Breaking Radial Dipole Symmetry in Planar Macrocycles Modulates Edge-to-Edge Packing and Disrupts Cofacial Stacking.

Dipolar interactions are ever-present in supramolecular architectures, though their impact is typically revealed by making dipoles stronger. While it is also possible to assess the role of dipoles by altering their orientations by using synthetic design, doing so without altering the molecular shape is not straightforward. We have now done this by flipping one triazole unit in a rigid macrocycle, tricarb. The macrocycle is composed of three carbazoles (2 Debye) and three triazoles (5 Debye) defining an array of dipoles aligned radially but organized alternately in and out. These dipoles are believed to dictate edge-to-edge tiling and face-to-face stacking. We modified our synthesis to prepare isosteric macrocycles with the orientation of one triazole dipole rotated 40°. The new dipole orientation guides edge-to-edge contacts to reorder the stability of two surface-bound 2D polymorphs. The impact on dipole-enhanced π stacking, however, was unexpected. Our stacking model identified an unchanged set of short-range (3.4 Å) anti-parallel dipole contacts. Despite this situation, the reduction in self-association was attributed to long-range (~6.4 Å) dipolar repulsions between π-stacked macrocycles. This work highlights our ability to control the build-up and symmetry of macrocyclic skeletons by synthetic design, and the work needed to further our understanding of how dipoles control self-assembly.

Tuning Ligand-Coordinated Single Metal Atoms on TiO2 and their Dynamic Response during Hydrogenation Catalysis.

Invited for this month's cover is the group of Steven Tait at Indiana University. The image shows single metal atoms stabilized by small molecules on a titanium dioxide powder support that are active in catalyzing ethylene hydrogenation. The Full Paper itself is available at 10.1002/cssc.202100208.

Variations in Complementary Hydrogen Bonds Direct Assembly Patterns of Isosteric Polyheteroaromatics at Surfaces.

Intermolecular interactions guide self-assembly on the surface. Precise control over these interactions by rational design of the molecule should allow fine control over the self-assembly patterns. Functional groups installed for electronic modulation often induce significant changes in the molecular dimensions, thereby disrupting the original assembly pattern. To overcome this challenge, we have employed a family of isosteric phenazine derivatives, DHP, DAP, and DBQD, to investigate the impacts of hydrogen bonding on two-dimensional molecular self-assembly. While these molecules are similar in size and chemical composition, the strength and directionality of hydrogen bonding differ significantly depending on the chemical structure of donor-acceptor pairs and prototropic tautomerization from positional isomerism. Scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) characterization of the assembled structures on Ag(111), Au(111), and Cu(100) surfaces revealed that minimal changes in molecular structure have a profound impact on the self-assembly patterns. While DHP exhibits highly ordered and robust assemblies, DAP and DBQD show either spatially confined or ill-defined assemblies. In conjunction with hydrogen bonding, prototropic tautomerism is a potent strategy to modulate molecular 2D lattices on surfaces.

Tuning Ligand-Coordinated Single Metal Atoms on TiO2 and their Dynamic Response during Hydrogenation Catalysis.

Ligand-coordinated supported catalysts (LCSCs) are of growing interest for heterogeneous single-atom catalysis. Here, the effect of the choice of organic ligand on the activity and stability of TiO2 -supported single-atom Pt-ligand catalysts was investigated for ethylene hydrogenation. The activity of these catalysts showed a significant dependence on the choice of ligand and also correlated with coordination number for Pt-ligand and Pt-Cl- . Of the three ligands examined in this study, the one with the lowest Pt coordination number, 1,10-phenanthroline-5,6-dione (PDO), showed the lowest reaction temperature and highest reaction rate, likely due to those metal sites being more accessible to reactant adsorption. In-situ X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) experiments showed that the activity also correlated with good heterolytic dissociation of hydrogen, which was supported by OH/OD exchange experiments and was the rate-determining step of the hydrogenation reaction. In these in-situ XAS experiments up to 190 °C, the supported Pt-ligand catalyst showed excellent stability against structural and chemical change. Instead of Pt, the PDO ligand could be coordinated with Ir on TiO2 to form Ir LCSCs that showed slow activation by loss of Ir-Cl bonds, then excellent stability in the hydrogenation of ethylene. These results provide the chance to engineer ligand-coordinated supported catalysts at the single-atom catalyst level by the choice of ligand and enable new applications at relatively high temperature.

On-Surface Synthesis of a Five-Membered Carbon Ring from a Terminal Alkynyl Bromide: A [4 + 1] Annulation.

We report an on-surface synthesis of five-membered carbon ring via a [4 + 1] annulation reaction, starting from a simple terminal alkynyl bromide, 4-(bromoethynyl)biphenyl, on Ag(110). The combination of scanning tunneling microscopy (STM), synchrotron radiation photoemission spectroscopy (SRPES), and density functional theory (DFT) calculations unravel the reaction pathway and mechanism. Three basic reaction steps are involved, successively including the formation of alkynyl-Ag-alkynyl bridged organometallic dimer, the generation of alkylidene carbene intermediate, and the final [4 + 1] annulation involving a hydrogen transfer step.

In Situ Investigations of Al/Perovskite Interfacial Structures.

Interfacial properties of perovskite layers and metal electrodes play a crucial role in device performance and long-term stability of perovskite solar cells. In this work, we performed a comprehensive study of the interfacial structures and ion migration at the interface of a CH3NH3PbI3 perovskite layer and an Al electrode using in situ synchrotron radiation photoemission spectroscopy measurements. It was found that the Al electrode can react with the perovskite layers, leading to the formation of aluminum iodide species and the bonding between Al and N, as well as the reduction of Pb2+ ions to metallic Pb species at the interface. Moreover, during the Al deposition, iodide ions can migrate from the CH3NH3PbI3 subsurface to the Al electrode, while the reduced Pb remains at the subsurface. The depth profile photoemission measurements, made by varying the photon energies of incident synchrotron radiation X-rays, demonstrate that the reaction occurs at the Al/CH3NH3PbI3 interface at least with a thickness of ∼3.5 nm below the perovskite surface. This study provides an atomic-level fundamental understanding of the Al/CH3NH3PbI3 interfacial structures and insight into the degradation mechanisms of perovskite solar cells when using Al metal as the electrode.

Sequence-Defined Macrocycles for Understanding and Controlling the Build-up of Hierarchical Order in Self-Assembled 2D Arrays.

Anfinsen's dogma that sequence dictates structure is fundamental to understanding the activity and assembly of proteins. This idea has been applied to all manner of oligomers but not to the behavior of cyclic oligomers, aka macrocycles. We do this here by providing the first proofs that sequence controls the hierarchical assembly of nonbiological macrocycles, in this case, at graphite surfaces. To design macrocycles with one (AAA), two (AAB), or three (ABC) different carbazole units, we needed to subvert the synthetic preferences for one-pot macrocyclizations. We developed a new stepwise synthesis with sequence-defined targets made in 11, 17, and 22 steps with 25, 10, and 5% yields, respectively. The linear build up of primary sequence (1°) also enabled a thermal Huisgen cycloaddition to proceed regioselectively for the first time using geometric control. The resulting macrocycles are planar (2° structure) and form H-bonded dimers (3°) at surfaces. Primary sequences encoded into the suite of tricarb macrocycles were shown by scanning-tunneling microscopy (STM) to impact the next levels of supramolecular ordering (4°) and 2D crystalline polymorphs (5°) at solution-graphite interfaces. STM imaging of an AAB macrocycle revealed the formation of a new gap phase that was inaccessible using only C3-symmetric macrocycles. STM imaging of two additional sequence-controlled macrocycles (AAD, ABE) allowed us to identify the factors driving the formation of this new polymorph. This demonstration of how sequence controls the hierarchical patterning of macrocycles raises the importance of stepwise syntheses relative to one-pot macrocyclizations to offer new approaches for greater understanding and control of hierarchical assembly.

Reaction selectivity of homochiral versus heterochiral intermolecular reactions of prochiral terminal alkynes on surfaces.

Controlling selectivity between homochiral and heterochiral reaction pathways on surfaces remains a great challenge. Here, competing reactions of a prochiral alkyne on Ag(111): two-dimensional (2D) homochiral Glaser coupling and heterochiral cross-coupling with a Bergman cyclization step have been examined. We demonstrate control strategies in steering the reactions between the homochiral and heterochiral pathways by tuning the precursor substituents and the kinetic parameters, as confirmed by high-resolution scanning probe microscopy (SPM). Control experiments and density functional theory (DFT) calculations reveal that the template effect of organometallic chains obtained under specific kinetic conditions enhances Glaser coupling between homochiral molecules. In contrast, for the reaction of free monomers, the kinetically favorable reaction pathway is the cross-coupling between two heterochiral molecules (one of them involving cyclization). This work demonstrates the application of kinetic control to steer chiral organic coupling pathways at surfaces.

Supramolecular Tessellations at Surfaces by Vertex Design.

Assembly and tessellation of organic species at surfaces are important for the design of advanced materials, particularly for the development of spontaneous self-assemblies of supramolecular systems of increasing complexity. However, there are few examples where the ability to steer the system between supramolecular tessellations has been achieved. Here, we demonstrate a series of steps to reduce and then restore molecular symmetry; those variations impact vertex symmetry and thus generate a series of tessellations that reflect the molecular symmetry. We deposit 4,4'-dihydroxybiphenyl on the Ag(111) surface, then anneal at specific temperatures to achieve stepwise dehydrogenation of the terminal hydroxyls. The symmetry of tessellation vertices in the self-assembled structure also changes, as characterized by scanning tunneling microscopy and synchrotron radiation photoemission spectroscopy. This control over vertex geometry and spontaneous tessellation structure extends our understanding of supramolecular design control and advances architectural complexity for the development of functional surfaces.

Surface Self-Assembly, Film Morphology, and Charge Transport Properties of Semiconducting Triazoloarenes.

Surface-assisted molecular self-assembly is a powerful strategy for forming molecular-scale architectures on surfaces. These molecular self-assemblies have potential applications in organic electronics, catalysis, photovoltaics, and many other technologies. Understanding the intermolecular interactions on a surface can help predict packing, stacking, and charge transport properties of films and allow for new molecular designs to be tailored for a required function. We have previously studied a molecular platform, tris( N-phenyltriazole) (TPT), that exhibits planar stacking through >20 molecular layers through donor-acceptor-type intermolecular π-π contacts between the electron-deficient tris(triazole) core and electron-rich peripheral phenyl units. Here, we investigate an expanded family of TPT-based molecules with variations made on the peripheral aryl groups to modulate the molecular electron distribution and examine the impact on molecular packing and charge transport properties. Molecular-resolution scanning tunneling microscopy was used to compare the molecular packing in the monolayer and to investigate the effects that the structural and electronic modifications have on the stacking in subsequent layers. Conductivity measurements were made using the four-point probe van der Pauw technique to demonstrate charge transport properties comparable to pentacene. Although molecular packing is clearly impacted by the chemical structure, we find that the charge transport efficiency is quite tolerant to small structural variations.

Multi-electron Reduction Capacity and Multiple Binding Pockets in Metal-Organic Redox Assembly at Surfaces.

Metal-ligand complexation at surfaces utilizing redox-active ligands has been demonstrated to produce uniform single-site metals centers in regular coordination networks. Two key design considerations are the electron storage capacity of the ligand and the metal-coordinating pockets on the ligand. In an effort to move toward greater complexity in the systems, particularly dinuclear metal centers, we designed and synthesized tetraethyltetra-aza-anthraquinone, TAAQ, which has superior electron storage capabilities and four ligating pockets in a diverging geometry. Cyclic voltammetry studies of the free ligand demonstrate its ability to undergo up to a four-electron reduction. Solution-based studies with an analogous ligand, diethyldi-aza-anthraquinone, demonstrate these redox capabilities in a molecular environment. Surface studies conducted on the Au(111) surface demonstrate TAAQ's ability to complex with Fe. This complexation can be observed at different stoichiometric ratios of Fe:TAAQ as Fe 2p core level shifts in X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy. Scanning tunneling microscopy experiments confirmed the formation of metal-organic coordination structures. The striking feature of these structures is their irregularity, which indicates the presence of multiple local binding motifs. Density functional theory calculations confirm several energetically accessible Fe:TAAQ isomers, which accounts for the non-uniformity of the chains.

Kinetic Strategies for the Formation of Graphyne Nanowires via Sonogashira Coupling on Ag(111).

The selection of a reaction pathway with high energy barrier in a multipath on-surface reaction system has been challenging. Herein, we report the successful control of the reaction system of 1,1'-biphenyl-4-bromo-4'-ethynyl (BPBE) on Ag(111), in which three coupling reactions (Glaser, Ullman, Sonogashira) are involved. Either graphdiyne (GDY) or graphyne (GY) nanowires can be formed by distinct kinetic strategies. As the energetically favorable pathway, the formation of a GDY nanowire is achieved by hierarchical activation of Glaser (with lowest energy barrier) and Ullman coupling of BPBE. On the other hand, the formation of a GY nanowire originates from the high selectivity of the high-barrier Sonogashira coupling, whose indispensable kinetic parameters are high surface temperature, low molecular coverage, and low precursor evaporation rate, as derived from a series of control experiments. This work achieves the fabrication of GY nanowires via on-surface Sonogashira coupling for the first time and reveals mechanistic control strategies for potential syntheses of other functional nanostructures via cross-couplings on surfaces.

Amphiphile self-assembly dynamics at the solution-solid interface reveal asymmetry in head/tail desorption.

Amphiphilic alkoxybenzonitriles (ABNs) of varying chain length are studied at the solution/graphite interface to analyze dynamics of assembly. Competitive self-assembly between ABNs and alkanoic acid solvent is shown by scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) to be controlled by concentration and molecular size. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations reveal key roles of the sub-nanosecond fundamental steps of desorption, adsorption, and on-surface motion. We discovered asymmetry in desorption-adsorption steps. Desorption starting from alkyl chain detachment from the surface is favored due to dynamic occlusion by neighbouring chains. Even though the nitrile head has a strong solvent affinity, it more frequently re-adsorbs following a detachment event.

Redox Isomeric Surface Structures Are Preferred over Odd-Electron Pt1.

The formation of metal-ligand coordination networks on surfaces that contain redox isomers is a topic of considerable interest and is important for bifunctional metallochemistry, including heterogeneous catalysis. Towards this end, a tetrazine with two electron withdrawing pyrimidinyl substituents was co-deposited with platinum metal on the Au(100) surface. In a 2:1 metal:ligand ratio, only half of the platinum is oxidized to the +2 oxidation state, with the remainder coordinating to the ligand without charge transfer, as Pt0 . The resultant Pt0 /PtII mixed valence structure is thought to form due to the aversion of the ligand towards a four-electron reduction and the strong preference of Pt towards 0 and +2 oxidation states. These results were confirmed through a series of experiments varying the on-surface metal:ligand stoichiometry in the redox assembly formed: added oxidant does not oxidize the already complexed Pt0 . Scanning tunneling microscopy reveals irregular chain structures that are attributed to the mixture of Pt valence states, each with distinct local coordination geometries. Density functional theory calculations give further detail about these local geometries. These results demonstrate the formation of a mixture of valence states in on-surface redox assembly of metal-organic networks that extends the library of single-site metal structures for surface chemistry and catalysis. Redox-isomeric Pt0 versus Pt2+ surface structures can coexist in this ligand environment.

Supramolecular Assemblies on Surfaces: Nanopatterning, Functionality, and Reactivity.

Understanding how molecules interact to form large-scale hierarchical structures on surfaces holds promise for building designer nanoscale constructs with defined chemical and physical properties. Here, we describe early advances in this field and highlight upcoming opportunities and challenges. Both direct intermolecular interactions and those that are mediated by coordinated metal centers or substrates are discussed. These interactions can be additive, but they can also interfere with each other, leading to new assemblies in which electrical potentials vary at distances much larger than those of typical chemical interactions. Earlier spectroscopic and surface measurements have provided partial information on such interfacial effects. In the interim, scanning probe microscopies have assumed defining roles in the field of molecular organization on surfaces, delivering deeper understanding of interactions, structures, and local potentials. Self-assembly is a key strategy to form extended structures on surfaces, advancing nanolithography into the chemical dimension and providing simultaneous control at multiple scales. In parallel, the emergence of graphene and the resulting impetus to explore 2D materials have broadened the field, as surface-confined reactions of molecular building blocks provide access to such materials as 2D polymers and graphene nanoribbons. In this Review, we describe recent advances and point out promising directions that will lead to even greater and more robust capabilities to exploit designer surfaces.

Redox-active ligand controlled selectivity of vanadium oxidation on Au(100).

Metal-organic coordination networks at surfaces, formed by on-surface redox assembly, are of interest for designing specific and selective chemical function at surfaces for heterogeneous catalysts and other applications. The chemical reactivity of single-site transition metals in on-surface coordination networks, which is essential to these applications, has not previously been fully characterized. Here, we demonstrate with a surface-supported, single-site V system that not only are these sites active toward dioxygen activation, but the products of that reaction show much higher selectivity than traditional vanadium nanoparticles, leading to only one V-oxo product. We have studied the chemical reactivity of one-dimensional metal-organic vanadium - 3,6-di(2-pyridyl)-1,2,4,5-tetrazine (DPTZ) chains with O2. The electron-rich chains self-assemble through an on-surface redox process on the Au(100) surface and are characterized by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, scanning tunneling microscopy, high-resolution electron energy loss spectroscopy, and density functional theory. Reaction of V-DPTZ chains with O2 causes an increase in V oxidation state from VII to VIV, resulting in a single strongly bonded (DPTZ2-)VIVO product and spillover of O to the Au surface. DFT calculations confirm these products and also suggest new candidate intermediate states, providing mechanistic insight into this on-surface reaction. In contrast, the oxidation of ligand-free V is less complete and results in multiple oxygen-bound products. This demonstrates the high chemical selectivity of single-site metal centers in metal-ligand complexes at surfaces compared to metal nanoislands.

From Foldable Open Chains to Shape-Persistent Macrocycles: Synthesis, Impact on 2D Ordering, and Stimulated Self-Assembly.

Small molecule self-assembly at surfaces offers an efficient route to highly ordered organic films that can be programmed for a variety of chemical and electronic applications. The success of these materials depends on the ability to program intermolecular interactions to guide precise structural ordering. Toward this objective, we have designed and synthesized a series of bis(triazolo)benzene-based π-conjugated molecules. Our synthesis exploits a last-stage C-C cross-coupling reaction to close up zigzag-shaped linear precursors to cyclized products, so that direct side-by-side comparisons can be made for their structure-dependent self-assembly behavior at surfaces and response to external stimuli. Indeed, scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) analysis revealed distinct differences as the conformational flexibility of the molecular backbone and the chemical structure of the peripheral groups are varied. Specifically, alkyl chains adsorb and form interdigitated structures, whereas oligo ethylene glycol (OEG) chains remain desorbed and thus shift self-assembly to more densely packed π-conjugated cores. While the macrocycles self-assemble immediately and spontaneously, their linear precursors exhibit slower self-assembly kinetics, which could be attributed to the difference in the degree of conformational freedom. We also found that perturbation by the STM tip and the addition of cosolutes profoundly impacted the kinetics of self-assembly and surface patterning. This highly unusual behavior highlights the importance of noncovalent interactions that are inherently weak in solution but can be made strong for symmetric and conformationally restricted molecules confined within 2D surfaces.

Complex molecular surfaces and interfaces: concluding remarks.

This paper is derived from our concluding remarks presentation and the ensuing conversations at the Faraday Discussions meeting on Complex Molecular Surfaces and Interfaces, Sheffield, UK, 24th-26th July 2017. This meeting was comprised of sessions on understanding the interaction of molecules with surfaces and their subsequent organisation, reactivity or properties from both experimental and theoretical perspectives. This paper attempts to put these presentations in the wider context and focuses on topics that were debated during the meeting and where we feel that opportunities lie for the future development of this interdisciplinary research area.