Unnatural amino acids increase sensitivity and provide for the design of highly selective caspase substrates.

Traditional combinatorial peptidyl substrate library approaches generally utilize natural amino acids, limiting the usefulness of this tool in generating selective substrates for proteases that share similar substrate specificity profiles. To address this limitation, we synthesized a Hybrid Combinatorial Substrate Library (HyCoSuL) with the general formula of Ac-P4-P3-P2-Asp-ACC, testing the approach on a family of closely related proteases - the human caspases. The power of this library for caspase discrimination extends far beyond traditional PS-SCL approach, as in addition to 19 natural amino acids we also used 110 diverse unnatural amino acids that can more extensively explore the chemical space represented by caspase-active sites. Using this approach we identified and employed peptide-based substrates that provided excellent discrimination between individual caspases, allowing us to simultaneously resolve the individual contribution of the apical caspase-9 and the executioner caspase-3 and caspase-7 in the development of cytochrome-c-dependent apoptosis for the first time.

Activation mechanism and substrate specificity of the Drosophila initiator caspase DRONC.

Drosophila Nedd2-like caspase (DRONC), an initiator caspase in Drosophila melanogaster and ortholog of human caspase-9, is cleaved during its activation in vitro and in vivo. We show that, in contrast to conclusions from previous studies, cleavage is neither necessary nor sufficient for DRONC activation. Instead, our data suggest that DRONC is activated by dimerization, a mechanism used by its counterparts in humans. Subsequent cleavage at Glu352 stabilizes the active dimer. Since cleavage is at a Glu residue, it has been proposed that DRONC is a dual Asp- and Glu-specific caspase. We used positional-scanning peptide libraries to define the P1-P4 peptide sequence preferences of DRONC, and show that it is indeed equally active on optimized tetrapeptides containing either Asp or Glu in P1. Furthermore, mutagenesis reveals that Asp and Glu residues are equally tolerated at the primary autoprocessing site of DRONC itself. However, when its specificity is tested on a natural substrate, the Drosophila executioner caspase DRICE, a clear preference for Asp emerges. The formerly proposed Glu preference is thus incorrect. DRONC does not differentiate between Asp and Glu in poor substrates, but prefers Asp when tested on a good substrate.

The mechanism of peptide-binding specificity of IAP BIR domains.

We describe the peptide-binding specificity of the baculoviral IAP repeat (BIR) domains of the human inhibitor of apoptosis (IAP) proteins, X-linked IAP, cellular IAP1 and neuronal apoptosis inhibitory protein (NAIP). Synthetic peptide libraries were used to profile each domain, and we distinguish two types of binding specificity, which we refer to as type II and type III BIR domains. Both types have a dominant selectivity for Ala in the first position of the four N-terminal residues of the peptide ligands, which constitute a core recognition motif. Our analysis allows us to define the signature of type III BIRs that demonstrate a preference for Pro in the third residue of the ligand, resembling the classic IAP-binding motif (IBM). The signature of the type II BIRs was similar to type III, but with a striking absence of specificity for Pro in the third position, suggesting that the definition of an IBM must be modified depending on the type of BIR in question. These findings explain how subtle changes in the peptide-binding groove of IAP BIR domains can significantly alter the target protein selectivity. Our analysis allows for prediction of BIR domain protein-binding preferences, provides a context for understanding the mechanism of peptide selection and heightens our knowledge of the specificity of IAP antagonists that are being developed as cancer therapeutics.

Mechanism-based inactivation of caspases by the apoptotic suppressor p35.

Caspases play a crucial role in the ability of animal cells to kill themselves by apoptosis. Caspase activity is regulated in vivo by members of three distinct protease inhibitor families, one of which--p35--has so far only been found in baculoviruses. P35 has previously been shown to rapidly form essentially irreversible complexes with its target caspases in a process that is accompanied by peptide bond cleavage. To determine the protease-inhibitory pathway utilized by this very selective protease inhibitor, we have analyzed the thermodynamic and kinetic stability of the protein. We show that the conformation of p35 is stabilized following cleavage within its reactive site loop. An inactive catalytic mutant of caspase 3 is bound by p35, but much less avidly than the wild-type enzyme, indicating that the protease catalytic nucleophile is required for stable complex formation. The inhibited protease is trapped as a covalent adduct, most likely with its catalytic Cys esterified to the carbonyl carbon of the scissile peptide bond. Together these data reveal that p35 is a mechanism-based inactivator that has adopted an inhibitory device reminiscent of the widely distributed serpin family, despite a complete lack of sequence or structural homology.

Inhibition of distant caspase homologues by natural caspase inhibitors.

Caspases play an important role in the ability of animal cells to kill themselves by apoptosis. Caspase activity is regulated in vivo by members of three distinct protease inhibitor families, two of which, baculovirus p35 and members of the inhibitor of apoptosis (IAP) family, are thought to be caspase specific. However, caspases are members of the clan of cysteine proteases designated CD, which also includes animal and plant legumains, and the bacterial proteases clostripain, gingipain-R and gingipain-K. Since these proteases have been proposed to have a common mechanism and evolutionary origin, we hypothesized that the caspase inhibitors may also regulate these other proteases. We tested this hypothesis by examining the effect of the natural caspase inhibitors on other members of protease clan CD. The IAP family proteins were found to have only a slight inhibitory effect on gingipain-R. The cowpox viral cytokine-response modifier A (CrmA) serpin had no effect on any of the proteases tested but a single point mutation of CrmA (Asp-->Lys) resulted in strong inhibition of gingipain-K. More substantial, with respect to the hypothesis, was the strong inhibition of gingipain-K by wild-type p35. The site in p35, required for inhibition of gingipain-K, was mapped to Lys94, seven residues C-terminal to the caspase inhibitory site. Our data indicate that the virally encoded caspase inhibitors have adopted a mechanism that allows them to regulate disparate members of clan CD proteases.

Lysosomal protease pathways to apoptosis. Cleavage of bid, not pro-caspases, is the most likely route.

We investigated the mechanism of lysosome-mediated cell death using purified recombinant pro-apoptotic proteins, and cell-free extracts from the human neuronal progenitor cell line NT2. Potential effectors were either isolated lysosomes or purified lysosomal proteases. Purified lysosomal cathepsins B, H, K, L, S, and X or an extract of mouse lysosomes did not directly activate either recombinant caspase zymogens or caspase zymogens present in an NT2 cytosolic extract to any significant extent. In contrast, a cathepsin L-related protease from the protozoan parasite Trypanosoma cruzi, cruzipain, showed a measurable caspase activation rate. This demonstrated that members of the papain family can directly activate caspases but that mammalian lysosomal members of this family may have been negatively selected for caspase activation to prevent inappropriate induction of apoptosis. Given the lack of evidence for a direct role in caspase activation by lysosomal proteases, we hypothesized that an indirect mode of caspase activation may involve the Bcl-2 family member Bid. In support of this, Bid was cleaved in the presence of lysosomal extracts, at a site six residues downstream from that seen for pathways involving capase 8. Incubation of mitochondria with Bid that had been cleaved by lysosomal extracts resulted in cytochrome c release. Thus, cleavage of Bid may represent a mechanism by which proteases that have leaked from the lysosomes can precipitate cytochrome c release and subsequent caspase activation. This is supported by the finding that cytosolic extracts from mice ablated in the bid gene are impaired in the ability to release cytochrome c in response to lysosome extracts. Together these data suggest that Bid represents a sensor that allows cells to initiate apoptosis in response to widespread adventitious proteolysis.

Crystal structure of the apoptotic suppressor CrmA in its cleaved form.

BACKGROUND: Cowpox virus expresses the serpin CrmA (cytokine response modifier A) in order to avoid inflammatory and apoptotic responses of infected host cells. The targets of CrmA are members of the caspase family of proteases that either initiate the extrinsic pathway of apoptosis (caspases 8 and 10) or trigger activation of the pro-inflammatory cytokines interleukin-1beta and interleukin-18 (caspase 1). RESULTS: We have determined the structure of a cleaved form of CrmA to 2.26 A resolution. CrmA has the typical fold of a cleaved serpin, even though it lacks the N-terminal half of the A helix, the entire D helix, and a portion of the E helix that are present in all other known serpins. The reactive-site loop of CrmA was mutated to contain the optimal substrate recognition sequence for caspase 3; however, the mutation only marginally increased the ability of CrmA to inhibit caspase 3. Superposition of the reactive-site loop of alpha1-proteinase inhibitor on the cleaved CrmA structure provides a model for virgin CrmA that can be docked to caspase 1, but not to caspase 3. CONCLUSIONS: CrmA exemplifies viral economy, selective pressure having resulted in a 'minimal' serpin that lacks the regions not needed for structural integrity or inhibitory activity. The docking model provides an explanation for the selectivity of CrmA. Our demonstration that engineering optimal substrate recognition sequences into the CrmA reactive-site loop fails to generate a good caspase 3 inhibitor is consistent with the docking model.

Caspase-14 is a novel developmentally regulated protease.

Caspases are a family of cysteine proteases related to interleukin-1 converting enzyme (ICE) and represent the effector arm of the cell death pathway. The zymogen form of all caspases is composed of a prodomain plus large and small catalytic subunits. Herein we report the characterization of a novel caspase, MICE (for mini-ICE), also designated caspase-14, that possesses an unusually short prodomain and is highly expressed in embryonic tissues but absent from all adult tissues examined. In contrast to the other short prodomain caspases (caspase-3, caspase-6, and caspase-7), MICE preferentially associates with large prodomain caspases, including caspase-1, caspase-2, caspase-4, caspase-8, and caspase-10. Also unlike the other short prodomain caspases, MICE was not processed by multiple death stimuli including activation of members of the tumor necrosis factor receptor family and expression of proapoptotic members of the bcl-2 family. Surprisingly, however, overexpression of MICE itself induced apoptosis in MCF7 human breast cancer cells, which was attenuated by traditional caspase inhibitors.

The DCC gene product induces apoptosis by a mechanism requiring receptor proteolysis.

The development of colonic carcinoma is associated with the mutation of a specific set of genes. One of these, DCC (deleted in colorectal cancer), is a candidate tumour-suppressor gene, and encodes a receptor for netrin-1, a molecule involved in axon guidance. Loss of DCC expression in tumours is not restricted to colon carcinoma, and, although there is no increase in the frequency of tumour formation in DCC hemizygous mice, reestablishment of DCC expression suppresses tumorigenicity. However, the mechanism of action of DCC is unknown. Here we show that DCC induces apoptosis in the absence of ligand binding, but blocks apoptosis when engaged by netrin-1. Furthermore, DCC is a caspase substrate, and mutation of the site at which caspase-3 cleaves DCC suppresses the pro-apoptotic effect of DCC completely. These results indicate that DCC may function as a tumour-suppressor protein by inducing apoptosis in settings in which ligand is unavailable (for example, during metastasis or tumour growth beyond local blood supply) through functional caspase cascades by a mechanism that requires cleavage of DCC at Asp 1,290.

Interaction of the baculovirus anti-apoptotic protein p35 with caspases. Specificity, kinetics, and characterization of the caspase/p35 complex.

The anti-apoptotic protein p35 from baculovirus is thought to prevent the suicidal response of infected insect cells by inhibiting caspases. Ectopic expression of p35 in a number of transgenic animals or cell lines is also anti-apoptotic, giving rise to the hypothesis that the protein is a general inhibitor of caspases. We have verified this hypothesis by demonstrating that purified recombinant p35 inhibits human caspase-1, -3, -6, -7, -8, and -10 with kass values from 1.2 x 10(3) to 7 x 10(5) (M-1 s-1), and with upper limits of Ki values from 0.1 to 9 nM. Inhibition of 12 unrelated serine or cysteine proteases was insignificant, implying that p35 is a potent caspase-specific inhibitor. Mutation of the putative inhibitory loop to favor caspase-1 resulted in a substantial decline in caspase-3 inhibition, but minimal changes in caspase-1 inhibition. The interaction p35 with caspase-3, as a model of the inhibitory mechanism, revealed classic slow-binding inhibition, with both active-sites of the caspase-3 dimer acting equally and independently. Inhibition resulted from complex formation between the enzyme and inhibitor, which could be visualized under nondenaturing conditions, but was dissociated by SDS to give p35 cleaved at Asp87, the P1 residue of the inhibitor. Complex formation requires the substrate-binding cleft to be unoccupied. Taken together, these data revealed that p35 is an active-site-directed inhibitor highly adapted to inhibiting caspases.

Proteolytic activation of the cell death protease Yama/CPP32 by granzyme B.

The serine protease granzyme B, which is secreted by cytotoxic cells, is one of the major effectors of apoptosis in susceptible targets. To examine the apoptotic mechanism of granzyme B, we have analyzed its effect on purified proteins that are thought to be components of death pathways inherent to cells. We demonstrate that granzyme B processes interleukin 1beta-converting enzyme (ICE) and the ICE-related protease Yama (also known as CPP32 or apopain) by limited proteolysis. Processing of ICE does not lead to activation. However, processing by granzyme B leads directly to the activation of Yama, which is now able to bind inhibitors and cleave the substrate poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase whose proteolysis is a marker of apoptosis initiated by several other stimuli. Thus ICE-related proteases can be activated by serine proteases that possess the correct specificity. Activation of pro-Yama by granzyme B is within the physiologic range. Thus the cytotoxic effect of granzyme B can be explained by its activation of an endogenous protease component of a programmed cell death pathway.