ABSTRACT
In a one-year period, 149 adult cases of Clostridium difficile-associated diarrhea and colitis were compared with 148 diarrhea-free controls. Eighty-seven percent were nosocomial and 75% were on surgical services. Endoscopy revealed pseudomembranes in 51% of the 109 cases in which stool cytotoxin was present, compared with 11% of the 40 cases that were culture-positive but cytotoxin-negative. Cases diagnosed only by stool culture showed essentially no differences from controls, 21% of whom had asymptomatic stool colonization. We estimate that only 20% of these cases had diarrhea due to C difficile. Compared with controls, cases diagnosed by the presence of cytotoxin or pseudomembranes were found to have been hospitalized longer at diarrhea onset, to have had more antecedent infections, and to have received clindamycin, multiple antimicrobials, and therapeutic antimicrobials more often than controls, but controls received prophylactic antimicrobials more frequently than cases. Cultures of the environment, patients, and personnel failed to detect a mechanism of acquisition.
Subject(s)
Clostridium Infections , Cross Infection/etiology , Diarrhea/etiology , Enterocolitis, Pseudomembranous/etiology , Adult , Aged , Anti-Bacterial Agents/adverse effects , Clostridium/isolation & purification , Clostridium Infections/diagnosis , Cross Infection/diagnosis , Cytotoxins/analysis , Diarrhea/diagnosis , Endoscopy , Enterocolitis, Pseudomembranous/diagnosis , Feces/microbiology , Female , Humans , Male , Middle Aged , Prospective StudiesABSTRACT
101 patients with Clostridium-difficile-associated diarrhoea or colitis were prospectively randomised to 10-day oral courses of metronidazole, 250 mg four times a day, or vancomycin, 500 mg four times a day. 7 did not complete the protocol and were dropped from analysis. Pseudomembranous colitis (PMC) was diagnosed after endoscopy in 33 patients. Of the remaining patients without PMC, 38 had both C difficile culture and cytotoxin and 23 had only culture evidence of C difficile. 52 evaluable patients received vancomycin and 42 received metronidazole. There were two treatment failures with metronidazole and none with vancomycin (p = 0.20); and two relapses with metronidazole versus six with vancomycin (p = 0.17). Treatment in 1 patient in each group was discontinued because of drug intolerance. Response and relapse rates of the 33 patients with PMC were no different from those of the remaining patients. Pharmacy cost for the dosage used was $387.48 to $520.00 for vancomycin and $11.84 for metronidazole. Metronidazole and vancomycin have equivalent efficacy and relapse rates and are tolerated to a similar extent by patients with C-difficile-related diarrhoea and colitis, but metronidazole is considerably more economical.
