Identification of protein binding partners of small molecules using label-free methods.

INTRODUCTION: Drug discovery efforts across the globe are chasing new drug targets and novel mechanisms of action. To support the identification of novel mechanisms of action, phenotype-based drug screening has significantly increased over the last decade. Along with the rise in phenotypic screening, methods and technologies that can help to identify drug targets of phenotypically screened 'hits' have also evolved significantly. AREAS COVERED: This article provides an overview of successful examples, limitations and advances in small-molecule target identification methodologies. Primarily, the methods are described, where small-molecules without derivatization are used as test-molecules for identifying their direct binding protein partners, the targets, in detail. A brief discussion of other affinity chromatography coupled mass-spectrometry based target identification methods are also presented for comparative appreciation of label-free methods. EXPERT OPINION: Label-free methods do not require (a) extensive structure activity analysis of phenotypically screened 'hits' and (b) preparation of tool compounds or target capturing probes for target identification. These methods are significantly shortening the time required for the identification and the downstream validation of targets and hence are gaining popularity as the method of choice for target identification.

Dynamics and mechanism of DNA repair in a biomimetic system: flavin-thymine dimer adduct.

To mimic photolyase for efficient repair of UV-damaged DNA, numerous biomimetic systems have been synthesized, but all show low repair efficiency. The molecular mechanism of this low-efficiency process is still poorly understood. Here we report our direct mapping of the repair processes of a flavin-thymine dimer adduct with femtosecond resolution. We followed the entire dynamic evolution and observed direct electron transfer (ET) from the excited flavin to the thymine dimer in 79 ps. We further observed two competitive pathways, productive dimer ring splitting within 435 ps and futile back-ET in 95 ps. Our observations reveal that the underlying mechanism for the low repair quantum yield of flavin-thymine dimer adducts is the short-lived excited flavin moiety and the fast dynamics of futile back-ET without repair.

Affinity-based chemoproteomics with small molecule-peptide conjugates.

In affinity-based chemoproteomics strategies, the direct immobilization of small bioactive probe molecules to a solid support may pose problems with respect to the preservation of the functional activity toward the target proteins. Typically, immobilized molecules on solid supports exhibit lower affinity for target proteins compared to the free parent molecule. This may lead to a failure to specifically capture the target proteins or to unacceptable losses during the washing steps. To circumvent these shortcomings, we have devised small molecule-peptide conjugates (SMPCs), which enable wide-ranging experimental strategies for the capturing of protein targets of small molecules from cells or tissues. With the possibilities of synthesizing peptides of tailored biochemical and biophysical properties, SMPCs enable the identification of protein targets of small molecules from cell-lysates and intact cells. Moreover, labeling of these conjugates with fluorophores can provide information on the cellular localization and distribution of the target.

Ultrafast solvation dynamics at binding and active sites of photolyases.

Dynamic solvation at binding and active sites is critical to protein recognition and enzyme catalysis. We report here the complete characterization of ultrafast solvation dynamics at the recognition site of photoantenna molecule and at the active site of cofactor/substrate in enzyme photolyase by examining femtosecond-resolved fluorescence dynamics and the entire emission spectra. With direct use of intrinsic antenna and cofactor chromophores, we observed the local environment relaxation on the time scales from a few picoseconds to nearly a nanosecond. Unlike conventional solvation where the Stokes shift is apparent, we observed obvious spectral shape changes with the minor, small, and large spectral shifts in three function sites. These emission profile changes directly reflect the modulation of chromophore's excited states by locally constrained protein and trapped-water collective motions. Such heterogeneous dynamics continuously tune local configurations to optimize photolyase's function through resonance energy transfer from the antenna to the cofactor for energy efficiency and then electron transfer between the cofactor and the substrate for repair of damaged DNA. Such unusual solvation and synergetic dynamics should be general in function sites of proteins.

Capture of drug targets from live cells using a multipurpose immuno-chemo-proteomics tool.

Recently we have described the development of an Immuno-chemo-proteomics method for drug target deconvolution and profiling the toxicity of known drugs ( Saxena , C. ; Zhen , E. ; Higgs , R. E. ; Hale , J. E. J. Proteome Res. 2008, 8 , 3490 - 3497 ). The orthogonal nature and advantage of the newly developed method over existing ones were presented. Most commonly, a small molecule was coupled to an epitope and used as an affinity probe to bind targets and later antibody against the epitope was used to isolate the probe-protein complex. However, such studies performed using cell lysates are prone to false positive identification because the protein source is not in its native physiological condition. Here we describe the development and application of a multipurpose soluble probe where a small molecule was coupled to a fluorophore-tagged cell-permeable peptide epitope, which was used to affinity isolate binding proteins from live cells. Fluorophore coupling allowed direct visualization of the compound in the cells, and cell permeability of the probe provided opportunity to capture the targets from the live cell. The GSK3-beta inhibitor Bisindolylmaleimide-III was coupled to a peptide containing the fluorescein-tagged TAT epitope. Following incubation with the live cells, the compound and associated proteins were affinity isolated using antifluorescein antibody beads. Using this approach, we captured the known Bisindolylmaleimide-III target GSK3-beta and previously unidentified targets from live cells. Dose-dependent inhibition of target binding to probe in the presence of uncoupled compound validated the approach. This method was directly compared with the one where cell lysate was used as the protein source providing an advanced strategy to aid in target deconvolution and help to eliminate false positives originating from non-native protein source.

Small-molecule affinity chromatography coupled mass spectrometry for drug target deconvolution.

BACKGROUND: Current drug discovery organizations have renewed interest in phenotypic/function based screening for the identification of novel small-molecule drug candidates. Phenotypic screening faces the challenge of deconvoluting the identity of molecular targets of small-molecules through which they exert their biological effect. The identity of the target is crucial for understanding the mechanism of drug action, rational drug design, interpretation of any toxicological findings and patient stratification. Several methods are available to deconvolute the targets of small-molecules. OBJECTIVE: This review describes successful examples, limitations and advances of drug target deconvolution using small-molecule affinity chromatography coupled mass spectrometry based methods. A brief discussion of other target deconvolution methods is also presented for comparative appreciation of mass spectrometry based methods. CONCLUSION: The use of small-molecule affinity chromatography coupled mass spectrometry based methods is gaining popularity as a technique for target identification. Mass spectrometry based methods provide fast, reliable and high-content information on the target. They can be used with relatively intact biological systems to develop a system-wide understanding of the drug-target interaction.

Ultrafast dynamics of flavins in five redox states.

We report here our systematic studies of excited-state dynamics of two common flavin molecules, FMN and FAD, in five redox states--oxidized form, neutral and anionic semiquinones, and neutral and anionic fully reduced hydroquinones--in solution and in inert protein environments with femtosecond resolution. Using protein environments, we were able to stabilize two semiquinone radicals and thus observed their weak emission spectra. Significantly, we observed a strong correlation between their excited-state dynamics and the planarity of their flavin isoalloxazine ring. For a bent ring structure, we observed ultrafast dynamics from a few to hundreds of picoseconds and strong excitation-wavelength dependence of emission spectra, indicating deactivation during relaxation. A butterfly bending motion is invoked to get access to conical intersection(s) to facilitate deactivation. These states include the anionic semiquinone radical and fully reduced neutral and anionic hydroquinones in solution. In a planar configuration, flavins have a long lifetime of nanoseconds, except for the stacked conformation of FAD, where intramolecular electron transfer between the ring and the adenine moiety in 5-9 ps as well as subsequent charge recombination in 30-40 ps were observed. These observed distinct dynamics, controlled by the flavin ring flexibility, are fundamental to flavoenzyme's functions, as observed in photolyase with a planar structure to lengthen the lifetime to maximize DNA repair efficiency and in insect type 1 cryptochrome with a flexible structure to vary the excited-state deactivation to modulate the functional channel.

An immuno-chemo-proteomics method for drug target deconvolution.

Chemical proteomics is an emerging technique for drug target deconvolution and profiling the toxicity of known drugs. With the use of this technique, the specificity of a small molecule inhibitor toward its potential targets can be characterized and information thus obtained can be used in optimizing lead compounds. Most commonly, small molecules are immobilized on solid supports and used as affinity chromatography resins to bind targets. However, it is difficult to evaluate the effect of immobilization on the affinity of the compounds to their targets. Here, we describe the development and application of a soluble probe where a small molecule was coupled with a peptide epitope which was used to affinity isolate binding proteins from cell lysate. The soluble probe allowed direct verification that the compound after coupling with peptide epitope retained its binding characteristics. The PKC-alpha inhibitor Bisindolylmaleimide-III was coupled with a peptide containing the FLAG epitope. Following incubation with cellular lysates, the compound and associated proteins were affinity isolated using anti-FLAG antibody beads. Using this approach, we identified the known Bisindolylmaleimide-III targets, PKC-alpha, GSK3-beta, CaMKII, adenosine kinase, CDK2, and quinine reductase type 2, as well as previously unidentified targets PKAC-alpha, prohibitin, VDAC and heme binding proteins. This method was directly compared to the solid-phase method (small molecule was immobilized to a solid support) providing an orthogonal strategy to aid in target deconvolution and help to eliminate false positives originating from nonspecific binding of the proteins to the matrix.

Femtochemistry in enzyme catalysis: DNA photolyase.

Photolyase uses light energy to split UV-induced cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers in damaged DNA. This photoenzyme encompasses a series of elementary dynamical processes during repair function from early photoinitiation by a photoantenna molecule to enhance repair efficiency, to in vitro photoreduction through aromatic residues to reconvert the cofactor to the active form, and to final photorepair to fix damaged DNA. The corresponding series of dynamics include resonance energy transfer, intraprotein electron transfer, and intermolecular electron transfer, bond breaking-making rearrangements and back electron return, respectively. We review here our recent direct studies of these dynamical processes in real time, which showed that all these elementary reactions in the enzyme occur within subnanosecond timescale. Active-site solvation was observed to play a critical role in the continuous modulation of catalytic reactions. As a model system for enzyme catalysis, we isolated the enzyme-substrate complex in the transition-state region and mapped out the entire evolution of unmasked catalytic reactions of DNA repair. These observed synergistic motions in the active site reveal a perfect correlation of structural integrity and dynamical locality to ensure maximum repair efficiency on the ultrafast time scale.

Direct observation of thymine dimer repair in DNA by photolyase.

Photolyase uses light energy to split UV-induced cyclobutane dimers in damaged DNA, but its molecular mechanism has never been directly revealed. Here, we report the direct mapping of catalytic processes through femtosecond synchronization of the enzymatic dynamics with the repair function. We observed direct electron transfer from the excited flavin cofactor to the dimer in 170 ps and back electron transfer from the repaired thymines in 560 ps. Both reactions are strongly modulated by active-site solvation to achieve maximum repair efficiency. These results show that the photocycle of DNA repair by photolyase is through a radical mechanism and completed on subnanosecond time scale at the dynamic active site, with no net change in the redox state of the flavin cofactor.

Ultrafast dynamics of resonance energy transfer in cryptochrome.

In this communication, we report the ultrafast dynamics of resonance energy transfer in a blue-light photoreceptor, Vibrio cholerae cryptochrome. The transfer was observed to occur in 60 ps. We also studied the local rigidity and solvation around the binding site of the photoantenna molecule. The results for the first time show energy transfer in cryptochrome suggesting some mechanistic similarities between photolyase that repairs damaged DNA and cryptochrome that mediates blue-light signaling.

Femtosecond dynamics of flavin cofactor in DNA photolyase: radical reduction, local solvation, and charge recombination.

We report here our femtosecond studies of the photoreduction dynamics of the neutral radical flavin (FADH) cofactor in E. coli photolyase, a process converting the inactive form to the biologically active one, a fully reduced deprotonated flavin FADH(-). The observed temporal absorption evolution revealed two initial electron-transfer reactions, occurring in 11 and 42 ps with the neighboring aromatic residues of W382 and F366, respectively. The new transient absorption, observed at 550 nm previously in photolyase, was found from the excited-state neutral radical and is probably caused by strong interactions with the adenine moiety through the flavin U-shaped configuration and the highly polar/charged surrounding residues. The solvation dynamics from the locally ordered water molecules in the active site was observed to occur in approximately 2 ps. These ultrafast ordered-water motions are critical to stabilizing the photoreduction product FADH(-) instantaneously to prevent fast charge recombination. The back electron-transfer reaction was found to occur in approximately 3 ns. This slow process, consistent with ultrafast stabilization of the catalytic cofactor, favors photoreduction in photolyase.