Management of suspected antenatal torsion: what is the best strategy?

Currently, management of the newborn with suspected antenatal torsion is somewhat controversial. Many surgeons recommend early surgical exploration within the first few days of life, primarily to avoid errors in diagnosis. However, since the surgical and general anesthetic risks at this age are increased, it might be preferable to defer an operation until risks to the patient are minimized. The optimal solution to this dilemma would be the ability to diagnose torsion and exclude other conditions noninvasively. We present a series of 12 patients 1 to 14 days old who presented with a scrotal mass secondary to suspected antenatal testis torsion. Color Doppler ultrasound in each case demonstrated abnormal testicular blood flow and architecture consistent with testis torsion. Eventual exploration of all 12 patients confirmed prenatal torsion. We conclude that scrotal ultrasound with color Doppler enhancement can accurately identify neonates with antenatal testis torsion and exclude other scrotal pathological conditions. If elected, surgery for torsion can then be deferred until the risks of anesthesia and surgery are improved.

Do all children with an acute scrotum require exploration?

A total of 77 consecutive children ranging in age from 1 day to 17 years was evaluated for an acute scrotum by a single examiner (E. J. K.). In 10 children a definite diagnosis of acute spermatic cord torsion was made based upon the history and physical examination. No imaging studies were performed and torsion was confirmed at surgery in 9 children. The diagnosis of testis torsion was not as clear-cut in the remaining 67 children and, therefore, a color Doppler ultrasound was performed before any surgical intervention. The study demonstrated normal or increased blood flow in 55 of these children and none proved to have testicular torsion, although other scrotal pathology requiring surgery was noted in 5 children. Twelve children did not demonstrate evidence of testicular blood flow on the color Doppler ultrasound and all had surgical confirmation of testis torsion. We conclude that in our experience the majority (71%) of children with an acute scrotum did not require immediate surgical exploration. Color Doppler ultrasound can reliably identify those children with an acute scrotum who require exploration and spare the majority needless surgery. Routine scrotal exploration is no longer necessary for all children with an acute scrotum.