Blinded comparison of biopsy needles and automated devices in vitro: 1. Biopsy of diffuse hepatic disease.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to compare several of the commonly used needles with several of the new automated biopsy devices (biopsy guns) for biopsy of diffuse hepatic disease. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Nine different biopsy needles or automated devices were each used to do three biopsies of 10 cadaveric livers. The specimens were reviewed in a blinded fashion by a pathologist who did not know which needle or device was used, and they were compared on the basis of a previously published histopathologic grading scale. RESULTS: The three conventional biopsy needles (16-gauge Jamshidi, 18-gauge Sure-Cut, and 14-gauge Tru-Cut) obtained a large amount of tissue with an average of 4.1 intact portal triads per biopsy. The 18-gauge Biopty gun obtained equivalent results. The 18-gauge Autovac gun with a 2-cm biopsy depth did not obtain any tissue in 18.5% of attempts. The 14- and 16-gauge Biopty guns and the 18-gauge Autovac gun with a 4-cm biopsy depth performed best with respect to fragment size and number of intact portal triads. CONCLUSION: Automated biopsy devices can provide more diagnostic specimens than can manual or conventional needles in biopsy for diffuse hepatic disease.

Blinded comparison of biopsy needles and automated devices in vitro: 2. Biopsy of medical renal disease.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to compare several of the commonly used manual biopsy needles with several of the new automated biopsy devices (biopsy guns) for biopsy of medical renal disease. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Ten different biopsy needles or automated devices were each used to do two biopsies of 10 cadaveric kidneys. The specimens were reviewed in a blinded fashion by a pathologist using a previously published histopathologic scale. RESULTS: Of the four conventional biopsy needles tested (16-gauge Jamshidi, 18-gauge Sure-Cut, 14-gauge Tru-Cut, and 14-gauge Vim Silverman), the Jamshidi needle obtained the greatest average number of glomeruli (5.64). Results similar to those obtained with the conventional needles were obtained with the 16- and 18-gauge Biopty and Ultra-Cut biopsy guns. The 18-gauge Autovac gun with either a 2- or 4-cm depth of biopsy suffered from a significant number of biopsies from which no tissue was obtained. The 14-gauge Biopty gun was clearly superior, leading in all graded categories including the average number of glomeruli (8.11) per biopsy. CONCLUSION: The automated biopsy device, or biopsy gun, can provide more diagnostic specimens than can manual or conventional needles in biopsy for medical renal disease.

Automated biopsy devices: a blinded evaluation.

To evaluate 20 different automated biopsy devices with respect to the quality of tissue obtained for histopathologic analysis, a total of 1,470 18-gauge biopsy specimens were obtained from 10 fresh autopsy cases, including 30 liver, 20 kidney, 10 pancreas, and 10 psoas muscle biopsy specimens per device and per biopsy depth. There was no statistical difference in the performance of the long-throw Biopty, ASAP 18, 1.9-cm UltraCut, long-throw Monopty, and 2.5-cm ABS biopsy guns. All obtained a large amount of tissue with minimal fragmentation or crush artifact. Most of the short-throw biopsy guns (depth of biopsy < or = 1.1 cm) did not perform as well. Although the other guns performed adequately, less than optimal results were obtained with the Temno, Bio-Gun, Roth, Klear Kut, ABC, and Urocut biopsy guns. Most 18-gauge automated biopsy devices with a biopsy excursion of at least 2.0 cm provide a high-quality, diagnostically adequate specimen for histopathologic analysis.

Readability of informed consent forms for use with iodinated contrast media.

Informed consent forms used before intravenous administration of contrast media by both private practice (Pennsylvania Blue Shield) and academic (Association of University Radiologists) physician groups were analyzed to evaluate for readability and content. Most of the 160 consent forms required at least a high school education to be understood; 10 (6%) required a college education. Consent forms from academic institutions tended to be longer and contain more problems with sentence structure than those from private practice. Consent forms from both groups tended to have a weak, wordy writing style. Although most of the consent forms discussed at least some of the potential adverse reactions from intravenous contrast media, 37 (23%) made no mention of any potential adverse reaction. Indeed, 25 (16%) made no mention of contrast media at all. Only 12 (8%) consent forms included a discussion of nonionic contrast media. The authors provide sample consent forms that cover the common risks of ionic and nonionic contrast media and describe the availability of nonionic contrast media; these forms are understandable by an individual reading at only an eighth-grade level.

Fine-needle aspiration biopsy for cytopathologic analysis: utility of syringe handles, automated guns, and the nonsuction method.

The performances of seven techniques and devices used with 22-gauge needles to obtain biopsy specimens for cytologic analysis were compared by means of single-blinded evaluation with an objective, previously published grading scheme. A total of 420 specimens were obtained from 10 fresh human cadavers (42 specimens per cadaver), including 30 hepatic, 20 renal, and 10 pancreatic specimens per technique or device. No statistical differences existed in the liver, kidney, or pancreas or in the combined data in the performance of the aspirator gun, syringe holders, vacuum needle, and end-cut gun versus the manual aspiration biopsy technique performed with a 22-gauge Chiba needle. However, nonaspiration, fine-needle capillary biopsy (FNCB) performed statistically significantly worse than any other technique or device in the kidney and pancreas and in comparison with the overall combined data. In the liver, no statistically significant difference existed in the overall performance of FNCB versus conventional aspiration biopsy, but the amount of cellular material obtained with FNCB was statistically significantly less.