ABSTRACT
Understanding how species loss impacts ecosystem stability is critical given contemporary declines in global biodiversity. Despite decades of research on biodiversity-stability relationships, most studies are performed within a trophic level, overlooking the multitrophic complexity structuring natural communities. Here, in a global analysis of diversity-synchrony-stability (DSS) studies (n = 420), we found that 74% were monotrophic and biased towards terrestrial plant communities, with 91% describing stabilizing effects of asynchrony. Multitrophic studies (26%) were representative of all biomes and showed that synchrony had mixed effects on stability. To explore potential mechanisms, we applied a multitrophic framework adapted from DSS theory to investigate DSS relationships in algae-herbivore assemblages across five long-term tropical and temperate marine system datasets. Both algal and herbivore species diversity reduced within-group synchrony in both systems but had different interactive effects on species synchrony between systems. Herbivore synchrony was positively and negatively influenced by algal diversity in tropical versus temperate systems, respectively, and algal synchrony was positively influenced by herbivore diversity in temperate systems. While herbivore synchrony reduced multitrophic stability in both systems, algal synchrony only reduced stability in tropical systems. These results highlight the complexity of DSS relationships at the multitrophic level and emphasize why more multitrophic assessments are needed to better understand how biodiversity influences community stability in nature.
ABSTRACT
Understanding the drivers of ecosystem stability has been a key focus of modern ecology as the impacts of the Anthropocene become more prevalent and extreme. Marine protected areas (MPAs) are tools used globally to promote biodiversity and mediate anthropogenic impacts. However, assessing the stability of natural ecosystems and responses to management actions is inherently challenging due to the complex dynamics of communities with many interdependent taxa. Using a 12-year time series of subtidal community structure in an MPA network in the Channel Islands (United States), we estimated species interaction strength (competition and predation), prey species synchrony, and temporal stability in trophic networks, as well as temporal variation in sea surface temperature to explore the causal drivers of temporal stability at community and metacommunity scales. At the community scale, only trophic networks in MPAs at Santa Rosa Island showed greater temporal stability than reference sites, likely driven by reduced prey synchrony. Across islands, competition was sometimes greater and predation always greater in MPAs compared with reference sites. Increases in interaction strength resulted in lower temporal stability of trophic networks. Although MPAs reduced prey synchrony at the metacommunity scale, reductions were insufficient to stabilize trophic networks. In contrast, temporal variation in sea surface temperature had strong positive direct effects on stability at the regional scale and indirect effects at the local scale through reductions in species interaction strength. Although MPAs can be effective management strategies for protecting certain species or locations, our findings for this MPA network suggest that temperature variation has a stronger influence on metacommunity temporal stability by mediating species interactions and promoting a mosaic of spatiotemporal variation in community structure of trophic networks. By capturing the full spectrum of environmental variation in network planning, MPAs will have the greatest capacity to promote ecosystem stability in response to climate change.
Efectos de la protección y variación de la temperatura sobre la estabilidad temporal en una red de reservas marinas Resumen El conocimiento sobre las causas de la estabilidad ambiental ha sido un enfoque importante de la ecología moderna conforme el impacto del Antropoceno se vuelve más prevaleciente y extremo. Las áreas marinas protegidas (AMP) son herramientas que se usan en todo el mundo para promover la biodiversidad y mediar el impacto antropogénico. Sin embargo, analizar la estabilidad de los ecosistemas naturales y la respuesta a las acciones de manejo es complicado debido a las dinámicas complejas entre las comunidades y varios taxones interdependientes. Usamos una serie temporal de 12 años de estructura comunitaria submareal en una red de AMP en las Islas del Canal (Estados Unidos) para estimar la fuerza de interacción de las especies (competencia y depredación), la sincronía de las especies depredadas y la estabilidad temporal en las redes tróficas, así como la variación temporal de la temperatura superficial del mar para explorar los factores causales de la estabilidad temporal a escala comunitaria y meta-comunitaria. A nivel de comunidad, sólo las redes tróficas en las AMP de la Isla Santa Rosa mostraron una estabilidad temporal mayor que en los sitios de referencia, probablemente debido a la reducción en la sincronía de presas. Entre las islas, la competencia a veces fue mayor y la depredación siempre fue mayor en las AMP comparadas con los sitios de referencia. Los incrementos en la fuerza de interacción causaron una menor estabilidad temporal en las redes tróficas. Aunque las AMP redujeron la sincronía de presas a nivel meta-comunitario, las reducciones no fueron suficientes para estabilizar las redes tróficas. Por el contrario, la variación temporal de la temperatura en la superficie marina tuvo grandes efectos positivos directos sobre la estabilidad a nivel regional y efectos indirectos a escala local por medio de reducciones en la fuerza de interacción entre las especies. Aunque las AMP pueden ser una estrategia efectiva de manejo para proteger ciertas especies o localidades, nuestros hallazgos en esta red de AMP sugieren que la variación térmica tiene una influencia más fuerte sobre la estabilidad temporal metacomunitaria cuando regula las interacciones entre especies y promueve un mosaico de variación espaciotemporal en la estructura comunitaria de las redes tróficas. Cuando se captura el espectro completo de variación ambiental en la planeación de redes, las AMP logran tener la capacidad máxima para promover la estabilidad del ecosistema como respuesta al cambio climático.
ABSTRACT
Understanding the drivers and impacts of spatiotemporal variation in species abundance on community trajectories is key to understanding the factors contributing to ecosystem resilience. Temporal variation in species trajectories across patches can provide compensation for species loss and can influence successional patterns. However, little is known about the underlying mechanisms that lead to patterns of species or spatial compensation and how those patterns may be mediated by consumer-resource relationships. Here we describe an experiment testing whether habitat attributes (e.g., structural complexity and spatial heterogeneity) mediate the effects of herbivory on tropical marine macroalgal communities by reducing accessibility and detectability, respectively, leading to variable trajectories among algal species at community (within patch) and metacommunity (i.e., among patch) scales. Reduced accessibility (greater habitat complexity) decreased the effects of herbivory (i.e., depressed consumption rate, increased algal species richness), and both accessibility and detectability (spatial heterogeneity) influenced algal community structure. Moreover, decreased accessibility at the community scale and a mosaic of accessibility at the metacommunity scale led to variation in community assembly. We suggest that habitat attributes can be important influencers of consumer-resource interactions on coral reefs, which in turn can increase species diversity, promote species succession, and enhance stability in algal metacommunities.
