Genetic evidence for functional diversification of gram-negative intermembrane phospholipid transporters.

The outer membrane of gram-negative bacteria is a barrier to chemical and physical stress. Phospholipid transport between the inner and outer membranes has been an area of intense investigation and, in E. coli K-12, it has recently been shown to be mediated by YhdP, TamB, and YdbH, which are suggested to provide hydrophobic channels for phospholipid diffusion, with YhdP and TamB playing the major roles. However, YhdP and TamB have different phenotypes suggesting distinct functions. It remains unclear whether these functions are related to phospholipid metabolism. We investigated a synthetic cold sensitivity caused by deletion of fadR, a transcriptional regulator controlling fatty acid degradation and unsaturated fatty acid production, and yhdP, but not by ΔtamB ΔfadR or ΔydbH ΔfadR. Deletion of tamB recuses the ΔyhdP ΔfadR cold sensitivity further demonstrating the phenotype is related to functional diversification between these genes. The ΔyhdP ΔfadR strain shows a greater increase in cardiolipin upon transfer to the non-permissive temperature and genetically lowering cardiolipin levels can suppress cold sensitivity. These data also reveal a qualitative difference between cardiolipin synthases in E. coli, as deletion of clsA and clsC suppresses cold sensitivity but deletion of clsB does not. Moreover, increased fatty acid saturation is necessary for cold sensitivity and lowering this level genetically or through supplementation of oleic acid suppresses the cold sensitivity of the ΔyhdP ΔfadR strain. Together, our data clearly demonstrate that the diversification of function between YhdP and TamB is related to phospholipid metabolism. Although indirect regulatory effects are possible, we favor the parsimonious hypothesis that YhdP and TamB have differential phospholipid-substrate transport preferences. Thus, our data provide a potential mechanism for independent control of the phospholipid composition of the inner and outer membranes in response to changing conditions based on regulation of abundance or activity of YhdP and TamB.

The unusual substrate specificity of Escherichia coli cardiolipin synthase C does not require the product of the transcriptionally engaged ymdB gene.

Polycistronic transcription and translation of ymdB-clsC have been thought to be required for full activity of ClsC. The authentic initiation codon of the clsC gene is present within the open reading frame of the upstream located ymdB gene. ClsC translated from authentic initiation codon drives cardiolipin (CL) synthesis without transcriptionally paired YmdB. YmdB is not necessary for the substrate specificity of ClsC utilizing phosphatidylethanolamine (PE) as a co-substrate.

On the lipid dependence of bacterial mechanosensitive channel gating in situ.

For bacterial mechanosensitive channels acting as turgor-adjusting osmolyte release valves, membrane tension is the primary stimulus driving opening transitions. Because tension is transmitted through the surrounding lipid bilayer, it is possible that the presence or absence of different lipid species may influence the function of these channels. In this work, we characterize the lipid dependence of chromosome-encoded MscS and MscL in E. coli strains with genetically altered lipid composition. We use two previously generated strains that lack one or two major lipid species (PE, PG, or CL) and engineer a third strain that is highly enriched in CL due to the presence of hyperactive cardiolipin synthase ClsA. We characterize the functional behavior of these channels using patch-clamp and quantify the relative tension midpoints, closing rates, inactivation depth, and the rate of recovery back to the closed state. We also measure the osmotic survival of lipid-deficient strains, which characterizes the functional consequences of lipid-mediated channel function at the cell level. We find that the opening and closing behavior of MscS and MscL tolerate the absence of specific lipid species remarkably well. The lack of cardiolipin (CL), however, reduces the active MscS population relative to MscL and decreases the closing rate, slightly increasing the propensity of MscS toward inactivation and slowing the recovery process. The data points to the robustness of the osmolyte release system and the importance of cardiolipin for the adaptive behavior of MscS.

CdsA, a CDP-diacylglycerol synthase involved in phospholipid and glycolipid MPIase biosynthesis, possesses multiple initiation codons.

CdsA is a CDP-diacylglycerol synthase essential for phospholipid and glycolipid MPIase biosynthesis, and therefore for growth. The initiation codon of CdsA has been assigned as "TTG," while methionine at the 37th codon was reported to be an initiation codon in the original report. Since a vector containing the open reading frame starting with "TTG" under a controllable promoter complemented the cdsA knockout, "TTG" could function as an initiation codon. However, no evidence supporting that this "TTG" is the sole initiation codon has been reported. We determined the initiation codon by examining the ability of mutants around the N-terminal region to complement cdsA mutants. Even if the "TTG" was substituted with a stop codon, the clear complementation was observed. Moreover, the clones with multiple mutations of stop codons complemented the cdsA mutant up to the 37th codon, indicating that cdsA possesses multiple codons that can function as initiation codons. We constructed an experimental system in which the chromosomal expression of cdsA can be analyzed. By means of this system, we found that the cdsA mutant with substitution of "TTG" with a stop codon is fully functional. Thus, we concluded that CdsA contains multiple initiation codons.

Functional diversification of gram-negative intermembrane phospholipid transporters by intrinsic substrate preference.

The outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria is a barrier to chemical and physical stress. Phospholipid transport between the inner and outer membranes has been an area of intense investigation and, in E. coli K-12, it has recently been shown to be mediated by YhdP, TamB, and YdbH, which are suggested to provide hydrophobic channels for phospholipid diffusion, with YhdP and TamB playing the major roles. However, YhdP and TamB have different phenotypes suggesting distinct functions. We investigated these functions using synthetic cold sensitivity (at 30 °C) of a strain with deletion of yhdP, but not tamB or ydbH, and fadR, a transcriptional regulator controlling fatty acid degradation and unsaturated fatty acid production. Deletion of tamB, redirecting phospholipid transport to YdbH, suppresses the ΔyhdP ΔfadR cold sensitivity suggesting this phenotype is directly related to phospholipid transport. The ΔyhdP ΔfadR strain shows a greater increase in cardiolipin upon transfer to the non-permissive temperature and genetically lowering cardiolipin levels can suppress cold sensitivity. These data also reveal a qualitative difference between cardiolipin synthases in E. coli, as deletion of clsA and clsC suppresses cold sensitivity but deletion of clsB does not despite lower cardiolipin levels. In addition to increased cardiolipin, increased fatty acid saturation is necessary for cold sensitivity and lowering this level genetically or through supplementation of oleic acid suppresses the cold sensitivity of the ΔyhdP ΔfadR strain. A parsimonious explanation for our data is that YhdP and TamB have differential substrate transport preferences, most likely with YhdP preferentially transporting more saturated phospholipids and TamB preferentially transporting more unsaturated phospholipids. We envision cardiolipin contributing to this transport preference by sterically clogging TamB-mediated transport of saturated phospholipids. Thus, our data provide a potential mechanism for independent control of the phospholipid composition of the inner and outer membranes in response to changing conditions.

Coordinated upregulation of two CDP-diacylglycerol synthases, YnbB and CdsA, is essential for cell growth and membrane protein export in the cold.

YnbB is a paralogue of CdsA, a CDP-diacylglycerol synthase. While the cdsA gene is essential, the ynbB gene is dispensable. So far, no phenotype of ynbB knockout has been observed. We found that a ynbB knockout strain acquired cold-sensitivity on growth under CdsA-limited conditions. We found that MPIase, a glycolipid involved in protein export, is cold-upregulated to facilitate protein export in the cold, by increasing the mRNA levels of not only CdsA but also that of YnbB. Under non-permissive conditions, phospholipid biosynthesis proceeded normally, however, MPIase upregulation was inhibited with accumulation of precursors of membrane and secretory proteins such as M13 procoat and proOmpA, indicating that YnbB is dedicated to MPIase biosynthesis, complementing the CdsA function.

Interaction between glycolipid MPIase and proteinaceous factors during protein integration into the cytoplasmic membrane of E. coli.

Protein integration into biomembranes is an essential biological phenomenon common to all organisms. While various factors involved in protein integration, such as SRP, SecYEG and YidC, are proteinaceous, we identified a glycolipid named MPIase (Membrane Protein Integrase), which is present in the cytoplasmic membrane of E. coli. In vitro experiments using inverted membrane vesicles prepared from MPIase-depleted strains, and liposomes containing MPIase showed that MPIase is required for insertion of a subset of membrane proteins, which has been thought to be SecYEG-independent and YidC-dependent. Also, SecYEG-dependent substrate membrane proteins require MPIase in addition. Furthermore, MPIase is also essential for insertion of proteins with multiple negative charges, which requires both YidC and the proton motive force (PMF). MPIase directly interacts with SecYEG and YidC on the membrane. MPIase not only cooperates with these factors but also has a molecular chaperone-like function specific to the substrate membrane proteins through direct interaction with the glycan chain. Thus, MPIase catalyzes membrane insertion by accepting nascent membrane proteins on the membrane through its chaperone-like function, i.e., direct interaction with the substrate proteins, and then MPIase functionally interacts with SecYEG and YidC for substrate delivery, and acts with PMF to facilitate and complete membrane insertion when necessary. In this review, we will outline the mechanisms underlying membrane insertion catalyzed by MPIase, which cooperates with proteinaceous factors and PMF.

Interplay between MPIase, YidC, and PMF during Sec-independent insertion of membrane proteins.

Integral membrane proteins with the N-out topology are inserted into membranes usually in YidC- and PMF-dependent manners. The molecular basis of the various dependencies on insertion factors is not fully understood. A model protein, Pf3-Lep, is inserted independently of both YidC and PMF, whereas the V15D mutant requires both YidC and PMF in vivo. We analyzed the mechanisms that determine the insertion factor dependency in vitro. Glycolipid MPIase was required for insertion of both proteins because MPIase depletion caused a significant defect in insertion. On the other hand, YidC depletion and PMF dissipation had no effects on Pf3-Lep insertion, whereas V15D insertion was reduced. We reconstituted (proteo)liposomes containing MPIase, YidC, and/or F0F1-ATPase. MPIase was essential for insertion of both proteins. YidC and PMF stimulated Pf3-Lep insertion as the synthesis level increased. V15D insertion was stimulated by both YidC and PMF irrespective of the synthesis level. These results indicate that charges in the N-terminal region and the synthesis level are the determinants of YidC and PMF dependencies with the interplay between MPIase, YidC, and PMF.

Expression of Cds4/5 of Arabidopsis chloroplasts in E. coli reveals the membrane topology of the C-terminal region of CDP-diacylglycerol synthases.

CDP-diacylglycerol synthases (Cds) are conserved from bacteria to eukaryotes. Bacterial CdsA is involved not only in phospholipid biosynthesis but also in biosynthesis of glycolipid MPIase, an essential glycolipid that catalyzes membrane protein integration. We found that both Cds4 and Cds5 of Arabidopsis chloroplasts complement cdsA knockout by supporting both phospholipid and MPIase biosyntheses. Comparison of the sequences of CdsA and Cds4/5 suggests a difference in membrane topology at the C-termini, since the region assigned as the last transmembrane region of CdsA, which follows the conserved cytoplasmic domain, is missing in Cds4/5. Deletion of the C-terminal region abolished the function, indicating the importance of the region. Both 6 × His tag attachment to CdsA and substitution of the C-terminal 6 residues with 6 × His did not affect the function. These 6 × His tags were sensitive to protease added from the cytosolic side in vitro, indicating that this region is not a transmembrane one but forms a membrane-embedded reentrant loop. Thus, the C-terminal region of Cds homologues forms a reentrant loop, of which structure is important for the Cds function.

Biosynthesis of glycolipid MPIase (membrane protein integrase) is independent of the genes for ECA (enterobacterial common antigen).

MPIase (membrane protein integrase) is an essential glycolipid that drives protein integration into the inner membrane of E. coli, while glycolipid ECA (enterobacterial common antigen) is a major component at the surface of the outer membrane. Irrespective of the differences in molecular weight, subcellular localization and function in cells, the glycan chains of the two glycolipids are similar, since the repeating unit comprising the glycan chains is the same. A series of biosynthetic genes for ECA, including ones for the corresponding nucleotide sugars, have been identified and extensively characterized. In this study, we found that knockouts as to the respective genes for ECA biosynthesis can grow in the minimum medium with the normal expression level of MPIase, indicating that MPIase can be biosynthesized de novo without the utilization of any compounds generated through ECA biosynthesis. Conversely, ECA was expressed normally upon MPIase depletion. From these results, we conclude that the biosynthetic genes for MPIase and ECA are independent.

The bacterial protein YidC accelerates MPIase-dependent integration of membrane proteins.

Bacterial membrane proteins are integrated into membranes through the concerted activities of a series of integration factors, including membrane protein integrase (MPIase). However, how MPIase activity is complemented by other integration factors during membrane protein integration is incompletely understood. Here, using inverted inner-membrane vesicle and reconstituted (proteo)liposome preparations from Escherichia coli cells, along with membrane protein integration assays and the PURE system to produce membrane proteins, we found that anti-MPIase IgG inhibits the integration of both the Sec-independent substrate 3L-Pf3 coat and the Sec-dependent substrate MtlA into E. coli membrane vesicles. MPIase-depleted membrane vesicles lacked both 3L-Pf3 coat and MtlA integration, indicating that MPIase is involved in the integration of both proteins. We developed a reconstitution system in which disordered spontaneous integration was precluded, which revealed that SecYEG, YidC, or both, are not sufficient for Sec-dependent and -independent integration. Although YidC had no effect on MPIase-dependent integration of Sec-independent substrates in the conventional assay system, YidC significantly accelerated the integration when the substrate amounts were increased in our PURE system-based assay. Similar acceleration by YidC was observed for MtlA integration. YidC mutants with amino acid substitutions in the hydrophilic cavity inside the membrane were defective in the acceleration of the Sec-independent integration. Of note, MPIase was up-regulated upon YidC depletion. These results indicate that YidC accelerates the MPIase-dependent integration of membrane proteins, suggesting that MPIase and YidC function sequentially and cooperatively during the catalytic cycle of membrane protein integration.

Two-step induction of cdsA promoters leads to upregulation of the glycolipid MPIase at cold temperature.

Glycolipid MPIase, essential for membrane protein integration into the cytoplasmic membrane of Escherichia coli, is upregulated at cold temperatures. This upregulation is rapid and sustainable. CdsA, a CDP-diacylglycerol synthase, is a rate-limiting enzyme for MPIase biosynthesis. Upregulation of CdsA is responsible for the increase in the MPIase level at low temperature. Investigation of cdsA regulatory regions revealed at least two cold-inducible promoters, a cold-shock promoter that functions transiently and immediately in the cold, and one that is sustainable in the cold. The stability of the cdsA transcript was comparable with that of tufA, which is not cold-inducible. Thus, cdsA is induced through two-step cold-induction to maintain MPIase at a high level rapidly and sustainably in the cold.

Increased expression of the bacterial glycolipid MPIase is required for efficient protein translocation across membranes in cold conditions.

Protein integration into and translocation across biological membranes are vital events for organismal survival and are fundamentally conserved among many organisms. Membrane protein integrase (MPIase) is a glycolipid that drives membrane protein integration into the cytoplasmic membrane in Escherichia coli MPIase also stimulates protein translocation across the membrane, but how its expression is regulated is incompletely understood. In this study, we found that the expression level of MPIase significantly increases in the cold (<25 °C), whereas that of the SecYEG translocon does not. Using previously created gene-knockout E. coli strains, we also found that either the cdsA or ynbB gene, both encoding rate-limiting enzymes for MPIase biosynthesis, is responsible for the increase in the MPIase expression. Furthermore, using pulse-chase experiments and protein integration assays, we demonstrated that the increase in MPIase levels is important for efficient protein translocation, but not for protein integration. We conclude that MPIase expression is required to stimulate protein translocation in cold conditions and is controlled by cdsA and ynbB gene expression.

CdsA is involved in biosynthesis of glycolipid MPIase essential for membrane protein integration in vivo.

MPIase is a glycolipid that is involved in membrane protein integration. Despite evaluation of its functions in vitro, the lack of information on MPIase biosynthesis hampered verification of its involvement in vivo. In this study, we found that depletion of CdsA, a CDP-diacylglycerol synthase, caused not only a defect in phospholipid biosynthesis but also MPIase depletion with accumulation of the precursors of both membrane protein M13 coat protein and secretory protein OmpA. Yeast Tam41p, a mitochondrial CDP-diacylglycerol synthase, suppressed the defect in phospholipid biosynthesis, but restored neither MPIase biosynthesis, precursor processing, nor cell growth, indicating that MPIase is essential for membrane protein integration and therefore for cell growth. Consistently, we observed a severe defect in protein integration into MPIase-depleted membrane vesicles in vitro. Thus, the function of MPIase as a factor involved in protein integration was proven in vivo as well as in vitro. Moreover, Cds1p, a eukaryotic CdsA homologue, showed a potential for MPIase biosynthesis. From these results, we speculate the presence of a eukaryotic MPIase homologue.

YnbB is a CdsA paralogue dedicated to biosynthesis of glycolipid MPIase involved in membrane protein integration.

MPIase is a glycolipid involved in protein integration in E. coli. Recently, we identified CdsA, a CDP-diacylglycerol (CDP-DAG) synthase, as a biosynthetic enzyme for MPIase. YnbB is a CdsA paralogue with a highly homologous C-terminal half. Under CdsA-depleted conditions, YnbB overproduction restored MPIase expression, but not phospholipid biosynthesis. YnbB complemented the growth defect of the cdsA knockout when Tam41p, a mitochondrial CDP-DAG synthase, was co-expressed, suggesting that YnbB possesses sufficient activity for MPIase biosynthesis, but not for phospholipid biosynthesis. Consistently, a chimera consisting of the CdsA N-terminal half and the YnbB C-terminal half (CdsA-N-YnbB-C) complemented the cdsA knockout by itself, but a chimera consisting of the YnbB N-terminal half and the CdsA C-terminal half (YnbB-N-CdsA-C) required co-expression of Tam41p for the complementation. The biosynthetic rate for CDP-DAG in CdsA and CdsA-N-YnbB-C was much faster than that in YnbB and YnbB-N-CdsA-C, indicating that the N-terminal half of CdsA accelerates CDP-DAG biosynthesis to give the fast cell growth. Therefore, the role of YnbB seems to be as a backup for MPIase biosynthesis, suggesting that YnbB is dedicated to MPIase biosynthesis. A mutant with a high pH-sensitive CdsA8 was unable to grow even under permissive conditions when the ynbB gene was deleted, supporting its auxiliary role in the CdsA function.