using physical occlusion to modify epigenetic marks at target sites without a requirement for any epigenetic enzyme. This may prove to be a safer alternative for more specific epigenetic editing.

The PROTECTOR strategy employs dCas orthologs to sterically shield off-target sites from CRISPR/Cas activity.

Off-target mutagenesis of CRISPR/Cas systems must be solved to facilitate safe gene therapy. Here, we report a novel approach, termed "PROTECTOR", to shield known off-target sites by directing the binding of an orthologous nuclease-dead Cas protein to the off-target site to sterically interfere with Cas activity. We show that this method reduces off-target mutation rates of two well-studied guide RNAs without compromising on-target activity and that it can be used in combination with high-fidelity Cas enzymes to further reduce off-target editing. This expands the suite of off-target mitigation strategies and offers an ability to protect off-target sites even when their sequences are fully identical to target sites.

Enzyme-free targeted DNA demethylation using CRISPR-dCas9-based steric hindrance to identify DNA methylation marks causal to altered gene expression.

DNA methylation involves the enzymatic addition of a methyl group primarily to cytosine residues in DNA. This protocol describes how to produce complete and minimally confounded DNA demethylation of specific sites in the genome of cultured cells by clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR)-dCas9 and without the involvement of an epigenetic-modifying enzyme, the purpose of which is the evaluation of the functional (i.e., gene expression or phenotypic) consequences of DNA demethylation of specific sites that have been previously implicated in particular pathological or physiological contexts. This protocol maximizes the ability of the easily reprogrammable CRISPR-dCas9 system to assess the impact of DNA methylation from a causal rather than correlational perspective: alternative protocols for CRISPR-dCas9-based site-specific DNA methylation or demethylation rely on the recruitment of epigenetic enzymes that exhibit additional nonspecific activities at both the targeted site and throughout the genome, confounding conclusions of causality of DNA methylation. Inhibition or loss of DNA methylation is accomplished by three consecutive lentiviral transductions. The first two lentiviruses establish stable expression of dCas9 and a guide RNA, which will physically obstruct either maintenance or de novo DNA methyltransferase activity at the guide RNA target site. A third lentivirus introduces Cre recombinase to delete the dCas9 transgene, which leads to loss of dCas9 from the target site, allowing transcription factors and/or the transcription machinery to interact with the demethylated target site. This protocol requires 3-8 months to complete owing to prolonged cell passaging times, but there is little hands-on time, and no specific skills beyond basic molecular biology techniques are necessary.

Unraveling the functional role of DNA demethylation at specific promoters by targeted steric blockage of DNA methyltransferase with CRISPR/dCas9.

Despite four decades of research to support the association between DNA methylation and gene expression, the causality of this relationship remains unresolved. Here, we reaffirm that experimental confounds preclude resolution of this question with existing strategies, including recently developed CRISPR/dCas9 and TET-based epigenetic editors. Instead, we demonstrate a highly effective method using only nuclease-dead Cas9 and guide RNA to physically block DNA methylation at specific targets in the absence of a confounding flexibly-tethered enzyme, thereby enabling the examination of the role of DNA demethylation per se in living cells, with no evidence of off-target activity. Using this method, we probe a small number of inducible promoters and find the effect of DNA demethylation to be small, while demethylation of CpG-rich FMR1 produces larger changes in gene expression. This method could be used to reveal the extent and nature of the contribution of DNA methylation to gene regulation.

Transcriptome Sequencing Reveals Candidate NF-κB Target Genes Involved in Repeated Cocaine Administration.

Background: Drug-induced alterations in gene expression play an important role in the development of addictive behavior. Numerous transcription factors have been implicated in mediating the gene expression changes that occur in drug addiction. Nuclear factor kappa B is an inducible transcription factor complex that is rapidly activated by diverse stimuli. Methods: We performed next-generation high-throughput sequencing of the prefrontal cortex in a mouse model of repeated cocaine administration combined with pharmacological nuclear factor kappa B inhibition to identify nuclear factor kappa B target genes that participate in the cocaine addiction process. Results: We found that the nuclear factor kappa B antagonist sodium diethyldithiocarbamate trihydrate significantly reversed the cocaine-induced expression changes of the amphetamine addiction pathway. Genes that demonstrated differential expression in response to cocaine treatment that was also reversed by sodium diethyldithiocarbamate trihydrate were enriched for the axon guidance pathway. Furthermore, the nuclear factor kappa B homo-dimer motif could be mapped to 86 of these sodium diethyldithiocarbamate trihydrate-reversed genes, which were also enriched for axon guidance. Conclusions: We suggest that nuclear factor kappa B directly modifies the expression of axon guidance pathway members, leading to cocaine sensitization. Our findings reveal the role of prefrontal cortex nuclear factor kappa B activity in addiction and uncover the molecular mechanisms by which nuclear factor kappa B drives changes in the addicted brain.

Genetic Polymorphisms in the ESR1 and VDR Genes Do Not Correlate With Osteoporosis in Patients With Familial Dysautonomia.

One of the major clinical manifestations of familial dysautonomia (FD)-a rare, neurodegenerative, autosomal-recessive disorder-is a high incidence and early onset of osteoporotic bone fractures. Early diagnosis is essential to initiate preventative therapy in at-risk patients and thus improve quality of life. However, the current lack of understanding of the complex relationship between FD and osteoporosis etiology precludes early diagnosis, and as such, accurate predictors of osteoporosis development in FD patients remain to be determined. It has been previously reported that a restriction fragment length polymorphism in the gene encoding the vitamin D receptor (VDR) and the number of thymine-adenine (TA) repeats in the gene encoding the estrogen receptor alpha (ESR1) may each be associated with determinants of bone mineral density and may thus predict the development of osteoporosis across a number of non-FD populations. In this study, we aimed to examine the correlation between osteoporosis and the presence of these genetic polymorphisms and to establish whether they could be used as predictive markers of osteoporosis development in the context of FD. The correlations between osteoporosis and either the BsmI restriction site polymorphism in VDR or the (TA)n repeat polymorphism in ESR1 were analyzed in 73 and 67 genotyped patients, respectively. Osteoporosis was defined as a bone mineral density greater than 2.5 (T-score) or greater than 2 (Z-score) standard deviations below the mean, as measured by dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry of the spine or hip. In both instances, no statistically significant difference in the frequency of polymorphism could be detected between FD patients with and without osteoporosis. Neither polymorphism can serve as a predictive marker for the development of osteoporosis in FD patients.

DNA methylation controls unmethylated transcription start sites in the genome in trans.

AIM: DNA methylation downregulates transcription. However, a large number of genes, which are unmethylated in the promoter region, are inactive. We tested the hypothesis that these genes are regulated by DNA methylation of upstream regulators. METHODS: We inhibited DNMT1 with 5-aza-2'-deoxycytidine or depleted it with shRNA to map the transcription initiation positions controlled by DNMT1 using ChIPseq with RNApolIIser5 antibody. Ingenuity pathway analysis identified potential methylated upstream regulators. Their functional role in controlling unmethylated promoters was determined by CRISPR/Cas9 gene editing. RESULTS: We show that a large group of unmethylated promoters is regulated by DNMT1 through DNA methylation dependent silencing of upstream regulators such as transcription factor HNF4A. CONCLUSION: The landscape of genes regulated by DNA methylation is more wide-ranging than genes downregulated by methylation of their own cis-regulatory sequences; regulation of unmethylated promoters is dependent on the methylation state of upstream trans regulators.