Evaluation of the Genetic Systems Corp. Integra HIV-1 Pageblot system.

The Genetic Systems Corp. Integra HIV-1 Pageblot system was evaluated as a supplementary assay to confirm the presence of antibodies to human immunodeficiency virus type 1 in 57 specimens from individuals at high risk of infection with the virus. Forty-one specimens identified as reactive in the Genetic Systems Integra HIV-1 Pageblot system were likewise identified as reactive in a U.S. Food and Drug Administration-licensed (Biotech/Dupont) Western blot (immunoblot). Six specimens identified as indeterminate in either or both immunoblot assays were all identified as nonreactive in a U.S. Food and Drug Administration-licensed enzyme immunoassay with recombinant antigens.

Evaluation of the Recombigen HIV-1 Latex Agglutination Test.

The Recombigen HIV-1 Latex Agglutination (LA) Test was recently licensed by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration for use as a rapid screening assay for human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) antibodies. However, its performance in various settings and in different populations has not been firmly established. Consequently, we evaluated the test in the Cleveland Clinic Retrovirus Laboratory, a regional reference laboratory for HIV diagnostic testing and a testing laboratory for the Ohio Department of Health Anonymous HIV Testing and Counseling Program. Serum samples from 93 individuals presumed to be at high risk for HIV infection were evaluated. The sera were initially tested for HIV antibodies by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). All repeatedly reactive sera were subjected to confirmatory Western blot (WB; immunoblot) testing. Of 97 serum specimens tested (5 were from one seroconverter), 44 were repeatedly reactive by ELISA and 53 were nonreactive. Of the reactive serum specimens, 31 were confirmed positive and 12 were indeterminate by WB. All of the sera were coded and then retested by the LA test. Of 53 serum specimens nonreactive by ELISA, 51 were also nonreactive in the LA test. Of the 44 serum specimens reactive by ELISA, 16 were nonreactive by LA; however, 3 of the latter were WB positive. No serum specimen with an ELISA ratio (specimen optical density/cutoff optical density) of less than 2.1 scored reactive in the LA test. The LA test was positive for only two of five consecutive serum specimens from a seroconverter despite the fact that all but the earliest of these were ELISA reactive and WB positive. Although the LA test appears to be an adequate first-line screening test when appropriately used according to the directions of the manufacturer, our data suggest that occasional sera with low levels of reactivity by ELISA may not be readily detected as reactive by the LA test.