Improved method for measuring the ensemble average of strand breaks in genomic DNA.

The cis-syn cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer (CPD) is the major photoproduct induced in DNA by low wavelength ultraviolet radiation. An improved method was developed to detect CPD formation and removal in genomic DNA that avoids the problems encountered with the standard method of endonuclease detection of these photoproducts. Since CPD-specific endonucleases make single-strand cuts at CPD sites, quantification of the frequency of CPDs in DNA is usually done by denaturing gel electrophoresis. The standard method of ethidium bromide staining and gel photography requires more than 10 microg of DNA per gel lane, and correction of the photographic signal for the nonlinear film response. To simplify this procedure, a standard Southern blot protocol, coupled with phosphorimage analysis, was developed. This method uses random hybridization probes to detect genomic sequences with minimal sequence bias. Because of the vast linearity range of phosphorimage detection, scans of the signal profiles for the heterogeneous population of DNA fragments can be integrated directly to determine the number-average size of the population.

DNA repair of a single UV photoproduct in a designed nucleosome.

Eukaryotic DNA repair enzymes must interact with the architectural hierarchy of chromatin. The challenge of finding damaged DNA complexed with histone proteins in nucleosomes is complicated by the need to maintain local chromatin structures involved in regulating other DNA processing events. The heterogeneity of lesions induced by DNA-damaging agents has led us to design homogeneously damaged substrates to directly compare repair of naked DNA with that of nucleosomes. Here we report that nucleotide excision repair in Xenopus nuclear extracts can effectively repair a single UV radiation photoproduct located 5 bases from the dyad center of a positioned nucleosome, although the nucleosome is repaired at about half the rate at which the naked DNA fragment is. Extract repair within the nucleosome is >50-fold more rapid than either enzymatic photoreversal or endonuclease cleavage of the lesion in vitro. Furthermore, nucleosome formation occurs (after repair) only on damaged naked DNA (165-bp fragments) during a 1-h incubation in these extracts, even in the presence of a large excess of undamaged DNA. This is an example of selective nucleosome assembly by Xenopus nuclear extracts on a short linear DNA fragment containing a DNA lesion.

Low- and high-resolution mapping of DNA damage at specific sites.

Measurement of DNA damage and repair at the nucleotide level in intact cells has provided compelling evidence for the molecular details of these events as they occur in intact organisms. Furthermore, these measurements give the most accurate picture of the rates of repair in different structural domains of DNA in chromatin. In this report, we describe two methods currently used in our laboratories to map DNA lesions at (or near) nucleotide resolution in yeast cells. The low-resolution method couples damage-specific strand breaks in DNA with indirect end-labeling to measure DNA lesions over a span of 1.5 to 2 kb of DNA sequence. The resolution of this method is limited by the resolution of DNA length measurements on alkaline agarose gels (about +/-20 bp on average). The high-resolution method uses streptavidin magnetic beads and special biotinylated oligonucleotides to facilitate end-labeling of DNA fragments specifically cleaved at damage sites. The latter method maps DNA damage sites at nucleotide resolution over a shorter distance (<500 bp), and is constrained to the length of DNA resolvable on DNA sequencing gels. These methods are used in tandem for answering questions regarding DNA damage and repair in different chromatin domains and states of gene expression.

Nucleotide excision repair of the 5 S ribosomal RNA gene assembled into a nucleosome.

A-175-base pair fragment containing the Xenopus borealis somatic 5 S ribosomal RNA gene was used as a model system to determine the effect of nucleosome assembly on nucleotide excision repair (NER) of the major UV photoproduct (cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer (CPD)) in DNA. Xenopus oocyte nuclear extracts were used to carry out repair in vitro on reconstituted, positioned 5 S rDNA nucleosomes. Nucleosome structure strongly inhibits NER at many CPD sites in the 5 S rDNA fragment while having little effect at a few sites. The time course of CPD removal at 35 different sites indicates that >85% of the CPDs in the naked DNA fragment have t(12) values <2 h, whereas <26% of the t(12) values in nucleosomes are <2 h, and 15% are >8 h. Moreover, removal of histone tails from these mononucleosomes has little effect on the repair rates. Finally, nucleosome inhibition of repair shows no correlation with the rotational setting of a 14-nucleotide-long pyrimidine tract located 30 base pairs from the nucleosome dyad. These results suggest that inhibition of NER by mononucleosomes is not significantly influenced by the rotational orientation of CPDs on the histone surface, and histone tails play little (or no) role in this inhibition.

The oxidative DNA lesion 8,5'-(S)-cyclo-2'-deoxyadenosine is repaired by the nucleotide excision repair pathway and blocks gene expression in mammalian cells.

Xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) patients with inherited defects in nucleotide excision repair (NER) are unable to excise from their DNA bulky photoproducts induced by UV radiation and therefore develop accelerated actinic damage, including cancer, on sun-exposed tissue. Some XP patients also develop a characteristic neurodegeneration believed to result from their inability to repair neuronal DNA damaged by endogenous metabolites since the harmful UV radiation in sunlight does not reach neurons. Free radicals, which are abundant in neurons, induce DNA lesions that, if unrepaired, might cause the XP neurodegeneration. Searching for such a lesion, we developed a synthesis for 8,5'-(S)-cyclo-2'-deoxyadenosine (cyclo-dA), a free radical-induced bulky lesion, and incorporated it into DNA to test its repair in mammalian cell extracts and living cells. Using extracts of normal and mutant Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells to test for NER and adult rat brain extracts to test for base excision repair, we found that cyclo-dA is repaired by NER and not by base excision repair. We measured host cell reactivation, which reflects a cell's capacity for NER, by transfecting CHO and XP cells with DNA constructs containing a single cyclo-dA or a cyclobutane thymine dimer at a specific site on the transcribed strand of a luciferase reporter gene. We found that, like the cyclobutane thymine dimer, cyclo-dA is a strong block to gene expression in CHO and human cells. Cyclo-dA was repaired extremely poorly in NER-deficient CHO cells and in cells from patients in XP complementation group A with neurodegeneration. Based on these findings, we propose that cyclo-dA is a candidate for an endogenous DNA lesion that might contribute to neurodegeneration in XP.

Mitotic viability and metabolic competence in UV-irradiated yeast cells.

Colony formation is the classic method for measuring survival of yeast cells. This method measures mitotic viability and can underestimate the fraction of cells capable of carrying out other DNA processing events. Here, we report an alternative method, based on cell metabolism, to determine the fraction of surviving cells after ultraviolet (UV) irradiation. The reduction of 2,3,5-triphenyl tetrazolium chloride (or TTC) to formazan in mitochondria was compared with cell colony formation and DNA repair capacity in wt cells and two repair-deficient strains (rad1Delta and rad7Delta). Both TTC reduction and cell colony formation gave a linear response with different ratios of mitotically viable cells and heat-inactivated cells. However, monitoring the formation of formazan in non-dividing yeast cells that are partially (rad7Delta) or totally (wt) proficient at DNA repair is a more accurate measure of cell survival after UV irradiation. Before repair of UV photoproducts (cis-syn cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers or CPDs) is complete, these two assays give very different results, implying that many damaged cells are metabolically competent but cannot replicate. For example, only 25% of the rad7Delta cells are mitotically viable after a UV dose of 12 J/m(2)75% of these cells are metabolically competent and remove over 55% of the CPDs from their genomic DNA. Moreover, repair of CPDs in wt cells dramatically decreases after the first few hours of liquid holding (L.H.; incubation in water) and correlates with a substantial decrease in cell metabolism over the same time period. In contrast, cell colony formation may be the more accurate indicator of cell survival after UV irradiation of rad1Delta cells (i.e., cells with little DNA repair activity). These results indicate that the metabolic competence of UV-irradiated, non-dividing yeast cells is a much better indicator of cell survival than mitotic viability in partially (or totally) repair proficient yeast cultures.

Ultraviolet damage and nucleosome folding of the 5S ribosomal RNA gene.

The Xenopus borealis somatic 5S ribosomal RNA gene was used as a model system to determine the mutual effects of nucleosome folding and formation of ultraviolet (UV) photoproducts (primarily cis-syn cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers, or CPDs) in chromatin. We analyzed the preferred rotational and translational settings of 5S rDNA on the histone octamer surface after induction of up to 0.8 CPD/nucleosome core (2.5 kJ/m(2) UV dose). DNase I and hydroxyl radical footprints indicate that UV damage at these levels does not affect the average rotational setting of the 5S rDNA molecules. Moreover, a combination of nuclease trimming and restriction enzyme digestion indicates the preferred translational positions of the histone octamer are not affected by this level of UV damage. We also did not observe differences in the UV damage patterns of irradiated 5S rDNA before or after nucleosome formation, indicating there is little difference in the inhibition of nucleosome folding by specific CPD sites in the 5S rRNA gene. Conversely, nucleosome folding significantly restricts CPD formation at all sites in the three helical turns of the nontranscribed strand located in the dyad axis region of the nucleosome, where DNA is bound exclusively by the histone H3-H4 tetramer. Finally, modulation of the CPD distribution in a 14 nt long pyrimidine tract correlates with its rotational setting on the histone surface, when the strong sequence bias for CPD formation in this tract is minimized by normalization. These results help establish the mutual roles of histone binding and UV photoproducts on their formation in chromatin.

Accessing DNA damage in chromatin: insights from transcription.

Recently, there has been a convergence of fields studying the processing of DNA, such as transcription, replication, and repair. This convergence has been centered around the packaging of DNA in chromatin. Chromatin structure affects all aspects of DNA processing because it modulates access of proteins to DNA. Therefore, a central theme has become the mechanism(s) for accessing DNA in chromatin. It seems likely that mechanisms involved in one of these processes may also be used in others. For example, the discovery of transcriptional coactivators with histone acetyltransferase activity and chromatin remodeling complexes has provided possible mechanisms required for efficient repair of DNA in chromatin.

Nucleotide excision repair in a constitutive and inducible gene of a yeast minichromosome in intact cells.

Repair of UV-induced cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPDs) was measured in a yeast minichromosome, having a galactose-inducible GAL1:URA3 fusion gene, a constitutively expressed HIS3 gene and varied regions of chromatin structure. Transcription of GAL1:URA3 increased >150-fold, while HIS3 expression decreased <2-fold when cells were switched from glucose to galactose medium. Following galactose induction, four nucleosomes were displaced or rearranged in the GAL3-GAL10 region. However, no change in nucleosome arrangement was observed in other regions of the minichromosome following induction, indicating that only a few plasmid molecules actively transcribe at any one time. Repair at 269 cis-syn CPD sites revealed moderate preferential repair of the transcribed strand of GAL1:URA3 in galactose, consistent with transcription-coupled repair in a fraction of these genes. Many sites upstream of the transcription start site in the transcribed strand were also repaired faster upon induction. There is remarkable repair heterogeneity in the HIS3 gene and preferential repair is seen only in a short sequence immediately downstream of the transcription start site. Finally, a mild correlation of repair heterogeneity with nucleosome positions was observed in the transcribed strand of the inactive GAL1:URA3 gene and this correlation was abolished upon galactose induction.

Synthesis and nucleosome structure of DNA containing a UV photoproduct at a specific site.

A strategy was developed to assemble nucleosomes specifically damaged at only one site and one structural orientation. The most prevalent UV photoproduct, a cis-syn cyclobutane thymine dimer (cs CTD), was chemically synthesized and incorporated into a 30 base oligonucleotide harboring the glucocorticoid hormone response element. This oligonucleotide was assembled into a 165 base pair double stranded DNA molecule with nucleosome positioning elements on each side of the cs CTD-containing insert. Proton NMR verified that the synthetic photoproduct is the cis-syn stereoisomer of the CTD. Moreover, two different pyrimidine dimer-specific endonucleases cut approximately 90% of the dsDNA molecules. This cleavage is completely reversed by photoreactivation with E. coli UV photolyase, further demonstrating the correct stereochemistry of the photoproduct. Nucleosomes were reconstituted by histone octamer exchange from chicken erythocyte core particles, and contained a unique translational and rotational setting of the insert on the histone surface. Hydroxyl radical footprinting demonstrates that the minor groove at the cs CTD is positioned away from the histone surface about 5 bases from the nucleosome dyad. Competitive gel-shift analysis indicates there is a small increase in histone binding energy required for the damaged fragment (DeltaDeltaG approximately 0.15 kcal/mol), which does not prevent complete nucleosome loading under our conditions. Finally, folding of the synthetic DNA into nucleosomes dramatically inhibits cleavage at the cs CTD by T4 endonuclease V and photoreversal by UV photolyase. Thus, specifically damaged nucleosomes can be experimentally designed for in vitro DNA repair studies.

Base excision repair of N-methylpurines in a yeast minichromosome. Effects of transcription, dna sequence, and nucleosome positioning.

Base excision repair of dimethyl sulfate induced N-methylpurines (NMPs) was measured in a yeast minichromosome that has a galactose-inducible GAL1:URA3 fusion gene, a constitutively expressed HIS3 gene, and varied regions of chromatin structure. Removal rates of NMPs varied dramatically (>20-fold) at different sites along three selected fragments encompassing a total length of 1775 base pairs. Repair of NMPs was not coupled to transcription, because the transcribed strands of HIS3 and induced GAL1:URA3 were not repaired faster than the nontranscribed strands. However, the repair rate of NMPs was significantly affected by the nearest neighbor nucleotides. Slow repair occurred at NMPs between purines, especially guanines, whereas fast repair occurred at NMPs between pyrimidines. NMPs between a purine and pyrimidine were repaired at moderate rates. Moreover, a rough correlation between nucleosome positions and repair rates exists in some but not all regions that were analyzed.

Tight correlation between inhibition of DNA repair in vitro and transcription factor IIIA binding in a 5S ribosomal RNA gene.

UV-induced photoproducts (cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers, CPDs) in DNA are removed by nucleotide excision repair (NER), and the presence of transcription factors on DNA can restrict the accessibility of NER enzymes. We have investigatigated the modulation of NER in a gene promoter using the Xenopus transcription factor IIIA (TFIIIA)-5S rDNA complex and Xenopus oocyte nuclear extracts. TFIIIA alters CPD formation primarily in the transcribed strand of the 50 bp internal control region (ICR) of 5S rDNA. During NER in vitro, CPD removal is reduced at most sites in both strands of the ICR when TFIIIA is bound. Efficient repair occurs just outside the TFIIIA-binding site (within 10 bp), and in the absence of 5S rRNA transcription. Interestingly, three CPD sites within the ICR [+56, +75 (transcribed strand) and +73 (non-transcribed strand)] are repaired rapidly when TFIIIA is bound, while CPDs within approximately 5 bases of these sites are repaired much more slowly. CPDs at these three sites may partially displace TFIIIA, thereby enabling rapid repair. However, TFIIIA is not completely displaced during NER, at least at sites outside the ICR, even though the NER complex could be sterically hindered by TFIIIA. Such inefficient repair of transcription factor binding sites could increase mutation frequency in regulatory regions of genes.

Modulation of DNA damage and DNA repair in chromatin.

DNA is packaged in the highly compact and dynamic structure of chromatin in eukaryotic cells. It is generally accepted that DNA processing events in the nucleus, such as transcription, replication, recombination, and repair, are restricted by this packaging. For some processes (e.g., transcription), the chromatin fiber is "preset" in a more open structure to allow access of proteins to specific regions of DNA within this structural hierarchy. These regions contain modified nucleosomes that accommodate a less compact state of chromatin and allow access to specific regions of DNA. DNA repair proteins, however, must access DNA lesions in all structural domains of chromatin after sudden insult to the genome. Damaged DNA must be recognized, removed, and replaced by repair enzymes at all levels of chromatin packaging. Therefore, the modulation of DNA damage and its repair in chromatin is crucial to our understanding of the fate of potential mutagenic and carcinogenic lesions in DNA. In this review, we discuss the modulation of DNA damage and DNA repair by chromatin structure, and the modulation of chromatin structure by these events.

Nucleosome unfolding during DNA repair in normal and xeroderma pigmentosum (group C) human cells.

The fate of nucleosomes during nucleotide excision repair is unclear. We have used organomercurial chromatography to capture accessible thiol groups of proteins at (or near) nascent repair sites in normal and xeroderma pigmentosum (group C) human cells. The reactive groups include cysteine 110 of histone H3, which is exposed in unfolded nucleosomes. Immediately after UV irradiation and a short pulse labeling of repair patches, intact nuclei were digested with restriction enzymes to release approximately 18% of the chromatin into soluble fragments, which are enriched (approximately 4-fold) in a constitutively transcribed gene. Upon organomercurial affinity fractionation, approximately 1.8% of the soluble chromatin remains bound in high salt (0.5 M NaCl) and is released with dithiothreitol. In normal cell chromatin, this fraction is enriched in nascent repair patches (1.5-1.8-fold) over the unbound fraction. This enrichment decreases following short chase periods with a time course similar to the loss of enhanced nuclease sensitivity of these regions (t 1/2 approximately 30 min). Much less enrichment of nascent repair patches is observed in the thiol-reactive fraction from XPC cells, which repair primarily the transcribed strand of active genes. These results suggest that transient nucleosome unfolding occurs during nucleotide excision repair in normal human cells, and this unfolding may require the XPC protein.

Strand-specific modulation of UV photoproducts in 5S rDNA by TFIIIA binding and their effect on TFIIIA complex formation.

The relationship between UV-induced photoproduct formation and transcription factor binding was studied in a 214 bp fragment containing the entire Xenopus borealis 5S rRNA gene. DNA mobility shift and DNase I footprinting show a strong inhibition of TFIIIA binding to UV-damaged 5S rDNA. An average of approximately 2 cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPDs) per 214 bp fragment, and a lesser amount of pyrimidine-pyrimidone (6-4) dimers, reduced the fraction of TFIIIA bound by approximately 70%. Furthermore, irradiation of the TFIIIA/5S rDNA complex displaces TFIIIA at doses of 0.8-2 CPDs/fragment, indicating the complex is unable to accommodate UV photoproducts. UV photofootprinting of the 50 bp TFIIIA binding region of 5S rDNA (or ICR) shows that TFIIIA binding modulates photoproduct formation primarily in the template strand. Formation of CPDs at six different sites is strongly inhibited, while another CPD site is strongly enhanced, by TFIIIA binding. Most of these sites are located in one of three boxes (A, IE, or C) designated as TFIIIA contact sites in the ICR, while one site is between these boxes. Formation of (6-4) dimers is also inhibited at several sites in the template strand by TFIIIA binding. However, formation of photoproducts in the nontemplate strand is much less affected by TFIIIA binding, where only one CPD site is inhibited in the complex. These data indicate that formation of UV photoproducts in 5S rDNA can be markedly affected by TFIIIA binding, and complex formation is inhibited by UV photoproducts.

DNA damage can alter the stability of nucleosomes: effects are dependent on damage type.

We have investigated the effects of DNA damage by (+/-)-anti-benzo[a]pyrene diol epoxide (BPDE) and UV light on the formation of a positioned nucleosome in the Xenopus borealis 5S rRNA gene. Gel-shift analysis of the reconstituted products indicates that BPDE damage facilitates the formation of a nucleosome onto this sequence. Competitive reconstitution experiments show that average levels of 0.5, 0.9, and 2.1 BPDE adducts/146 bp of 5S DNA (i.e., the size of DNA associated with a nucleosome core particle) yield changes of -220, -290, and -540 cal/mol, respectively, in the free energy (delta G) of nucleosome formation. These values yield increases of core histone binding to 5S DNA (K(a)) of 1.4-, 1.6-, and 2.5-fold, compared with undamaged DNA. Conversely, irradiation with UV light decreases nucleosome formation. Irradiation at either 500 or 2500 J/m2 of UV light [0.6 and 0.8 cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer/146 bp (on average), respectively] results in respective changes of +130 and +250 cal/mol. This translates to decreases in core histone binding to irradiated 5S DNA (K(a)) of 1.2- and 1.5-fold compared with undamaged DNA. These results indicate that nucleosome stability can be markedly affected by the formation of certain DNA lesions. Such changes could have major effects on the kinetics of DNA processing events.

The octadecanoid signalling pathway in plants mediates a response to ultraviolet radiation.

Many plant genes that respond to environmental and developmental changes are regulated by jasmonic acid, which is derived from linolenic acid via the octadecanoid pathway. Linolenic acid is an important fatty-acid constituent of membranes in most plant species and its intracellular levels increase in response to certain signals. Here we report that irradiation of tomato leaves with ultraviolet light induces the expression of several plant defensive genes that are normally activated through the octadecanoid pathway after wounding. The response to ultraviolet light is blocked by an inhibitor of the octadecanoid pathway and it does not occur in a tomato mutant defective in this pathway. The ultraviolet irradiation maximally induces the defence genes at levels where cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer formation, an indicator of DNA damage, is less than 0.2 dimers per gene. Our evidence indicates that this plant defence response to certain wavelengths of ultraviolet radiation requires the activation of the octadecanoid defence signalling pathway.

Rad23 is required for transcription-coupled repair and efficient overrall repair in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

The repair of UV-induced photoproducts (cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers) in a well-characterized minichromosome, genomic DNA, and a transcribed genomic gene (RPB2) of a rad23delta mutant of Saccharomyces care was examined. Isogenic wild-type cells show a strong bias for the repair of the transcribed strands in both the plasmid and genomic genes and efficient overall repair of both DNAs (>80% of the dimers were removed in 6 h). However, the rad23delta mutant shows (i) no strand bias for repair in these genes and decreased repair of both strands, (ii) partial repair of genomic DNA (approximately 45% in 6 h), and (iii) very poor repair of the plasmid overall approximately 15% in 6 h). These features, coupled with the decreased UV survival of rad23delta cells, indicate that Rad23 is required for both transcription-coupled repair and efficient overall repair in S. cerevisiae.

Strand breaks are repaired efficiently in human ribosomal genes.

We examined repair of DNA strand breaks induced by the anti-cancer drug bleomycin in both Pol I and Pol II transcribed genes in permeabilized human fibroblasts. The majority of these breaks (>80%) are single strand breaks (SSBs) thought to be repaired by base excision repair enzymes. Repair was examined in each strand of a 7. 2-kilobase fragment, completely within the Pol I transcribed region of ribosomal DNA (rDNA) and an 8.3-kilobase fragment completely within the Pol II transcribed region of the dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) gene. Bleomycin dose-response studies revealed no bias for SSBs in either strand of the rDNA fragment. Furthermore, repair of SSBs is rapid (approximately 80% resealed in 60 min) in both the transcribed and nontranscribed strands of rDNA. Rapid repair of SSBs is also observed in both strands of the DHFR gene (approximately 60% resealed in 60 min). In contrast, little (or no) repair of UV photodimers occurs in either strand of human rDNA, regardless of whether cells are confluent or actively growing. Thus, DNA lesions in human ribosomal genes may be more accessible to base excision repair enzymes than those involved in nucleotide excision repair.