Homologous chromosome pairing in meiosis of higher eukaryotes-still an enigma?

Meiosis is the basis of the generative reproduction of eukaryotes. The crucial first step is homologous chromosome pairing. In higher eukaryotes, micrometer-scale chromosomes, micrometer distances apart, are brought together by nanometer DNA sequences, at least a factor of 1000 size difference. Models of homology search, homologue movement, and pairing at the DNA level in higher eukaryotes are primarily based on studies with yeast where the emphasis is on the induction and repair of DNA double-strand breaks (DSB). For such a model, the very large nuclei of most plants and animals present serious problems. Homology search without DSBs cannot be explained by models based on DSB repair. The movement of homologues to meet each other and make contact at the molecular level is not understood. These problems are discussed and the conclusion is that at present practically nothing is known of meiotic homologue pairing in higher eukaryotes up to the formation of the synaptonemal complex, and that new, necessarily speculative models must be developed. Arguments are given that RNA plays a central role in homology search and a tentative model involving RNA in homology search is presented. A role of actin in homologue movement is proposed. The primary role of DSBs in higher eukaryotes is concluded to not be in paring but in the preparation of Holliday junctions, ultimately leading to chromatid exchange.

Incomplete pole orientation of kinetochores in complex meiotic metaphase I configurations delays metaphase-anaphase transition in Secale.

To prevent unbalanced chromosome segregation, meiotic metaphase I - anaphase I transition is carefully regulated by delaying anaphase until all kinetochores are well oriented (anaphase checkpoint) in mammals and insects. In plants this has not yet been established. In heterozygotes of two reciprocal translocations of Secale cereale, with one chromosome replaced by its two telocentric arms, anaphase delay was correlated with the orientation of the kinetochores of the complex of five chromosomes. The terminal kinetochores of the half chromosomes were readily elongated and pole oriented. Chains of five chromosomes with all five kinetochores orienting on alternate poles where the first to start anaphase. Kinetochores of two adjacent chromosomes when oriented on the same pole were partly shielded and less well pole directed. Anaphase was delayed. Cells with this configuration accumulated during anther development. Kinetochores in metacentric chromosomes lacking chiasmata in one arm (in trivalents and bivalents) were slightly better pole oriented and delayed anaphase less. Release of chromatid cohesion as triggered by kinetochore stretch is apparently delayed by inadequate exposition and pole orientation of the kinetochores. It is a mild form of an anaphase checkpoint, in normal material synchronizing bivalent segregation.

Can epigenetic control explain pronounced within-plant heterogeneity of meiosis in a translocation trisome of Secale L.?

Meiotic metaphase I configuration frequencies were determined in different tillers of genetically related plants of rye ( Secale cereale L.) heterozygous for reciprocal translocation T248W (between chromosome arms 1RS and 6RS) and with an additional (telocentric) arm 1RS. Seventeen different configurations could be recognized, grouped into three categories. Very different configuration frequencies were found not only between sister plants from the same parents but also between tillers of the same plant grown under identical conditions (climate chambers at 15 °C and 20 °C). The heterogeneity reflects variation in chromosome pairing and crossing over, and is variable and unpredictable. Anthers within florets were homogeneous. Between tiller heterogeneity is insufficient to explain differences between sister plants. It is ascribed to random somatic variation in the conditions of the chromatin which, at meiosis, govern chromosome pairing. During sexual differentiation, these conditions are fixed and subsequent cell lineages have the same pairing and crossing over characteristics. As homology search is an activity of DNA, this control of pairing and crossing over, consistent over long cell lineages, may be considered to be epigenetic even when no realistic suggestions concerning its character can be given.

Trisomy greatly enhances interstitial crossing over in a translocation heterozygote of Secale.

Chromosomal rearrangements, including reciprocal translocations, may prevent recombinational transfer of genes from a donor genotype to a recipient, especially when the gene is located in an interstitial segment. The effect of trisomy of chromosome arm 1RS on recombination was studied in translocation heterozygote T248W of rye ( Secale cereale ), involving chromosome arms 1RS and 6RS. (Pro)metaphase I configuration frequencies were analyzed. Crossing over, estimated as chiasma parameters, in five genetically different euploid heterozygotes was compared with those of 10 different single arm trisomics. The addition of 1RS greatly altered the crossing over pattern around the translocation break point, with a special increase in the interstitial segment of 6RS and adjoining regions, normally hardly accessible to recombination. Furthermore, there was considerable variation between plants of closely related genotypes. Heterogeneity widens the distribution of crossing overs, including segments normally not accessible to recombination, but decreases average recombination in other segments. The extra chromosome and abnormal segregants are eliminated by using the trisomic as the pollen parent.

Epigenetic control may explain large within-plant heterogeneity of meiotic behavior in telocentric trisomics of rye.

In telocentric trisomics (telotrisomics) of organisms in which the chromosomes normally have two distinct arms, a single chromosome arm with a centromere is present in addition to a complete diploid set of chromosomes. It is the simplest form of polysomy and suitable for analyzing meiotic pairing and recombination patterns in situations where chromosomes compete for pairing. When no suitable meiotic chromosome markers are available, four metaphase I configurations can be distinguished. Their relative frequencies are indicative of the pairing and recombination patterns. In short arm (1RS) telotrisomics of chromosome 1R of rye (Secale cereale) we observed great differences in pairing and recombination patterns among spikes from different tillers and clones of the same plants. Anthers within spikes were only very rarely different. We analyzed a large number of genotypes, including inbreds as well as hybrids. The effects of genetic and environmental conditions on heterogeneity, if any, were limited. Considering that the reproductive tissue of a spike is derived from one primordial cell, it seems that at the start of sexual differentiation there was variation among cells in chromosomal control, which at meiosis determines pairing and crossing-over competence. We suggest that it is an epigenetic system that rigidly maintains this pattern through generative differentiation. In competitive situations the combination most competent for pairing will pair preferentially, forming specific meiotic configurations with different frequencies for different spikes of the same plant. This would explain the heterogeneity between spikes and the homogeneity within spikes. The epigenetic system could involve chromatin conformation or DNA methylation. There were no signs of heterochromatinization.

Estimating meiotic chromosome pairing and recombination parameters in telocentric trisomics.

Telocentric trisomics (telotrisomics; one arm of a metacentric chromosome present in addition to two complete genomes) are used in theoretical studies of pairing affinities and chiasma formation in competitive situations and applied in genome analysis, gene localization, gene transfer, and breakage of close linkages. These applications require knowledge of the recombination characteristics of telotrisomics. Appropriate cytological and molecular markers and favorable chromosome morphology are not always available or applicable for quantitative analyses. We developed new mathematical models for extracting the maximum information from simple metaphase I observations. Two types of telotrisomics of the short arm of chromosome 1R of rye (Secale cereale), including several genotypes, were used as test material. In simple telotrisomics, pairing between morphologically identical complete chromosomes was more frequent than pairing between the telocentric and either of the normal chromosomes. In the telocentric substitution, morphologically identical telocentrics paired less frequently with each other than either one with the normal chromosome. Pairing partner switch was significant. Interaction between the two arms was variable. Variation within plants was considerable. Telotrisomics without markers are suitable for analyzing pairing preferences, for gene localization and gene transfer, and for breaking tight linkages, but less so for genome analysis.

The relation between pairing preference and chiasma frequency in tetrasomics of rye.

The association pattern of marked tetrasomes of Secale chromosome 1R at meiotic first metaphase was analyzed. Two of the four chromosomes were identical with terminal C-bands at both arms; the other two were also identical but lacked C-bands and were homologous or homeologous with the first two. Four different types of heterozygotes for 1R were studied: (i). autotetraploid hybrids between genetic variants within Secale cereale subsp. cereale, (ii). tetraploid hybrids between subspecies of Secale cereale, (iii). tetraploid hybrids between species of Secale, and (iv). autotetrasomes of S. cereale in a wheat background. Earlier observations that heterozygous associations (banded with unbanded) had consistently higher chiasma frequencies than homozygous associations were extended and confirmed. To analyze this phenomenon more closely, the possible relations between this correlation and several other meiotic phenomena were studied. For this analysis, three genetically different autotetraploid hybrids within S. cereale were selected that differed with respect to the relation between pairing type and chiasma frequency. Special attention was given to different patterns of interference and other meiotic phenomena in the two chromosome arms of chromosome 1R. No relations between such phenomena and the relation between pairing type and chiasma frequency could be established. A hypothesis is formulated assuming that long-distance homologue attraction is concentrated in a limited number of sites and that in different genotypes, different patterns of active sites are present. Moderately weak attraction sites can pair with strong homologous sites under favorable genetic conditions, but two weak sites cannot. Then, heterozygotes have more effective pairing initiation and consequently chiasma formation than homozygotes. Under less favorable conditions, only strong sites are effective, and then, homozygotes pair better, but the chiasma frequency is lower. A model of the forces involved in homologue attraction is presented.

What makes homologous chromosomes find each other in meiosis? A review and an hypothesis.

The conditions re reviewed that must be met by any model of long distance attraction and transport of homologous chromosomes to the points of intimate DNA synapsis. A proposal for possible mechanisms is presented. It includes transcription and repair factors acting on coding sequences as a preparatory step toward pairing, and the attachment of specific pairing proteins to these sequences. Double-strand break formation is prepared but not immediately completed at the same sites. It is concluded that DNA-DNA interactions cannot bridge the distances between homologous chromosomes in the nucleus, and it is suggested that protein chains are formed between homologous segments. These attach to homologous chains emanating from homologous sequences in other chromosomes, and the chains move along each other until the homologous DNA sequences meet. Then, if required, a synaptonemal complex is formed, and exchange can take place.

Chromosome pairing and chiasma formation in autopolyploids of different Lathyrus species.

Chromosome pairing and chiasma formation were studied in natural and induced tetraploids (2n = 28) of Lathyrus odoratus (induced), Lathyrus pratensis (natural and induced), Lathyrus sativus (induced), and Lathyrus venosus (natural), as well as in triploids of L. pratensis and diploids of L. odoratus, L. pratensis, and L. sativus. All natural tetraploids appeared to be autotetraploids and their meiotic metaphase I behaviour was very similar to that of the induced autotetraploids, with average numbers of pairing partner switches exceeding 4 or even 5. Multivalent frequencies were high, but the numbers of chiasmata were not much higher than necessary to maintain the configurations. Interstitial chiasmata were common, but not predominant. Fertility was reduced, but sufficient for predominantly vegetatively reproducing species. The triploids of L. pratensis had an even higher multivalent frequency than the tetraploids, but still produced some viable progeny at or close to the tetraploid level, suggesting that in mixed populations of diploids and tetraploids, triploids can contribute to gene flow between the ploidy levels. There was no significant correlation between chiasma frequency and ring bivalent frequency in the diploids and multivalent frequency in the corresponding tetraploids. In the tetraploids, chiasma frequency and multivalent frequency were negatively correlated.

Chromosome pairing affinity and quadrivalent formation in polyploids: do segmental allopolyploids exist?

When polyploid hybrids with closely related genomes are propagated by selfing or sib-breeding, the meiotic behaviour will turn into essentially autopolyploid behaviour as soon as the affinity between the genomes is sufficient to permit occasional homoeologous pairing. An allopolyploid will only be formed when the initial differentiation is sufficient to completely prevent homoeologous pairing (in some cases enhanced by specific genes), or when segregational dysgenesis prevents transmission of recombined chromosomes. A new polyploid hybrid may be considered a segmental allopolyploid and may show reduced multivalent formation as a result of preferential pairing between the least differentiated genomes. An established polyploid is either an autopolyploid or an allopolyploid. In exceptional cases it is thinkable that a stable segmental allopolyploid arises, in which some sets of chromosomes are well differentiated and behave as in an allopolyploid, whereas other sets are not well differentiated and behave as in an autopolyploid. No clear cases have been found in the literature so far. Key words : chromosome, pairing affinity, quadrivalent frequency, segmental allopolyploidy.

Recombination and chiasmata: few but intriguing discrepancies.

The paradigm that meiotic recombination and chiasmata have the same basis has been challenged, primarily for plants. High resolution genetic mapping frequently results in maps with lengths far exceeding those based on chiasma counts. In addition, recombination between specific homoeologous chromosomes derived from interspecific hybrids is sometimes much higher than can be explained by meiotic chiasma frequencies. However, almost the entire discrepancy disappears when proper care is taken of map inflation resulting from the shortcomings of the mapping algorithm and classification errors, the use of dissimilar material, and the difficulty of accurately counting chiasmata. Still, some exchanges, especially of short interstitial segments, cannot readily be explained by normal meiotic behaviour. Aberrant meiotic processes involving segment replacement or insertion can probably be excluded. Some cases of unusual recombination are somatic, possibly premeiotic exchange. For other cases, local relaxation of chiasma interference caused by small interruptions of homology disturbing synaptonemal complex formation is proposed as the cause. It would be accompanied by a preference for compensating exchanges (negative chromatid interference) resulting from asymmetry of the pairing chromatid pairs, so that one side of each pair preferentially participates in pairing. Over longer distances, the pairing face may switch, causing the normal random chromatid participation in double exchanges and the relatively low frequency of short interstitial exchanges. Key words : recombination frequency, map length, chiasmata, discrepancy, chromatid interference.

Cytogenetics of Lathyrus palustris, a natural autohexaploid.

American as well as British forms of the perennial plant Lathyrus palustris have 2n = 42 chromosomes with one group of 6 long submetacentric chromosomes, two groups of 6 medium-long subacrocentric chromosomes, three groups of 6 medium-long to medium-short submetacentric to subacrocentric chromosomes, and one group of 6 medium-short metacentric chromosomes. One haploid complement measures 45.8 μm at somatic metaphase. At meiotic first metaphase both forms show extensive multivalent formation. In 50 metaphase I cells of one plant of the British form there were 51 ring hexavalents, 80 chain and open-branched hexavalents of various forms, 2 quinquivalents, 41 ring quadrivalents, 58 chain quadrivalents, 20 branched quadrivalents of various forms, 1 trivalent, 128 ring bivalents, 280 open bivalents, and 9 univalents. It is concluded that L. palustris is most likely a natural autohexaploid with frequent multivalent pairing, many points of pairing initiation, several partner exchanges per multivalent, and many interstitial chiasmata. It may well be the first fully documented true natural autohexaploid reported. Pollen fertility was 56.2% and seed set 37%, apparently sufficient for a perennial plant species.

Preferential pairing estimates from multivalent frequencies in tetraploids.

Mathematical models are presented for estimating preferential pairing and chiasma parameters in amphidiploids and autotetraploids on the basis of diakinesis or metaphase I configuration frequencies and are compared with other approaches of estimating affinity. With a preferential pairing factor p, estimated from quadrivalent and trivalent frequencies, and estimated chiasmate association factors for the two arms in quadrivalents (a(qu) and b(qu) for arms A and B, respectively) and in bivalents (a(bi) and b(bi)) a perfect fit between observed and predicted configuration frequencies can often be obtained in amphidiploids of several plant species, including Solanaceae and Gramineae. Since several proven autotetraploids give very similar apparent preferential pairing estimates, the biological significance of such parameters as preferential pairing and affinity factors is considered limited. The same is true for pairing parameters estimated by optimizing fit of configuration frequencies expected on the basis of theoretical models to observed data.

Pachytene pairing and metaphase I configurations in a tetraploid somatic Lycopersicon esculentum x L. peruvianum hybrid.

In the tetraploid somatic hybrid between the diploid Lycopersicon species L. esculentum (tomato) and L. peruvianum, synaptonemal complexes formed quadrivalents in 73 of the 120 sets of four chromosomes (60.8%) in 10 cells studied in detail at pachytene. Of these, 43 had one pairing partner exchange, 22 had two, and 8 had three, very close to a Poisson distribution. The points of pairing partner exchange were concentrated at the middle of the two arms. The frequency per arm corresponded with physical arm length. There was a sharp drop around the centromere, and pericentric heterochromatin had a slightly lower probability of being involved in pairing partner exchange than euchromatin. The chromosomes align before pairing and there are several points of pairing initiation, with concentrations at or near the ends and the centromere. From zygotene to late pachytene the quadrivalent frequency decreased considerably. At late pachytene it was lower than expected with the observed high frequency of pairing partner exchange. Pairing affinity between species was only slightly lower than affinity within species, in spite of considerable genetic differentiation. The frequency of recombination nodules increased from early to late zygotene and then decreased strongly to full pachytene. There is a highly significant negative correlation between percent pairing and SC length. At metaphase I the frequency of quadrivalents was 0.444, and branched quadrivalents were rare, probably caused by interference and restriction of chiasma formation to distal euchromatin. Metaphase I quadrivalent frequency is a relatively good indication of pairing affinity in this material.

Generative transmission of the extra chromosome in a rye tertiary trisomic and its relation with inbreeding depression and pollen quality.

Transmission of the extra (translocated) chromosome of tertiary trisomic T282W of rye (Secale cereale L.) upon seifing, through the male and/or the female, ranged from 0% to 36% in different inbred lines. Tetrasomics arising from simultaneous male and female transmission were not recovered and thus apparently not viable. Low seed weight, poor seed germination and a low transmission rate were correlated with low seed weight and reduced plant vigour. Inbreeding depression was concluded to affect transmission rate through its effect on the relative viability of trisomic seeds or seedlings.Male transmission in testcrosses with disomics averaged 7%, but varied between lines. Genetic factors were involved, but their expression remains uncertain. Pollen quality, as determined by a fluorescence reaction, was somewhat lower in trisomics than in disomics of the same genetic background and was not correlated with male transmission rate, which appears to be determined mainly by relative pollen-tube growth of euploid and aneuploid gametophytes. The results are discussed in relation to the use of tertiary trisomics in balanced chromosomal systems for hybrid breeding.

Mapping seed storage protein loci Sec-1 and Sec-3 in relation to five chromosomal rearrangements in rye (Secale cereale L.).

Linkage relationships were established between the secalin loci, Sec 1 (40-K gamma and omega secalins, homologous to the wheat gliadins) and Sec 3 (HMW = high-molecular-weight secalins, homologous to the wheat HMW glutenin subunits), and five chromosomal rearrangements involving chromosome 1R of rye (Secale cereale L.). These were: interchanges T273W (1RL/5RS), T306W (1RS/5RL), and T850W (1RS/ 4RL), Robertsonian centromere split Rb1RW and the interchanged Robertsonian split Rb2R/248W. The analysis established the linkage relationships between the secalin loci and the breakpoints of the rearrangements, in addition to the quantitative effects of the rearrangements on the linkage. Sec-1 is located in the satellite at a position at least 2.5 cMorgan from the proximal border of the terminal C-band, and about 30 cMorgan from the nucleolar organizing region (NOR). The locus is also physically closer to the terminal C-band than to the NOR, but not as much as corresponds with the map distances. Similarly, the physical distance between Sec-3 and the centromere is greater than corresponds with the recombination frequency (0%-9%). Although overall recombination in 1RL remains the same, recombination between the centromere and Sec-3 is greatly reduced in the Robertsonian split combined with the interchange. This is not the case with the single Robertsonian split.

Meiotic multivalent orientation and cell developmental delay.

In the heterozygote for the combination of an interchange (662W;3R/6R) and a Robertsonian split (3R) of rye, one type of adjacent orientation leads to trisomy in the progeny. Pollen mother cells with adjacent orientation of the translocation quinquivalent or with a trivalent and a bivalent were delayed in their development and appeared at prometaphase and metaphase later than cells with alternate quinquivalents. Delay in cell development is ascribed to unfavorable (early) prophase positioning of chromosomes.

Meiotic behaviour of telo-tertiary compensating trisomics of rye: evaluation for use in hybrid varieties.

Meiosis of four telocentric-tertiary compensating trisomics of rye (Secale cereale L.) was studied with the purpose of evaluating their suitability for use in maintaining genic male-sterile lines applied in hybrid varieties. They had been constructed from four different reciprocal translocations and three different telocentrics. In one trisomic a slight, but significant tendency was demonstrated for preferential pairing of the two normal chromosomes associated with the compensating complex. This promotes the desired segregation into one normal and one compensating karyotype. In all trisomies, however, too high a frequency of failure of chiasma formation in a critical segment of the complex was evident. This is correlated with the ease of recovery of the trisomics, but results in undesired segregational products. Interstitial chiasmata leading to the formation of branched configurations were also present, more in some trisomics than in others. These also result in undesired segregations. The behaviour at meiosis was so closely correlated with the length of the chromosome segments involved that a prediction of the most favourable combination of telocentric and translocation can be made. The telocentric should be large, the corresponding translocated segment large and the interstitial segment small. The non-translocated arm of the translocated chromosome should be large and the second translocated segment small. The combinations of translocations and telocentrics had not been selected for these criteria and did not meet the requirements for practical application.

In vitro culture of cell aggregates of rye (Secale cereale L.) at low densities.

The growth of cell aggregates from a rye suspension culture was tested at low density in three culture systems. Mass seeding was the most supportive system, followed by agarose droplets. Microdroplet culture using Cuprak dishes was the least effective system. Growth was stimulated by the presence of a feeder layer of suspension cells but only if the feeder contact with the nursed cells was via a liquid and not a gaseous phase. Plating efficiences were enhanced by the feeder effect, whereas the subsequent growth rates were less affected. The techniques described should prove useful in programs aimed at the in vitro genetic manipulation of rye or other cereals.