Proton beam scattering system optimization for clinical and research applications.

PURPOSE: To develop and test a method for optimizing and constructing a dual scattering system in passively scattered proton therapy. METHODS: A beam optics optimization algorithm was developed to optimize the thickness of the first scatterer (S1) and the profile (of both the high-Z material and Lexan) of the second scatterer (S2) to deliver a proton beam matching a given set of parameters, including field diameter, fluence, flatness, and symmetry. A new manufacturing process was also tested that allows the contoured second scattering foil to be created much more economically and quickly using Cerrobend casting. Two application-specific scattering systems were developed and tested using both experimental and Monte Carlo techniques to validate the optimization process described. RESULTS: A scattering system was optimized and constructed to deliver large uniform irradiations of radiobiology samples at low dose rates. This system was successfully built and tested using film and ionization chambers. The system delivered a uniform radiation field of 50 cm diameter (to a dose of ± 7% of the central axis) while the depth dose profile could be tuned to match the specifications of the particular investigator using modulator wheels and range shifters. A second scattering system for intermediate field size (4 cm < diameter < 10 cm) stereotactic radiosurgery and radiation therapy (SRS and SRT) treatments was also developed and tested using GEANT4. This system improved beam efficiency by over 70% compared with existing scattering systems while maintaining field flatness and depth dose profile. In both cases the proton range uniformity across the radiation field was maintained, further indicating the accuracy of the energy loss formalism in the optimization algorithm. CONCLUSIONS: The methods described allow for rapid prototyping of scattering foils to meet the demands of both research and clinical beam delivery applications in proton therapy.

Monte Carlo simulation of single-plane magnetically focused narrow proton beams.

We present Monte Carlo simulations of magnetically focused proton beams shaped by a single quadrapole magnet. Such beams are narrowly focused in one longitudinal plane but fan out in the perpendicular plane producing elongated elliptical beam spots (a 'screwdriver' shape). The focused beams were compared to passively collimated beams (the current standard of delivery for small radiosurgery beams). Beam energies considered were relevant to functional radiosurgery and standard radiosurgery clinical applications. Three monoenergetic beams (100, 125, and 150 MeV) and a modulated beam were simulated. Monoenergetic magnetically focused beams demonstrated 28 to 32% lower entrance doses, 31 to 47% larger central peak to entrance depth dose ratios, 26 to 35% smaller integral dose, 25 to 32% smaller estimated therapeutic ratios, 19 to 37% smaller penumbra volumes, and 38 to 65% smaller vertical profile lateral penumbras at Bragg depth, compared to the collimated beams. Focused modulated beams showed 31% larger central peak to entrance dose ratio, and 62 to 65% smaller vertical lateral penumbras over the plateau of the spread out Bragg peak. These advantages can be attributed to the directional acceleration of protons in the transverse plane due to the magnetic field. Such beams can be produced using commercially available assemblies of permanent rare earth magnets that do not require electric power or cryrogenic cooling. Our simulations suggest that these magnets can be inexpensively incorporated into the beam line to deliver reduced dose to normal tissue, and enhanced dose to elongated elliptical targets with major and minor axes on the order of a few centimeters and millimeters, respectively. Such beams may find application in novel proton functional and standard radiosurgery treatments in and around critical structures.

Analysis of a metalloporphyrin antioxidant mimetic (MnTE-2-PyP) as a radiomitigator: prostate tumor and immune status.

Due to radiation-induced immune depression and development of pathologies such as cancer, there is increasing urgency to identify radiomitigators that are effective when administered after radiation exposure. The main goal of this study was to determine the radiomitigation capacity of MnTE-2-PyP[Mn(III) tetrakis (N-ethylpyridinium-2-yl) porphyrin], a superoxide dismutase (SOD) mimetic, and evaluate leukocyte parameters in spleen and blood. C57BL/6 mice were total-body exposed to 2 Gy γ-rays (Co-60), i.e., well below a lethal dose, followed by subcutaneous implantation of 5 × 10(5) RM-9 prostate tumor cells and initiation of MnTE-2-PyP treatment (day 0); interval between each procedure was 1-2 h. The drug was administered daily (12 times). Tumor progression was monitored and immunological analyses were performed on a subset per group on day 12. Animals treated with MnTE-2-PyP alone had significantly slower tumor growth compared to mice that did not receive the drug (P < 0.05), while radiation alone had no effect. Treatment of tumor-bearing mice with MnTE-2-PyP alone significantly increased spleen mass relative to body mass; the numbers of splenic white blood cells (WBC) and lymphocytes (B and T), as well as circulating WBC, granulocytes, and platelets, were high compared to one of more of the other groups (P < 0.05). The results show that MnTE-2-PyP slowed RM-9 tumor progression and up-regulated immune parameters, but mitigation of the effects of 2 Gy total-body irradiation were minimal.

MO-A-213AB-10: Scattering System Optimization for Proton Therapy.

PURPOSE: To describe a method for optimization and production of a dual scattering system for proton beam delivery. METHODS: Dual-foil passive scattering is currently the prevalent modality for proton therapy delivery. Large uniform proton fields are created using a 2-stage scattering system comprising an upstream uniform lead foil (stage 1) followed by a contoured lead/Lexan foil to provide beam and range uniformity (stage 2). Optimizing the parameters of these foils, including thickness, contour and placement, provides not only a flat and symmetrical radiation field with a uniform range, but also affects the overall efficiency of the beam line. An analytical method for optimizing the scattering system design was applied and validated with GEANT4 simulations. This method has been used to create passively scattered therapeutic and research proton fields at our proton therapy facility. A novel Cerrobend casting method is described that allows for cost-effective and accurate production of this important beam-line component. RESULTS: A number of dual scattering foil combinations for research and therapeutic purposes have been created and were evaluated with GEANT4 simulations. We demonstrated that the use of this system can generate passively scattered proton fields up to 60cm diameter with improved efficiency and beam flatness over existing dual-scattering systems. Scattering system performance was verified using physical measurements including Gafchromic film and ion chamber data. CONCLUSIONS: This analytical method allows the user to optimize the proton dual scattering system with respect to specific input parameters, while the casting method provides a cost-effective way to create a unique scattering system for a given application.

Radioprotective effect of a metalloporphyrin compound in rat eye model.

PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the efficacy of the antioxidant Mn (III) tetrakis (N-ethylpyridinium-2-yl) porphyrin (MnTE-2-PyP) in protecting ocular tissue and retinal microvasculature from radiation damage. MATERIALS AND METHODS: 75 rats were treated with Mn TE-2-PyP at 2.5 micro g/injection into one eye an hour before proton irradiation. The radiation was delivered in a single fraction to total doses of 8 Gray (Gy) or 28 Gy; Rats were sacrificed 3 days and 3, 6, 9, and 12 months thereafter for histology and quantification of photoreceptor cell populations and retinal capillary changes. RESULTS: By 6 months following radiation, there was significant loss of retinal outer and inner nuclear layers in eyes receiving radiation only (8 and 28 Gy) (p < 0.05) compared to their controls and to the eyes of rats treated with radiation plus metalloporphyrin. Retinal microvessel length density decreased significantly 6 months following 28 Gy (p < 0.05) compared to their controls and to MnTE-2-PyP treated rats. By 12 months following irradiation, irradiated eyes showed extensive damage to the photoreceptor layer, whereas the eyes of animals receiving radiation plus MnTE-2-PyP showed almost no morphological damage. MnTE-2-PyP treatment also suppressed radiation-induced apoptosis in our study. CONCLUSIONS: These results demonstrated that MnTE-2-PyP protected both photoreceptors and retinal capillaries from radiation damage, suggesting that this metalloporphyrin antioxidant is effective in regulating the damage induced by proton radiation.

A clinical interactive technique for MR-CT image registration for target delineation of intracranial tumors.

Replacement of current CT-based, three-dimensional (3D) treatment planning systems by newer versions capable of automated multi-modality image registration may be economically prohibitive for most radiation oncology clinics. We present a low-cost technique for MR-CT image registration on a "first generation" CT-based, 3D treatment planning system for intracranial tumors. The technique begins with fabrication of a standard treatment mask. A second truncated mask, the "minimask," is then made, using the standard mask as a mold. Two orthogonal leveling vials glued onto the minimask detect angular deviations in pitch and roll. Preservation of yaw is verified by referencing a line marked according to the CT laser on the craniocaudal axis. The treatment mask immobilizes the patient's head for CT. The minimask reproduces this CT-based angular treatment position, which is then maintained by taping the appropriately positioned head to the MR head coil for MR scanning. All CT and MR images, in DICOM 3.0 format, are entered into the treatment planning system via a computer network. Interactive registration of MR to CT images is controlled by real-time visual feedback on the computer monitor. Translational misalignments at the target are eliminated or minimized by iterative use of qualitative visual inspection. In this study, rotational errors were measured in a retrospective series of 20 consecutive patients who had undergone CT-MR image registration using this technique. Anatomic structures defined the three CT orthogonal axes from which angular errors on MR image were measured. Translational errors at the target isocenter were within pixel size, as judged by visual inspection. Clinical setup using the minimask resulted in overall average angular deviation of 3 degrees +/-2 degrees (mean +/- SD) and translational deviation within the edges of the target volume of typically less than 2 mm. The accuracy of this registration technique for target delineation of intracranial tumors is compatible with practice guidelines. This method, then, provides a cost-effective means to register MR and CT images for target delineation of intracranial tumors.

Effects of proton and combined proton/photon beam radiation on pulmonary function in patients with resectable but medically inoperable non-small cell lung cancer.

STUDY OBJECTIVES: We evaluated the effects on pulmonary function of irradiating lung cancer with protons alone or protons combined with photons. DESIGN: Prospective phase I/II study. SETTING: University medical center. PATIENTS AND INTERVENTIONS: Ten patients with stage I-II non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) and FEV(1) < or = 1.0 L were irradiated with protons to areas of gross disease only, using 51 cobalt gray equivalents (CGE) in 10 fractions (protocol 1). Fifteen patients with stage I-IIIA NSCLC and FEV(1) > 1.0 L received 45-Gy photon irradiation to the primary lung tumor and the mediastinum, plus a 28.8-CGE proton boost to the gross tumor volume (protocol 2). MEASUREMENTS: Pulmonary function was evaluated prior to treatment and 1 month, 3 months, and 6 to 12 months following irradiation. RESULTS: In patients receiving protocol 1, no significant changes in pulmonary function occurred. In patients receiving protocol 2, at 6 to 12 months, the diffusion capacity of the lung for carbon monoxide had declined from 61% of predicted to 45% of predicted (p < 0.05), total lung capacity had declined from 114% of predicted to 95% of predicted (p < 0.05), and residual volume had declined from 160% of predicted to 132% of predicted (p < 0.05). Airway resistance increased from 3.8 to 5.2 cm H(2)O/L/s (p < 0.05). No statistically significant changes occurred in vital capacity, FEV(1), or PaO(2). CONCLUSIONS: Our observations indicate that it is feasible to apply higher-than-conventional doses of radiation at a higher-than-conventional dose per fraction without excess pulmonary toxicity when conformal radiation techniques with protons are used.

Carbon dioxide management and the cerebral response to hemodilution during hypothermic cardiopulmonary bypass in dogs.

BACKGROUND: Increases in blood flow support oxygen (O2) delivery with hemodilution. However, with alpha-stat management, the cerebral response to hemodilution is blunted. We tested the hypothesis that carbon dioxide (CO2) management is a primary determinant of the cerebral blood flow (CBF) response to hemodilution during hypothermic bypass. METHODS: Following Animal Care Committee approval, 15 dogs underwent bypass at 18 degrees C (pH-stat, n = 7 or alpha-stat, n = 8). Measurements were obtained after progressive hemodilution, and cerebral blood flow was determined by sagittal sinus outflow. Arterial pressure was maintained at 60 to 70 mm Hg. The CBF response to hemodilution and cerebral metabolic rate were compared in the two groups of animals. RESULTS: In both groups, hemodilution increased CBF. At every hematocrit, CBF and O2 delivery in the pH-stat group exceeded that of alpha-stat group, although O2 demand did not differ between groups. While absolute CBF in the pH-stat group was greater at every hematocrit, the relative change in CBF from control and the slope of the CBF-Hct relationship did not differ between groups. CONCLUSIONS: pH-stat management is associated with a greater absolute CBF and a greater ratio of cerebral O2 supply to demand for any degree of hemodilution. However, over the range of hematocrits common in practice, CO2 management per se does not determine the cerebral response to hemodilution.

Kinetically selective binding of single stranded RNA over DNA by a pyrrolidine-amide oligonucleotide mimic (POM).

Replacing the sugar-phosphodiester backbone of nucleic acids with a pyrrolidine-amide backbone results in an oligonucleotide mimic POM 1 which binds with high affinity and specificity to complementary DNA and RNA. Unlike other modified oligonucleotides, POM binds much more rapidly to single stranded RNA than DNA.

Distribution and hierarchy of regional blood flow during hypothermic cardiopulmonary bypass.

BACKGROUND: Cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) may decrease oxygen delivery relative to the nonbypass state. We predicted that a hierarchy of regional blood flow could be characterized under hypothermic (27 degrees C) CPB. METHODS: Ten pigs underwent bypass at 27 degrees C. Fluorescent microspheres were administered before and during CPB at four randomized flows: 1.9, 1.6, 1.3, and 1.0 L x min(-1) x m(-2). At completion, tissue samples were obtained from brain, renal cortex and medulla, pancreas, small bowel, and limb muscle for regional blood flow determination. RESULTS: Cerebral blood flow remained unchanged between CPB flows of 1.9 and 1.3 L x min(-1) x m(-2). Renal perfusion was stable between flows of 1.9 and 1.6 L x min(-1) x m(-2), whereas perfusion of small bowel decreased linearly with pump flow. Pancreatic perfusion was unchanged over the range of flows studied; muscle blood flow was profoundly reduced at the highest CPB flow and further decreased if pump flow was reduced below 1.6 L x min(-1) x m(-2). CONCLUSIONS: This study characterizes the organ-specific hierarchy of blood flow and oxygen distribution during hypothermic CPB. These dynamics are relevant to clinical decisions for perfusion management.

Hierarchy of regional oxygen delivery during cardiopulmonary bypass.

BACKGROUND: Relative to the nonbypass state, cardiopulmonary bypass may decrease whole-body oxygen (O2) delivery. We predicted that during cardiopulmonary bypass, a hierarchy of regional blood flow and O2 delivery could be characterized. METHODS: In 8 46.5 +/- 1.2-kg pigs, fluorescent microspheres were used to determine blood flow and O2 delivery to five organ beds before and during 37 degrees C cardiopulmonary bypass at four randomized bypass flows (1.4, 1.7, 2.0, and 2.3 L/min/m2). At completion, 18 tissue samples were obtained from the cerebral cortex (n = 4), renal cortex (n = 2), renal medulla (n = 2), pancreas (n = 3), small bowel (n = 3), and limb muscle (n = 4) for regional blood flow determination. RESULTS: At conventional cardiopulmonary bypass flow (2.3 L/min/m2), whole-body O2 delivery was reduced by 44 +/- 6% relative to the pre-cardiopulmonary bypass state (p < 0.05). Over a range of cardiopulmonary bypass flows (2.3 to 1.7 L/min/m2), brain and kidney maintained their perfusion. Blood flow and O2 delivery to both regions were reduced when the cardiopulmonary bypass flow was reduced to 1.4 L/min/m2. However, perfusion and O2 delivery to other visceral organs (pancreas, small bowel) and skeletal muscle showed pump flow dependency over the range of flows tested. CONCLUSIONS: This study characterizes the organ-specific hierarchy of blood flow and O2 distribution during cardiopulmonary bypass. These dynamics are relevant to clinical decisions for perfusion management.

Research activities at the Loma Linda University and Proton Treatment Facility--an overview.

The Loma Linda University (LLU) Radiobiology Program coordinates basic research and proton beam service activities for the university and extramural communities. The current focus of the program is on the biological and physical properties of protons and the operation of radiobiology facilities for NASA-sponsored projects. The current accelerator, supporting facilities and operations are described along with a brief review of extramural research projects supported by the program. These include space craft electronic parts and shielding testing as well as tumorigenesis and animal behavior experiments. An overview of research projects currently underway at LLU is also described. These include: 1) acute responses of the C57Bl/6 mouse immune system, 2) modulation of gene expression in the nematode C. elegans and rat thyroid cells, 3) quantitation of dose tolerance in rat CNS microvasculature, 4) behavioral screening of whole body proton and iron ion-irradiated C57Bl/6 mice, and 5) investigation of the role of cell integration into epithelial structures on responses to radiation.

Determination of the air w-value in proton beams using ionization chambers with gas flow capability.

The purpose of this work was to determine the w-value of air for protons using the paired gas method. Several plastic- and magnesium-walled chambers were used with air, synthetic air, nitrogen, and argon flowing gases. Using argon as a reference gas, the w-value of air was measured and ranged from 32.7 to 34.5 J/C for protons with energies encountered in radiotherapy. Using nitrogen as a reference gas, the w-value of air ranged from 35.2 to 35.4 J/C over the same range of proton energies. The w-value was found, at a given energy, to be independent of the ion chamber used. The uncertainty in these measurements was estimated at 5.2% at the 2sigma level. This uncertainty was dominated by the 4.4% uncertainty in the w-value of the reference gas.

Dose response of rat retinal microvessels to proton dose schedules used clinically: a pilot study.

PURPOSE: This preclinical rat pilot study quantifies retinal microvessel, endothelial, and pericyte population changes produced by proton irradiation METHODS AND MATERIALS: The left eyes of rats were irradiated with single doses of 8, 14, 20, and 28 Gy protons; right eyes, with two fractions. Animals were euthanized, and eyes were removed; elastase digests were prepared, and cell populations were counted in sample fields. Results were compared with unirradiated controls. RESULTS: Progressive time- and dose-dependent endothelial cell loss occurred following all schedules. Cell loss was significantly different from control values (p < 0.001) following 28 Gy and following 20 Gy (p < 0.05) in a single dose. Endothelial cell loss was the same for single- and split-dose schedules. Progressive endothelial cell loss produced vessel collapse and acellular vessel strands. Endothelial cells were in the G(0) phase of the mitotic cycle. 28 Gy produced photoreceptor cell loss. CONCLUSION: The retinal digest is an elegant bioassay to quantify the microvessel population response. Single- and split-dose schedules appear to yield similar outcomes, in terms of endothelial cell density.

Conformal proton radiation therapy of the posterior fossa: a study comparing protons with three-dimensional planned photons in limiting dose to auditory structures.

PURPOSE: Conventional radiation therapy for pediatric posterior fossa tumors can cause sequelae such as hearing loss and impairments in language and learning. Modern three-dimensional (3D) treatment techniques have improved dose conformity to the posterior fossa. This report compares the normal tissue dose-sparing capabilities of proton radiation therapy (PRT) with 3D conformal photon plans. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Nine children underwent previous PRT for primary CNS malignancies. Using original planning CT scans, the posterior fossa, inner and middle ear, and temporal lobes were delineated. Three-dimensional treatment plans were generated for protons and photons. Normal tissue exposures were calculated by averaging mean doses received and by analysis of dose-volume histogram. RESULTS: The 95% isodose encompassed the posterior fossa in all plans. Normal structures received markedly less radiation from PRT plans than from 3D photon plans. The cochlea received an average mean of 25 +/- 4% of the prescribed dose from PRT, and 75 +/- 6% from photons. Forty percent of temporal lobe volume was completely excluded using protons; with photons 90% of the temporal lobe received 31% of the dose. CONCLUSION: PRT resulted in increased dose sparing of normal structures analyzed. Posterior fossa conformity of 3D photons came at the expense of increasing amounts of normal tissue receiving low to moderate doses.

Analysis of head motion prior to and during proton beam therapy.

PURPOSE: We report on the use of a noninvasive patient motion monitoring system to evaluate the amount of head motion prior to and during proton radiation therapy sessions. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Two optical displacement sensors, placed close to the patient's head, were used for online monitoring of the head position, with submillimeter accuracy. Motion data, including the difference between start and end position (Dx) and the maximum displacement during the recorded session (Dx-max), were acquired for pretreatment sessions to analyze alignment radiographs, and for treatment sessions. We have recorded 102 pretreatment and 99 treatment sessions in 16 patients immobilized with a thermoplastic mask, and 44 pretreatment and 56 treatment sessions in 13 patients immobilized with vacuum-assisted dental fixation. To avoid incorrect data analysis due to replicate observations, only 1 pretreatment and 1 treatment session per patient were selected at random for statistical comparison of mean or median motion parameters in different subgroups. RESULTS: Both techniques showed similar immobilization efficiencies. The median Dx and Dx-max values were 0. 18 mm and 0.46 mm, respectively, for 16 treatment sessions with mask immobilization, and 0.22 mm and 0.50 mm, respectively, for 13 treatment sessions with dental immobilization. Motion parameters for pretreatment and treatment sessions were not statistically different. CONCLUSION: Online verification of patient's head motion is feasible and provides valuable data for confirmation of proper treatment delivery in individual patients, as well as for the evaluation of different immobilization methods.

Acute effects of whole-body proton irradiation on the immune system of the mouse.

The acute effects of proton whole-body irradiation on the distribution and function of leukocyte populations in the spleen and blood were examined and compared to the effects of photons derived from a (60)Co gamma-ray source. Adult female C57BL/6 mice were exposed to a single dose (3 Gy at 0.4 Gy/min) of protons at spread-out Bragg peak (SOBP), protons at the distal entry (E) region, or gamma rays and killed humanely at six different times thereafter. Specific differences were noted in the results, thereby suggesting that the kinetics of the response may be variable. However, the lack of significant differences in most assays at most times suggests that the RBE for both entry and peak regions of the Bragg curve was essentially 1.0 under the conditions of this study. The greatest immunodepression was observed at 4 days postexposure. Flow cytometry and mitogenic stimulation analyses of the spleen and peripheral blood demonstrated that lymphocyte populations differ in radiosensitivity, with B (CD19(+)) cells being most sensitive, T (CD3(+)) cells being moderately sensitive, and natural killer (NK1.1(+)) cells being most resistant. B lymphocytes showed the most rapid recovery. Comparison of the T-lymphocyte subsets showed that CD4(+) T helper/inducer cells were more radiosensitive than the CD8(+) T cytotoxic/suppressor cells. These findings should have an impact on future studies designed to maximize protection of normal tissue during and after proton-radiation exposure.

Value and perspectives of proton radiation therapy for limited stage prostate cancer.

BACKGROUND: This review article will focus on clinical results and limitations of proton beam irradiation. Possible technological, biological and medical perspectives will be addressed. PATIENTS AND METHODS: A total of 911 patients with limited stage prostate cancer were treated with proton beam irradiation at Loma Linda University between 1991 and 1996. Endpoints of this evaluation were biochemically no evidence of disease survival (bNED) as well as acute and late treatment-related toxicity. RESULTS: The bNED survival rate was 82% at 5 years. Among 870 patients evaluable for late toxicity the following late effects were observed: Grade 3/4: 0%, Grade 2 rectal: 3.5% and bladder: 5.4%. CONCLUSIONS: Despite relatively short follow-up times it seems justified to conclude that proton beam irradiation of prostate cancer can improve bNED rates by 10% and decrease Grade 2 late effects by more than 10%. There were no Grade 3 and 4 late effects.

Combination of pGL1-TNF-alpha gene and radiation (proton and gamma-ray) therapy against brain tumor.

The major goal of this study was to determine if treatment with the newly constructed plasmid vector for tumor necrosis factor-alpha (pGL1-TNF-alpha) could enhance the radiation-induced growth reduction of C6 rat glioma. In addition, two different forms of ionizing radiation (gamma-rays and protons) were utilized. Body and spleen mass, leukocyte blastogenesis, and flow cytometry analysis of cell populations in blood and spleen were performed to detect toxicity, if any, and to identify mechanisms that may correlate with the anti-tumor action of combination therapy. C6 tumor cells were implanted subcutaneously into athymic mice and allowed to become established before treatment initiation. pGL1-TNF-alpha was injected into the implanted tumors, which were then irradiated 16-18 hr later; each modality was administered three times over 8-9 days. The addition of pGL1-TNF-alpha significantly enhanced the anti-tumor effect of radiation (p < 0.05). The effect was more than additive, since pGL1-TNF-alpha alone did not slow tumor progression and radiation alone had only a modest effect. Administration of pGL1-TNF-alpha together with proton radiation resulted in tumor volumes that were 23% smaller than those following pGL1-TNF-alpha + gamma-ray treatment; a similar differential in tumor size was observed in the groups receiving only radiation. Body weights and blood and spleen cell analyses did not reveal treatment-related toxicity. High basal proliferation of blood leukocytes and increased B cell levels in the spleen were associated with pGL1-TNF-alpha + 60Co (gamma-radiation) or proton treatment. Overall, the results suggest that the pGL1-TNF-alpha/radiation combination is effective and safe under the conditions employed. This is the first study to combine gene and proton radiation therapy and to show, under controlled experimental conditions, that proton radiation may have a greater effect against malignant tumors compared to the same physical dose of gamma-radiation.