Farm level bio-economic modelling of aquatic animal disease and health interventions.

A farm level bio-economic model, for aquatic animal production, of the relationships between inputs (e.g. purchased animals), outputs (e.g. harvested animals) and gross margin (GM) was developed to assess ex-ante the economics of disease and animal health interventions. Feed costs were calculated from estimates of food conversion ratio (FCR), animals harvested and mortality. The model was applied to a typical grow-out rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) farm on Lake Titicaca, Peru and a typical shrimp (Paenus vannamei) farm in the Mekong Delta, Vietnam. The model was used in two analyses. Firstly, an approach to assess the burden of disease developed by the Global Burden of Animal Diseases (GBADs) project was adopted. Output under conditions of 'ideal health' was estimated by reducing mortality to zero and removing health costs. GM in both systems increased by approximately 25% when production was kept constant (and stocking rates reduced) and more than doubled if production was allowed to rise (and initial stocking increased). The increase in GM under conditions of ideal compared with current production provided an estimate of the maximum possible benefit from improved health management. Secondly, break-even analysis was used to assess the economics of vaccination against infectious pancreatic necrosis (IPN) vaccine (rainbow trout - RBT) and probiotics (shrimp). If initial stocking was kept constant, and production allowed to rise, break-even points for the intervention (when GM was the same with and without the intervention) were achieved when mortality was reduced by 16% in RBT fry and juvenile and 28% in shrimp. If production was kept constant and benefit realised by reduced initial stocking, the break-even point was achieved for i) vaccination of RBT when mortality in fry and juveniles was reduced by 39%, and ii) probiotics in shrimp production when there was a 15% reduction in mortality (nursery and grow-out), 10% increase in shrimp weight at harvest and 10% improvement in FCR. The results demonstrate how relatively simple models, parameterised with basic farm production data, can assess the burden of disease and quantify ex-ante the potential benefit of interventions. In the absence of trial data, these analyses support decision-making by farmers. The models can be adapted for many aquaculture systems. Farm level results can be extrapolated to estimate disease burden, and benefits of interventions, at regional or national level and thus support informed decision-making and allocation of resources to health management.

[Laboratory findings during the classic swine fever epidemic of 1997-1998]. / Laboratoriumbevindingen van de klassieke-varkenspest-epizoötie 1997-1998.

The results of the laboratory tests carried out by the Institute for Animal Science and Health (ID-Lelystad), the Netherlands, on samples collected during the Classical Swine Fever (CSF) epidemic 1997-1998 are summarized in this article. The relevance of the different laboratory tests and various samples collected on the eradication of CSF during an outbreak is evaluated.

[Foot-and-mouth disease of cattle is not a zoonosis]. / De runderziekte mond- en klauwzeer is geen zoönose.

In 1997 there was an outbreak of foot-and-mouth disease (FMD) among cattle in Turkey. People visiting that country were warned against importing animal products into the Netherlands. This had nothing to do with hazards to human health, as FMD virus is not a zoonotic virus, but with the risk of spread of the disease to livestock in the Netherlands, notably to cattle and pigs. A disease with similar clinical symptoms in pigs is swine vesicular disease (SVD), which is not a zoonosis either. FMD virus is an aphtovirus, SVD virus is an enterovirus. Hand-foot-and-mouth disease in humans is caused by other enteroviruses, i.e. Coxsackie virus and enterovirus 71.

[Immunobiology of bovine respiratory syncytial virus infections]. / Immunobiologie van pinkengriep.

This paper describes recent findings on the immunobiology of bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) infections. The pathobiology of alveolar macrophages and BRSV, and the immunological reaction of cattle to the virus after natural or experimental infection, or vaccination, were studied. Because in severe cases BRSV infection leads to lower respiratory tract disease, replication of BRSV in alveolar macrophages was studied. Alveolar macrophages, which are important aspecific defense cells in the lower respiratory tract, exhibited a high intrinsic resistance to BRSV. Furthermore, BRSV-infected alveolar macrophages produced significantly less nitric oxide (which has a bacteriocidal effect) than uninfected macrophages. The kinetics of antibody titres against the envelope protein G were different from those of antibody titres against the envelope protein F. For example, many animals that are reinfected do not possess antibodies against the G protein. After vaccination or after natural infection, antibody titres against the F and G protein, and against epitopes on the F protein, differed markedly, and also in animals with different MHC haplotypes. These findings may be related to differences in protection. The strains of BRSV that circulate in the Netherlands belong to the subgroups A and AB. There was no evidence for differences in virulence between these subgroups. BRSV could be detected in 30% of lungs obtained from calves suffering from severe lower respiratory tract disease. Based on cross-protection studies, calves that were infected with a virus from a particular BRSV subgroup were protected against reinfection with a virus from a different subgroup. A recombinant gE-protein negative bovine herpesvirus 1 vaccine carrying a gene encoding the G protein of BRSV, and a DNA vaccine encoding the same protein afforded protection after experimental challenge of calves. This offers the possibility to develop effective multivalent (gE-negative BHV1) marker vaccines in the future.

A bovine respiratory syncytial virus strain with mutations in subgroup-specific antigenic domains of the G protein induces partial heterologous protection in cattle.

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) strains are tentatively divided in subgroups A, AB and B, based on antigenic differences of the G protein. A Dutch BRSV strain (Waiboerhoeve: WBH), could not be assigned to one of the subgroups, because the strain did not react with any monoclonal antibody against the G protein. We describe here that the WBH strain has accumulated critical mutations in subgroup-specific domains of the G protein gene, which also occur but then independently in G protein genes of BRSV subgroup A or B strains. Although the comparison of nucleotide residues 256-792 of the G gene of the WBH strain with those of subgroup A and B strains showed that the G gene of the WBH strain is different from that of BRSV subgroup A and B strains, the sequence divergence was not more than observed within the G genes of human respiratory syncytial virus subgroup A or B strains. The WBH strain did not induce severe disease after experimental infection of calves, and induced partial protection against a heterologous challenge. Despite the dissimilarity of the conserved central regions of the G protein of the WBH strain and that of the challenge strain, a secondary antibody response against this region was induced in WBH-infected calves after challenge. We conclude that complete BRSV virus can partially protect against a BRSV infection with a strain that contains an antigenic dissimilar G protein.

Critical factors affecting the diagnostic reliability of enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay formats.

This paper aims to evaluate different formats of the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISAs) for detection of virus-specific antibodies and focuses on factors that may influence the diagnostic reliability of such tests. Newly developed and well-established ELISAs for detection of infections of bovine herpesvirus 1 (BHV1), bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV), classical swine fever virus (CSFV), pseudorabies virus (PRV) and bovine viral diarrhoea virus (BVDV) are used as examples. Differences between competitive and non-competitive ELISAs are described, with special reference to the influence of the antigen, the conjugated antibody and the test sample on the test results. Attention is drawn to interference, which may result in false positive or false negative test results, with special emphasis on the 'bridging' phenomenon. The use of monoclonal antibodies and discriminatory tests are briefly discussed. Diagnostic reliability is described for tests that are used in monitoring or eradication programmes, emphasising the consequences of false negative and false positive test results. Finally, reducing assay-time and functional quality control for such tests are discussed.

Comparison of DNA application methods to reduce BRSV shedding in cattle.

We compared the protection afforded by three different DNA application methods against bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) infection in cattle. A synthetic gene that codes for the G protein of BRSV was inserted into a eukaryotic vector and was used in the vaccine. Intradermal (i.d.) application with a needleless injector (NI), the Pigjet, reduced BRSV excretion significantly better after BRSV challenge than intramuscular (i.m.) or i.d. vaccination with a needle. Serum antibodies against the G protein were consistently the highest and showed less variation in Calves vaccinated with the NI compared with those in i.m. and i.d. vaccinated calves. After BRSV challenge, secondary serum and mucosal antibody responses were also the highest in NI vaccinated calves. We conclude that DNA application with the needleless injector is substantially better than i.m. or i.d. application, and is capable to prime the immune response at the respiratory mucosa.

Immunization of cattle with a BHV1 vector vaccine or a DNA vaccine both coding for the G protein of BRSV.

A gE-negative bovine herpesvirus 1 (BHV1) vector vaccine carrying a gene coding for the G protein of bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) (BHV1/BRSV-G) induced the same high degree of protection in calves against BRSV infection and BHV1 infection as a multivalent commercial vaccine. A DNA plasmid vaccine, carrying the same gene as the BHV1/BRSV-G vaccine, significantly reduced BRSV shedding after BRSV infection compared with that in control calves, but less well than the BHV1/BRSV-G vaccine. Flow cytometric analysis showed a significant relative increase of gamma/delta+ T cells in peripheral blood after BRSV challenge-infection of the calves of the control group but not in the vaccinated groups. These results indicate that the G protein of BRSV can induce significant protection against BRSV infection in cattle, and that the BHV1/BRSV-G vaccine protects effectively against a subsequent BRSV and BHV1 infection.

Antibody responses against epitopes on the F protein of bovine respiratory syncytial virus differ in infected or vaccinated cattle.

The fusion protein F of bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) is an important target for humoral and cellular immune responses, and antibodies against the F protein have been associated with protection. However, the F protein can induce antibodies with different biological activity, possibly related to distinct antigenic regions on the protein. Therefore, epitopes were mapped on the F protein using monoclonal antibodies. Two epitopes (A and B) were identified that induced neutralizing antibodies, and one epitope (C) that did not elicit neutralizing antibodies. Subsequently, antibody responses were analysed against these epitopes in cattle sera after natural infection, experimental infection or vaccination. After natural infection or reinfection, the antibody titres against epitope A were significantly higher than those against epitope B or C. After experimental infection and after vaccination with an inactivated vaccine, antibody titres against epitope B and C were significantly higher than after natural infection. Conversely, virus neutralizing antibody titres were significantly lower in these animals with higher antibody titres against epitopes B and C than in naturally infected cattle. Because after natural infection the epitope-specific-antibody titres against epitope A, B or C differed markedly between the cattle, the magnitude of the antibody titres against epitope A, B or C in relation to the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) genes of cattle (BoLA) was studied. The magnitude of the antibody responses against epitope A of the F protein, but not against the G protein, appeared to be associated with the bovine lymphocyte antigen (BoLA) haplotype.

Subgrouping of bovine respiratory syncytial virus strains detected in lung tissue.

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus is an important respiratory pathogen in cattle. Recently, subgroups of BRSV have been identified, based on antigenic differences. However, little is known about subgroups of BRSV that circulate in the cattle population. Therefore, we determined the reactivity of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs), directed against the G, F, or P protein of BRSV, with lung tissue from 47 calves, that suffered from severe respiratory disease. Fourteen animals (30%) proved to be infected with BRSV, because they all reacted with mAbs against the P or F protein, as detected by fluorescent antibody tests. Monoclonal antibodies against the G protein were able to discriminate between the BRSV-positive specimens: 7 strains were identified as subgroup A strains, and 5 strains as subgroup AB, which is introduced as BRSV subgroup in this paper. Two strains could not be identified unambiguously. It is concluded that BRSV subgroup A and AB were associated with severe respiratory disease, and that strains belonging to either subgroup circulated concurrently in the cattle population in the Netherlands.

Antibody responses against the G and F proteins of bovine respiratory syncytial virus after experimental and natural infections.

Antibodies against the two major surface glycoproteins of bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV), G and F, play a role in protection against BRSV-associated disease, but only the antibody response against the F protein has been well described. Therefore, we used a novel peptide-based enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (G peptide-ELISA) to compare immunoglobulin G (IgG) and IgG subclass antibody responses against the G protein with the antibody response against the F protein, as measured by a conventional BRSV ELISA (F-ELISA). Experimental infection of cattle induced significantly lower antibody titers than did natural infection. After natural primary infection, G peptide-specific antibodies declined more rapidly and to lower levels than the F protein-specific antibodies. As a consequence, the G peptide-ELISA detected more reinfections than did the F-ELISA. Ratios of G- and F-specific IgG1/IgG2 antibody titers did not differ markedly after infection or vaccination. Interestingly, after natural infection calves did not develop an IgG2 response to the complete G protein. In contrast, adult cattle had high IgG2 titers against this protein. Vaccination with a live vaccine induced low antibody titers, similar to the titers after experimental infection, whereas vaccination with an inactivated vaccine induced high titers. The results indicate that the kinetics of the G- and F-specific antibody responses differ. Furthermore, the IgG subclass response against the unglycosylated central region of the G protein is similar to the IgG subclass response to the F protein, but the IgG subclass response differs from the response to the complete G protein.

Experimental reproduction of respiratory disease in calves with non-cell-culture-passaged bovine respiratory syncytial virus.

To reproduce experimentally clinical bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) infections in cattle, we isolated BRSV from a calf in the field that suffered from acute respiratory disease. Cell culture passage of the virus was avoided to prevent any modification of the biological properties of the virus. The isolated BRSV was passaged in specific-pathogen-free (SPF) calves. Lung lavage fluids of these calves, which contained at least 10(3) TCID50/ml BRSV and which were found to be free of other known respiratory pathogens, were collected and pooled for experimental infection. To reproduce a clinical BRSV infection, two groups of six SPF calves were inoculated intranasally with 2 ml of 10(3.9) TCID50/ml BRSV of the obtained virus stock. Another five calves, which were persistently infected with bovine virus diarrhoea virus (BVDV), were given the same inoculum. One group of six calves served as mock-infected controls. Clinical signs were closely monitored from 1 week before until 16 days after inoculation. Reproducible clinical signs consisting of significantly (p < 0.05) increased respiratory rates and elevated body temperatures were recorded but not in all BRSV-inoculated calves. Although clinical signs were induced by experimental infection with non-cell-culture-passaged BRSV, the respiratory signs were not as serious as in the most severe cases in the field.

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus replicates minimally in bovine alveolar macrophages.

The interaction between two different bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) strains and bovine alveolar macrophages (BAMs) was studied in vitro. Bovine respiratory syncytial virus replicated minimally in BAMs and most of the virus produced remained cell-associated. Approximately 1 out of 1,000 BAMs produced infectious virus, a number that further declined during the 7 days of culture. In contrast, BAMs exposed to bovine parainfluenza 3 virus (PI3V) produced high amounts of infectious virus. The number of BAMs that contained BRSV antigen depended on the antigen load of the inoculum and not on the infectivity of the virus. Antibody mediated enhancement of infection was not detected. It is concluded that bovine alveolar macrophages exhibit a high intrinsic resistance to BRSV, but not to PI3V.

[HCH soil pollution (hexachlorocyclohexane) in Twente, public health aspects]. / HCH-bodemverontreiniging in Twente, volksgezondheidsaspecten.

A large waste heap consisting of HCH isomers was stored near the factory. In the seventies the spread of this waste was found to give rise to severe pollution of the soil resulting in unacceptable contamination of foods. Regulations on the basis of the Meat Inspection Act are recommended, under which slaughtered cattle from polluted areas may be traced according to Meat Inspection regulations.

[Safety aspects of the practical application of a gI-negative subunit vaccine against Aujeszky's disease in swine]. / Veiligheidsaspecten van toepassing van een gI-negatief sub-unitvaccin tegen de ziekte van Aujeszky bij varkens in de praktijk.

On two farms in an area in which Aujeszky's disease is endemic, 192 pregnant sows were vaccinated with a gI-negative sub-unit vaccine against Aujeszky's disease. The rectal temperatures of the sows were recorded once daily for seven consecutive days, starting on the day of vaccination, and the vaccinated animals were observed for local and systemic reactions. The temperatures recorded did not exceed 39.8 degrees C in any case, and local or systemic reactions caused by vaccinations were not observed. One sow (0.6 per cent) aborted, but other symptoms of disease were not apparent, and there was no relationship with vaccination. In a second experiment, the carcasses of 120 pigs, vaccinated once or twice with the same vaccine, were carefully examined for local reactions. In eleven pigs (9.1 per cent) slight cicatricial reactions were visible within from 20 to 34 days after inoculation, the diameter not exceeding 1.5 cm in any of the cases. Traces of vaccination were no longer perceptible within 84 days after vaccination. The vaccine was found to be very safe for pregnant sows under field conditions.