Parity violating energetic difference and enantiomorphous crystalsp-caveats; reinvestigation of tyrosine crystallization.

The present article challenges reports claiming to have demonstrated the Parity Violating Energetic Difference (PVED) between enantiomorphous D- and L-crystals. Apart from PVED, the presence of minute quantities and differing profiles of impurities incorporated during their different history of preparation will affect the physical properties of D- and L-crystals. These impurities are anticipated to play a much greater role in affecting crystallization behavior than PVED. The effect of impurities on the growth and dissolution of enantiomorphous crystals is illustrated with some representative examples. Shinitzky et al. (2002) reported recently dramatic differences in the growth and dissolution properties of the D- and L-crystals of tyrosine. We have repeated these experiments using commercial samples from different sources and employing a validated enantioselective gas chromatographic technique. We attribute Shinitzky's findings either to the use of inappropriate analytical techniques for the determination of enantiomeric composition and/or to the presence of unidentified contaminants in the commercial tyrosine samples. Related caveats hold also for the recently published claims by Shinitzky (2006) and Scolnik et al. (2006) to have observed experimentally PVED between enantiomeric helices of poly-glutamic acid composed of 24 repeating units.

Homochiral oligopeptides by chiral amplification within two-dimensional crystalline self-assemblies at the air-water interface; relevance to biomolecular handedness.

A possible role that might have been played by ordered clusters at interfaces for the generation of homochiral oligopeptides under prebiotic conditions has been probed by a catalyzed polymerization of amphiphilic activated alpha-amino acids, in racemic and chiral non-racemic forms, which had self-assembled into two-dimensional (2D) ordered crystallites at the air-aqueous solution interface. As model systems we studied N(epsilon)-stearoyl-lysine thioethyl ester (C(18)-TE-Lys), gamma-stearyl-glutamic thioethyl ester (C(18)-TE-Glu), N(alpha)-carboxyanhydride of gamma-stearyl-glutamic acid (C(18)-Glu NCA) and gamma-stearyl-glutamic thioacid (C(18)-thio-Glu). According to in-situ grazing incidence X-ray diffraction measurements on the water surface, (R,S)-C(18)-TE-Lys, (R,S)-C(18)-TE-Glu, and (R,S)-C(18)-Glu-NCA amphiphiles self-assembled into ordered racemic 2D crystallites. Oligopeptides 2-12 units long were obtained at the air-aqueous solution interface after injection of appropriate catalysts into the water subphase. The experimental relative abundance of oligopeptides with homochiral sequence generated from (R,S)-C(18)-TE-Lys and (R,S)-C(18)-TE-Glu, as determined by mass spectrometry on enantioselectively deuterium-labeled samples, was found to be significantly larger than that obtained from (R,S) C(18)-thio-Glu which polymerizes randomly. An efficient chiral amplification was obtained in the polymerization of non-racemic mixtures of C(18)-Glu-NCA since the monomer molecules in the racemic 2D crystallites are oriented such that the reaction occurs between heterochiral molecules related by glide symmetry to yield heterochiral oligopeptides whereas the enantiomer in excess, in the enantiomorphous crystallites, yield oligopeptides of a single handedness.

Oligopeptides with homochiral sequences generated from racemic precursors that spontaneously separate into enantiomorphous two-dimensional crystalline domains on water surface.

The feasibility of generating oligopeptides with homochiral sequence via lattice-controlled polymerization of racemic mixtures of precursor molecules that undergo spontaneous segregation into two-dimensional (2-D) enantiomorphous domains at the air-aqueous solution interface was analyzed. For model systems, we studied the polymerization reaction within 2-D crystalline domains of mixtures of (R,S)-N(epsilon)-stearoyl-thio-lysine with approximately 10% (R,S)-N(epsilon)-stearoyl-lysine, and (R,S)-N(alpha)-carboxyanhydride of N(epsilon)-stearoyl-lysine. According to in situ grazing incidence X-ray diffraction (GIXD) measurements at the air-water interface, the molecules form 2-D crystallites packing by translation symmetry only. Oligopeptides 4-6 units long were obtained at the air-solution interface after injection of an appropriate catalyst into the subphase. The course of the chemical transformations was monitored by GIXD. The distribution of the diastereoisomeric oligopeptides was determined by matrix-assisted laser-desorption ionization time-of-flight (MALDI-TOF MS) mass spectrometry on samples prepared from precursor molecules enantioselectively labeled with deuterium. The experimental relative abundance of oligopeptides with homochiral sequence was found to be larger than that calculated for a theoretical random process, yielding an excess by a factor of 2.5-3.5 for the tetra- to hexapeptides. The present studies may be relevant for probing the role that might have been played by ordered clusters at interfaces for the generation of homochiral oligopeptides under prebiotic conditions.

Chiral amplification of oligopeptides in two-dimensional crystalline self-assemblies on water.

Differences in the two-dimensional packing arrangements of racemic and enantiomeric crystalline self-assemblies on the water surface of amphiphilic activated analogs of lysine and glutamic acid have been used to prepare oligopeptides of homochiral sequence and oligopeptides of single handedness from chiral nonracemic mixtures. The crystalline structures on the water surface were determined by grazing incidence x-ray diffraction and the diastereomeric composition of the oligopeptides by matrix-assisted laser desorption time-of-flight mass spectrometry with enantio-labeling. These results suggest that reactivity of ordered clusters at interfaces might have played a role in the generation of early homochiral biopolymers.