Afferent and efferent specificity in the induction and elicitation of parental cross-protective immunity by an immunogenic murine tumor variant: associative recognition of a unique tumor-specific antigen on somatic cell hybrids.

Highly immunogenic (Imm+) murine tumor cell variants can engender a strong tumor-specific, cross-protective immune response against challenge with the weakly immunogenic parental tumor cell line. We examined the afferent induction and efferent specificity of the parental cross-protective immunity observed following immunization with the Imm+ variant of the murine fibrosarcoma MCA-F, designated MCA-FM1. Specificity of the afferent and efferent responses against the parental tumor in mice immunized with the MCA-FM1 variant were monitored by challenge with the tumor MCA-D, which expresses a tumor-specific antigen that is immunologically distinct from but biochemically related to the MCA-F antigen. We observed that mixture of MCA-D and MCA-FM1 cells at immunization failed to elicit a strong tumor rejection response against challenge with MCA-D. Challenge of MCA-FM1-immune mice with a mixture of MCA-FM1 and MCA-D cells resulted in a significant bystander effect at the site of Imm+ rejection, with reduced growth of the MCA-D tumor. To test the hypothesis that the induction of parental cross-protective immunity required the associative recognition of both the Imm+ neoantigen and the parental tumor antigen on the same cell, we constructed somatic cell hybrids of MCA-D with either MCA-F or MCA-FM1. Surprisingly, the hybrids did not express either parental tumor-specific antigen present on the fusion partners but displayed a unique antigenic specificity designated F/D. Expression of the F/D antigen by both the immunogenic and nonimmunogenic hybrid cell lines demonstrated that the tumor-specific F/D antigen was the focus of the cross-protective immunity. These results demonstrate that associative recognition of the tumor-specific parental antigen with the strongly immunogenic neoantigen coexpressed on the surface of the Imm+ variant is responsible for the afferent induction and efferent elicitation of anti-parental cross-protective immunity. Furthermore, this study is the first to report that the fusion of two syngeneic tumor cell lines reproducibly results in a new tumor antigen specificity at the expense of the original parental specificities.

Immunological characteristics of immunogenic variants induced in the MCA-F murine fibrosarcoma using 1-methyl-3-nitro-1-nitrosoguanidine, 5-aza-2'-deoxycytidine, or ultraviolet radiation.

The purpose of this study was to compare the frequency of generation and in vivo cross-reactivity of highly immunogenic (Imm+) clones induced in a single parental murine fibrosarcoma cell line MCA-F by 4 weekly treatments with either UV-B radiation, 1-methyl-3-nitro-1-nitrosoguanidine, or 5-aza-2'-deoxycytidine. These agents are believed to induce Imm+ variants by different mechanisms. The frequency of Imm+ variant generation was similar for the three different protocols, suggesting that the frequency of Imm+ generation was related more closely to the cell line than the inducing agent used. The strength of the immunogenic phenotype, however, was better correlated to the agent used, since 1-methyl-3-nitro-1-nitrosoguanidine yielded clones with the strongest immunogenicities. Three of four UV-B-induced Imm+ clones grew preferentially in chronically UV-irradiated syngeneic mice, a phenotype associated with UV-induced skin tumors. Cross-reactivity was tested with two Imm+ clones from each treatment group in a modified immunoprotection assay that selectively engendered antivariant, but not antiparental, immunity. Under these conditions each clone, except one, protected against itself. The clones displayed a complex pattern of cross-protection. Intervariant cross-protection was sensitive to the challenge dose, suggesting possible differences in the strengths of the cross-reacting immunities. Conversely, parental cross-protection was observed only with high immunizing multiplicities of Imm+ cells. The clones expressed the Imm+ phenotype in both C3H/HeN and C3H/HeJ mice, suggesting that expression of mammary tumor virus antigens did not account for the strong antitumor immune response. We also investigated whether the level of major histocompatibility complex class 1 or class 2 expression and immunogenic phenotype were correlated. Flow cytofluorography using haplotype-specific anti-Kk and anti-Dk monoclonal antibodies did not reveal a consistent difference in the constitutive or gamma-interferon-induced class 1 expression by Imm+ clones. However, we did observe a significant increase in the constitutive expression of IAk by most of the Imm+ variant clones. Together, these data demonstrate that in this system Imm+ variants engendered by a variety of mechanisms can express a range of cross-reactive tumor rejection neoantigens, independent of parental tumor antigens or major histocompatibility complex antigen expression.

Characterization of variant and parental-cross-protective immunity to immunogenic variants of a murine fibrosarcoma using the local adoptive transfer assay.

The purpose of this study was to characterize the lymphocyte populations responsible for rejection of immunogenic (Imm+) tumor variants, and the cross-protective immunity engendered by Imm+ variants against the weakly immunogenic parental tumor. Immunogenic clones of the weakly immunogenic methylcholanthrene-induced fibrosarcoma MCA-F have been generated using 1-methyl-3-nitro-1-nitrosoguanidine, 5-aza-2'-deoxycytidine, or ultraviolet radiation (UV-B; 280-320 nm). These clones grow progressively in immunosuppressed adult-thymectomized irradiated mice, but are rejected by immunocompetent syngeneic hosts. The parental MCA-F tumor grows progressively in both groups. Mice that have rejected a challenge of 1 x 10(5) Imm+ cells show an anamnestic immune response against both the Imm+ clone and the parental MCA-F tumor. Using the local adoptive transfer assay and depletion of T-cell subsets with antibody plus complement, we show that immunity induced by the Imm+ variants against the parent MCA-F was mediated by the Thy1.2+, L3T4a+ population without an apparent contribution by Lyt2.1+ cells. Although antivariant immunity was also dependent upon Thy1.2+ cells, depletion of either the L3T4a+ or the Lyt2.1+ cells failed to abolish immunity against the variant. A role for Lyt2.1+ T lymphocytes in antivariant immunity, but not antiparent immunity, was supported by the results of cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) assays. Following immunization with high numbers (1 x 10(5) to 5 x 10(5) of viable Imm+ cells, antivariant, but not antiparent CTL activity was detected in mixed lymphocyte tumor cell cultures. Immunization with lower numbers (3 x 10(4] of viable Imm+ or with high numbers of mitomycin-C-treated Imm+ engenders only antivariant immunity without parental cross-protection. Under these conditions lymphocytes mediating immunity against the variant in the local adoptive transfer assay were exclusively of the Thy1.2+, L3T4a+ phenotype, with no contribution from the Lyt2.1+ cells. Identical results were obtained for Imm+ clones of MCA-F induced by methylnitronitrosoguanidine, 5-azadeoxycytidine, and UV-B, suggesting that the nature of the antitumor immunity engendered by Imm+ is not significantly affected by the agent used. Furthermore, these results demonstrate that the cross-reactivity and cellular effectors of antitumor immunity in this system are influenced by the immunizing dose of Imm+ cells: the predominant effectors of both antivariant and parental-cross-reactive immunity were of the CD4+ T cell subclass, with a CD8+ cytotoxic population contributing to antivariant immunity only after high-dose immunization.

Differential extraction of tumor-specific antigens from two ultraviolet light-induced murine fibrosarcomas with the use of 1-butanol.

The purpose of this study was to investigate the immunobiological characteristics of the tumor-specific cell surface antigen expressed by the UV-induced murine fibrosarcoma, UV-2240. UV-2240 is classified as a regressor UV tumor because it is immunologically rejected by normal syngeneic mice but grows in immunocompromised or UV-irradiated hosts. The strong tumor-specific rejection antigen expressed by UV-2240 was found on the plasma membrane, and unlike the previously characterized antigen of UV-1591, the UV-2240 antigen was removed by using the noncytolytic butanol extraction technique. The tumor antigen activity in butanol extracts was resistant to digestion by endoglycosidase F and alpha-mannosidase, but was destroyed by pronase. In addition, the immunoprotective activity in extracts of UV-2240 was thermostable. These data demonstrate that the UV-2240-specific tumor antigen possesses physicochemical properties distinct from those of its well-characterized counterpart UV-1591.

Immunogenic variants of a murine fibrosarcoma induced by mutagenesis: requirement of viable cells for antigen-specific cross-protection.

The purpose of the study was to investigate the immunological and biological consequences of neoantigen expression by immunogenic tumor variants (Imm+) following in vitro treatment with the mutagen 1-methyl-3-nitro-1-nitrosoguanidine. The weakly immunogenic murine fibrosarcoma MCA-F was used because we have previously characterized the tumor-specific transplantation antigen expressed by this tumor. Immunogenic variant clones were obtained at high frequency following four treatments with 1-methyl-3-nitro-1-nitrosoguanidine. The immunogenicity of the Imm+ clones was confirmed by their progressive growth in immunosuppressed C3H/HeN mice and their lack of growth in normal syngeneic (C3H/HeN mice. The immune response engendered in immunocompetent mice after a single immunization with viable Imm+ cells was tumor specific, completely protecting hosts against challenge with 10,000-fold the minimum tumorigenic dose of parental MCA-F cells, but not against 10 minimum tumorigenic doses of the non-cross-reactive tumor MCA-D. The strong cross-protection elicited by Imm+ neoantigens against the parental tumor-specific transplantation antigen was not observed when soluble extracts or isolated plasma membranes of Imm+ cells were used for immunization. Immunogenic variant cells inactivated using either mitomycin C or gamma-irradiation also demonstrated a significantly diminished immunoprotective activity against challenge with the parent tumor. However, inactivated Imm+ cells and their isolated plasma membranes still expressed sufficient neoantigen to completely protect mice against homotypic Imm+, but not parental challenge. These results suggest that (a) the MCA-F Imm+ variants express neoantigens capable of engendering a strong specific as well as cross-protective immunity against challenge with either the parent or the variant and (b) the associative recognition of neoantigen and TSTA that results in strong cross-protection against challenge with the parent tumor requires immunization with viable Imm+ cells for full expression of the immunogenic phenotype.