Practice Doesn't Make Perfect: Clinical Experience With Procedures Does Not Correlate Well With Competence in Third-Year Medical Students.

OBJECTIVE: There is limited data available about factors which promote competence with procedures in medical students. Specifically, the relationship between procedural clinical experience and performance on an assessment is unclear. We sought to determine whether a correlation exists between the amount and type of clinical experience with a procedure and student performance on a standardized assessment of that procedure. DESIGN: Faculty performed standardized assessments of third-year medical students on ten procedures using simulation. We prospectively surveyed students about 3 types of experience (performed, observed, and simulated) with these procedures during their clerkships. We then analyzed whether a correlation exists between student experience and their competency assessment scores using Pearson's correlation. SETTING/PARTICIPANTS: Third-year medical students at the University of Kentucky College of Medicine. RESULTS: In 2018 to 2019, 131 students were assessed on procedural competency with 10 failures. One hundred and twenty students (91.6%) completed the clinical experience survey. Correlations between types of experience and competency scores were small to moderate, with only 5 of 40 being significant. We found no correlation between experience having performed a procedure and competency score. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, we did not find convincing evidence of a correlation between experience with procedures during clerkships and performance on a competency assessment. This suggests other factors may be contributing to procedural competence, which has implications for how educators should develop procedural competence in students.

Are Graduating Pediatric Residents Prepared to Perform Infant Lumbar Punctures?: A Multi-Institutional Descriptive Study.

OBJECTIVES: Few published studies describe graduating pediatric residents' procedural skills or success rates. This information would help guide supervisors' decisions about graduating residents' preparedness, training, and supervision needs. This study aimed to measure success rates for graduating pediatric residents performing infant lumbar puncture (LP) during the final months of their training and to describe their experiences performing and supervising infant LPs during the course of their training. METHODS: This survey-based study was conducted at 10 academic medical institutions in 2013. The survey consisted of 4 domains: (1) demographics, (2) exposure to infant LP training as an intern, (3) number of LPs performed and supervised during residency, and (4) specific information on the most recent clinical infant LP. RESULTS: One hundred ninety-eight (82%) of 242 eligible graduating residents responded to the survey. A 54% success rate was noted for graduating residents when they were the first provider performing the infant LPs. Success rates were 24% if they were not the first provider to attempt the LP. Overall, graduating residents were supervised on 29% of their LPs, used anesthesia for 29%, and used the early stylet removal technique for 63%. The graduating residents performed a median of 12 infant LPs and supervised others on a median of 5 infant LPs throughout their residency. The vast majority reported feeling confident and prepared to perform this procedure. CONCLUSIONS: At the end of residency, graduating pediatric residents were rarely supervised and had low infant LP success rates despite confidence in their skills. However, graduating residents frequently supervised others performing this procedure.