Risk assessment and management of new and existing chemicals.

An evaluation was made of the recently developed risk assessment methodologies for new and existing chemicals in the European Communities. The evaluation also included the methodologies to prioritize chemicals and procedures for risk management, i.e., the (draft) guidance document for the development of strategies for risk reduction. The way in which chemicals are prioritized is accepted with only very few comments. Clear progress has been made in the development and harmonization of risk assessment methodologies and the application of estimation methodologies. Nevertheless, improvements are necessary for the estimation of consumer and occupational exposure, the derivation, use and transparency of assessment factors for chemicals and classes of chemicals based on the mode of toxic action, environmental exposure models and their validation and relation with monitoring data. As far as risk management is concerned it was recommended to improve the integration of the myriad of directives and regulations, to clarify definitions, to provide clear guidance on the determination and weighing of advantages and implications of risk reduction measures and to develop tools, including voluntary agreements, to speed up the slow chemical-by-chemical approach.

Sequestration of environmental cadmium by metallothionein in the roach (Rutilus rutilus) and the stone loach (Noemacheilus barbatulus).

Two species of coarse fish that are relatively resistant to cadmium poisoning were exposed to sub-lethal concentrations of the metal in their aquarium water. Thus, roach were exposed to cadmium concentrations between 30 and 500 micrograms/l for periods of 14-70 days whereas stone loach were exposed to 1250 micrograms Cd/l for 21-77 days. Under all conditions of exposure, it was found upon analysis of the major organs of accumulation of cadmium in the two species that the toxic metal was sequestered by a single isoform of metallothionein. The amino acid compositions of roach and stone loach metallothionein were determined and found to be similar to those reported for other piscine metallothioneins. The two proteins were found to contain Cd:Zn:Cu in approximate ratios of 4:1:2 per mole of protein. The sequestration of Cd by metallothionein in the two resistant species of fish is contrasted with the situation observed previously in a cadmium-sensitive species, the rainbow trout.

Metallothionein gene expression and cadmium toxicity in freshwater fish.

Certain species of fish e.g. rainbow trout, are particularly susceptible to poisoning by cadmium in their aquatic environment whereas others e.g. roach and stone loach, are much more resistant. It is postulated that the vulnerability of the salmonids arises because 1) existing metallothionein (MT) in the tissues of these fish is unable to bind cadmium and 2) the toxic metal (in contrast to zinc) cannot switch on the gene(s) for apo-thionein production de novo. Consequently, cadmium is sequestered in the liver, kidney and gills of these fish by two low mol.wt. non-metallothionein proteins for which no excretion mechanism appears to exist.

Cadmium accumulation and protein binding patterns in tissues of the rainbow trout, Salmo gairdneri.

Rainbow trout were exposed to defined levels of cadmium in their aquarium water for differing periods at a variety of near-lethal concentrations that ensured the survival of the majority of the fish. The gills, liver and kidney together accounted for 99% of the accumulated load of body cadmium in the fish under these conditions. Although the proportion of total cadmium present in the liver remained relatively constant throughout, the distribution of the remainder between gill and kidney altered with the time of exposure. The cadmium in all three organs was bound by two low molecular weight proteins distinct in character from metallothionein. The isoforms of metallothionein were also present but were found to bind only zinc and copper. By contrast, when trout were injected with cadmium intraperitoneally, most of the metal accumulated in the liver where it was sequestered by the two isoforms of metallothionein. Pre-exposure of the trout to either a low concentration of cadmium (for several months) or to an elevated concentration of zinc (for 5 days) allowed the animals to survive a subsequent exposure to a high, otherwise lethal concentration of cadmium. The proteins responsible for sequestration of the two metals were identified, but two different mechanisms seemed to be involved in the protection of the animals. The significance of these observations in terms of the induction of proteins and the prevention of the toxic effects of cadmium is considered.

A comparison of the differential accumulation of cadmium in the tissues of three species of freshwater fish, Salmo gairdneri, Rutilus rutilus and Noemacheilus barbatulus.

Roach and stone loach were exposed to cadmium dissolved in their aquarium water at 500 and 1250 micrograms/l, respectively, and the distribution of the metal accumulated in the major body organs was determined. The pattern of distribution for each species was somewhat different and was distinct in each case from that observed previously with rainbow trout. The total body loads of cadmium accumulated by the three species were assessed during the period of exposure and found not to correlate directly with the concentration of cadmium to which the individual species had been exposed. An alternative comparator was devised which as the quotient of the total body cadmium accumulation (microgram/100 g body wt) and the notional cadmium dose (microgram/l) X weeks was described as a fractional retention coefficient for cadmium. The coefficient was constant for each species at different periods of exposure to cadmium alone. The values of the coefficient for roach and stone loach were however much lower than that for rainbow trout. When rainbow trout were preexposed to zinc (100 micrograms/l, 5 days) before being exposed to cadmium, the fractional retention coefficient for cadmium fell to a value similar to those seen with roach and stone loach exposed to cadmium alone. The significance of these observations in relation to the nature of the intracellular proteins to which cadmium is bound in the three species is discussed in the light of their differential susceptibility to the toxic effects of cadmium.

A comparison of the sequestration of cadmium and zinc in the tissues of rainbow trout (Salmo gairdneri) following exposure to the metals singly or in combination.

Rainbow trout were exposed to either cadmium (9 micrograms/l) or zinc (100 micrograms/l) in their aquarium water. They were then transferred to water containing concentrations of cadmium (54 micrograms/l) that would have otherwise proved fatal to the majority of the fish without the pretreatment. Most of the fish survived under both sets of conditions. However, two different mechanisms seem to be involved in the protection of the animals against the toxic manifestations of cadmium. In both cases, more than 99% of the total body load of cadmium was found in the liver, kidney and gills of the animals. Analysis of the metal-binding proteins in these organs was carried out. In the fish exposed to the two concentrations of cadmium, the toxic metal was found only in association with two low mol. wt specific binding proteins despite the presence of zinc- (and copper)-containing isometallothioneins in all three organs. On the other hand, cadmium was distributed between these binding-proteins and metallothioneins in the liver, kidney and gill of the trout pretreated with zinc before their exposure to cadmium.

A comparison of the accumulation and protein binding of environmental cadmium in the gills, kidney and liver of rainbow trout (Salmo gairdneri Richardson).

Rainbow trout were exposed to cadmium in their aquarium water for different lengths of time and at different concentrations. More than 99% of the total body loads accumulated under all such conditions of exposure was found in the liver, kidney and gills. Comparison of the metal-binding proteins in these organs indicated that two low mol. wt proteins sequestered the cadmium while zinc was bound to metallothionein. Cadmium was not found in association with metallothionein unless artificially high concentrations were introduced either by intraperitoneal injection of the fish or by dialysis of tissue extracts in vitro.