Protein Grafting Techniques: From Peptide Epitopes to Lasso-Grafted Neobiologics.

Protein engineering techniques have vastly expanded their domain of impact, notably following the success of antibodies. Likewise, smaller peptide therapeutics have carved an increasingly significant niche for themselves in the pharmaceutical landscape. The concept of grafting such peptides onto larger protein scaffolds, thus harvesting the advantages of both, has given rise to a variety of protein engineering strategies that are reviewed herein. We also describe our own "Lasso-Grafting" approach, which combines traditional grafting concepts with mRNA display to streamline the production of multiple grafted drug candidates for virtually any target.

Targeting the Plasmodium falciparum UCHL3 ubiquitin hydrolase using chemically constrained peptides.

The ubiquitin-proteasome system is essential to all eukaryotes and has been shown to be critical to parasite survival as well, including Plasmodium falciparum, the causative agent of the deadliest form of malarial disease. Despite the central role of the ubiquitin-proteasome pathway to parasite viability across its entire life-cycle, specific inhibitors targeting the individual enzymes mediating ubiquitin attachment and removal do not currently exist. The ability to disrupt P. falciparum growth at multiple developmental stages is particularly attractive as this could potentially prevent both disease pathology, caused by asexually dividing parasites, as well as transmission which is mediated by sexually differentiated parasites. The deubiquitinating enzyme PfUCHL3 is an essential protein, transcribed across both human and mosquito developmental stages. PfUCHL3 is considered hard to drug by conventional methods given the high level of homology of its active site to human UCHL3 as well as to other UCH domain enzymes. Here, we apply the RaPID mRNA display technology and identify constrained peptides capable of binding to PfUCHL3 with nanomolar affinities. The two lead peptides were found to selectively inhibit the deubiquitinase activity of PfUCHL3 versus HsUCHL3. NMR spectroscopy revealed that the peptides do not act by binding to the active site but instead block binding of the ubiquitin substrate. We demonstrate that this approach can be used to target essential protein-protein interactions within the Plasmodium ubiquitin pathway, enabling the application of chemically constrained peptides as a novel class of antimalarial therapeutics.

Engineering tRNAs for the Ribosomal Translation of Non-proteinogenic Monomers.

Ribosome-dependent protein biosynthesis is an essential cellular process mediated by transfer RNAs (tRNAs). Generally, ribosomally synthesized proteins are limited to the 22 proteinogenic amino acids (pAAs: 20 l-α-amino acids present in the standard genetic code, selenocysteine, and pyrrolysine). However, engineering tRNAs for the ribosomal incorporation of non-proteinogenic monomers (npMs) as building blocks has led to the creation of unique polypeptides with broad applications in cellular biology, material science, spectroscopy, and pharmaceuticals. Ribosomal polymerization of these engineered polypeptides presents a variety of challenges for biochemists, as translation efficiency and fidelity is often insufficient when employing npMs. In this Review, we will focus on the methodologies for engineering tRNAs to overcome these issues and explore recent advances both in vitro and in vivo. These efforts include increasing orthogonality, recruiting essential translation factors, and creation of expanded genetic codes. After our review on the biochemical optimizations of tRNAs, we provide examples of their use in genetic code manipulation, with a focus on the in vitro discovery of bioactive macrocyclic peptides containing npMs. Finally, an analysis of the current state of tRNA engineering is presented, along with existing challenges and future perspectives for the field.

Fine-tuning the tRNA anticodon arm for multiple/consecutive incorporations of ß-amino acids and analogs.

Ribosomal incorporation of ß-amino acids into nascent peptides is much less efficient than that of the canonical α-amino acids. To overcome this, we have engineered a tRNA chimera bearing T-stem of tRNAGlu and D-arm of tRNAPro1, referred to as tRNAPro1E2, which efficiently recruits EF-Tu and EF-P. Using tRNAPro1E2 indeed improved ß-amino acid incorporation. However, multiple/consecutive incorporations of ß-amino acids are still detrimentally poor. Here, we attempted fine-tuning of the anticodon arm of tRNAPro1E2 aiming at further enhancement of ß-amino acid incorporation. By screening various mutations introduced into tRNAPro1E2, C31G39/C28G42 mutation showed an approximately 3-fold enhancement of two consecutive incorporation of ß-homophenylglycine (ßPhg) at CCG codons. The use of this tRNA made it possible for the first time to elongate up to ten consecutive ßPhg's. Since the enhancement effect of anticodon arm mutations differs depending on the codon used for ß-amino acid incorporation, we optimized anticodon arm sequences for five codons (CCG, CAU, CAG, ACU and UGG). Combination of the five optimal tRNAs for these codons made it possible to introduce five different kinds of ß-amino acids and analogs simultaneously into model peptides, including a macrocyclic scaffold. This strategy would enable ribosomal synthesis of libraries of macrocyclic peptides containing multiple ß-amino acids.

A Compact Reprogrammed Genetic Code for De Novo Discovery of Proteolytically Stable Thiopeptides.

Thiopeptides make up a group of structurally complex peptidic natural products holding promise in bioengineering applications. The previously established thiopeptide/mRNA display platform enables de novo discovery of natural product-like thiopeptides with designed bioactivities. However, in contrast to natural thiopeptides, the discovered structures are composed predominantly of proteinogenic amino acids, which results in low metabolic stability in many cases. Here, we redevelop the platform and demonstrate that the utilization of compact reprogrammed genetic codes in mRNA display libraries can lead to the discovery of thiopeptides predominantly composed of nonproteinogenic structural elements. We demonstrate the feasibility of our designs by conducting affinity selections against Traf2- and NCK-interacting kinase (TNIK). The experiment identified a series of thiopeptides with high affinity to the target protein (the best KD = 2.1 nM) and kinase inhibitory activity (the best IC50 = 0.15 µM). The discovered compounds, which bore as many as 15 nonproteinogenic amino acids in an 18-residue macrocycle, demonstrated high metabolic stability in human serum with a half-life of up to 99 h. An X-ray cocrystal structure of TNIK in complex with a discovered thiopeptide revealed how nonproteinogenic building blocks facilitate the target engagement and orchestrate the folding of the thiopeptide into a noncanonical conformation. Altogether, the established platform takes a step toward the discovery of thiopeptides with high metabolic stability for early drug discovery applications.

Cheminformatics-Guided Cell-Free Exploration of Peptide Natural Products.

There have been significant advances in the flexibility and power of in vitro cell-free translation systems. The increasing ability to incorporate noncanonical amino acids and complement translation with recombinant enzymes has enabled cell-free production of peptide-based natural products (NPs) and NP-like molecules. We anticipate that many more such compounds and analogs might be accessed in this way. To assess the peptide NP space that is directly accessible to current cell-free technologies, we developed a peptide parsing algorithm that breaks down peptide NPs into building blocks based on ribosomal translation logic. Using the resultant data set, we broadly analyze the biophysical properties of these privileged compounds and perform a retrobiosynthetic analysis to predict which peptide NPs could be directly synthesized in augmented cell-free translation reactions. We then tested these predictions by preparing a library of highly modified peptide NPs. Two macrocyclases, PatG and PCY1, were used to effect the head-to-tail macrocyclization of candidate NPs. This retrobiosynthetic analysis identified a collection of high-priority building blocks that are enriched throughout peptide NPs, yet they had not previously been tested in cell-free translation. To expand the cell-free toolbox into this space, we established, optimized, and characterized the flexizyme-enabled ribosomal incorporation of piperazic acids. Overall, these results demonstrate the feasibility of cell-free translation for peptide NP total synthesis while expanding the limits of the technology. This work provides a novel computational tool for exploration of peptide NP chemical space, that could be expanded in the future to allow design of ribosomal biosynthetic pathways for NPs and NP-like molecules.

An anticodon-sensing T-boxzyme generates the elongator nonproteinogenic aminoacyl-tRNA in situ of a custom-made translation system for incorporation.

In the hypothetical RNA world, ribozymes could have acted as modern aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (ARSs) to charge tRNAs, thus giving rise to the peptide synthesis along with the evolution of a primitive translation apparatus. We previously reported a T-boxzyme, Tx2.1, which selectively charges initiator tRNA with N-biotinyl-phenylalanine (BioPhe) in situ in a Flexible In-vitro Translation (FIT) system to produce BioPhe-initiating peptides. Here, we performed in vitro selection of elongation-capable T-boxzymes (elT-boxzymes), using para-azido-l-phenylalanine (PheAZ) as an acyl-donor. We implemented a new strategy to enrich elT-boxzyme-tRNA conjugates that self-aminoacylated on the 3'-terminus selectively. One of them, elT32, can charge PheAZ onto tRNA in trans in response to its cognate anticodon. Further evolution of elT32 resulted in elT49, with enhanced aminoacylation activity. We have demonstrated the translation of a PheAZ-containing peptide in an elT-boxzyme-integrated FIT system, revealing that elT-boxzymes are able to generate the PheAZ-tRNA in response to the cognate anticodon in situ of a custom-made translation system. This study, together with Tx2.1, illustrates a scenario where a series of ribozymes could have overseen aminoacylation and co-evolved with a primitive RNA-based translation system.

Selective targeting of human TET1 by cyclic peptide inhibitors: Insights from biochemical profiling.

Ten-Eleven Translocation (TET) enzymes are Fe(II)/2OG-dependent oxygenases that play important roles in epigenetic regulation, but selective inhibition of the TETs is an unmet challenge. We describe the profiling of previously identified TET1-binding macrocyclic peptides. TiP1 is established as a potent TET1 inhibitor (IC50 = 0.26 µM) with excellent selectivity over other TETs and 2OG oxygenases. TiP1 alanine scanning reveals the critical roles of Trp10 and Glu11 residues for inhibition of TET isoenzymes. The results highlight the utility of the RaPID method to identify potent enzyme inhibitors with selectivity over closely related paralogues. The structure-activity relationship data generated herein may find utility in the development of chemical probes for the TETs.

mRNA display reveals a class of high-affinity bromodomain-binding motifs that are not found in the human proteome.

Bromodomains (BDs) regulate gene expression by recognizing protein motifs containing acetyllysine. Although originally characterized as histone-binding proteins, it has since become clear that these domains interact with other acetylated proteins, perhaps most prominently transcription factors. The likely transient nature and low stoichiometry of such modifications, however, has made it challenging to fully define the interactome of any given BD. To begin to address this knowledge gap in an unbiased manner, we carried out mRNA display screens against a BD-the N-terminal BD of BRD3-using peptide libraries that contained either one or two acetyllysine residues. We discovered peptides with very strong consensus sequences and with affinities that are significantly higher than typical BD-peptide interactions. X-ray crystal structures also revealed modes of binding that have not been seen with natural ligands. Intriguingly, however, our sequences are not found in the human proteome, perhaps suggesting that strong binders to BDs might have been selected against during evolution.

Deep Learning-Driven Library Design for the De Novo Discovery of Bioactive Thiopeptides.

Broad substrate tolerance of ribosomally synthesized and post-translationally modified peptide (RiPP) biosynthetic enzymes has allowed numerous strategies for RiPP engineering. However, despite relaxed specificities, exact substrate preferences of RiPP enzymes are often difficult to pinpoint. Thus, when designing combinatorial libraries of RiPP precursors, balancing the compound diversity with the substrate fitness can be challenging. Here, we employed a deep learning model to streamline the design of mRNA display libraries. Using an in vitro reconstituted thiopeptide biosynthesis platform, we performed mRNA display-based profiling of substrate fitness for the biosynthetic pathway involving five enzymes to train an accurate deep learning model. We then utilized the model to design optimal mRNA libraries and demonstrated their utility in affinity selections against IRAK4 kinase and the TLR10 cell surface receptor. The selections led to the discovery of potent thiopeptide ligands against both target proteins (KD up to 1.3 nM for the best compound against IRAK4 and 300 nM for TLR10). The IRAK4-targeting compounds also inhibited the kinase at single-digit µM concentrations in vitro, exhibited efficient internalization into HEK293H cells, and suppressed NF-kB-mediated signaling in cells. Altogether, the developed approach streamlines the discovery of pseudonatural RiPPs with de novo designed biological activities and favorable pharmacological properties.

Mechanism of selective recognition of Lys48-linked polyubiquitin by macrocyclic peptide inhibitors of proteasomal degradation.

Post-translational modification of proteins with polyubiquitin chains is a critical cellular signaling mechanism in eukaryotes with implications in various cellular states and processes. Unregulated ubiquitin-mediated protein degradation can be detrimental to cellular homeostasis, causing numerous diseases including cancers. Recently, macrocyclic peptides were developed that selectively target long Lysine-48-linked polyubiquitin chains (tetra-ubiquitin) to inhibit ubiquitin-proteasome system, leading to attenuation of tumor growth in vivo. However, structural determinants of the chain length and linkage selectivity by these cyclic peptides remained unclear. Here, we uncover the mechanism underlying cyclic peptide's affinity and binding selectivity by combining X-ray crystallography, solution NMR, and biochemical studies. We found that the peptide engages three consecutive ubiquitins that form a ring around the peptide and determined requirements for preferential selection of a specific trimer moiety in longer polyubiquitin chains. The structural insights gained from this work will guide the development of next-generation cyclic peptides with enhanced anti-cancer activity.

Macrocyclic Peptides Closed by a Thioether-Bipyridyl Unit That Grants Cell Membrane Permeability.

Membrane permeability is an important factor that determines the virtue of peptides targeting intracellular molecules. By introducing a membrane penetration motif, some peptides exhibit better membrane permeabilities. Previous choices for such motifs have usually been polycationic sequences, but their protease vulnerabilities and modest endosome escapability remain challenging. Here, we report a strategy for macrocyclization of peptides closed by a hydrophobic bipyridyl (BPy) unit, which grants an improvement of their membrane permeability and proteolytic stability compared with the conventional polycationic peptides. We chemically prepared model macrocyclic peptides closed by a thioether-BPy unit and determined their cell membrane permeability, giving 200 nM CP50 (an indicative value of membrane permeability), which is 40-fold better than that of the ordinary thioether macrocycle consisting of the same sequence composition. To discover potent target binders consisting of the BPy unit, we reprogrammed the initiator with chloromethyl-BPy (ClMeBPy) for the peptide library synthesis with a downstream Cys residue(s) and executed RaPID (Random nonstandard Peptide Integrated Discovery) against the bromodomains of BRD4. One of the obtained sequences exhibited a single-digit nanomolar dissociation constant against BRD4 in vitro and showed approximately 2-fold and 10-fold better membrane permeability than positive controls, R9 and Tat peptides, respectively. Moreover, we observed an intracellular activity of the BPy macrocycle tagged with a proteasome target peptide motif (RRRG), resulting in modest but detectable degradation of BRD4. The present demonstration indicates that the combination of the RaPID system with an appropriate hydrophobic unit, such as BPy, would provide a potential approach for devising cell penetrating macrocycles targeting various intracellular proteins.

Switching Prenyl Donor Specificities of Cyanobactin Prenyltransferases.

Prenyltransferases in cyanobactin biosynthesis are of growing interest as peptide alkylation biocatalysts, but their prenylation modes characterized so far have been limited to dimethylallylation (C5) or geranylation (C10). Here we engaged in structure-guided engineering of the prenyl-binding pocket of a His-C2-geranyltransferase LimF to modulate its prenylation mode. Contraction of the pocket by a single mutation led to a His-C2-dimethylallyltransferase. More importantly, pocket expansion by a double mutation successfully repurposed LimF for farnesylation (C15), which is an unprecedented mode in this family. Furthermore, the obtained knowledge of the essential residues to construct the farnesyl-binding pocket has allowed for rational design of a Tyr-O-farnesyltransferase by a triple mutation of a Tyr-O-dimethylallyltransferase PagF. These results provide an approach to manipulate the prenyl specificity of cyanobactin prenyltransferases, broadening the chemical space covered by this class of enzymes and expanding the toolbox of peptide alkylation biocatalysts.

Display Selection of a Hybrid Foldamer-Peptide Macrocycle.

Expanding the chemical diversity of peptide macrocycle libraries for display selection is desirable to improve their potential to bind biomolecular targets. We now have implemented a considerable expansion through a large aromatic helical foldamer inclusion. A foldamer was first identified that undergoes flexizyme-mediated tRNA acylation and that is capable of initiating ribosomal translation with yields sufficiently high to perform an mRNA display selection of macrocyclic foldamer-peptide hybrids. A hybrid macrocyclic nanomolar binder to the C-lobe of the E6AP HECT domain was selected that showed a highly converged peptide sequence. A crystal structure and molecular dynamics simulations revealed that both the peptide and foldamer are helical in an intriguing reciprocal stapling fashion. The strong residue convergence could be rationalized based on their involvement in specific interactions with the target protein. The foldamer stabilizes the peptide helix through stapling and through contacts with key residues. These results altogether represent a significant extension of the chemical space amenable to display selection and highlight possible benefits of inserting an aromatic foldamer into a peptide macrocycle for the purpose of protein recognition.

A comprehensive analysis of translational misdecoding pattern and its implication on genetic code evolution.

The universal genetic code is comprised of 61 sense codons, which are assigned to 20 canonical amino acids. However, the evolutionary basis for the highly conserved mapping between amino acids and their codons remains incompletely understood. A possible selective pressure of evolution would be minimization of deleterious effects caused by misdecoding. Here we comprehensively analyzed the misdecoding pattern of 61 codons against 19 noncognate amino acids where an arbitrary amino acid was omitted, and revealed the following two rules. (i) If the second codon base is U or C, misdecoding is frequently induced by mismatches at the first and/or third base, where any mismatches are widely tolerated; whereas misdecoding with the second-base mismatch is promoted by only U-G or C-A pair formation. (ii) If the second codon base is A or G, misdecoding is promoted by only G-U or U-G pair formation at the first or second position. In addition, evaluation of functional/structural diversities of amino acids revealed that less diverse amino acid sets are assigned at codons that induce more frequent misdecoding, and vice versa, so as to minimize deleterious effects of misdecoding in the modern genetic code.

MET-Activating Ubiquitin Multimers.

Receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs) are generally activated through their dimerization and/or oligomerization induced by their cognate ligands, and one such RTK hepatocyte growth factor (HGF) receptor, known as MET, plays an important role in tissue regeneration. Here we show the development of ubiquitin (Ub)-based protein ligand multimers, referred to as U-bodies, which act as surrogate agonists for MET and are derived from MET-binding macrocyclic peptides. Monomeric Ub constructs (U-body) were first generated by genetic implantation of a macrocyclic peptide pharmacophore into a structural loop of Ub (lasso-grafting) and subsequent optimization of its flanking spacer sequences via mRNA display. Such U-body constructs exhibit potent binding affinity to MET, thermal stability, and proteolytic stability. The U-body constructs also partially/fully inhibited or enhanced HGF-induced MET-phosphorylation. Their multimerization to dimeric, tetrameric, and octameric U-bodies linked by an appropriate peptide linker yielded potent MET activation activity and downstream cell proliferation-promoting activity. This work suggests that lasso-grafting of macrocycles to Ub is an effective approach to devising protein-based artificial RTK agonists and it can be useful in the development of a new class of biologics for various therapeutic applications.

Discovery and characterization of cyclic peptides selective for the C-terminal bromodomains of BET family proteins.

DNA-encoded cyclic peptide libraries can yield high-potency, high-specificity ligands against target proteins. We used such a library to seek ligands that could distinguish between paralogous bromodomains from the closely related bromodomain and extra-terminal domain family of epigenetic regulators. Several peptides isolated from a screen against the C-terminal bromodomain of BRD2, together with new peptides discovered in previous screens against the corresponding domain from BRD3 and BRD4, bound their targets with nanomolar and sub-nanomolar affinities. X-ray crystal structures of several of these bromodomain-peptide complexes reveal diverse structures and binding modes, which nevertheless display several conserved features. Some peptides demonstrate significant paralog-level specificity, although the physicochemical explanations for this specificity are often not clear. Our data demonstrate the power of cyclic peptides to discriminate between very similar proteins with high potency and hint that differences in conformational dynamics might modulate the affinity of these domains for particular ligands.

Translation initiation with exotic amino acids using EF-P-responsive artificial initiator tRNA.

Translation initiation using noncanonical initiator substrates with poor peptidyl donor activities, such as N-acetyl-l-proline (AcPro), induces the N-terminal drop-off-reinitiation event. Thereby, the initiator tRNA drops-off from the ribosome and the translation reinitiates from the second amino acid to yield a truncated peptide lacking the N-terminal initiator substrate. In order to suppress this event for the synthesis of full-length peptides, here we have devised a chimeric initiator tRNA, referred to as tRNAiniP, whose D-arm comprises a recognition motif for EF-P, an elongation factor that accelerates peptide bond formation. We have shown that the use of tRNAiniP and EF-P enhances the incorporation of not only AcPro but also d-amino, ß-amino and γ-amino acids at the N-terminus. By optimizing the translation conditions, e.g. concentrations of translation factors, codon sequence and Shine-Dalgarno sequence, we could achieve complete suppression of the N-terminal drop-off-reinitiation for the exotic amino acids and enhance the expression level of full-length peptide up to 1000-fold compared with the use of the ordinary translation conditions.

Combining Chemical Protein Synthesis and Random Nonstandard Peptides Integrated Discovery for Modulating Biological Processes.

Chemical manipulation of naturally occurring peptides offers a convenient route for generating analogs to screen against different therapeutic targets. However, the limited success of the conventional chemical libraries has urged chemical biologists to adopt alternative methods such as phage and mRNA displays and create libraries of a large number of variants for the screening and selection of novel peptides. Messenger RNA (mRNA) display provides great advantages in terms of the library size and the straightforward recovery of the selected polypeptide sequences. Importantly, the integration of the flexible in vitro translation (FIT) system with the mRNA display provides the basis of the random nonstandard peptides integrated discovery (RaPID) approach for the introduction of diverse nonstandard motifs, such as unnatural side chains and backbone modifications. This platform allows the discovery of functionalized peptides with tight binding against virtually any protein of interest (POI) and therefore shows great potential in the pharmaceutical industry. However, this method has been limited to targets generated by recombinant expression, excluding its applications to uniquely modified proteins, particularly those with post-translational modifications.Chemical protein synthesis allows a wide range of changes to the protein's chemical composition to be performed, including side chain and backbone modifications and access to post-translationally modified proteins, which are often inaccessible or difficult to achieve via recombinant expression methods. Notably, d-proteins can be prepared via chemical synthesis, which has been used in mirror image phase display for the discovery of nonproteolytic d-peptide binders.Combining chemical protein synthesis with the RaPID system allows the production of a library of trillions of cyclic peptides and subsequent selection for novel cyclic peptide binders targeting a uniquely modified protein to assist in studying its unexplored biology and possibly the discovery of new drug candidates.Interestingly, the small post-translational modifier protein ubiquitin (Ub), with its various polymeric forms, regulates directly or indirectly many biochemical processes, e.g., proteasomal degradation, DNA damage repair, cell cycle regulation, etc. In this Account, we discuss combining the RaPID approach against various synthetic Ub chains for selecting effective and specific macrocyclic peptide binders. This offers an advancement in modulating central Ub pathways and provides opportunities in drug discovery areas associated with Ub signaling. We highlight experimental approaches and conceptual adaptations required to design and modulate the activity of Lys48- and Lys63-linked Ub chains by macrocyclic peptides. We also present the applications of these approaches to shed light on related biological activities and ultimately their activity against cancer. Finally, we contemplate future developments still pending in this exciting multidisciplinary field.

Ribosomal Synthesis of Peptides Bearing Noncanonical Backbone Structures via Chemical Posttranslational Modifications.

Noncanonical peptide backbone structures, such as heterocycles and non-α-amino acids, are characteristic building blocks present in peptidic natural products. To achieve ribosomal synthesis of designer peptides bearing such noncanonical backbone structures, we have devised translation-compatible precursor residues and their chemical posttranslational modification processes. In this chapter, we describe the detailed procedures for the in vitro translation of peptides containing the precursor residues by means of genetic code reprogramming technology and posttranslational generation of objective noncanonical backbone structures.